If you're looking for a nice place where you can sit outside and have an espresso, this is it! I hate drinking out of a paper cup. They have actual illy mugs here... kudos to them. The espresso was perfect, and paired with the crb cake it was primo!! Super friendly barista, he recommend the crumb cake, much appreciated! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Crumb cake and espresso - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Very good bakery to grab something in a pinch. The man behind the counter was very nice and helpful. Small table or two out front to eat. I think one inside. I went in for pies. The banana cream pie was a 10/10 and will definitely be back for it. It was the staff favorite as well. I got two key lime pies. One was pretty good. The other was bitter. Almost as if they took too much of the lime rind when making it. Reasonably priced. Will be back read more

I happened to be heading to the Upper East Side, which was a rarity, and I figured I should make the most of it by finding a bakery at which to pick up some treats. The tiny place was certainly not a "cafe", unless you considered their outdoor table to qualify as seating, but they made the most of their cramped interior with a huge display case packed with goodies. In fact, they had so many options that it was a really tough selection process. The gracious staff was very friendly and remained patient while I worked through my options. In the end, I selected 2 squares of yumminess - a chunk of crumb cake and a blondie. The Crumb Cake had about a 70-30% ratio of cake to crumb. The dense cake was topped with a thick layer of crunchy, large crumb pieces and powdered sugar. The whole thing had notes of cinnamon and brown sugar and was absolutely delicious. The Blondie was a bit buttery and oily, but the sweet flavor was very enjoyable. It was also packed with chocolate chips. I thought both of Crumbly's renditions of those classics were well-executed, and I definitely plan to go back in the future to try some of their other delicacies. read more

This spot has really reliable, pastries, and coffee as a go to grab and go. I've tried their coffee cake which they're famous for, it's good, but it's really rich. They have great muffins and it's giving a cute timeless bakery. The service is great and they are really friendly. read more

Everything in this bakery looks scrumptious! Based on the name of the establishment and the accolades posted on their walls, I had to try their crumb cake for $4.90. It was absolutely divine! The perfect amount of sweetness and the cake was super moist. The crumb topping was not super delicate unlike other crumb cakes so each bite was sufficiently enjoyable. Definitely coming back! read more

I've had a variety of baked goods from here over the years but none was as bad as the cranberry orange slice I had today . Most cakes are moist and some are wet such as a tres leches . This was a wet cake . It smelled like eggs and just was a soggy mess that instantly put me in a bad mood . The only reason I'm giving 2 stars is because I've had slightly above average muffins before ( pistachio being my favorite) . I've never tried anything from here that wowed me outside of its appearance and I've tried their stuff on At least 3 or 4 occasions . Foolish me might still end up giving them a chance based of their lack of competition within the area . read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Corner of cranberry orange cake . Disgusting ! - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

My mom surprised me by having the loveliest, most delicious Birthday Cake delivered from Crumbly last week. She lives out of state and has gotten me cakes from some of the best bakeries in the city over my 20+ years living here. I swear, Crumbly's B Day Cake is the best I've had, hands down! My brother was visiting from Texas, and I sent him home (at his request) with a couple big slices...kind of rethinking my generosity!! Glad I live close by anytime I have a craving for a slice once I run out. Thank you Crumbly for making my B Day extra sweet this year! PS - Also included were 3 Chocolate Chip Cookies and 3 S'mores Cookies. Both excellent! The S'mores Cookies are extra special. Literally taste like a S'more, not like a double chocolate cookie with some marshmallows and graham crackers thrown in. They are light and decadent all at once. Crumbly really nails the flavor. My mom got me those cookies not even knowing they have become a new favorite! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I usually go to eclair but eclair was closed due to a fire so I came here. And no... I do not understand all the 5 star reviews. I had a chocolate chip scone and let's just say Whole Foods has better scones. read more

Crumbly is definitely a bakery, but cafe, I don't think so. I was so disappointed that I couldn't sit down to eat. No seating. Everything looks delicious and is baked on premises. I accidentally made the wrong selection. I wanted Spinach Feta and had a Cheese Boureka. It was very tasty but the cheese was only in my last two bites. I won't get it again. I'm definitely going back to try a cookie. The muffins look delicious too. Plus I still need to try their Spinach Feta Pastry. They have only been open for a week. They plan to put some seats outside. There's definitely no space inside. They are going to get business cards and menus too. The prices are really good for fresh baked pastries and dessert. The employees are very friendly and helpful. I wanted to buy one of everything but I need to do that when I'm heading home one day. They have a steady stream of customers so word is getting out. I suggest you give them a try. I feel bad they are hidden under scaffolding! Please spread the word that there's a new bakery in town. read more

See all

the pistachio latte is to die for!!! and their salted caramel almond cookie is the best!!

A new option in the Sutton area, so I was glad to see this place open recently. Their baked goods look homemade and are tasty. We tried a couple of muffins and a brownie so far and will check out the other treats in the future. They were friendly and are ready to welcome visitors! They have cold brew coffee on tap, lattes, teas, and a good coffee shop assortment of drinks. The only issue is that their cups and lids for hot drinks really do not seem to match or fit...a couple of people in our group kept getting leaks of hot/warm drinks due to the lid issue. read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

I was in the bakery yesterday to pick up a chocolate cake for my nephews birthday and it was beyond delicious! We all Loved it so much! Thank you read more

This bakery exceeds all expectations in every way a bakery good. I frequent the shop for a latte and pastry (the tastiest spinach feta bistro) and recently I bought a chocolate cake from them for my brother which was a huge hit - so delicious! Love this place I never go anywhere else for my morning treats! The service is incredible, great people running it. And the shop itself is so cute. read more

Loved their matcha!! Its the best in town. The girl on the counter recommended it to me, and she was absolutely right! A great way to cool off outside in a quiet space. read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Good coffee. Friendly staff. Excellent treats. The slice of layered chocolate cake is my favorite so far of what I've tried. Enjoyed a tasty walnut cookie today. Major points for using compostable takeout coffee cups - can happily throw them in the orange electronic bins rather than feeling guilty about not making my own brew instead :) read more

The vegan banana walnut muffin was delicious. I'll have to come back for the quinoa croissant (the other vegan baked good). It would be great to see even more vegan pastries and options here! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Vegan Banana Walnut Muffin - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Solid neighborhood bakery spot just a few steps after Marinara Pizza. The service is friendly and I really enjoyed their crumb cake! Coffee tasted average. I like the outdoor seating. I've been back already! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Interior - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

10/10! I custom ordered a cake for my friends birthday and it absolutely exceeded every expectation. I sent one photo for inspiration and they did everything I wanted and more. Please look at the pictures and order from them! Also, the cake was delicious. A lot of times I order pretty cakes, and they don't taste as good as they look. This was different. Will definitely order again! Judge this book by its cover ! read more

See all

Excellent little neighborhood cafe for some sweet and savory pastries, cakes and coffee. We've tried many of their treats as bad they never disappoint Great service and friendly staff are an added incentive read more

See all

Wide variety of choices drinks and desserts. This small bakery is very cozy and I bought a few desserts including the baklava which was very sweet and tasty. read more

See all

Cakes were fine - home style. New customer bought various items including a piece of marble cake. Can't understand why server cut the end piece when cake was already cut. Crust was dry and overcooked. Once I discarded this- rest of it was fine but why risk a bad review by cutting from the wrong end that should have been discarded. Rest of the cakes were fine. This not a gourmet French bakery but cakes are good. read more

A friend recommended this place and it did not disappoint! It's a small spot however even though it's not a huge bakery the assortment of choices on display vary between cupcakes, cakes, pies, cheesecakes, muffins, puddings, cookies and other pastries... you get the picture they do a lot and they do it well. Our favorites being the Oreo cheesecake & banana cream pie. They offer small and big pieces and the small Oreo cheesecake could easily be split between 2 people or one very hungry person :) read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Oreo Cheesecake @ Crumbly - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Tiny cheerful place, friendly staff, a couple of outdoor tables...and totally yummy delights. Crumb cake is a huge slice of uncomplicated heaven, amazing Irish Soda Bread on St. Patty's day, challah to die for, iced cinnamon rolls (not the giant Cinnabon thingies, the flat raisin filled kind - my fave). There's always at least one cake by the slice - often multi-layered carrot, a bit sweet but lip smacking. A few weeks ago they had bite sized walnut butter cookies like my mom made - those were crescent shaped, I bet you know the ones I mean. Everything is fresh, first class and it's the kind of store that "makes" a neighborhood. read more

There have been many chain cafes opening up near this area, but my family and I were happy to find out that this place is a family-run business! We tried the oreo cheesecake and one of the cupcakes with blue/white frosting. Both were really great - cheesecake was my favorite, although my siblings liked the cupcake better. Next items that I want to try are the cookies and all of the different puddings (yes, they have banana pudding here). I was also told that there would be a rewards option soon! Highly recommend. read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Menu - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Crumbly at Sutton Place did an amazing job, with a one-day turnaround, on a cake with a customized image of a rowing oar, and the names of 8 graduating seniors, for Yale Womens Crew. Besides the eye-catching appearance, the taste was amazing, as was the communication. Thanks! read more

Asked them to make me a dairy free cake at the last minute and they were very accommodating on time. However, the cake was too tall so it fell over in the box. In addition, the icing was salty, and not in a sweet/salty good kind of way. Overall, not impressed by the quality and taste . read more

Most delicious marble cake and coffee I've ever had! Everything is homemade. One of the best bakerys in NYC hands down! Pricing is also affordable and staff are super friendly and pleasant. Comfy outdoor seating area. Highly recommend!! If I could give this place 10 stars I would read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

They have the best Oreo cheesecake I've ever tried. the packaging is so cute and the atmosphere is so warming and welcoming. service was fast and efficient will definitely come again. read more

The treats here are good, but I think they are on the pricey side. The small hot chocolate was SO small and I think around $4-$5? It was a little bit ridiculous IMO. They were also out of chocolate chip cookies when I came which was a little bit disappointing. I ended up getting the s'mores cookie and it was really good and fresh! I split up over the course of a couple days and it stayed fresh and heated up well. I would come here again, just not too regularly because of the prices. read more

Nice neighborhood bakery with excellent service. I love all the homemade desserts, so far I have tried an Oreo ball, lemon bar and the Nutella pie, I enjoyed everything we got from here and I cannot wait to try more. So glad my friend brought me here! read more

Enjoyed the coffee cake from Crumbly Cafe & Bakery. Inside is a cozy vibe and staff was friendly. This is my preferred bakery in the area. Will be back to try other treats and a coffee probably. read more

Amazing family owned/run bakery (midtown east and UES locations) with all homemade recipes. MUST get the carrot cake and cake pops. Don't miss the Nutella cookie pie either! read more

Absolute favorite bakery in midtown east, hands down. Food is so fresh (particularly love the muffins and crumb cake) and the drinks are to die for. Everyone working is so friendly and its always decked out for the different holidays! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Truely happy this bakery opened and our company comes here to get all our bday cakes now! Their cakes are fresh and not overly sweet as most bakeries make it. Some of my coworkers who dont likes sweets likes their cakes. We also had their cookies and cupcakes which are just as good. Crumbly's dont offer much flavor options for cakes. They are trying to expand their flavors. The bakery is small and it's meant for takeout. No seating i side or outside. It's a simple bakery that offers coffee, hot chocolate and teas. But if you need a cake for an occassion, cant go wrong with that! Definately give this place a try if you're in or heading to the upper east side. read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Strawberry shortcake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Love, love , love this place!! My daughter and I stumbled upon this little haven. It is sooooo adorable and everything is soooo delicious! There are so many pastries, sandwiches, specialty drinks, and everything under the sun! We loved this place so much that we will need to come back on our next trip! The owner is so friendly and nice! Such a friendly place and a sweet oasis to come back to-- great food and great service! read more

See all

Excellent food and awesome staff!! Owner gave us two extra cookies for free. Great owner operated bakery

Good coffee cake, vanilla cake with chocolate icing and sprinkles was just okay, the woman working was super sweet and the inside is small but very cute. read more

I ordered a graduation cake from Crumbly Cafe & Bakery. In short notice they delivered an exquisite product. Everything from the experience of ordering the cake to the packaging of the cake on down to the delivery was perfect. A little on the pricey side but then again they say, "You get what you pay for." Thank you Crumbly Cafe & Bakery! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Red velvet graduation cake. - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Aw what a sweet experience! Was having a blue morning and I stopped by this place on my way to work to get an espresso. Chatted with the owner and he told me all about how his wife bakes all the baked goods, and even gave me a little walnut cookie ! Totally made my morning. Espresso and cookie delish as well! Will be back, Crumbly read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Oh my goodness, the feta spinach pastry was THE BEST IVE EVER HAD! It was so soft and buttery and flavorful. I'm sitting outside right now and I want to go in and ask for more but I don't wanna seem crazy! But I want a second one RIGHT NOW! The americano was delicious too, the espresso didn't taste burnt or bitter, it was really smooth. Definitely coming back here tomorrow for another coffee and pastry! read more