If you're looking for a "hole in the wall" pizza place with good food - stop here. We ordered a Stromboli and it was fabulous. Mozzarella was fresh, sauce was good, and cooked to perfection. I have officially added it to my I-10 route to stop while traveling. It's about five miles off the interstate. Cooks and wait staff very friendly too. Will be back. It is a small space and maybe not a five star restaurant, but it was exactly as I expected. Food was great! read more

Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Large Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Florida

Stopped here heading on our way to our hunt camp in Shady Groves the staff is friendly The pizza was cooked perfectly.

Delicious local pizzas! Thin crusted, yummy sauce and ample toppings. Called it in, easy quick pickup. Made a special no-cheese veggie pizza for my vegan hubby, and I had a tasty mushroom sausage pie. Fast, friendly service, we were happy to support a local business. read more

Great pizza came here after going to Madison blue springs only about 10 minutes away. Great pizza definitely worth the drive and great customer service as well read more

Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Cucinella's brick oven pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Florida

What an amazing surprise! Just off the highway this cute little town is hiding one of the best pizza restaurants in the South! Nice set up inside with a chalk wall for kids and two separate dining areas capable of holding larger groups. Coke products available (which is always a plus) and the best Garlic knots you will ever have in your life! Soft and chewy on the inside, slight crispiness on the outside with a sharp Parmesan flavor permeating throughout! If you thought the appetizer was good then wait till you try the pizza! Perfectly cooked and not skimping on the toppings! Gooey, cheesy goodness is the only way to describe it. Exploding with flavor and perfectly proportioned! Do yourself a favor and come off the highway on your next trip to try this amazing restaurant! Expect a 30 minute wait for food. read more

Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Garlic knot - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Florida

See all

This place is SOOOO good! Not too far off the interstate! Haven't had a bad experience ever. We have had their subs, pizzas, and pastas. All delicious. The staff treats their customers like family and always have a smile. read more

Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Menu 2024 - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Florida

See all

I've gotten pizza and salads here a few times. It was all ok. The pizza makes me think the oven isn't hot enough. They are all nice.

Best pizza around, hands down! Even the gluten free crust is pretty good - and if you've ever had gluten free pizza, you know it's a real complement to say its good lol The cookies are also a family favorite in our house, so if they have some on the counter when you go - be sure to buy one, or two or three! The Julie salad is our daughter's favorite, and I highly recommend the White Pizza. read more

Cucinella's used to have the best pizza around. But then you started using less dough making the pizza very very thin almost like thin cardboard. Also the crust of the pizza is very wide, leaving less room for toppings. I'm very disappointed. Please go back to your original ways of making your pizza. read more

What a great local find ! Hand tossed pizza simple but quality . Quick fast service and great prices . Excellent find on way home from wild adventure. Support local businesses read more

This locally owned place has great food! I found out that you order at the counter. Having never been here before we looked over the menu and ordered. I had the calzone with onions in addition to the meat. My brother had the spaghetti and meatballs. I was so pleasantly surprised and even though the onions that I thought would be inside the calzone was outside, everything was delicious. The calzone was the best I've ever had! I can't wait to come back to this local hole in the wall! read more

Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Spaghetti and meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Florida

See all

Love their pizza and italian dishes! Great service every time! You feel like family when you dine in.

our family loves this place!! The kids especially love their garlic knots! a must try!

My large veggie pizza had almost no cheese ;lots of sauce which was good. Low amount of toppings. Probably nine inches of the center crust was soggy to wet. It was busy day but the reviews did not hold true for me. read more

Good food and prices are good as well. The best place to buy pizza is from a locally owned business

Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria is a great addition to this community and not that bad of a trip off of Interstate 10 if you are traveling along that Highway and want to grab a meal of pizza or something Italian. The service was good and the pizza I found to be a nice hidden gem in northern Florida. Being from New Jersey, I find it hard to find good pizza in a lot of the rest of the country. When I find places like this, I am sure to embrace them. I have heard people try to say that you can't make good pizza in Florida due to the water, but places like Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria proves that to simply be not true. I would definitely recommend a visit the Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria. Pizza then how did Marsha resist is a wonderful culinary gift and this place presents a wonderful version of this culinary gift. read more

Friendly staff Pizza was good Can get one slice however you wanted Great salad Cute town read more

Best pizza I've had in a long time! Wasn't fancy or overpriced, just honest, perfect pizza. Perfect balance of crispy chewy crust, stringy cheese, cooked up gloriously. ...maybe I'm too easy to please but Pizza's one of my favorite foods and this is truly the best I've had in a long, long time. Kind of reminded me of the pizza places we'd hit as a kid in the 80s, just no Joust or Mrs. Pac Man over in the corner. Was something very familiar or comfortable about them. Friendly people too. Let's be honest, I strike out often enough, too often perhaps, on my yelpie adventures; this was a long-overdue home run!!! Top quality Pizza, this. And don't skip the brownies! read more

See all

The Best Pizza you will find,The owners and the staff are the Best around. Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza is the Best I have ever had. And don't forget the Garlic knot Will not find any better anywhere. read more

Great service and solid pizza!! Would recommend if passing through the area. My fiancé and I cleared an entire supreme.

Great Lasagna and side salad. The bread knots were the icing on the cake. Take out or eat in! Service is just like the ole' days GREAT Love the simple family ambiance too read more

Pizza, Garlic Knots and salad are all amazing, Each time we come to Madison! Friendly atmosphere and reasonably priced.

We were visiting the area and based on reviews we decided to try Cucinella's. The employees were all very nice and helpful. We ordered a pizza that was delicious. We also got Buffalo wings and cinnamon knots both were so good! If we ever visit this area again we will definitely go back. read more

How did I not get pictures??? This was amazing!! Got the $30 something family feast Pizza, Calzone, Garlic knots, and Salad and our family of four could not finish it all! It was so delicious! It was a teensy detour on our way to Disney. We would definitely make the detour again! Yummers! read more

Best pizza in the city. I order with low sauce and doble cheese, and they do it as I order. Nice and friendly people too.

Pizza is probably best in the south. ( if your from the Northeast it's not that ). Little pricey. Lasagna was over the top. Staff pleasant all around nice place read more

Was traveling for vacation and stopped in to this place. Was very happy with the service and pizza. The pizza had a hole in it and they offered to make us another small pizza to make up for it. We declined but the thought that they would do that without us even asking is great. Love going to local places and giving support to small business owners. read more

Food is always fantastic, great atmosphere and amazing friendly staff! Salad pizza or pasta everything is good here.

First time in. Friendly staff. Prompt service. Thinner crust but not too thin ( I am from the Bronx so slices are thick). My buddy from Buffalo has been in Florida 22 years said this is the best pizza he ever had in Florida.. Recommended! read more

Great service and friendly staff. The food was delicious! We had pizza and spaghetti and loved every bite.

Deserves every single star. A small town pizza place that is very clean and has such a friendly staff. We ordered the family feast. Everything from the salad to the drinks were fresh. Calzone was amazing. Their garlic knots are made with a wonderfully thick, pull apart dough smothered with delicious garlic and butter...... but the cheese pizza, which I wouldn't usually order ( our kids were with us) was out of this world - best cheese pizza I've ever had! My older son had the lasagna and said it was almost as good as mom's ;). So if you're passing through this beautiful small town and want to get your moneys worth, eat at Cucinella's! read more

Great pizza and subs. Very large portions, plenty for leftovers! Affordable pricing as well.

I called in my order since everything is made to order. I ordered lasagna but didn't want the garlic knots. The lady offered to substitute another item like a side salad but I didn't know if I could eat it all. I saw the HOMEMADE brownies when I arrived and she offered one as my side! (I actually ordered 2!). The restaurant is always clean, portions are big and hearty and everything is delicious. I highly recommend that you stop by! read more

Excellent pizza. The crusty is just right. Not too thin and not too thick. The toppings are nice and fresh and the cheese was super. Wish I lived closer but will definitely eat here again when we are in Madison again. read more

I was VERY surprised how delicious this little joint want. I love looking for the local hole in the wall pizza spots all across the country and THIS is a good one. Def get the garlic knots read more

Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Dining room - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Florida

This little, local Pizzeria is my favorite place to eat lunch when I am working in Madison. They have fairly priced 1 and 2 slice lunch options and can/bottled drinks. They have a POS system that can take Apple Pay. The staff are mostly females and all are very friendly and kind. The pizza is handspun and cooked in the brick oven that you can see while waiting for the pizza. The location has been clean every time I have visited and the staff are very helpful (they even gave me an extra silce because they were afraid one of the other slices wasn't big enough! read more

We have been going to the Perry location for years and have never had a problem. We thought we would try the Madison location and was severely disappointed. Upon walking in, we were not greeted and when my friend told Jonathan that we would be dining in, he ignored us and put down that we were carry-out. He wrote down the wrong name and then tried to tell us that he called out the name 10 times before yelling "Hey! Yeah you!" at us. He did not call out our name, let alone the correct name, and we were also the only customers in the restaurant. I am giving this review 1 star becuase we found hair baked into our pizza crust and Jonathan, the extremely rude server out front, ruined the experience for us. read more

Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria - There is a hair baked into the pizza crust. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Florida

Really great pizza, salads and pasta dishes in downtown Madison. Friendly staff. Pizza by the slice at lunch. Wish they were closer. read more

Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria - The pizza connoisseur approves. - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Florida

See all

Currently sitting here now... AWESOME PIZZA! I've eaten pizza all over the country and this place is a hidden gem. Glad I seen this place.

I hurt myself at this place. It was worth it though. On a road trip my girlfriend and I started craving pizza made a little detour. I'm so glad we stopped here and not a chain. First of the garlic knots were covered in garlic and lying in a pool of garlic and olive oil. I'm assuming there was a wizard in the kitchen who enchanted the knots as well because they had a mystical quality of goodness that surely couldn't be attributed to a mere collection of mundane ingredients. Next, the pizza. This thing was the stringiest, meltiest pizza I've ever had. The squishiness of the the thick layer of cheese was of set by the perfectly crispy crust. Once again, there had to be some occult force at work in crafting this cuisine. If you are within a 15 minute drive on a road trip and are craving pizza. You should make the trip. read more

Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Florida

See all