We got the Buffaroni pizza which is pepperoni with ranch, buffalo, and hot honey. I enjoyed the toppings. Both my husband and I agreed the pizza was undercooked. I would suggest ordering well done for a fully cooked pizza. The service was order at the counter and they were very polite. We would give it 3.5/5 stars. read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - Buffa-Roni 14" - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

Excellent customer service. Pizza was good too! I had a 2-slice combo with a soda. It was a nice, warm, Fall Saturday. We ordered at the counter and sat outside. They delivered it to our table. Nothing bad to say. Nice job! read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - Aloha Pizza and Carolina Pie (my "2 Slice" Cheese Combo) - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

I want to start this off by saying I am not one to complain because I am also in the food industry. The service I received tonight was unexplainable. It would be a totally different thing if they were making hourly. The workers here make well over 15 an hour and still beg for tips, but yet they still ensure your out before THEY CLOSE. My friends and I came In prior to 10 and ordered, but they still took until at least 10:30 to provide us with our food. We had no complaints as we knew they were busy, but to our surprise one of the workers kept reminding us that they were closing soon. Little did we know they were closing at 11... but they tried to kick us out at 10:45. I honestly think this is ridiculous if you are working for tips because quite frankly I have stayed well over my shift to take care of my tables. Not to mention they make a good hourly and still ask to supplement with tips. Once we left one of the girls (pictured) shoved the pizza box out of my hands and was extremely rude. Multiple of the workers were screaming GET OUT even though it was prior to their closing time of 11:00 pm. I just thought this was extremely ridiculous because they aren't working for hourly, they are working for tips and don't even take care of the tables or wait courteously for them to leave. I have never experienced service like this ESPECIALLY when they are asking for additional tips (which I did add). read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

I had pizza here a few months ago and it was absolutely delicious! I honestly can't remember what I got, but I remember being very happy with my choices. The service was wonderful and they lady behind the counter did a great job. The dining room was clean and bright. I can't remember much about it other than that. Finally they had some good draft beer selections. Will definitely be back next time I visit my family! read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

Unfortunately, this was the "penne alfredo" we were served "to go". In addition, the garlic knots had raw garlic clearly from a jar, scooped on top. I definitely don't recommend this place when there are better high-quality Italian restaurants in Greenville to spend good hard earned money. read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - Penne Alfredo and Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

See all

We've been waiting for Cucinella's to open their location in uptown Greenville and were excited to try a new place. We had the pig and fig pizza and were blown away! That has definitely been the favorite and we end up ordering it almost every time. All their pizzas do not disappoint, especially the specialties. The pizzas are a great thin crust while still having fluffy edges. It's a casual place serving very flavorful nyc style pizza and I highly recommend getting a slice here. read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - Pig and Fig 12" - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

Just received pizza delivery. Cold. So disappointing. Didn't have it in something to keep it warm from vehicle to door either. Apparently they use DoorDash? Ugh. Delivery fee plus tipped ahead of time. read more

This is the kind of pizza I crave when I truly crave pizza! You can expect a good portion with great flavor for a reasonable price! My fav is the Cheese well done to get alittle extra flavor in each bite! read more

Hoagies, Pizzas & Italian water ices are great. They know exactly how to serve & prepare toasted hoagies as well. The place reminds of many good pizza & hoagies restaurants from upstate NY. Great Restaurant read more

We ordered pizza and calzone this is the second time we have had problems....So we tried again but we are done they used to be so good but the quality of the food has gone down.....and both times the owner said it was a new cook first day solo....we are done unfortunately... read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

See all

We ate at Kings ahead of coming here. My son did not like his food at all so we walked here. We ordered two slices of cheese pizza. The service was friendly and fast. The pizza came out piping hot and was obviously fresh. From my 14-year-old: The crust was flavorful, the is cheese creamy, sauce excellent. Highly recommend. read more

Love this pizza. It will be a new staple for me. It's fresh, thin and a lil crispy just like I like it.

Food is good but the girl with glasses always messes up my order and then has the smart attitude to match when you try and correct her! Too many times to return! read more

Love the unusual flavors offered here. The crust is not the typical kind you find throughout NC. Thin yet chewy, soft, but not soggy! We tried the Special pizza that had peach habanero glaze on it with prosciutto and it was so good. Also had the Greek salad, also delish. Was too hungry to snap pictures, but you will not be disappointed here! read more

Delicious cheese bread, fresh salads, crispy crust pizza and fast delivery make this a great option for an impromptu catered office lunch.

The pizza is excellent. The employees are cool. I wanted the garlic knots so bad when I got home I have the buffalo chicken sub instead and was good. After all the Pizzeria was justified read more

the girl with the unibrow was so rude and was so disrespectful to customers. she told us we can't get a whole pie and that we can each get 5 pieces so we said we have multiple girls can we each get 5 pieces and she said no that's defeats the whole purpose you can't do that. she literally told us that's what we should do. so annoying. read more

Omg this pizza place was sooooo good! The wait was like 45 mins long bc they were really that busy haha. My first time I got a cheese pizza and it was delicious! The sauce was really good and there was a good ratio of sauce to cheese. The second time I ordered through Uber eats and I got the calzone. I had it with sausage and green peppers and it was amazing! My one and only complaint is that they only gave me one Mariana sauce when I asked and paid for two. I needs my sauce lmao! Overall I would recommend this place if you're looking for and easy and delicious meal. read more

Nice pizza. Pizza is good. Pizza is yummy. I like the food. I like the pizza. I had the pizza. The pizza was tasty. I liked the pizza very much. I recommend the pizza. I also had some garlic knots or something. Those were good. I liked the garlic knots. The garlics knots were tasty. The garlic knots were very yummy. Pretty good good. I would recommend it. I would eat there. The food is great. You could even say it's great. Magnificent. The food was good. The food was great. The food was magnificent. I liked the food. The pizza was good. The garlic knots were good. I would probably eat there again. The food was very good. You should eat there. I did. I ate there. I ate the food. Eat it. EAT IT. read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

I've been here multiple times (not as much as downtown) but I'm here to say that this is the best pizza in Greenville!! Hands down! The service is always so quick and personalized. The wait staff always make me feel welcomed and are always easily relatable. The atmosphere of this place is just always 10/10!! I LOVE CUCINELLAS PIZZA! read more

Insanely great pizza and garlic knots. Elizabeth took our order, worked cashier, delivered food to tables, cleaned tables all with a cheerful attitude. Awesome employee. read more

The food was so delicious and the customer service was extraordinary, shout out Jenna F. for her welcoming personality. Will definitely be coming back for late-night cravings!! read more

Great food, great staff. Excited for the new location and having the dining area. Pie of the week is always good!

From the incredible owners to the delicious food, Cucinella's is a clear home run. They are the only pizza we will eat in the area and you just can't beat their Italian ice, gelato, and gelati! Whether you live in town or are visiting, Cucinella's is a must stop in Greenville/Winterville. read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - Just look at this pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

See all

Really good Italian sandwich and we got the uncle Pauly pizza which was also really good.

Really good food. Some of the best pizza in town. And we love that they add hot honey to them. So good. We always enjoy going here.

Pizza 12" Spartan was meh. Grinder was meh. Won't order again. No parmesan or red chili pepper flakes or anything comes with the pizza. I am letting my dogs eat the food. Grubhub driver was the laziest I have ever experienced and rude. The pizza box was falling apart. He took a 20 min+ break at an apartment complex before going to to pick up the pizza... I think the restaurant was closing and my pizza had been made and left sitting for a long time. Grinder as well. To pay these overinflated prices... it's disturbing how little restaurants seem to care about dinner delivery customers. Grubhub never sent me their rating text as I'd already given feedback directly to them. Note: I won't be trying this restaurant again. I should have got a cheap pizza from a cheap chain place. At least I'd have paid a lot less. I did get a refund in the pizza and a 7.00 credit for the inconvenience from Grubhub. read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - 12' - The Spartan. Box partly open. Pizza cold upon delivery. - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

We visited Greenville for the day and had Cucinellas recommended to us. The restaurant is clean, with a friendly staff, and the food is outstanding. We ordered a simple cheese pie and a meatball grinder and a chicken parm grinder. The NY style thin crust pizza with a homemade sauce is just delicious, but the grinders stole the show. I tasted my wife's meatball grinder and she tasted my chicken parm and we can't decide which was best, because both were just bursting with flavor. My only disappointment is that Cucinellas doesn't offer a simple pasta marinara, because the sauce they use on the grinders is mouth watering and just begging for at least a side dish of pasta. It would be easy to add to the menu. read more

Super delicious pizza and gelato! The best service and environment for a bite. I highly recommend the flamethrower if you like some spice. It's family owned as well and they're awesome! read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - a row of pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

See all

Pretty legit pizza spot serving up NY style pies. It's definitely top 2 in Greenville. Has a few small tables if you want to eat in but seemed mainly takeout. read more

Tried for the first time last week. Blanca (white) pizza was pretty good. I don't know how long they've been next to Best Buy, but it would have been nice if we were told they moved when we showed up to pick up our pizza at the Winterville location THAT STILL HAS A BIG FAT SIGN ON IT. read more

I'm not sure where to start, this place used to be so good when the location was on Tar Rd. We went in last night, my husband and i, and ordered two pizzas to eat in. We tend to like different things so got two different pizzas. Since they were on the same order we assumed they would come out at the same time. Wrong! We anticipated a wait, not a problem. His pizza was out in about 20 minutes and as the waitress was delivering it she said mine would be out next. That turned out to be 20 minutes later and only after my husband had to go ask about it. The pizza, well my husband's words were I have eaten better Pizza out of the freezer section at the grocery store. They were not good, and including a tip which in retrospect is never a good idea to do before you get your food, was $45. That was definitely not $45 worth of food. We got two 12-in pizzas and one beverage because I drank water. I just couldn't believe it, we wasted and eat out on such lousy food. Very disappointing, obviously we will not be back. read more

I ordered some food from here over the weekend and it was quite good, I ordered the flame thrower pizza and a meatball sub. The pizza was delicious and the sun was decent. The meatballs were a bit bland and lacking flavor, but the bread was perfect not soggy but soft and warm. read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - 18' - Flamethrower Pie - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

See all

Great local spot. They are extremely busy. It takes an hour to pick up but that is not a problem for great pizza. Very good pizza and cheesy garlic knots. read more

Cucinella's - Midtown - a man in a red shirt - Pizza Near Me - Greenville, North Carolina

Pizza is delicious, reminds me of NY pizza. Very tasty. Best in Greenville no doubt. They're from my hometown of Rochester NY.

After many pizza and salad orders I think they are the best pizza Greenville has. They really have come to stand out here. Very very good.

The food was absolutely delicious. Love a good fresh and cheesy pizza! Service was also excellent!

Love Cucinella's pizza especially the think crust and delicious fresh flavors. Up next, sorbet.

Finally stopped in to try their pizza and was blown away! I had a slice of margherita pizza, a chicken and pesto sub, and a strawberry mango gelati. Everything was great! The pizza was probably my favorite, the pesto chicken was delicious, a little messy but a lot of flavor! The gelati was also tasty, I had never tried it before but overall I was very pleased with the entire meal. read more

See all

Best pizza in Greenville hands down and some of the best I've ever had in general. The crust is the perfect mix of crispy and soft and you can taste every single ingredient individually on the pizza. Cooked perfectly and super flavorful! read more