Great little spot next to the canal. Outside dining was great. It was a beautiful day by the water. The menu had a wide variety of items to pick from we decided on a Reuben sandwich and a spicy maple chicken wrap and some French toast The server was pleasant and right on with our drinks. So far the best place we visited in Brockport read more

Custom House Bar & Grill - Outside dining with a super fresh Genny cream ale - American Near Me - Brockport, New York

I just moved to brockport and have eaten here twice. It seems like it will be a good to for a long time. Overall I have a lot of confidence in the menu. The Asian dishes seem to need some work and they over cook their broccoli consistently. My wife odered a steak one night and it was quite good. The truffle burger did not have the truffle flavor and the mushrooms were watery--whicch sucks on a burger. I liked their pepponi pizza--the hot honey isn't worth it-- just give me some spicy pepperoni and more of it. To end, my father in-law will order the fried mozzarella every time and everyone will agree. read more

See all

This was my first occasion to go to Custom House under the new ownership and management. Fantastic lunch. I brought my wife and two daughters. The food was delicious and prepared with love and care. The menu is outstanding with really thoughtful choices that I now cannot wait to try. Something for everyone. Definitely elevated Pub Food. Every one of us was excited about our meal. I will definitely return soon. My highest recommendation. P.s. The service was also great read more

Custom House Bar & Grill - Corned Beef Crunch Wrap - American Near Me - Brockport, New York

Didn't get any service for 20 mins not even to get a drink order or anything so we had to leave. I feel bad for the waitresses they look over worked and understaffed read more

I'm in brockport at lest one's a week and have been meaning to check this place out, it's a beautiful tavern Lake restaurant with a basement bar overlooking the Erie Canal. Service was amazing and amazing recommendations. It was a Friday so I asked about the fish fry and I talked about how I liked it. Nice and crispy. When it came out, it was perfectly cooked and excellent crispy. You could definitely tell the server pay attention to me talking and had the food cooked to my liking!! Amazing place 100% would go again and would recommend to anyone else !! Ps. You need to get the French onion it was to die for read more

See all

***Under new ownership **** Amanda & Trevor have done an amazing job taking over the restaurant. New menu which now includes pizza. Can't wait to try the pizzas. Taco Tuesday is always great as $3 taco and they usually have a specialty one read more

See all

We've been 3 times since under new ownership and have had wonderful experiences each time! Brunch and dinner have both been amazing! Burger, loaded Bloody Mary, wings, and Custom Tso chicken all are worth going back for on a future visit! read more

Custom House Bar & Grill - Custom Tso Chicken - American Near Me - Brockport, New York

See all

We arrived in the afternoon so it wasn't very busy. Service was pretty good, and the view was nice since we sat right next to the canal. We ordered the shrimp tacos and BLT. Food was decent, but a little greasy. Not sure we'd pay that much for it again. In all, it was a very decent meal with a nice location. -@cophiescrumbs on insta read more

Custom House Bar & Grill - Shrimp tacos - American Near Me - Brockport, New York

See all

Wow, that was bad... No manager working, one "cook" who left alot to be desired. One waitress/ bartender. Zero flavor, except copious amounts of black pepper. Waited 2 hours for cold, dry, uninspired, underwhelming, sad, overpriced food. The gave a discount, but it did not make up for the disappointing experience. The only question now is, where are we going to eat after we leave here??? read more

Service was ok. I had a burger it was good. My wife had a Ruben. My god was it awful. 1st it was burnt. 2nd it had almost no corn beef. 3rd they used the heel of the loaf. They did take it off the bill but it was an awful experience. I asked to talk with a manager and was told there wasn't one. Don't recommend at all. read more

Hadn't gone there in a long time and was pleasantly surprised. The food is great and so are the drinks. I had a specialty cocktail today and was not disappointed. Service was a little slow, but the server was really nice. read more

Visited on a rainy Tuesday afternoon with a few people. Between us, we got the tacos (taco Tuesday, $3 tacos mix & match), a burger, grilled cheese, and the Hot Robbie sandwich. All of the food was excellent and hot. Portion sizes were more than enough to fill you up. Our server was friendly, attentive and offered helpful suggestions. A couple of people were being loud at the bar, but not too distractingly so, and it is a bar so what do you expect. Probably wouldn't recommend it for kids, but will definitely go back with adult friends. Overall 5/5. read more

Lovely dinner last night at Custom House. We're sailing down the Erie Canal and docked here for the night. Had cocktails, drinks, truffle fries, pizzas. All was very yummy! I'm not a huge fan of truffle fries, but theirs were not overly done on the truffle. Good pizzas - personal-sized. We sat upstairs in the dining room which was very nice. There is also a bar area downstairs. Great view of the canal in both spots. Sage was our server and was helpful, cheerful, and attentive. We would definitely go again and had a great time! read more

Up in Brockport for a fishing trip, after the long trip 8 hours, we decided on Custom House. First off their selection of a wide variety of bourbons were outstanding and reasonably priced! I ordered The Godfather sandwich, it consisted of slow cooked shredded beef, caramelized onions, cherry peppers and topped with provolone cheese on a great ciabatta roll. My choice for my side was an order of macaroni salad, it was a penne pasta salad with mayo, celery and bell peppers I was completely satisfied with my choice!! This is a must try spot that's on the Historic Erie Canal. read more

We typically like it here for weekend brunches but recently this place has gone so downhill. We waited over an hour for our food and it came out cold and overall was not good. We barely ate anything and left to go somewhere else. They must have some serious management issues going on for there to only be one bartender for the entire restaurant. We try to support local but there are so many better places in brockport than this. read more

Food is overpriced for what you get, and service is less than desirable. Customers shouldn't have to ask for things multiple times and never have it show up. It did seem like there was only one person taking care of the bar AND tablea...maybe hire more staff? There are better options nearby. read more

It was nice and lovely outside the entrance near the canal. It got not so nice once I walked in. For starters I believe the waitress was also the bartender and cook. My simple poutine order took a little over 45 minutes. Not to mention that it was topped with overcooked bacon. It had its good moments. The drinks were good and the time to leave came. If you're in the area I recommend to only go for a drink or two. read more

Custom House Bar & Grill - Tater Tot Poutine - American Near Me - Brockport, New York

Pretty decent food. I had the onion soup which was delicious but the bread wasn't toasted so not great but okay. I liked sitting next to the canal, very pleasant. I'd like to go back on a rainy day because the vibe is nice. It's odd though that the online menu doesn't reflect the same items as onsite menu. I really wanted to try the crab dip but it wasn't on the menu there! The service was decent but she brought us the ticket without asking if we wanted anything else so had to have her change it so we could have another drink. Kind of felt like being shoved out the door because the waitress wanted to close out her shift which was off putting. All considered, will revisit hoping these issues were just a result of who was working that evening. read more

Service from waitress was good food took forever and I have worked in restaurants when it arrived nobody could or wanted to finish. Dry overcooked hard rolls no thanks we won't be back read more

Nice seating and ambiance next to the canal however the menu isn't extensive and service was sluggish. I can't see myself visiting again when there's a good variety and options elsewhere. I ordered the French fries after a long wait. Thinking this would be quick and simple, they came out in a reasonable time but were cold and not appetizing. read more

Custom House Bar & Grill - View sitting canal side - American Near Me - Brockport, New York

Late night craving for nachos so we ordered take out. Very disappointed in the nachos as they had very little toppings. They were dry and I didn't taste one piece of cilantro. Wings were also not the best and very greasy. read more

See all

We don't get the mediocre reviews. Local gem. Food is outstanding. Staff are engaging and friendly. Right on the canal, so view is great. It was our go to place in Brockport. read more

Great food! good variety at very reasonable prices. love the intimate atmosphere! friendly staff and incredible drink selection

Once seated and food was ordered, it took an hour for food to be served. Yet the table beside us, whom came in about an hour after us, they had food served in 30 mins. Out of almost everything on the food and drink menus, and ridiculously expensive. read more

Little to no desire to go back. Such a beautiful location but disappointing food. We ordered nachos for an appetizer and it came with very little toppings other than salsa! Needed more cheese and other toppings. Second, the blacked shrimp tacos were lacking. If I order blacked anything i expect to see some seasoning. They looked like shrimp cocktail thrown on a tortilla. The waitress although friendly forgot a steak knife for my brother in law as well as his mashed potatoes. It took a good 25 min for our appetizers to show and she never checked to see how our food tasted. Sorry custom house but the food outweighs the location and not in your favor. read more

Custom House Bar & Grill - American Near Me - Brockport, New York

Made a reservation at 3 pm in Valentine's Day. Wasn't told that there was just their "special Valentine's menu" available. Arrived and was sat at a table that was beyond wobbly... after the hostess/waitress didn't understand that we had a reservation for 6 not a party of 6. Absolute waste of our time. I understand a "special" menu.... But if you're going to overcharge, at least have better menu options and wine options with labels. I'm not one for a "bottle of wine" when I don't know what brand it will be. Just a hard pass. read more

Went there today with my girlfriend to catch up on the months events, very loud and service was extremely slow. Waitresses were super young (2) and quiet, to the point no one ever checked on us to see if all was ok. Ordered the Cookie skillet for dessert and waited so long for it to arrive to table, it was cold and ice cream soupy. Needed a spoon vs. a fork, asked for a spoon and never received it! Demanded check and left. Very very disappointed. Nice views and website, but service needs some serious help! read more

Stopped on Saturday early afternoon. We ordered off brunch menu. I ordered the poutine and thought the sausage gravy was awesome. My boys had tacos which they liked. Never saw fries in tacos. Interesting. Will be back. Service was sub par. read more

The high point for my girls and me at Custom Houses were the appetizer teriyaki wings - a careful mix of sweet and spice. They came out hot with chunky blue cheese dressing on the side. I was also pleasantly surprised by the wedge salad - cold, crisp and fresh lettuce with crispy bacon, blue cheese dressing and diced tomatoes. Excellent!! The veggie and carnitas tacos were good, although the carnitas could have been slightly moister and the veggie tacos had more salt that she'd prefer. None of the slight preferences take anything away from the flavor and experience, as the service was top notch - timely and attentive and cheerful. read more

Custom House Bar & Grill - Custom House teriyaki wings - American Near Me - Brockport, New York

I so wanted to give this restaurant 4 stars tonight. I love what they've done with the downstairs bar area. The bar is huge. It has a nicer, updated, comfortable look. There are USB ports around the bar. The server/bartender was fantastic! Decent beer selection and pretty solid liquor selection. So many positives!! The food is really where things fell short. I order the Bahn Mi sandwich. I was looking forward to the big flavors of spicy pickles, pickled carrots, cilantro, and wasabi aioli. What I got was a couple regular pickle slices, a few specks of cilantro, no pickled carrots, and not enough wasabi aioli to taste it over the pork and baguette. The pork and bread were delicious but that doesn't make a Bahn Mi sandwich. My boyfriend got the Rueben. It had a slab of corned beef which was a bit chewy. His favorite part of the dish was the French fries. Which he said were some of the best he's had. It's such a great space. I really hope they can step their food game up a bit!! read more

See all

This place has an outstanding selection whiskey. We tried a few kinds per the owners suggestion. The owner was very nice. I enjoyed his conversation and knowledge of the different whiskeys. We tried Four Roses, Heaven Hill and Pappy Van Winkle. Heaven hill was my favorite because it was smooth and a little sweeter than the others. We ordered food and it was OK , not the best. I got a Ruben with fries. The corn beef was good. it was seasoned and cooked well. The sauerkraut was so plan, no seasoning or anything. It was like they took it right out of the can or bag and put it on the sandwich. Plus it was only on one half of my sandwich so I had to wait for more to put on my other half. The wait was way to long for plan sauerkraut. The fries were good and crispy. My boyfriend got the loaded nachos. They were not the best. The brisket was very good and tender but they didn't season it with any Spanish/ Mexican flavors. It was just plan shredded beef. They only used a Mexican blend shredded cheese instead of nacho cheese too so when it got cold it turned hard. My 4 stars is for the great whiskey and our great conversation with the owner. read more

See all

They did not have a bartender so could not make any drinks. My taco salad had black slimy lettuce in it. Flavor was very bland. They served tarter sauce with the taco salad and I had to ask them to swap for sour cream. Service was friendly but slow. read more

In town for Mothers Day to visit our son at SUNY Brockport. thought this would be a good place to Eat and Have a Drink. ordered our food and French onion soup as appetizer. 20 minutes later we were told no French onion soup. Took 45 minutes to get our food. I ordered a Ruben sandwich. The toast was burnt and the corned beef was like beef jerky. slow service and unfortunately, I do not think I would visit this place again. read more

I've gotten food from this restaurant a few times over the years and every time it gets worse and worse. The last time I ordered a meal was "chicken French"... I can't even call it that. It was fried, not dredged, chicken over bow tie pasta that was 2 minutes to being Al dente, a sad lemon sauce and no escarole, which was supposed to be in the dish. It's an abomination. I've eaten chicken french from many restaurants but never has it been this horrible. This will be our last time getting food from custom house. read more

We will not be returning. We've come here several times and the service and food are hit or miss. Food is different every time you order it. We like trivia so we keep coming back. The last straw was being given a pitcher of water for our table. We got to the bottom and there were multiple flies stuck to the bottom of the pitcher. When we told our server she acted unsurprised and said sorry and asked if we wanted anything else. Nope, all set. read more

We waited 15 minutes for our waiter to take our order for appetizers. We had to go to the bar to ask someone to send him over. When we ordered our dinner we waited another 45 minutes for mediocre food. Do not waste your time or money on this place. read more

Best Bloody Mary I've ever had! For just $10, you can have lunch and a cocktail! This bad boy comes with half a creamy and delicious grilled cheese, bacon and shrimp! We also ordered the chicken sandwich with melted gruyere cheese and the corn beef hash brunch. Both were filling and satisfying! I definitely recommend stopping by for brunch! read more

See all

We've visited the establishment 3-4 times over the past 2 years. Each time is more disappointing than the last. Food is fine, typical pub food. Should you choose to try this place, give at least 2 full hours to have your order taken, then wait until your food comes out. We were there yesterday for lunch. We waited for 15 mins until the bar tender came to take our drink order: 2 iced teas and a water. 10 mins later, the iced tea arrived and it was basically colored water. 10 mins after than, she came to take our meal order. We asked for something different to drink. My husband tried to order a beer. They were out of both of his first two choices, landed on a third, I ordered a club soda and we all gave out orders: a total of 3 burgers and fries. Our New drinks can over fairly quickly, a little over a half hour later, our food had not come, nobody stopped by our table to check on us or even to acknowledge the length of time we were waiting. I got up, and asked one of the servers if he could help find out where our food was (our original server was stuck behind the bar) he said he didn't know, he just got in and went into the kitchen to check. Coming out, He let us know 'the burgers are on the grill'. During the next half hour to 40 mins, we watched waitstaff, including our original server as they went by our table several times carrying orders to tables seated after us. Again, never stopping to see how we were, let us know what was happening. We understand kitchens get behind, servers get over seated, things happen, but the fact that not one person acknowledged our table or how long we had been there was the last straw. We put a 5 on the table to pay for the beer and club soda and walked out after close to two hours. read more

It's okay food at a cheap price, decent whiskey on the canal which is cool. slow service though

Fantastic selection of whiskey. Even more fantastic grilled cheese. Mellow for a post-multi-mile run. I will be back...