I don't very often write reviews, but I had to write one today because the team at Max & Erma's in…read moreErie was absolutely AMAZING yesterday and completely saved my day!! I cannot thank them enough!! I had placed an online order through DoorDash for 28 people to be picked up on a Monday morning. I paid for my order and was given a pick-up window of 11:35-11:45 AM. On my way to pick up the order on Monday morning...at 11 AM...DoorDash sent me a text cancelling my order...stating the restaurant was unable to fulfill the order. I immediately called the restaurant and showed up around 11:20 (which was to be for the 11:35 pick-up). The restaurant had never even received the order to make the decision whether or not the restaurant was able to fulfill it!! SHANE and NINA at the Erie location WERE AMAZING!!! They led their team and fulfilled my complete order in 30 minutes--AND helped me carry it to my car!! They truly saved my day...and lunch for 28 people who were waiting!!! If I could give them 10 stars on a 5-star scale, I would!! Thank you all!!

We were excited to try somewhere new. But highly disappointed. Not sure if they were short staffed…read moreor what was going on. Took 5 minutes for anyone to approach us. 10 for anyone to ask us what we would like to drink which wasn't even our waitress. Our drinks came out wrong. Our food came out wrong and we did not receive extra plates or napkins. When we walked in there was tables full of dirty dishes and no one cleaning them.

I love taking my granddaughters there atleast once a month. The service is good and the custard is…read moregreat.

Loved it. He had a concrete? I had a Sunday. First time at a Rita's where have you been all my…read morelife. I love ice cream, custard, gelato and I truly appreciate great service. Walked up and asked how it works. Very patient explained what they offer. I would have a photo but you'll just have to trust me on this one. The large Sunday was delich. Carmel and fudge on vanilla. It was dinner and it was with worth the calories. Thank you!

I had mint chocolate chip; my friend had coffee Oreo. Both tasted amazing. Very good ice cream…read more Service is friendly and efficient: one window "order", the other "pick up". A lot of locals here, which is telltale sign of a solid place.

We really enjoyed stopping here on our way through town. I had their new flavor, lemon blueberry…read morecream pie, and I loved it! I typically like custard, but this converted me. The staff was unbelievingly friendly and let you know that they appreciated your business. Great find

2/8/2026 Ate list:…read more Country Fried Steak & Eggs - 9.6 Back in late high school/early college, the original Dave's Diner was open on Perry Square. It was a top 3 breakfast in town for me. I mourned their closing and was hopeful when I heard they would return. But I felt like, there's no way they could measure up to the original. They exceeded my memory. New location embody a throwback and is more spacious than the original. Service was kind and fast. And the country fried steak and eggs was some of the best I've ever had. Every bite was extraordinary. I love this place. Welcome back Dave's. I too will be back.

Nice little spot on the corner. Food came out fast and was delicious. Jace, our server was…read morefriendly. Will come back and recommend giving them a try.

What a surprise tasty treat! We tried a turkey sausage, two…read morekinds of hot dogs,a maple milkshake! Plus a mix of cotton candy ice cream, oreo, peanut butter, strawberry drizzle, PLUS snickers sprinkling!!! Everything was on point! Fun atmosphere with outside games and tables too! They have so many options. Stop on in!! Currently check out the little toys etc too! Would make great trick or treating hand outs

I was here a few times when it was Fat Lenny's and I happened to be next door and was surprised to…read moresee it open. And so I treated myself to some rolled ice cream! The price is fair and the ice cream is pretty darn good. I quite enjoy it and will have to return there soon for another. I'm hankering for some Oreo Cookies & Ice Cream and assume they have this. They make the rolled ice cream in front of you and have a large selection of toppings. They also sell some food there which I don't believe happened when it was Fat Lenny's. If you want some solid ice cream in Erie then hit up Mad Millz.

We just had their new (new?) ice cream sandwiches and they were amazing! I would recommend the…read moreraspberry lemon above others, we split the two. The other only has a superficial outer layer of candy coating. All in all, worth a quick trip around the bend!

First time at Gary's. On the whole I liked it. Pizza was solid--fresh dough, sauce that had a good…read moreflavor, and nice amount of cheese. Also had wings (2 flavors). They were ok. Wings should've been crisper, as they were a little undercooked. I'd definitely try Gary's again. I'd just order extra crispy wings.

I am very picky. I don't like chain restaurants and I like food that actually tastes good. I prefer…read moreto dine in nice locally owned places. This particular day I wanted something different and was down for a short drive. The first place that came to mind was the Waterford Hotel. I don't think I've ever eaten there prior. It was packed but we were seated immediately. They had a stuffed chicken breast on special that was my first choice. They were out of it so I settled on the 5oz sirloin steak with mushrooms and onions from the lighter menu. My partner chose the tavern turkey dinner that came with stuffing and gravy. Totally drool worthy. Almost every menu item comes with soup or salad, a roll, vegetable, and your choice of potato. It was like having a nice home cooked meal. This was my favorite part. The portions were perfect and all the food was delicious. I would return here weekly.

Mistakes Happen, Disrespect Doesn't…read more My friend and I ordered wings, which took a very long time to come out. When mine finally arrived, the order was completely wrong. I didn't eat them--I sent them back and politely asked for them to be removed from the bill. My friend got a box for his food and despite the experience, still left a tip. When we walked to our car, the waiter and other staff members proceeded to flip us off, give us thumbs-down gestures, and stare us down through the windows until we drove away. Why should I be expected to pay for or eat something I didn't order? Mistakes happen, but treating customers this way for respectfully addressing a mistake is extremely immature and unprofessional. Customers spend their hard-earned money to support your business and deserve basic respect. Your staff represents your business. If management allows this kind of behavior to continue without addressing it, it reflects poorly on the entire establishment and sends the message that treating customers this way is acceptable. We won't be returning.

Every single time I go here they mess my order up AND/OR forget something. Absolute worst Taco Bell…read moreto go to in erie. Every single time Stop putting that damn chipotle sauce on everything too my mouth be hurting

The last three times I've stopped here, the internet has been down and they aren't taking orders…read more Do yourselves a favor and go any where else.