I stopped in for a Salted Caramel Coconut Iced Latte, and wow... it was absolutely delicious. The flavors were perfectly balanced, smooth, and refreshing without being overly sweet. What really stood out to me was the atmosphere. The space is clean, bright, cozy, and surprisingly peaceful. There are plenty of comfortable seating options, making it a great spot to bring your laptop and get some work done, read a book, or simply enjoy a quiet break from the day. The staff was friendly and welcoming from the moment I walked in, and everything felt well cared for and inviting. I found myself wanting to stay longer than I planned. If you're looking for a coffee shop with great drinks, a relaxing vibe, and a space where you can actually hear yourself think, this is it. I'll definitely be back. Elite Tip: Grab a drink, bring a good book, and settle in for a while. This place makes it easy to slow down and enjoy the moment. read more

See all

Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen definitely deserves 5 stars. The space is clean, bright, and open, with a great overall vibe. The food and drinks were excellent, and the prices felt very reasonable for the quality. We ordered: Yogurt -- 5/5. Fresh and delicious. Cold Brew Coffee -- 4/5. Very good and refreshing. Blueberry Matcha Latte -- 5/5. Fresh, clean, and reminded me of Hawaii. Avocado Toast -- 5/5. Healthy but still packed with flavor. The sautéed red onions really made it stand out. They also have a restroom, parking, and a great variety of food and pastries. Overall, one of the best coffee spots I've visited recently. Definitely coming back. read more

See all

The food and coffee were good but definitely not worth the price point. We did enjoy eating outside but some palm trees or other foliage would add to ambiance. I would consider coming to sit inside during the winter to work or read for a while. read more

Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen - Salted Caramel Coconut Latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

I've been here twice, Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen has cracked the B.E.C. recipe and takes the crown for the best breakfast in Port Jefferson Harbor. Friday mornings, I take my B.E.C. breakfast very seriously. If you give me a sloppy mess for breakfast (Like a well known deli not too far down the road) I'll wish you well and take you out of my rotation. First time here, I wanted to see what the hubbub was all about so I stopped in for a latte and a savory muffin. Both the coffee and the muffin were baked very well. Today is B.E.C. Friday! I walked up to the window and was greeted by a cheerful hostess. I ordered the *Sayville's B.E.C. I asked about the bun which is freshly made on Long Island and I asked for the eggs to be softly scrambled. This B.E.C. is a banger! Made with Cage-free eggs, sautéed bacon and American cheese. They top it with some arugula and finish it on a toasted brioche bun. Also, the B.E.C comes with a side of potato chips? I mean, is this a Sayville thing? Those Bougie Sayville customers. Well the B.E.C. from Sayville? It rocks. They cracked the B.E.C code for sure, the eggs were not overcooked, very soft and fluffy. The toasted bun? Every NY B.E.C. should now have their bun toasted. Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen, I welcome you to the neighborhood. This is a large space with good seating. *Tim and Dre, welcome to Port Jeff Village. Listen, you gotta drop the Sayville thing. Port Jeff B.E.C. or The Culver B.E.C. would be a good name. As Billy Joel once famously said, "either you date a rich girl from the North Shore, or a cool girl from the South Shore" Welcome to the North Shore! read more

See all

Mhmmm so good. Everything I have gotten there has satisfied my craving and hunger. Honestly what I can't stop thinking about are there vegan nugs. Tastes just like chicken. Service is simple! Just order at the counter and find a seat! They'll bring everything out to you. I love sitting outside but inside has some very cute lounge seating and regular seats as well. read more

See all

Excellent coffee with some refreshingly different options for breakfast and lunch. Attentive, friendly staff. Will definitely go back

This place is wonderful! I went here for the first time with a mom's group, 4 of us with newborns all under 6 months. We felt welcomed and taken care of by the staff immediately! They offered high chairs, asked us what we needed, gave us space to let the babies play. We were comfy and able to relax without being in the way of other customers. The bathroom has a changing table too! The food and coffee were also delicious. Big menu that's full of great vegan options and it's easy to make lots of things gluten free. I first tried the oatmeal and it was great, a huge serving with yummy fruit on top. Went back a week later and got the little donkey with bacon, sooooooo yummy! It comes with a bag of chips. My sister got the Fig & Brie which she loved, and the coconut wild rice soup which was out of this world. Everything is plated beautifully and comes out fast and hot. I am so glad this place opened in port jeff - somewhere comfy which great food and service to meet friends for coffee and a bite to eat. It's clear the owners and staff know how to run a great operation. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

So excited about the second location of Dark Horse! I've tried so many things from here and have never been disappointed. My favorite is the cinnamon honey shaken espresso. Perfect amount of sweetness to coffee. The location is huge with a bunch of places to sit and enjoy your coffee or food. The owners are the nicest people & the employees are very attentive and knowledgeable. I highly recommend adding dark horse to your weekly rotation. read more

See all

Best coffee shop on Long Island!!This new location is beautiful with plenty of seating both inside and out, including a few different rooms and options like couches for hanging out with friends or tables for getting work done. They also have plenty of parking spots. The employees are always friendly and the service is fast. Every month, they feature drink and food specialties that I recommend trying. My go-to is the cinnamon honey shaken espresso, order this if you go!!! read more

Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

Soooo good I was so impressed with how yummy my breakfast sandwich was!! The bread is buttered and fresh and it's packed full of the fixings!! I also got a hot latte with their Irish cream syrup which was really delicious. My date got their honey cinnamon shaken espresso - HAVEEEE to get this, it was so iconic. The employees were all super kind and helpful. Even though the place was packed, we got our food pretty fast! Lots of seating and a great spot to hang out, do work, and enjoy read more

See all

This review is a few weeks late but as they say, "better late than never". Ok I was there with some friends on a Friday. It was my first time, but it seems like coffee shops are popping up all over the area. It's amazing, everyone of them is busy all the time. This coffee hop is a little different. A few years back it was a deli. I went there once and that was enough for me. But I noticed this building undergoing a renovation. So there's about 8 of us and impossible for all of us to sit together. So coffee, any kind you like and a few I've never had. I chose a coffee with turmeric. Well healthy anyway. The menu offers many items which I'll try at a different time. Big bonus, they have a rooftop deck with a view of Port Jefferson harbor. Looking forward to sitting there in the summer. So for now I was very pleased and plan to go back. read more

dark horse is a new café located in port jefferson. i went on a weekday morning, and it was very busy. it was hard to find a seat, and it seemed like everyone wanted to check out this new spot. they have a fairly extensive menu. i opted for the chai tea, which, compared to other chai teas i've had, tasted a bit watery and leaned more on the sweet side, with fewer spices than i expected. i tried the tomato mozzarella panini and it was pretty standard. they do have an extensive food menu, and honestly everything sounded really good, so i'd be open to coming back to try the food. while the chai wasn't my favorite, i'd be willing to try other coffee or drink options in the future. just note that seating can be difficult to find, so you may have to wait a bit. overall, everyone was nice, and the food and drinks came out in under 10 minutes. read more

See all

I tried this place out with my wife and we both really enjoyed the food and snacks they had. Unfortunately, we did not really enjoy their coffee or latte. There was a slight burnt taste in their espresso's and drip coffee. We've also been to another location on Long Island and had the same experience. However, the location and ambience of the café is really nice. inside they had multiple types of seating for both eating and relaxing. Overall, I would come here to get a quick lunch but would be getting my coffee elsewhere. read more

Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Tim and Dre opened their second location. It has private parking and the space inside is spacious! Outside seating available, lounge seating, or regular tables. The food and drinks are always on point. Today I went with the smoked salmon avocado toast and my husband got the Chorizo & Fontina burrito. Great staff! Very welcoming and attentive. Congrats Tim and Dre on your 2nd location! read more

See all

Very good food and great service. Whenever we have eaten here food has been consistent and yummy. Drinks are awesome as well!!

Great space, coffee & food. But what sets this place apart is the staff. They always have abundant workers keeping the joint spotless & well oiled, and they really do deliver service with a smile. read more

Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen - great tasting coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

This coffee shop is located right at the bottom of the hill on your way downport. Parking can be tricky as this place is so busy however you can park in the marina if you have the Brookhaven town pass or around the corner at a free parking lot that is a 5 minute walk away. The building itself it very well designed with a surprisingly large space. They also seem to have a cute little outdoor space which I look forward to experiencing once the weather gets warmer. I am so impressed with the food at this shop! My favorite "go to" is any of the chicken wraps with the peach avocado side salad (which is huge BTW). I have tried the coffee and matcha and it is okay however the food completely makes up for it. Their portions are enormous and the quality of the food is very high. I really cannot express enough how delicious the food is, I highly recommend! Additionally the service is efficient and they have someone constantly walking around and checking in on you to make sure you have utensils, napkins and that everything is how it should be. I purchased a hand full of gift cards during the holiday season for my family and friends so they can also experience this place! read more

See all

Me and my wife love this place. Dark Horse Coffee and Kitchen is exactly what Port Jeff needed and somehow they still went above and beyond anything we expected. The second you walk in, the vibe is just different. The service is on another level and honestly the best customer service I've ever had anywhere. Everyone there is warm, thoughtful, and you can tell they actually care about what they're doing. It shows. And the food... It's ridiculous. Easily the most intentional, well-put-together menu I've ever seen. You can tell every dish is crafted with purpose. The flavors hit, the ingredients are high quality, the presentation is clean and the coffee is insane. Everything they do is world-class. This place is the blueprint for how a business should run. Quality, hospitality, pride, everything. Port Jeff is lucky to have them. If you haven't been yet, just go. You'll get it as soon as you sit down. read more

Everything here is delicious and everyone is so nice. Recently had my daughter's baby shower catered by Dark Horse and our guests were still talking about the food the next day! read more

Awesome addition to Port Jefferson, love the clean modern aesthetic. We enjoyed our BEC, oatmeal and lattes. Very friendly staff and owners. read more

Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen - BEC, Oatmeal and lattes - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Food ..... both delicious and healthy options. Relaxed vibe for work or for a quick bite!! Will return often...... Service is great ! read more

I live and work locally and I love dark horse. Delicious food and coffee and a great atmosphere. I've come here with friends, to do work and with my kids and it's great for all 3! read more

Overall a big fan of DHC&K. Live in PJ Village and though there are some good breakfast/coffee spots in the Village, Dark Horse was a nice addition. Staff is super friendly and helpful. Order at the counter and coffee/food is brought to your table. Everything my wife and I have tried, both coffee and food, has been great. We've been there at least a dozen times. Here's the only little pet peeve. They only have plastic utensils. Food is served on wooden boards topped with paper. Makes for a nice presentation but if you order anything that requires cutting, like say one of the avocado toasts, it's impossible to cut with a little plastic knife on paper that is sliding everywhere. It's a mess! Please invest in metal utensils! That's all! read more

This coffee shop is truly something special! It's the kind of place that effortlessly invites you to settle in to work, meet friends, or gather socially. The atmosphere is welcoming and comfortable, and it's clear a lot of thought went into creating a space people genuinely want to be in -- from the lighting and color scheme to the overall ambiance, the variety of coffee options with add-ins, the stellar food offerings, and the friendly, approachable staff that make the experience delightful! The coffee is consistently excellent, with a great variety of options that taste just as good as they look. And the food? Plentiful, fresh, and delicious -- with thoughtful gluten-free and vegetarian options -there is truly something for everyone! What really sets this place apart is the team behind it! Tim and Dre are incredibly personable and hands-on, and it shows. They clearly care about their customers and about how their staff shows up each day. The service is friendly, attentive, and warm -- the kind that makes you feel like a regular even on your first visit. This second location is just as impressive as the first (Sayville and now Port Jeff Village), and in some ways even better, thanks to the spacious layout. If you're looking for great coffee, amazing food, and a place that feels both lively and welcoming, this is it -- without a doubt! read more

The food was delicious, fairly priced, and came out super fast. The employees were super attentive, checked in on us and cleared our table for us and were super kind. The place was cozy, welcoming and there was a ton of seating. Coffee was great too! Will be going back for sure. read more

Great place incredible food super friendly staff. Nice lounge area very comfortable setting