Definitely one of our favorite steakhouses in Brooklyn. The filet mignon was pure perfection.. I highly recommend this cut, it was definitely worth the price and came out beautiful tender and perfecly cooked. Love the creamed spinach as well, I find it better than most other steakhouses because it isn't just drowned in cream sauce. The service was polished without being stuffy, very classic old school vibes. The atmosphere classic but lively, and the entire experience felt elevated without trying too hard. From the cocktails to dessert, everything was on point. Honestly, it's better than Peter Luger. More consistent, more flavorful, and a far better overall vibe. read more

One of the variety of steakhouses in Williamsburg that offer great steaks. They have a wonderful ribeye which is flavorful and hits the spot. A mixed cocktail menu that has variety. Ambiance was standard but didn't give off the steakhouse atmosphere feel. It's a good spot for steak if in the area. For Williamsburg though there are other steakhouses that stand out more in the field. read more

See all

This place has been on my list for years. I'm giving up meat starting Jan 2nd for a month so why not enjoy some juicy steak. Please get the short rib rolls. There's mash potatoes in it as well as the ribs and some carrots. I'm not sure what the dipping sauce was but 2 thumbs up. The Caesar salad was just what I needed. By the time I finished both appetizers I was full lol Now on to the entrees- my son and I shared the porterhouse- medium. It was thick, juicy but needed more flavor for me. My son agreed. This doesn't mean I wouldn't return. I do which they had cracked black pepper and sea salt. The sides- creamed corn- perfection Creamed spinach- I would pass on this. Lacked taste Mash potatoes- lovely The owned walked around and checked in on us twice. He even gave me a drink on the house. Thank you ! read more

See all

This was an excellent experience, I'll start there. The service was absolutely perfect. The best anyone could possibly ask for. They go out of their way to make sure you have everything you could ever want. The restaurant is quiet, nicely laid out and the decor screams classic Brooklyn. I started with the sweet and spicy bacon appetizer and it was excellent. Nice little bit of back end heat, great pork belly and sweet with a slight crust. For dinner I have an absolutely perfect 12oz filet, with their house made shallot steak sauce which was incredible. Paired with a sidecar which again, flawless bar, and a special side of bacon Brussel sprouts. I finished with tiramisu. The only reason I can't give 5 stars was one, the room was freezing cold, the sprouts while well cooked just tasted like bacon fat and for the price, it's just gotta be perfect to get 5 stars from me at this level. Still, better than Peter Lugers in my opinion and I'd be back for sure for the tiramisu alone. read more

See all

Met up here for a birthday celebration. Service and food were great! You need to find parking on the street FYI read more

See all

DeStefano's steakhouse provides quality food with quality service. This steakhouse is dimly lit but sets a nice tone to the place. And while it doesn't present itself on the outside or inside like an upscale steakhouse, the quality of everything is that of one. Our waitress was attentive and friendly the entire evening. We started with the short rib rolls and the Caesar salad. The short rib rolls were full of delicious short rib and stuffed with mashed potatoes making the most decadent appetizer. The Caesar salad was one of the best I've ever had. The salad was perfectly dressed and so crispy. The croutons were also crunchy. I couldn't get enough! The ribeye steak was perfectly seasoned and was on the fattier side but it is a ribeye! I loved every bite and it was cooked a perfect medium rare. It paired perfectly with the mashed potatoes and the special of brussel sprouts. I did think the brussel sprouts were a little softer than I'd like as I prefer them a little crispy but they were so good cooked with bacon! Overall, I really enjoyed it here and would love to come back! read more

See all

For my Mother's Day I was craving a nice hearty steak with my small companion in amazing ambiance ! I searched on Yelp. I saw a couple of steakhouses in Brooklyn on Yelp but they were all booked. I made a reservation for 630.As soon as we entered, we were greeted with such a warm and positive welcome by Mr. Destafano ! He sat us at a table showed us all the nice pictures from the neighborhood, fellows and friends, and also actors that grew up in the area. He Got a highchair for my small companion and as soon as we were seated, we got bread and butter, as well as a bacon covered date with walnuts. It was a nice treat.. I ordered a Negroni while browsing the menu. I really want to try a ribeye or porterhouse, but I knew I couldn't eat it all so I opted for an 8 ounce filet mignon which was absolutely delicious. Cooked medium rare melted in my mouth seasoned perfectly. Mr. Destefano asked if I wanted my steak sliced, which I appreciated. because the waiter didn't ask me that, I got the cream style corn, which was delicious and garlic mashed potatoes. Overall the service everyone was very attentive, kind & accommodating, you feel like you're going to your Italian uncles house for a steak dinner so I'll be back Uncle Destefano. I need to try my ribeye or porterhouse steak next.! read more

See all

I came here to celebrate Thanksgiving last year after searching for spots that would be open on the holiday. On arrival, we decided to sit at the bar and got some drink recommendations from the lovely bartender- I forgot her name! There was a Thanksgiving menu but we decided to go with some steaks and side dishes. Everything was amazing- I absolutely love the creamed corn. I wish I lived closer by so I could eat here more often. The service and quality of the food/drinks is amazing and the space is very cozy. I would recommend DeStefano's for a date night or even for a delicious warm up to a night out in the area. read more

DeStefano's Steakhouse - Drink menu - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

DeStefano's is by far the best steakhouse in Brooklyn -- most certainly one of the absolute best in NYC. The vibe is wonderful--warm, cozy, neighborhood feels. The restaurant is so welcoming and the walls covered with photos of personalities who have come through the doors. The service is magnificent. Our server was absolutely wonderful. She was knowledgeable, personable, and took care of us so very well. Joe, the owner, is kind, welcoming and walked through the restaurant a few times, to each table, to assure everyone was pleased. Then there is the food. The care that goes into the food is so obvious. From preparation to presentation to taste, the food is absolutely incredible. We started with the Bacon. So flavorful and juicy. Then, we had the 12oz filet mignon. I've never seen a 12oz version in other steakhouses We also had the 24oz Ribeye. Both were perfect. The garlic mashed potatoes, and special Brussel sprouts were wonderful. The creamed spinach was my absolute favorite side. We ended with the mousse cake and it was simply perfect. DeStefano's is no joke. The vibe, food, and service will have you wanting to come back again and again. read more

See all

DeStafano's Steakhouse is such a gem of a steakhouse. Eating here feels like eating at gramdma's cottage with a such cozy dinning room. Service is very warm and welcoming and even more so with my toddler dinning with us which is not always the case at many other steakhouses. Favorites here are the sweet and spicy bacon (must try), brussel sprouts, and the infamous porterhouse for two. The bacon provide such a balance of flavors which complimented this flavorful cut of meat. The brussel sprouts were seasoned perfectly with the sweet taste of aged balsamic vinegar. Lastly the porterhouse was cooked a perfect medium rare and had a great sear. Overall, I highly recommend DeStefano's if you are looking for a steakhouse in the Brooklyn area. read more

See all

I like a more seasoned steak but the food was good. Garlic mashed potatoes were great as well. We enjoyed the winter lemon drop and the espresso martini's Would definitely return. read more

DeStefano's Steakhouse - Espresso martini & winter lemon drop - Steakhouses Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The ribeye steak is phenomenal. All the sides are delicious. It will cost you a pretty penny but the food is great. Wait staff was attentive and welcoming. The restaurant is a traditional steakhouse feel, with photo lined walls and designed for conversation and laughs. Will dine again read more

This place had such a cozy dining area. The staff was very friendly. Our server was attentive and very knowledgeable on the menu. We started with a few appetizers. The French onion soup was so cheesy and hot. The sweet and spicy bacon was grilled and had a kick to it. The crabcakes were creamy and baked two perfection. They literally melted it in your mouth. The cream corn was very creamy and baked, which gave it a crispy top layer of Parmesan. The steak was so flavorful and it was the perfect amount for two people the butter juice that it was soaked in was simply amazing. It was so flavorful it didn't need any sauces. read more

See all

We made a reservation for 7:30 got seated sat there for 20 minutes. No one even took our drink order even though other tables that came after us were serviced. Ended up walking up after being so excited to give it a try since we live in the area. So disappointed. I will say when we walked out one server did try to fix it and apologetic even though it wasnt his fault and we did get a call after leaving but still disappointed. doubt we will go back. read more

Went there last night. I had a good meal ordered the rib steak with the bone for 24 ounces. Was delicious , but was smaller than I thought it would be. Would not recommend splitting it. Everything was first rate , including service. read more

See all

I took my mom to this restaurant again for her birthday. The new location is not far from the old location and the decorations of the place are the same. Menu also the same or pretty close to last time my mom was here too. Steak is always great and I love bacon so much. My family enjoy so much and I'm happy that I take her out to her favorite restaurant. read more

This is a great NYC steakhouse. Food was very tasty and drinks were nicely made. Service was excellent as well. The restaurant also has both a casual and traditional vibe to it. I will definitely be back again and recommend this spot! read more

Went for the steak, left knowing that if I ever returned it would be for that glorious pork chop It's dark, it's old school, it's straight forward, the steak wasn't what I thought it would be l, and the porkchop was absolutely next level! read more

See all

I had a lovely experience here. I'm a little bummed I didn't take any photos. The drinks were great not too sweet, not to tart , just right. The steak was amazing. I honestly cannot wait to go back. I also enjoyed the crab cakes, it was moist and delectable .The waiter was very nice and was knowledgeable in the menu. He was able to steer me and my party in the right direction regarding sides and appetizers. The restaurant itself was nice . I enjoyed the Christmas decorations. read more

"Pork chop is incredible. Clover club and the NY sour were amazing. Wedge salad is underrated" I decided to head back and give DeStefano's another go. We came in on a Tuesday early in the night. It was nice for a quiet dinner. Our server had amazing recommendations and paid attention to the details. There wasn't a single second where we were waiting for him to come back around. For starters, we got the short rib rolls, which were something unique. They were each filled with a generous portion of meat. They came with a horseradish sauce, that was SO good. The wedge salad was served on a chilled plate and was seriously so good. You like Wedge salads, definitely try this one. For entrees, we got chicken cordon bleu and the pork chop. The pork chop was SO MOIST. Like criminally moist. It was the star of the show. The chicken was good, and a big portion. We got a small creamed corn for our side. The small is a good option for two people. We easily finished it. So cheesy. Our cocktails were both recommended by our server and he wasn't wrong. Clover club was fresh, a perfect summer cocktail. The Sour had red wine and bourbon, and they paired so well?? I would have never guessed. We also had to try espresso martinis for dessert. Perfect closer to a big dinner. read more

See all

The food was prepared perfectly. The staff were attentive and the service was excellent. The decor is charming and homey our server Jennifer was amazing . read more

See all

Absolutely delicious! one of the best steaks I have had in my life. Service was stellar, as well.

We chose DeStefanos as it was close to a show we were seeing on a Saturday night. We arrived at 5:30pm and were seated immediatley. It seemed rather quiet for a Saturday. She had the pistachio crusted lamb chopped. I really wanted the steak but hesitated as it was pricey. At the waiter's recommendation I went ahead and ordered the NY Strip. Both entrees were very good. Service was excellent. We needed the leftovers wrapped creatively as we ubering to a show and had to smuggle them in and out. The waiter was very accomodating. The only thing stopping a 5 star review was the price of the steak. read more

I love the food here, it's easy to get a reservation& it is in a perfect area. every time I go here, the food is amazing. I normally sit at the bar and the bartender is always a 10 out of 10. read more

The steaks were delicious. The waitstaff were very friendly and accommodating. Definitely will go back again.

Delicious steak dinner. Good portion sizes. Went to celebrate my retirement and happy with food, service and ambiance. Wait staff was helpful, friendly, and knowledgeable. Expensive but worth it. I didn't have room for dessert but had a spoonful of icecream in a chocolate shell and it was yummy! read more

See all

Service was excellent, filet was cooked perfectly and delicious. Crab meat appetizer was great. Would definitely come again.

We come here to celebrate special occasions! We love the atmosphere, the service, the neighborhood vibe... the food is incredible and it's never too crowded or loud. Best Porkchop I've ever had!! The crab cakes are good too! read more

Great steak. Simple but comfortable atmosphere fitting in Brooklyn neighborhood. Close to subway.

The food was spectacular. We got a NY Strip and a ribeye and they literally melted like butter. For sides we got the garlic mash which were Devine, and green beans which were good. Very crunchy. Service was amazing. The decor is cozy and classy at the same time. read more

As usual, this place feels like an old school trip to older steakhouses. The staff were nice, and the food is great. The Caesar salad was amazing, and the steak is a can't miss. read more

Food is AMAZING! Visiting my daughter in Williamsburg and we decided to go to DeStefano's for dinner. Pork chop, wedge salad, stuffed portobello, maple glazed carrots and garlic mashed. Almost forgot the prosciutto wrapped asparagus! All 10/10! Our waitress was from Ireland and was attentive and quick, but smooth. We had a really good time and will return. The pork chop was a star . Best I've EVER had! We will return. Attractive ambience! Clean and semi-dark, quiet place! read more

So I'm going to try and not be overly critical, but it's going be a challenge... I brought my boyfriend out for dinner tonight, hoping to celebrate my promotion locally, instead of traveling to the city for a nice dinner. I did my research and the reviews were so good, that I'm a bit confused of people's expectations for a dinner at the price point. A 4.5 star rating is very GENEROUS! We made a reservation for 8 PM and showed up at 7:45 PM. The bartender greeted us and sat us, (her personality was impeccable and so friendly - ideal hospitality energy). We got some sparkling water and a beautiful bottle of wine that was just divine. There was also a fantastic selection for a local restaurant. We ordered the Porterhouse for two, the pear salad, creamed parmesan corn, green beans with pancetta, and the garlic mashed potatoes. It came with two complementary rolls and butter. The salad came, it was KILLER, and I was so excited for the meal, as everything had been excellent so far. Then the main meal came... and what a disappointment! The steak was warm, and the oil was not even sizzling on arrival, the sides were all luke warm, not hot. Everything was just so utterly bland. It just had little to flavor, very little salt, no seasoning other than garlic and pepper, no herbs, no nothing. The creamed corn was just milky, the green beans were not crisp, but quite limp, however the garlic mashed potatoes were delicious. But can you really screw up mashed potatoes? I knew not to order to dessert, as the portions looked minuscule online, so we just asked for the bill at the end of meal. Our server was very pleasant, but I felt life for this price point, the service should be almost annoying - Similarly to Peter Luger. Especially as they are trying to mimic that type of environment it seems. For the two of us, it was $348.00... but for what was presented and the level of service, I would have expected the price point to be about $100 less than that. The restaurant wasn't even busy, there were three tables of two and one four top for two servers. But based on the customer base present during our meal, it seems to attract big ego men looking to take low brow women for a "high end" dinner experience where they don't want to be seen. But alas, price does not dictate quality. I wouldn't recommend for some someone celebrating something. There are far better restaurants for less money in the area that will whet the pallet throughly! Seek other options. read more

See all

Amazing steak and sides!! I'm 54 years old and could honestly say it's the best steak house I ever been to!! Been over 4 times and it gets better and better!! read more

This steakhouse is awesome. I had a 24oz. Prime Ribeye that was tender, flavorful, and broiled to perfection. My brother had a 16oz. Filet mignon that was equally delicious. The appetizers and side dishes were a worthy addition to the steaks. Service was impeccable and quick. Everyone raves about Peter Lugers , but DeStefano's gives it a run for its money. I've dined there several times and each time the meal was great. My friends and family love the food and you will too. read more

Good Customer service Ambiance Food was flavorful Drinks not watered down Wait staff knowledgeable about drinks and dishes read more

This place has AMAZING FOOD ... nice service and the owner walks around checking on you! Amazing time!! This place has a nice vibe and atmosphere! read more

See all

Took my bf here for his birthday dinner and we had such a great time! Very nice old school Italian steakhouse in a neighborhood. I loved the decor and service! We ordered the Cesar salad, ny strip steak, mahi mahi, garlic mashed potatoes, and crème brûlée cheesecake. Winners were the steak, mashed potatoes and cheesecake. Portions were huge and we actually fell into a food coma afterwards and went to bed very early. Amazing food and a great place to dine on special occasions! read more

See all

Had a great dinner at DeStefano everything was delicious. Great service. Steak cook and quality was excellent. Only thing missing is that sizzling presentation other big name steakhouses do. Was a little disappointed to not hear that beautiful steak coming to the table. However the the texture and quality of the steak was so good I would definitely return again. read more

See all

This restaurant is pretty good. The food is great and service is awesome. You should definitely check it out . read more