I made a purchase via the phone after seeing an item on the website. Evan was extremely helpful and answered all my questions. The item was shipped the same day I made the purchase and arrived carefully packaged with a lovely note and a velvet storage pouch. The bracelet is unique and the highest quality. It was delight to do business with Dewitt from beginnIng to end and I would not hesitate to purchase from them again. read more

Tucked away in the arcade and worth the walk. Evan is knowledgeable and very helpful. I wanted something special to celebrate a life event and Evan knew exactly what I wanted. Other stores had similar items that were significantly smaller for a much higher price. The selection was wide and I came out with the perfect item. Thanks again for many years of beautiful jewelry. read more

Went in to sell jewelry to these professionals and not only did they give me a good price but were kind enough to let me come back later when they were closed. Highly recommend. Professional, kind, fair. read more

This hidden gem in Cleveland is a great place to buy or sell jewelry. From the moment I walked in, I was promptly greeted even though they were busy. Evan DeWitt takes great care to learn your style and select creations just for you. I looked all around town at other jewelers and came back here because service and jewelry was the best for the cost. I'll be back and highly recommend. read more

DeWitt's Diamond & Gold Exchange - DeWitt's Jewelry in the Colonial Arcade, Cleveland. - Jewelry Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

My Fiance and I went to DeWitt's to have my grandmother's wedding set resized in January. Neither of us has any experience with jewelers or fine jewelry, and Evan was incredibly kind as he walked us through the process. He went above and beyond, answering all our questions and helping us decide on some small changes to the rings. The process was super easy and he had the rings resized and ready for pickup in a week. He also checked the rings for any potential issues (they had some wear and tear from being worn 50+ years) and let us know what to look out for. We'll definitely continue going to DeWitt's! read more

Visited the store over the weekend and walked out with a few beautiful pieces. The owner was very friendly, fair and knowledgeable. Will definitely return! read more

The most impressive jewelry store that I have ever been to. He has been a sponsor for many events held by a friend of mine and is a generous guy. I figured that I should buy a gold chain from him. A friend bought a diamond engagement ring here and was very satisfied. You can hawk any of your old jewelry here if you need some money and he will usually give a better price than other stores in the vicinity. If you want a crazy gold chain with diamonds in it, a Cartier or a Rolex, you can get it here. There is some really cool stuff on display including some nice medallions and charms. Some of the pieces and chains are in the high thousands price range. You need to ring a buzzer to gain entrance. If you are near the Colonial Arcade downtown you should stop in the shop and check out some really nice work. There are pictures of Mr. Dewitt with local celebrities Bone and other rich entertainers that he has done custom work for. read more

I've been going to DeWitt's for years, along with my whole family! Always pleasant, helpful, and if Evan DeWitt is there (which it always seems that he is), then that's even better. Very reasonable prices and a huge selection! Evan and his staff make you feel like you are part of the family and Evan's knowledge on jewelry and design is spectacular. This is a must see if you've never been. It's tucked away in the 5th st Arcade, but is such a hidden gem. read more

Evan and the crew were absolutely amazing! They are attentive, professional, and willing to go the extra mile for the client. Truly a 5-star establishment!!! read more

DeWitt's Diamond & Gold Exchange - Jewelry Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

I visited DeWitt's after searching 2 years for a setting that would match my current wedding band. I knew Evan could design a setting that would enhance my wedding band. The results were spectacular! His phenomenal work brought me to tears. Because I had researched many other jewelers I can honestly say I saved hundreds. His craftsmanship and knowledge were extraordinary. I have received numerous compliments and am delighted to tell anyone where I had it made. Thank You Evan I love, love, love my ring!!! read more

When my husband and I started talking about getting engaged we were told by many go to Dewitt. We tried a few other closer jewelers and were so depressed but the prices and service- I was beginning to think I would never get a ring that I liked. When we went to Dewitt we were treated so well. I of course found a ring that was out of my price range but Evan made it work. We sold some of our own jewelry and I got my dream ring! When it was time to buy our wedding bands we knew to go straight to Dewitt. We both love our bands and the service was once again stellar. I recently had a small problem with my ring and Evan took care of it free of charge. Great jewelry and great service. I will be a customer for life. read more

I went to DeWitt's based solely on his rave reviews. I had never met Evan or stepped foot in his store, so it was a leap of faith. And let me say Evan delivered the most gorgeous ring I could ever have imagined. I had several pieces of jewelry I was no longer wearing and I decided to combine them all into a custom made ring. Evan is an artist and designing that one-of-a-kind piece is what he does best! I had an idea what I wanted, and I brought to him some ideas I had and, together with his knowledge and understanding, he created a show stopper! He communicated throughout the entire process so I always knew what stage the design was in. He knew just what I had in mind and he delivered. I couldn't be happier! Thanks again, Evan! read more

I went to DeWitt's after my best friend had recommended them for an engagement ring purchase. I had a set budget in my mind and an idea of what I was looking for. The owner, Evan was an absolute pleasure to work with. He helped me transition the ideas in my head to paper and into one of the most beautiful rings ever. The whole process was made so simple, the communication was outstanding and the quality of work, amazing! read more

I went to Dewitt's to sell my diamond engagement/wedding ring set and got a fair quote, but wanted to shop around first. After visiting 3 other places, his was the best and I returned today. He GAVE ME FAR MORE MONEY THAN ANYONE! Also, the other store owners told me my ring wasn't as valuable because it was princess cut or that the diamond was too good for this market. Mr. Dewitt told me it was a beautiful ring and gave me a great deal, no cons or games. It was a sad thing to do and his honesty made it a little bit easier. He was extremely pleasant to deal with and he will definitely get all my jewelry business from now on! I would recommend him to anyone. read more

I went to DeWitt's to buy a ring setting for a sapphire engagement ring. At first I didn't know what to expect but it turned out to be a great shopping experience. Mr. DeWitt is an awesome guy and his work is pretty amazing. My first impression of him was that he's a very trustworthy person, which is quite different from what you'll find in most of the other jewelry stores around. Since I was in the process of buying the sapphire somewhere else, he gave me some tips with respect to the price range (helped a lot with the negotiations). He had a wide selection of ring settings at a fraction of the cost you would get in other big chain jewelry stores. He ended up mounting the stone and resizing the ring. Since the ring I found was much larger than what I needed, I was a bit concerned with how it would look after resizing it but he did a great job. The ring looks amazing. I highly recommend this place. read more

I purchased an engagement ring from Dewitt's recently and the experience was fantastic. I went in with a set budget and told the jeweler, Evan, exactly what I was looking for. He immediately knew what I wanted, and was able to provide a stunning engagement ring within my price range. Aside from the thousands of settings, he has an excellent selection of diamonds to choose from. He will tell you exactly what you need to look for and will educate you on how to get the most bang for your buck. My fiancee cannot be happier with the engagement ring I selected, and Evan definitely made this happen. read more

My fiancée had my engagement ring custom made by Evan and its GORGEOUS!! We just picked up my custom made wedding band and its just as amazing if not better! Such a nice guy who makes beautiful jewelry and listens to what you want. He really puts pride in making what you want just how you want! We will continue buying jewelry from here, I would refer him to anyone!! read more

Very happy with my transaction with the team at DeWitt - came downtown Jan 2012 from the suburbs to get offers on gold ring and diamond pendant. Their offer far better than others at Colonial Arcade; warm and friendly staff; efficient and very professional transaction. Gals, make sure you visit DeWitt's! read more

My boyfriend and I recently decided that we wanted to get married. I knew that I had always wanted to pick out my own ring. I had a design in mind and overtime, on websites and in stores only found the style I wanted in a few different options. Dewitts was recommended to me by my boss. When I went there, I brought a picture of the design that I loved. I figured that I would have a few options to choose from and that's it. I was wrong. Evan brought out probably 20 very similar rings to the one in my picture. I was absolutely blown away. Not only did he have a huge selection, everything he brought out was gorgeous! We had a price range in mind and Evan got us the absolute best quality diamond our money could buy. He even compared different sized diamonds and different colors and clarity that I could get within our price range. He made picking out my ring and finding the perfect diamond very easy! When it comes time to buy our wedding rings we know where we will be going. We had a wonderful experience with Evan and his staff. I highly recommend going to Dewitts for your jewelry needs. We will for sure be returning! read more