I just DESTROYED a Grandma's something or other Sicilian square slice, a white pizza with ricotta, and a garlic knot. I'm gonna need a minute before I hit up the cannoli. OMG I'm on Long Island visiting this week. I asked them where to get good pizza. I'm so glad they told me to come up here. Yum! Ugh...so stuffed now! read more

Due Paisanos - a slice of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Lake Ronkonkoma, New York

I ordered their special meal plan 19 meals for $50 (available Mon- Thurs ONLY & until May 31st) I called my choices in and then headed down to enjoy a slice with my nephew while they made my order, their pizza is delicious my nephew had a meatball slice and I had a garlic knot slice while we waited. We ordered (2) Penne Ala vodka, (2) Chicken Parmigiana, (2) Chicken Frances, (1) Spaghetti & Meatballs, (1) Baked Manicotti and (2) Sausage and Peppers dinners for a total of 10 dinners all together, they have a lot more to choose from and they all came in those nice take out tins so you're getting a full meal portion not some skimpy small portion for $5 a piece!! How can you beat that price?? I brought them home and put them in the freezer an My family and I have defrosted them and eaten them over the course of 2 weeks and eat meal was absolutely delicious, it was very easy to defrost and eat each meal and the portions were large enough for us to share with each other so we each had a little bit of whatever we defrosted that night it was like eating out at an Italian restaurant without having to cook or cleanup afterwards and again for an AMAZING PRICE! Go check them out and make your dinner plans next week easy and enjoy Paisano's food in your home! read more

Due Paisanos - Advertisement For 10 Meals for $50! - Pizza Near Me - Lake Ronkonkoma, New York

See all

We absolutely LOVE their food... staff is always pleasant on the phone... we always ask them to PLEASE call us when they arrive. We live in an apartment around back and it's just easier for everyone if we come out to get the food so the driver doesn't have to go around the back of the house and my landlords don't get disturbed. The past five times they have not only pulled into the driveway with loud music but did not call us and knocked on the front door. How hard is it to just call us when they're here? Super frustrating and landlord is annoyed. Will have to find a new spot unfortunately. read more

I have only been to this pizzeria 2x and I'm so incredibly impressed!!! They custom made me my own salad slices (their Italian dressing is also Devine) and tonight I tried their Mac and cheese slice! Sooo delicious- it definitely won't disappoint!! I brought some to my mom tonight and found it AMAZING as well! . Shout out to Nick for his great staff and the amazing Jack for my fantastic custom salad slices! read more

Due Paisanos - Custom Salad Slice - Briana style - Pizza Near Me - Lake Ronkonkoma, New York

See all

Everything on the menu will hit your Italian craving. I recommend any pizza pasta and especially the grilled chicken breast 5 Star customer service and food quality! TRY it!!! read more

I ve tried every pizza place in Ronkonkoma and I was not as happy till I came to try Paisano's in Portion road Ronkonkoma. My favorite is their pizza slices their combination platters and I love the tortellini brodo. They have great service and good manners and are very very accommodating to what you want. Jack always takes care of me very well whenever I go there look out for him. There shrimp hero is phenomenal and they do not cut corners with their food food which is their best quality. It's a great place with quality food and service in Ronkonkoma after a very long time! Highly HIGHLY recommend it. read more

See all

Got takeout through Grubhub, just a Brooklyn pie. Very doughy, mediocre sauce, mediocre cheese. Just ok, would be a 2.5 if I could make it that. read more

Paisano's worked with our club to provide catered food for 150 people for a big line dance event. It was off the charts delicious and we had rave reviews all night! The rigatoni ala vodka alone seems like it should have an incredible following, so so good! We also had the chicken parm, eggplant rollatini with salad and their ridiculously good garlic knots (trust me, you need them to soak up the sauces). They were very fair in pricing, addressed every concern we had and delivered exactly on time. We will definitely be using them again and there is no way I'm waiting a year before I go have more of that rigatoni! Cannot recommend them enough! read more

My daughter DoorDashed an order from here and I was shocked how great the food was!! The meatballs were huge and delicious! My granddaughter loved her penne alla vodka. My biggest surprise were the baked clams casino they were fabulous with the whole clam in them and so flavorful with the bacon and everything! I will definitely put this on my list of go to's read more

We ordered a pie and calzone last night , asked for delivery and was told 45 minutes ok I get it . Not bad the only thing is our food arrived cold . Such a shame because it was tasty ! Probably would have given 5 stars if our food was hot. read more

Really reliable pizza and really great service ! Ordered through grub hub because I had a coupon. On the app it didn't give us a choice to pick a sauce for our chicken wings so we called up and he added them free of charge !!! Thanks man! We had the rice balls which were delicious ! Super cheesy and amazing with the marinara sauce. The pizza was actually really great. As I said before, we only ordered there because of the coupon but were all very pleasantly surprised by the pizza !!! Ordered a plain cheese but it had really nice flavor and and even amount of ingredients We ordered wings too because we are savages when we sit down to watch ru Paul's drag race. They were also pretty good! I would like to request that they don't bread them. It takes away from the wing in my opinion. But it's probably just my personal preference. Overall.. good service and decent food gets a 5 in my book !!! read more

Great food. Great staff. Best grandma pizza. Catered Christmas and everything was fabulous.

Fresh mozz salad... umm no it isn't. And there isn't basil on the salad either. And considering that is what is listed in the ingredients in very disappointed. I also ordered the meatballs which were worse than meatloaf(no flavor or seasoning what so ever) and the baked ziti that was average to say the least. The best part of the food ordered was the fresh bread that came with the meal... unaltered....doesn't say much for the meal. read more

Due Paisanos - Pizza Near Me - Lake Ronkonkoma, New York

See all

Excellent food,, everybody loved it and on time delivery. We appreciate the wonderful service.

AVOID IF YOU CARE ABOUT COVID SAFETY!!! No one that is working there is wearing a mask in the height of omicron surge. They don't even have them on their chin to pull up when there are customers. It is the state mandate for everyone to be wearing masks especially employees. They don't care the health of their customers! read more

I wanted to try new places usually go to Selden Pizza which in my area seems to have the best pizza in truth usually takes a long time to get a pie 45 minutes or plus So I looked up online and I found this pizza place delivers the pie came pretty quickly the pie had very little cheese on it the meatballs would just cut and thrown on there some so small and some were tremendous some slices of the pie only had two pieces of meat ball touching them and some six I said OK looks can be deceiving Three bites into the pizza I realize this was not going to be good I should've took a picture but I was so aggravated I got the entire pie and I threw it out was a waste of money that pizza did not taste good and they should be embarrassed read more

Ordered the grandma's pizza. It was not what grandma's pie should be at all. It had a very focaccia like crust and a ton of cheese, both which do not belong to a grandma's pizza. The worst part was the cheese - some was like the standard cheese blend you find on a plain slice and some was the good stretched mozzarella you expect to find on a grandma's. Maybe if they'd axe the weird cheese blend and only do the good mozz it would maybe be acceptable. Maybe. I would not order nor recommend this pie. Maybe their other food is good but I'm so turned off by being served an imposter that I have no desire to try other food from here. We're on freaking LI, you should be able to get a decent grandma's slice here. read more

Stopped in today and got a few slices and a Grilled Chicken Wrap, and the food was amazing! They had a slice with Vodka Sauce, grilled chicken, and tortellini that I didn't want to ever end. Sauce was perfectly balanced. The wrap was a great portion and the ingredients were so fresh. Definitely going to be the new neighborhood go to. The owner, Nick, was also very personable and truly appreciative of everyone that walked through the door to have his food, thanking everyone for their business. read more

This pizzeria is one of my top go-to for good food. My fiancé and I have ordered from here numerous times and the food is always delicious, hot and fresh. Our favorite is the specialty garlic knot pizza. Also, their delivery service is reliable and the estimated time is typically correct. read more

Due Paisanos - Pizza Near Me - Lake Ronkonkoma, New York

See all

To address my review below, the restaurant reached out and 1) apologized, 2) went through the details to make sure it doesn't happen again and 3) is sending me a free dinner. I am more than happy with their response, and now believe that the blame falls more on grubhub than Paisano's. I will continue to order from here. Thus, I changed my rating as well. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- I order from here several times a month and the food is usually excellent. However, it has been taking longer and longer to arrive lately. Tonight i ordered through grubhub around 730 pm. I was waiting and around 9 i decided to call the restaurant...and they did not pickup. So i called grubhub only to find out the restaurant canceled my order. They did not call or email or text to tell me, so i was waiting for nothing and unable to order from elsewhere. By the time i knew it was too late to order dinner. I am absolutely furious and livid. read more

Got a grilled chicken Caesar wrap. WAY too much dressing and it tasted overpoweringly garlicky. The fries were really good but the ketchup tasted old and off. Also got mozzarella sticks and it wasn't breadcrumbed it was like this weird flour breading, definitely frozen. Overall not very impressed and would suggest going somewhere else. read more

Great pizza. Only pizza parlor I go to in the area. They are Also my go to catering place I use I have Been using them for over 4 years for All my catering events read more

We order lunch from them weekly. Food always fresh. Staff is always courteous and helpful. From pizza to salads, haven't had a bad meal

Great food and super friendly staff! My son loves the penne pizza. They have a Mac and Cheese slice he loves too. They're close, they deliver and food is good. We will be ordering from them again. Give 'em a try! read more

Due Paisanos - Mac and Cheese Slice! Yum!! - Pizza Near Me - Lake Ronkonkoma, New York

Stopped in their new location on Terry road in Smithtown. Ordered a sausage calzone. BEST calzone I ever had!! Great crust, not shy with cheese. I think I just found my new pizza place. Great job guys !! read more

Think i found my new pizza parlor stuck with the regular/sicilian slices and knotts big slices great sauce probably the best knotts around definitely will go back read more

The only pizza place in Brookhaven that we will order from. Always get the bacon and pineapple grandma style and it has never once disappointed. Our family from Michigan loves the pizza! read more

Ordered a chicken marsala dinner with pasta and the only thing that was edible was the pasta and the side of bread. I had to throw out the entire entree because it had prosciutto in it which was not listed on the menu, otherwise I would not have ordered it. I figured if there was only a few pieces on the top I could just remove them off of my plate and not make a big deal out of it. So after Scraping the prosciutto off I attempted to cut through the chicken which was 1. Rubbery and 2.rancid disgusting will never order from this "restaurant " again. read more

BEST SERVICE, HANDS DOWN!! From the moment you walk in you are treated like family! This place has amazing food for the price. My favorites are chicken marsala slices and buffalo chicken slices. Nick and crew are great! read more

I have ordered from them many times. Lately the quality of the food has declined. It used to be very consistent. The pizza we ordered looked like it was put together with random slices then heated up. A few slices did not look anything like the others. Arrived cold. Chicken wings were inedible. I hate that I have to give such a poor review but I think they need to pay more attention to quality control. read more

Pizza was "okay" not $45 dollars worth! Plus they told me 20-25 minutes and they took 35 minutes and they were not even busy. Plus there was someone in the back on their phone. read more

don't know what happened to this place missing items in the order food not good anymore incorrect food no one wearing mask or gloves when ask why they said they don't have covid 19 how do they know are they being tested hourly you may have tested negative a week ago but could have it now. I should have not come back after last time similar errors read more

Not a fan. Ordered the buffalo calamari through slice and it is not buffalo at all. They should call it fried calamari di avalo as it is smothered in spicy marinara sauce. The grandma pie was meh as it was a little under cooked and the garlic knots were on the stale side. read more

Place was good. The regular pie had a nice flavor. The dough was a little floppy and soggy. If it had been cooked a lil crispier it would have been way better. Penne ala vodka pizza was good also Tons of chicken. Good flavor. Same with Sicilian Pie. Overall place was good. I will come back. What I don not like is they charge you a 3.99% credit/debit fee. He told me my price, i gave him my card and then my receipt said almost 2 dollars more because of this fee. If you are going to charge a fee, don't leave it up to a sign to do the work for you, tell the customer. Its the principle at that point. The man who I believed owns the place runs the front. Was very nice and respectful. All in all. Good place read more

First time customer, ordered with grub hub. I ordered the large pie with free small baked ziti, and a small antipasto salad. I was worried the small would not be enough for two, but there was waaaaaaaay more than enough food. A large would have been too much for us. Food came fast ( less than 30 mins) it was hot, fresh, and delicious. I would definitely eat here again. read more

Most often I'd say yes, I recommend this place, but sometimes they do weird things. I ordered a panini and got a cold sandwich on ciabatta bread -- not pressed, not hot -- and the correct items weren't on the sandwich. Mozzarella was not "fresh," as the menu states. Stick with the pizza -- which is great. read more

Best pizza we have had yet in NY. As Michigan natives, we struggle to find pizza like back home. This pizza was great! Ingredients seem fresh and pizza was well made. We just wish they had a few more topping options, like banana peppers or jalapeños! read more

After ordering from them about an hour and half ago, I will never again. I can not believe the horrible treatment I just received. After waiting over an HOUR for 2 large pizzas, garlic knots, a side of sauce and a side of mozzarella cheese I called and the man on the phone said they lost my ticket and nobody offered to do anything to fix it. All they said they could do was make the order now. Which fine, I understand mistakes happen but after waiting even longer they forget the mozzarella cheese and the sauce. After calling, they said it would take a half hour for JUST the cheese and sauce to get to us. Ridiculous. read more

Great food and very friendly staff. My family eats more pizza than I care to admit and I drive past about six pizza places to get my pizza from Paisano's!! It's worth the trip as far as I'm concerned...we've never been disappointed. read more

Great food at a good price with huge portions. Exactly what I want from my local Italian joint. Had the chicken parm dinner and rice balls siciliano tonight. Both awesome. Nice thin cutlets, great sauce. Rice balls siciliano just add them to your order they are everything I've wanted on a rice ball. Welcome to our homes rotation Paisanos read more