Invited for a rehearsal dinner. Location was not far from our hotel. Ample parking across the street (but crowded on a Friday night). About 60 people in our group which fit nicely in the private room. We even had our own bar (with the Yankee game on TV). Service was outstanding and the food was surprisingly fantastic. Fix menus for dinner, salad, pasta and choice of entrees. I had the flounder franchese, which was one of the best I've had! Eggplant rolatine and chicken parm rounded out the choices. All good. Very happy for the invite as an out of town guest. Very pleased with Eatalia! read more

This place was such a life saver!! I completely forgot to book a restaurant for my daughter's communion and so it was a race two weeks before to find a place. Eatalia was able to fit in our small group of ten last minute. We ordered family style and it was such an amazing lunch. The food kept coming out...and if we wanted more of anything, they brought it out. Everything from the salad to the pasta to the chicken was amazing!! Everything was fresh and well prepared. The servers were wonderful and attentive. There was another large party there at the same time, but we didn't even notice it until we left. The restaurant is cute and tucked away in an off street in the village, so easy to miss it!! But now that we found it-we will be back. Al the owner was wonderful and so helpful!! read more

Excellent food--excellent staff--friendly environment. Can't go wrong dining here. We keep going back for more. Going there tonight for a 40th birthday party. Can' wait!! read more

I had an amazing shower here this past weekend and the food was fantastic! They gave us family style and all gluten free bc we had some allergies. It was so delicious. They accommodated and gave us the private room. The room hit the mark for my Vino Before Vows theme. 10/10 recommend having a party here. The staff was read more

Consider this restaurant for any occasion or party you may have to get people together! they do great events

This is a very nice, an elegantly decorated moderately priced restaurant in Huntington and is reviewed as such. The Sole Livornese and the Chicken Franchise were both well prepared, well plated and aesthetically pleasing. The chicken was tender and well complimented by the sauce. The sole was also tender, flaked easily, and bathed with a good tasting sauce. Service was prompt, the server was attentive and came back during the dinner to see if there was anything that was needed. Overall, a very good experience. read more

Eatalia - Chicken Florentine - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Had dinner here, food came out timely as it was prepared. Everything tasted fresh and service was great. I believe our server was named Greg and his recommendations were great. Would go back for sure. read more

Great food and fast service! The Gorgonzola dip is a fave and the chicken parm is great! The ambiance is warm. Highly recommend

I didn't know what to expect due to the mixed reviews. I decided to stop by as they have a great inexpensive lunch deal $10.99 everyday till 3 and there's many options. I thought to myself if it's not good no worries I'll just sample, pay the bill and go elsewhere. It's Huntington so I had other options. Check their website out to see all lunch options. To my surprise we were the only patrons sitting there on a Saturday at 2pm. At this point I really didn't know what to expect. Upon sitting water and bread came out promptly. I personally was not a fan of the bread. Now why I came here food! Lunch- Soprano pizza - Broccoli rabe,sausage,onions and marinara sauce. I'm not a fan of rabe or sausages didn't know what to expect and surprisingly I really enjoyed the pizza. I would order it again. Full of flavor. Chicken Milanese- huge order! Fried chicken cutlet,mozz,red & green peppers,arugula,romaine,red onions in a balsamic glaze dressing. Great dish and I took home left overs. Great meal and look forward to coming back. Service- no complaints the waiter was great. He left us alone most of the time but checked on us. read more

Eatalia - Lunch special $10.99- broccoli rabe sausage pizza tasty!! - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Awful cafeteria food and 0 ambience. We are so disappointed and embarrassed for the prior 5 star TAKE OUT review. Do NOT EVER eat here especially whoever you bring people from out of town thinking this is a good Italian restaurant. Why are they still in business when Hush Bistro is closed? Salmon was the only reason Eatalia got 2 stars. Everything is awful from the loud Christmas music to the poor acoustics. Bf had risotto with tiny shrimp which were rubbery and flavorless. Step kids had lobster and crab ravioli and cheese ravioli and the marinara sauce had the consistency of ketchup Overall a waste of $100 after the Groupon!! read more

See all

This is my absolute favorite restaurant. I live an hour away so I don't come here often but if I lived closer I would pretty much only go here while eating out. The food is perfect every time, it's fresh and you can tell the chef cares. The ambiance is nice. I'm obsessed with their eggplant rollatini and crave it everyday- no one else seems to be able to make it like them. My son gets spaghetti and meatballs, which seems simple but even he says no one can make the sauce or meatballs like them! When he likes something you know it has to be good because he's picky. Keep doing what you're doing Eatalia and we'll see you next time! read more

We were a party of 4, my husband and our best friends who are from Huntington. We came for dinner. We had the burrata to start which was very yummy, angel hair pasta with red sauce (which wasn't on the menu, but they were able to make for us), chicken Florentine and Orecchiette. All family style for us, 4 which was just right and we had leftovers as well. Each dish was good, we will come back! read more

Eatalia - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

Met a friend for lunch here. He ordered the chicken parm, I kept it simple and ordered penne vodka. Nice interior and vibe. Nice waitress. I am giving one star because I grew up in the city... next door to Italians my whole life. I have no idea what chef is back there but the pasta I ordered must've had bad tomatoes in it or spoiled cream. My tongue immediately swelled up and I had bumps on my tongue from something very acidic. I proceeded to throw up acid for about 30 min, no exaggeration. I've never been poisoned but I'd suspect &&it'd feel similar to what happened to me there. Horrible experience. read more

I've been to a number of parties (and dinners with my wife) at Eatalia on New Street and I cannot recommend this restaurant enough. The food was delicious, prepared with a lot of attention and quality ingredients. The service for both dinner and at parties was 10/10; polite, kind, and most importantly helpful servers and staff. The drinks were delicious (I prefer martinis and my wife mixed drinks) - not too light or heavy with alcohol. Eatalia is the only place I've been to that handles a party with full white glove service. I was asked if I wanted a drink upon arriving and always had servers available to me. If you have any occasion you're looking to celebrate in the near future, please think about Eatalia. We will continue coming back! read more

what a wonderful and unexpected delight. This is like Huntington's best kept secret. From outside, it looks small and ordinary...but when you enter, you are so pleasantly surprised! Tall ceilings, elegant design, tasteful beauty, and all the ambience of Italy. (Even the music that drew me in from the sidewalk!) THE FOOD IS SUPERB!! mouthwatering . This is an ideal place for a romantic dinner for two or a large group of family and friends. We had a 60th surprise birthday. The way Al the owner set up the room almost made me cry, it was so beautiful . Cannot recommend highly enough read more

Update: Within one hour of my poor rating (June 6th), Britany S. whom I later learned is the owner's daughter, posted back saying the prices were absurd and asked me to reach out to rectify this mistake. I called the following Tuesday and was told Al, the owner, would call me Wednesday. Thursday I had not heard anything, so I called again. Brittany eventually got on the phone and said I was mistakenly overcharged and she would refund me the overcharge which would take 3 - 5 days to appear on my credit card. Brittany said the price of a mixed drinks is $18. I was charged $24 for one and $23.75 for the other. Note, I was not in Manhattan or a Long Island waterfront eatery. Today is 13 days later and still no refund. I had to contact my credit card company to request a refund through a dispute. Also, I was not mistakenly overcharge. The night of the retirement party when I was given my receipt, I questioned the amount charged with the bartender and he looked at a price list posted on a wall and confirmed the prices I had paid were correct. I had told Brittany that someone is purposely overcharging and pocketing some of the money which she denied. I heard from a friend there was another teachers retirement party held there the following week and that some gossip was going on about the high prices of the drinks. I was not the only person complaining. Again...STAY AWAY FROM EATALIA RESTAURANT, 34 New St, Huntington NY. HUGE RIPOFF!!! read more

This place was very disappointing. I moved to Colorado 5 years ago and my biggest complaint about it is that the Italian food is terrible. Restaurants overcharge for simple dishes like chicken parm and it's sub-par and I always express how much better food is in NY. And then I came here. I ordered the chicken parm and I got half a chicken cutlet with a block of mozzarella cheese on it, it came with a side of potatoes, and it cost $28. It was bland as hell and honestly, tasted worse than what I've had in Colorado. I asked the waiter to split the check and he said yes and still brought us one check. The drinks are way over priced and the overall cost of this place was not worth it at all. There are so many better places in the area. I would recommend trying a different place. read more

I haven't posted a review in a long time but I felt like I needed to. I went here post hike and was famished. Anything would've tasted good but the pizza and the pasta tasted so bland and tasteless. Pizza had no flavor with random plop of tomato sauce. Pasta also had no flavor, was very oily, and the noodles were very overcooked. Added lots of pepper flakes and cheese to add more flavor which didn't help. My friends and I ate in silence and were very disappointed to say the least. read more

Eatalia - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

Great food and really nice size portions! Service was great! I will go back!! Baked Clams Chicken Milanese Penne Bolognese All great!! read more

I had a surprise birthday party for my mother's 80th birthday and I couldn't have been more pleased with the food, presentation & the service that we received. Everything was delicious. My mother was so happy & all the guests were complementing the food & ambience. The owner was especially cordial to us as well as the staff. Very attentive. The drinks were delicious. Although the tip was included, I added more to it for the excellent service we received. I can't have anything more positive to say about Eatalia except mangia & enjoy. You will not be disappointed. read more

Had a Groupon and decided to go with one of my friends. The Groupon was for the family style menu. They state that each family style dish serves 2-3 people. So we each ordered a dish to share. My friend ordered the rigatoni ala vodka. It was very good and had great flavor! Vodka sauce was great! I ordered the chicken scarpiello. It had hot & sweet peppers, sausage, potato in a white wine sauce. It was tasty as well. Very unique flavor. The potatoes were delicious. The bread served before the meal was just okay. It wasn't served warm, just at room temperature. Instead of butter it was served with an olive oil and seasoning mixture. That was a nice touch. What I didn't like is that the waiters just stand around and watch you eat if they aren't waiting on tables. That's a little uncomfortable. Who likes to be watched while they eat? Not me. SIDE NOTE/FUN FACT: My friend wanted chicken Parmesan to take home. If you order off the restaurant menu it's $21 and doesn't come with pasta. If you order it off of the pizza/cafe menu it's $14.50 and it comes with pasta. Hm, what? Don't pay more for less food....you can thank me later. :D read more

See all

Wonderful neighborhood restaurant. Loved the mozzarella wedge appetizer, delicious crispy melted cheese. Yum! Always good size portions and friendly and attentive service. Pasta Primavera was a perfect light summer dish with a variety of vegetables and tasty grilled chicken. Highly recommend. read more

Went here tonight for the first time and we were both super impressed!! First of all the place is huge with both indoor and outdoor seating as well as a private party room. The decor is beautiful and everything was spotless. The server was extremely attentive and the portions were generous! The salads are huge!! We got Caesar salads and margarita pizzettes along with one of the summer cocktails. Everything was delicious and enough to take home for the next day. Also everything was really affordable and the menu has a lot of options. Definitely been sleeping on this place but now that we know we will be back for sure and bring more people! 5/5 read more

Eatalia - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Very dishonest business. I ordered multiple items for takeout from their menu. Upon picking up and arriving at home I realized that the entire Pie wasn't given to me. I called about my missing pie and they responded that they "didn't give it to me and didn't charge me for it" .We went over the pricing and the pricing didn't add up. They then said "that the webmaster didn't update the online prices and prices went up." Anyways, They said they would amend the pricing and refund me for the missing pizza pie. Have been waiting since Jan 30 for them to "amend." Won't return again. read more

Hosted a 40th Birthday party for a friend in their private party room last night. In a word...fantastic! Al and Greg were extremely attentive and made my guests feel welcome. Many commented on how good the food was and the mixed drinks were well balanced and tasty. The room itself is large enough to feel comfortable but not cavernous. I was free to bring my own themed decor. The private bar is so convenient, guests don't have to leave the room to get a drink. Do not hesitate to book your next party or event here, you won't regret it--they make it so easy. Thank you Al and team! read more

Little Italy in Huntington. Huntington Village has a nice Italian eatery, Eatalia is a restaurant along with a side by side take out store.. Though somewhat new here they are not new to Huntington. They are affiliated with a local eatery north of the village which makes reliably good food, Italian soup etc. Eatalia makes authentic Italian served family style. My friend & I tried the restaurant side and ordered shrimp parmigiana, stuffed mushrooms family style. The people were helpful, knew the menu well and confirmed our choices. The menu had plenty of traditional favorites. Eatalia is a step above the local area Italian places, and was super fresh. A safe bet for reliable good Italian. In a town where restaurants, service & food is glitchy, it was nice to be in here. read more

See all

First, went there for a surprise birthday party and the food was great - salad, eggplant, bread rolls, fish, chicken - all tasted fresh. Second time we came for lunch and the third time we went as a group to dinner and I had the Rigatoni Primavera with organic grilled chicken, not heavy and tasted fresh, my brother had the organic chicken parmigiana and said it was one of the best he had, my sister in law and mother had the sole Francese which came in a generous portion. The kids had pizza and Caesar salad which they liked as well. We were very pleased. read more

The best place for a family gathering! This is my third time here;the food and service are equally exquisite Britany was so attentive and made our dinner experience so beautiful! I highly recommend this gem of a restaurant. read more

Ordered the lunch special and it was delicious. Chicken was super fresh. The workers were so kind and helpful. Will definitely return read more

Eatalia - Lunch specials 2021 - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Went to dinner Thursday for a friend's birthday. I am vegan and know how to order my food at an Italian restaurant but apparently this is impossible if the chef and/or waiter have no communication or idea what it means when someone says they do not eat dairy, eggs or meat/animal products. I asked about a dish with truffle oil. Does it have any dairy or chicken broth in the sauce. The waiter immediately said absolutely no chicken broth. I knew the fresh pasta would have egg so I ordered linguine. I asked him to confirm with the kitchen that this would be a vegan dish and he claimed he did. Based on years of experience, I called him over once again to confirm there would be no animal products in the dish. I apologized, as I do not like to be a difficult patron, but I do want to be certain of what I am eating. Well the dish arrived and I pushed aside the spaghetti (they don't have linguine, which they never bothered to tell me) and all I saw was cream sauce. My friends tried to tell me it was pasta water...nope - I know what I am looking at. I am a cooking teacher and long-time vegan, so I am 100% positive about how food is prepared and what it should look like. I called the waiter over and asked about the cream sauce. He came back from the kitchen with some cockamamie story about how the tomatoes were cooked in salt?!? BS. Not even a chance that was what it was and I never heard of tomatoes cooked with salt turning into cream sauce - if that were the case every vegan would use this technique and I told him that was impossible. Next the manager/owner (not sure who) came over, looked at the dish and asked what I ordered. When I told him he immediately took my plate and said it was cream sauce. Of course it was! I asked if they could just bring me linguine with garlic, oil and broccoli - no pasta water or liquid of any kind in the dish. He said they don't have linguine (what Italian restaurant serves spaghetti rather than linguine) and recommended I get the primavera vegetables. Okay - why not. The next dish came out with what I can only describe as dishwater with no oil whatsoever. Was I not clear? My friends said taste it. I will not taste anything I think is suspect, so one of them tasted the "broth". Even she couldn't place the flavor and said it was simply bad. They felt terrible, but I am used to this and told them not to worry but I wasn't eating it. It sat in front of me in an empty restaurant and I had some bread and oil. The waiter walked by several times and clearly saw I wasn't eating it but never stopped to ask why to get the manager. In the end they took the dish off the bill, but that was absolutely awful service from start to finish. My friends did not care for their food either and none of us will be returning to Eatalia. They could have at least offered me another drink on the house to make up for the disastrous experience. It's no wonder the place was empty in Huntington on a Thursday night at 6:30pm. read more

We got a groupon for this place and decided last night to come check it out. Pretty good food, good portions, we were able to park right in front on a week night so yeah that was good since it was raining. It's a cute little place. Good value and was good service. I was starving so besides the appetizer I didn't get a pic of my penne alla vodka lol. My hubs had the lasagna and the rest of my pasta. Mozzarella was good. read more

Eatalia - Pretty good mozz - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

The service is nice and pretty quick. The food is good. Ambiance is nice and pretty spacious.

Had a very good lunch here, sole francese. That wasn't the best part. The service here is extraordinary, friendly, wonderful. This is the second time that they have been very helpful. After lunch one hot day, I was waiting on their outside bench for the HART bus to pick me up--I'm an old lady. The bus was late. The owner or manager came outside and invited me back in, served me a cold drink, and offered to call the bus company. As he was on the phone, the bus appeared outside. A service person, a guy in whites, ran out to hold the bus for me. What more could I want? They are very special people. read more

Four of us went here for a work lunch. The atmosphere is great. They have a $14.99 lunch special. We ordered two chicken marsala's, one eggplant parm, and a beet salad. The Food was good, the service was good, and portion sizes were average. They serve warm bread with seasoned olive oil. I would come back again. read more

Amazing Pizzetta!!! Superb service! Would definitely return to try a different dish.

We were looking for a place for dinner and happened onto Eatalia. The place is very nice, spotless. The service was excellent and friendly. The food was very good and reasonably priced. I wholly recommend to give it a try read more

I had an amazing date night here. What a cute little place. I was looking for a place to eat around the Paramount theater and I found this place. I bought a groupon deal and it was a steal $25 for fifty dollars worth of food(drinks included as well).Truly loved everything I had. The chicken scarpiello off the bone was my dish and it was beyond what I expected. My boyfriend has the shrimp Fri Diavolo which was mildly spicy because we requested it (wow I will return for that alone). The tiramisu and Cannoli were delicately delicious. The dishes without the groupon a bit pricey. I had a great time. This may be my place to eat dinner before a show at the paramount. read more

See all

Came for late lunch on a Thursday and surprised it wasn't full. The food was excellent - Linguini and Clams in red sauce and Eatalia Pizza and the portions were quite filling. Will definitely visit again. Perfect family place, nice atmosphere and great food. read more

Eatalia - Eatalia Pizza was so tasty - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

One word to describe this restaurant - GREAT!!! Right from the time my wife and I entered the restaurant we were treated with impeccable service and we got lucky that Brittany ( whose family runs the restaurant) personally served us. My wife got the linguine with white clam sauce, which she said was delicious. And I got the papparadelle selese. The papparadelle was home made and cooked to a perfect al dente. And to make our dinner date even more perfect we got their fresh filled cannolis and chocolate mousse cake on the house, thanks to Brittany. We will definitely be going back to this restaurant because it felt like visiting my wife's family in Italy and getting authentic Italian food. read more

I love this Italian place! I understood it was "family style" but that did not alter how shocked I was when we laid eyes on our food. The portions are huuuuge! We got the fried calamari as an appetizers(feeds about 4) and it was great. Totally would recommend. Then the Chicken scarpiello which they told us was the most popular dish on the menu & their specialty. While it wasn't bad, it wasn't that great either. I don't understand why that's their specialty when they have an amazing menu full of other phenomenal items. Definitely would come back again, so happy that you opened up! read more

Eatalia - Fried calamari - Pizza Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all