Used to be my favorite place, but the last few times I've ordered have been horrible. Garlic knots coming completely stale and rock hard, pasta is dry. I used to go there once a week, now I am not sure if I'll return. read more

This place was so incredible. The crudo is spectacular!!! Highly enjoyed our experience and the drinks were great. read more

Eduardo's Trattoria - Pizza Near Me - Mahopac, New York

See all

I'm not one to write reviews, good or bad, but have to say ordered takeout last night. Was here within a half hour but beyond that, my chicken and broccoli rabe was literally the best I've ever had. I'm Italian so I know broccoli rabe and this was on point in every way. Wrap wasn't all bread and loaded with chicken and rabe. Just bravo. read more

Take out is amazing. Hot right to your door. One if the best steak and cheeses I've had in my life!

LOVE the food here!Always delicious. There are many Italian restaurants in the area but this is my favorite. Their grandma pizza is the best around! There have been a few times where they delivered the wrong food or gave us the wrong order but when we speak with them about the issue they are always quick to make it right. read more

There are plenty, I mean an abundance of Italian restaurants to choose from in our neighborhood, so I recommend selecting one where the staff is not so rude. Do not dine here. read more

They have the best lobster ravioli with cherry tomatoes and mushrooms.All the food is the best plus large portions. The wine not so great or I would give 5 stars. read more

Having driven past this restaurant many times, I decided to give it a try. Big mistake. A complete waste of money and food. $33 for a nasty sandwich and overcooked pasta. Barely any of it was consumed before it was disposed of quickly. I ordered the Eggplant Caprese "Panini" It consisted of what appeared to be soggy wonder bread, some sad looking eggplant and tomatoes haphazardly pressed together with coagulated cheese. I could not finish it. Horrible. Mrs. ordered some pasta primavera dish. Again, depressing looking veggies and soggy pasta. This was experimentation gone wrong and I feel ripped off. read more

We had an amazing dinner last night Good service and delicious bread while we waited for the food. We had delicious chicken dinners and one person got the personal pizza (not pictured) which she really enjoyed. It was pretty big and she had half left over to take home which was great for the price. Actually returned for lunch today again as we had family in town who heard we had gone here and wanted to check it out. Got the wrap and panini for lunch and really enjoyed them!! We loved Eduardos and will be returning in the future! read more

See all

how does a ton of hair end up in pizza?! And I'm not talking hair from someone's head. The delivery drivers don't know where to go, and when it's sitting in a box for an hour, the place should deliver a new pizza when you are late. Please keep the hair off anyone's pizza because I didn't order that as a topping! Seemed COMPLETELY INTENTIONAL. There are plenty of other places to get pizza. read more

Spaghetti Arabiata there was excellent. But portion was very small. Very small, intimate, husband, and wife team read more

First time there, worst experience ever, very rude. I ordered an eggplant parm sandwich, they gave me an eggplant parm dinner, I wasn't mad at that, however, when I told him that I ordered a sandwich he was very rude, he made me the sandwich but when it was ready, he brought it to the table and said I made it because I'm nice and he said that it wasn't even on the menu, he kept arguing with me. My friend didn't even finish his food. We left and at the end we got charged $57. Never going back there for sure. read more

Restaurant changed hands a year ago from "Three boys from Italy" to "Eduardo's Trattoria". The food is as good as it gets! Although some may call this place a Pizzeria, I have to disagree! It is a wonderful restaurant! My family comes here all the time because the kitchen turns out delicious food! Our favorite dishes are the Chicken San Giuseppe and the Contadina; and the pizza is amazing! We have NEVER had a bad experience at this restaurant. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive, everyone always seems to be in a good mood and happy to be there. They have an awesome lunch special and great happy hour deals, this place is an awesome addition to the neighborhood! I have had many meals in Mahopac but I have to say this is my favorite place for lunch and dinner! read more

Consistently good, my wife and I eat there very often. In addition, we have used their catering menu for numerous occasions, always successful. read more

Overall just awful rude and disrespectful service and the pizza tastes awful , honestly I think my school pizza was better . I have had awful experiences with this place on a numerous bases and they could care less about our concerns or there errors . There always right . It's sad. read more

We order from them a lot and as great as they once were, they have turned into a very rude disrespectful bunch. Jose who answers the phone and takes orders really needs a attitude adjustment because he makes us never want to give them our money. Otherwise food is decent, pizza is awful. read more

A wonderful place to be with family or friends. The staff are wonderful they make you feel so comfortable a place to enjoy a meal, glass of wine or an appetizer. Or maybe just hang out and enjoy the game! read more

Eduardo's Trattoria - Delvictoria, dine,dinner, or enjoy the game. Everyone is so nice they make sure that you are comfortable. And is not to far from home. - Pizza Near Me - Mahopac, New York

We ordered 3 salads and penne alla vodka. Our salads were missing the bacon and avocado- we called to let them know that we were a little disappointed but wasn't the end of the world. The owner himself got on the phone and told me that he would personally remake the salads. He actually delivered them very quickly to the door as well! We were so appreciative. The salads were amazing. Couldn't ask for better. Great portion and the penne was delicious. So friendly. Will definitely be ordering for him frequently. Great customer service! read more

We had Eduardo's cater our Super Bowl Party, the food was outstanding, thank you for a great day

I have to say I am pleasantly surprised with Eduardos! We've ordered 2 days in a row and both time the food was so delicious! It's hard to find a good salad around here for some reason and the Chopped Salad was exceptional. This is our new go to Pizza restaurant. read more

We have given this establishment more then one tries. We order from them at least once a week sometimes two. since they opened. Then we come across and order where they run out of what we ordered but did not bother to call us to tell us, The delivery guy dropped it off with not mention of the missing item. read more

Food is average but they do not wear masks!!! Everyone in kitchen had masks around their mouth... sorry but that does NOTHING. They do not take Covid seriously and it's disgusting. It reminds me of a high school hangout with always young kids just hanging around. Really not a good atmosphere. Will not be back. read more

Good neighborhood spot. Nice wine offerings.. Basic, Italian fare. Nice sized portions. Super nice staff and manager. I had been ordering take out, due to Covid. I assumed they were following the mandated precautions. But tonight, when I went in to pick up my food, they had diners seated at full capacity. Tables were not spaced out any differently than pre-covid. Customers' backs were 3-4 feet away from diners at the next table . The kitchen was FULL of people, cooking and prepping. One person was wearing his mask properly. The other 6-7 had their mask either on their chin, or partially covering their mouths, with noses uncovered. When I pointed it out to one of the staff, she said that "sometimes they remove their masks to talk to each other." As if that was OK...As if that was a good enough reason for them to be putting their customers lives at risk. They insist that we protect THEM. It's posted on the door. No entry unless wearing a face mask. But management will not protect YOU. Do not eat here; do not eat FROM here. Not unless you don't mind your food sprayed with droplets from kitchen staff, or from other diners. I am a nurse in NYC. I am pretty sure over a million people worldwide have died from Covid. I'm pretty sure the Covid pandemic was not a hoax. I'm pretty sure our numbers are going UP again. This kind of disregard for public safety is appalling. Shame on you, Eduardo's Trattoria! read more

They charge a service fee on every order????These policies, however, don't apply to all states. Credit card surcharges are illegal in California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, New York, Oklahoma, Maine and Texas. Merchants should be aware of their state laws before applying convenience fees or surcharges to transactions. read more

Disappointed they charged a 3.99% surcharge because we paid with a credit card. Service was not good - we were asked when our table was cleared if we wanted a second drink read more

It is not easy trying to find good pizza in this area! But this by far has the best buffalo chicken pizza and penne vodka! It is also very clean and nice inside. read more

I wouldn't even give it a rating the owner is a dick and treats his staff like shit food is barely even edible. Had shrimp scampi and puked from it, it didn't smell good at all and shrimp was barely even cooked. Pizza is barely even cooked I got a large pie and it was soggy right out of the oven no crunch. I suggest you go to Caccatori, Mike N Joes, or dBerto's Pizza. This place is horrible. read more

Always have had great food and friendly service here. I enjoy their salads mostly but the pizza is always a close second.

Great food, friendly and attentive staff. The specials are always on point and of course the regular menu is awesome as well

Love their salads - they are truly meals, and not just lettuce, onions and a couple of tomatoes like other pizzerias offer. My only criticism is that I don't think the bacon is cooked in their chopped salad. Of course it's smoked and perfectly safe to eat, but I'd prefer crunchy bacon or crunchy pancetta. Their pizza is good, but their panini sandwiches are a greasy mess. read more

Amidst the low/poor reviews, I ordered delivery from here. I had the chicken francese and veal marsala lunch specials, which were $10 and included a decent-sized portion of the main dish and a large side of pasta (sauce and noodle of choice). I also ordered a chicken panini. All of the food was good and delivered fast. read more

Love the pesto chicken salad!! Pizza is great too. We ate in there a few times and it was a little Italian restaurant feel, loved our experience. read more

These guys are the best around..Service is great and staff is always a pleasure all the time..I make a special trip for their food and well worth it. read more

one of my goto places. solid stuff all around. great vodka sauce, chicken and very good creamy balsamic. hands on owner , don't hesitate to try. read more

Penne vodka from here is fantastic! The plain slice is very tasty as well. Been ordering from here more recently because I really like the food and the people are friendly. My wife tried a panini from them and said it was unique and delicious, it had apples and gorgonzola i believe. Definitely recommend this place. read more

Our new favorite for delivery! Also a great place to go in and sit for lunch! Staff is friendly, food is fresh. We've ordered many different things from their menu, and each was amazing! read more

Eduardo's has a lot of good food but some are really bad. Service sucks and messed up on bunch of orders and one time I ordered delivery and they never delivered. I had a phili cheese steak and it was horrible, it was really soggy and dripping really badly. It is so hard to eat and all mush when you try to eat it. I highly don't recommend having a phili cheese steak. read more

This building has passed through many hands over the years, but I am hopeful that the current establishment will continue with a long and prosperous future. I appreciate this trattoria's attention to detail - from the generous portion of herbed olive oil which accompanied our bread, to the clean setting and attentive (though not intrusive) staff. I found the food to be well prepared and the menu to be sufficiently varied. Our various sandwiches were enjoyable and ample in portion size. I do wish that the kids' menu prices were cheaper, and the portion size could be reduced to compensate. But overall, we really enjoyed Eduardo's - the food is delish! read more

Excellent Food, Friendly service. I have not had a bad meal here and I've been eating here at least twice a week for months.

Not happy about service charge because we paid with DEBIT card and the floor was filthy with leftover food from previous diners. Food has been ok but don't think we'll go back. It was a very disappointing dinner. Daniella works hard and is attentive to her customers. I give her an A+ but restaurant a D. read more