I ate there and got food poisoning. The chicken is undercooked and everything tastes the same…read more Service was good but who cares if you get sick

Camarones a la Diabla is my go to dish. Service is solid, and the horchata was in a huge mug. There…read morewasn't anything wrong with the experience, it just wasn't anything that blew me away. I'll give them credit for execution of order customization by the other guests at my table.

Puerto has the best salsa in new Albany! They are generous with the salsa and chips. The service is…read morequick... like impossibly quick. The inside is clean and all the booths are nice! Can't beat Puerto for a quick simple meal!

We've tried the Jeffersonville restaurant, and with a coupon it was time to try this location. In…read moreJeff, I commented on lousy salsa. Here in NA, the salsa was thick, chunky and darn tasty. The chips were fresh, and not too thick. We were off to a good start. My wife ordered shrimp tacos. Three well packed tacos with a side of rice & guac. The shrimp were decent sized, perfectly grilled, and completely flavorless. Now, the fajitas. Just like in Jeff, Puerto Vallarta dices the chicken & beef rather than serving strips. A generous portion, perhaps lacking in onions & peppers, served sizzling hot. Again, only refried beans were offered. No black or boracho beans were available. And again, not a lot of seasoning for any special flavor. Puerto Vallarta offers lots of options on the menu. But, based on my two visits, the recipes need some serious tweaking to bring flavors forward. But if you like bland Mexican food, you'll love it here.

What a great little Mexican place... the chicken soup is 5 star! Wow. Service was great and the…read morerestaurant was clean and well lit.

Service was great! Attended to quickly after we entered the restaurant…read more Promptly seated! Drink orders taken. Food order taken. Drinks arrive quickly and food followed. The restaurant is nice and clean and vibrant colors. Always enjoy coming here! Food was great tasting and presentation was very nice!

I ordered door dash from them. Two dinners. My order was two…read moreBeef enchiladas with sour cream on the side. Did not get the side and I got two cheese enchiladas instead of two beef . I called and she spoke to the manager and I was told they would remake if I want to come get it. I paid 58$ for yhis and they would not redeliver, that I need to contact grub hub. Well guess what ? Grub hub did not screw this order up, the store did and I'm not calling anyone but the store. Terrible way to treat a new customer, just terrible. I will not and hope you don't make the mistake of ordering for this treatment. The other order was incorrect as well. I was so mad , I just hung up and yold them how terrible this is.

My first visit to a Señor Iguanas. Easy to walk right in and get a table on a Friday at night…read more Plenty of accessible parking and an accessible entrance. The atmosphere is fun and lighthearted, like a backyard gathering. There's plenty of outdoor patio seating on nice nights. The chips were fresh and tasty, the salsa was lovely, with a warming medium heat to it. I highly recommend the Spicy Pina'Rita (get the Grande!). The fact my server brought me a lemon water also without me having to ask was much appreciated. The elotes was perfect. Don't skip the lime. ‍ It is an incredible balance of sweet and heat, served at the perfect temperature. The street tacos were also good. The barbacoa was my favourite because it was the most juicy and flavorful. The flavor of the carnitas was so subtle it was almost entirely eclipsed by the onions. If I had any critique it would be to go easier on the cebollas or longer on marinating the pork. The carne asada was good, but I will probably not get it again simply because the barbacoa was really the stand out for me. The rice was light and fluffy, and the black beans were almost sweet at first with a nice earthy finish. Every staff member I encountered was super friendly and welcoming and I thoroughly enjoyed my experience here.

At first glance you think nothing is there but I am so glad I took a chance on this place…read more Management is absolutely amazing. Everybody's friendly. The food is made by hand. Everything homemade sopas are delicious. The tacos you can't get enough of and the sides are spot on. And it comes with this wonderful roasted jalapeño. You'll find yourself comfortable in a warm atmosphere. Busy during lunchtime. Perfect timing is a little after lunch. If you pass this place up, it's your loss,

The tacos are the size of my pinky toe and they're 5 dollars each!!! The water taste odd,…read moreundrinkable. Grantee they keep it that way to sell drinks. As they've done fooled me 3 times and it's the only thing that stayed consistent. The Bria tacos are the only reason to come check it out, you'll probably regret the overall experience though. The peanut hot sauce and service was very good. But they are obviously only in it for the money.

Awesome food and super Friendly staff. I recommend the carnitas...it's amazing. Parking can be…read moretight during busy times but worth it.

Food was good, but nothing spectacular. Environment is clean and large, but parking is limited…read more Margarita on the rocks was a bit watered down. Service was friendly and prompt. Portions are very large. Overall a good addition to the Henryville area.

If your kid comes home from a sleepover, and says that he had Fiesta Time at the party and it was…read morereally good, believe him. I'm really glad that we listened to mine and ventured out tonight for dinner. The menu isn't necessarily different from other Mexican restaurants, but the quality of food is. We started with their complementary salsa and chips. The salsa already has a bite to it, but if you would prefer something hotter, just ask. The queso is also really good and the large is enormous. I opted to stay on the sides menu and ask for the beef and bean burrito as well as one soft taco with grilled cheese. You get a lot of protein inside of your tortilla. I am so full! And I really appreciated having the option to have grilled chicken rather than shredded plus the burrito was not greasy. We were seated right away and had fantastic, quick service. Their parking lot shares space with several other businesses so there's plenty of spots to go around. Indoor seating as well as patio good for small or larger groups. We will definitely be back!

This place is just solid in every way. Food is always good, hot, fast, delicious. It's loud, and…read morebustling, but never slow and rarely overcrowded to the point they can't handle it. Seems to be a lively bar area also. Not a "destination", per se, but for nearby residents and folks just looking for good, authentic food, great drinks, and nice atmosphere (especially outdoors in nice weather) -- all for a great $ value -- I'd say you can't go wrong here.

5/7/2026 We took 21 Residents from the Swan Pointe HOA to el…read moreToro Mexican Restaurant. We were greeted by the GM, Hector. He is a supporter of Swan Pointe. We were using the big room in the back of the restaurant. Our servers were Isabella and Aracely (but is called Shellie). A lot of our residents go there to eat and knew exactly what they wanted to eat. I got some really nice pictures of the platters. I didn't really see a lot of duplication on the meals. My husband and I shared the Burrito Supremo that came with two burritos. We chose to get one Grilled Chicken and one Steak Burrito and Refried Beans and Rice. We also ordered an extra side of beans and rice. This one meal was enough for both of us. The servers were so good when the food came about knowing who got what! They checked in on us and brought refills for our drinks and cleared our dishes. We really had a good time at el Toro's and enjoyed talking. We were really relaxed and we had a couple of brand new homeowners at our dinner and even got to meet 2 family members. Robyn

THE BEST MEXICAN RESTAURANT!!!!! After evaluating every Mexican restaurant based on steak fajitas…read moreand quesadillas. El toro clears the competition, and makes me disappointed to eat anywhere else. Nothing compares. I0/10.