This is a 3.5 for me, rounding up to 4…read more I came here with a bunch of friends and had a nice meal! I love the cozy lodge atmosphere: it's pretty spacious inside, clean, and not too noisy (able to have good conversations without shouting). The server was also pretty attentive and friendly. Here's the food I tried: - Tater logs: giant delicious tater tots with cheese inside - "Walleye": It wasn't true walleye, but Alaska Pollock. However, I appreciate they disclosed that. It had great flavor and texture similar to lake walleye. The green beans were fresh and the rice pilaf was very flavorful with carrots and celery (not packaged minute rice) - Catfish: heavy breading, humongous portion. Catfish was never my favorite fish and this didn't change my mind. I appreciate the big portions, quality food, and great atmosphere. There aren't many restaurant options in the area, but this is definitely a good one!

Walleye dinner is more than $17.50 now, they haven't updated their prices on-line as of 06/21/26, I…read morewent a request for new on-line prices a week ago.

I ordered just a small pizza and a beer. Pizza finally came out and it was burnt…read more took a bite and I could not eat it. I ate the cheese off the top with the pepperoni. I had to go find her to get a bill. then she asked me if I wanted to take it home. I laughed at her and told her it was un Edible. And she just walked away! So when I paid my bill, I paid just for my food and a drink. I told her if she wants to take that nasty pizza off my bill she can have her tip that way. I will never ever go back there

Some of the food is ok, only the perch is what I would consider "good." Just had their pizza for…read morethe second time, both times were inedible. Unless you like spaghettios, the cheapest of "mozzella," and really tasteless meat. The crust, also not chewy and not as good as a hand tossed pizza should be, weirdly, my "Parmesan crust," tasted like it had sugar sprinkled in it. Could be the sauce was so sugary that it just seemed like it. I added garlic, pizza sauce and hot pepper flakes I like at home, and still threw it out. Not had a decent burger there either (they make the bartenders cook them frequently, and they're still paid less than their cooks are). I know it's a "local pub," but I wouldn't expect anything to be very good. One more note: literally the weirdest tasting dirty martini ever. Waiting to see if something was "off," but hoping it was just some nasty bitters or a spoiled olive, I ordered my fave vodka, so it wasn't that.

We have reviewed this restaurant many times. This is a review just to say it once again how great…read moretheir food is here. We had our traditional favorites. We tried two new dishes today. The garden party salad and the crème brûlée. Both were spectacular. We still love their vegetarian highlights here and hope they keep many on the menu. The service staff is nothing but spectacular as well. The overall vibe here is cozy in their booths. We will return again.

This place was fantastic. Really interesting historic building with cool decor and a great bar…read more Parking nearby. Menu with something for everyone; classic options along with some different, more adventurous stuff if so inclined. I enjoyed my halibut, as well as the salmon I had a few bites of -- it was perfectly cooked. I was super impressed with the risotto. Awesome flavor and the chicken was so well-seasoned. They have a solid cocktail list here, too. Friendly service and great food will have us coming back to try more! Our only gripe was that the olives appetizer should come with more bread :P

Five star every time I go there excellent very strong drinks excellent service, good ambience,…read moreexceptional quality every time would highly recommend if you ever want a fine dining experience and and impress someone by taking them there

Big Fish restaurant was the best food we had on our 12 day journey. Everything was excellent and…read morepresentation was beautiful. Staff was very helpful, welcoming and positive. Atmosphere also a plus. But the biggest plus is the food. One of those meals you think about later. Will go back if we are ever in town again.

Great beer and friendly service. Looks like a newish outside seating area that overlooks an…read moreinteresting intersection. Definitely some enetertainment value. The #13 and stout coffee highly recommend. Burgers great! The chicken wrap was tasty and seemingly healthier. If you are in Sandusky - RECOMMEND ! If we are around, we will be back!

This salad was delicious! Made with greens, cherries, pecans, Granny Smith apples, cheese, pretzel…read morecroutons with a yummy vinaigrette dressing!!! I had grilled chicken added. The service was great and fast too!!! My dining companions' food also looked amazing!!! I would be here often if I lived in the area.

recommend the chicken tenders and the reuben, good bar food! service was great and loved the design…read moreof the restaurant.

This time I have to complain about the food. I ordered the "bronzed salmon". It was BLACK AND…read moreBURNT. As were the veggies ...I'm talking BLACK! I ordered my dinner and sat and waited for my salad to be delivered. It was brought at the same time as my entree. The bartender showed it to the manager who offered me "more veggies". My appetite was gone by then. So they took about $1.25 off of my bill. BIG DEAL!!! If you do come here specify you'd like your salad first and don't care for blackened burnt veggies. Very disappointing! Perhaps the kitchen is having a bad night. Typically the food here is pretty good.

Came here with my kids one summer evening. The seats on the outside deck are one of the best views…read moreof the freighters as they navigate the river. Our service was great. The food was great )even the kids Mac & Cheese and chicken tenders.

We absolutely loved the waterfront dining outside, it was a perfect night and view - definitely…read moreadded to our experience! Our server was kind and attentive, he made good recommendations. The meal was very tasty, slightly overpriced in my opinion for the portion size comparative to other similar establishments but really delicious nonetheless. Great wine and cocktail selection.

4 people for dinner on a Wednesday. Arrived shortly before 4 PM. As requested, seated on first…read morefloor rear of restaurant about 3 steps above main floor. No one else seated in that area at that time. With entire floor empty, four of us were seated at the table at the back where all traffic to and from kitchen must pass. Not a problem, but by the time we had dinner with dessert, the entire area was filled with customers...subjecting us to the constant in/out business of the kitchen traffic. Clearly we were given the noisiest and worse table in a location where there was not a single occupied table. I didn't think we appeared that undesirable. The bill for our dinners with dessert came to almost $300...two of us had salmon with plum sauce, a dish we enjoyed and have had on prior visits. My complaint...1 person asked for extra plum sauce to take with her leftover salmon. She received a plastic container with approximately 3 ounces of sauce. The charge $3.00. I am not cheap, or I wouldn't be treating people to rib-eye steak or salmon that we enjoyed at a place like White Horse Inn. But...I do consider WHI to be cheap and willing to sacrifice losing a customer with that kind of service, or lack thereof. I know that you are popular, serve good food and I understand why that is true. No doubt you won't miss the four customers you have lost over the above issues.

The White Horse Inn is always a favorite. It's suitable for any occasion, dress up or dress down,…read moreand you and your party will still be comfortable and enjoy a great meal. Some of my favorites are the potato chip fish, the classic turkey dinner, and always the fresh baked chocolate chip cookies (to eat there or take home for later). While I haven't tried the igloos yet since I have an aversion to driving when it may snow, inside is always fun (while it's large, the vibe is cozy with tons of details), and outside is great in the late spring and summer for sure.