For being Detroit style in NYC, Emmy is pretty good. The service here at this location was so kind and helpful. Emmy's was clean and homey, with light music on the background. The pizza is great, my party of 3 got the Founders Pizza (sixer) - pepperoni, jalepnos, hot honey. Yumm! The brownie skillet was a great treat for someone like me who has a sweet tooth! read more

See all

My husband and I were in New York 10 years ago, and had pizza and the burger, and could not wait to come back and bring our boys here! To say they loved it is an understatement, my 15 year old son loved the burger so much he made us come back on our last day to get it again, his new favorite burger! The burger really is incredible. Get two patties, and let the sauce run all over your hands. The pretzel bun makes it, it's soft and salty, burger perfection! The pizza is also amazing!! The founders pizza is so good!! The perfect pepperoni, jalapeño, and honey, and that marinara sauce is crack, why is it so good??!! Good Pauline pizza and we added mushrooms- hello!! Delish!! We also tried the spicy chicken sandwich, and it's good, but not the greatest compared to the burger and pizza. We will come eat here EVERY time we are in New York! read more

See all

Service was fantastic. The food was really great! Got their VIP pizza. Loved the sesame crunch on the crust. Also had the chicken parm sandwich which was a perfect cheesy mess! Excellent flavor. Ambiance felt cozy but not too cramped. We'll definitely be back. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - VIP Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Stopped by to try a promotion on slices today! The cheese pizza was fresh and crispy. Could use a little more sauce but overall very good! Service was great! Kaae I think was her name was friendly and smiled making me feel welcome. The wait staff who brought out my pizza was also nice. A good spot for date night or large group dining. Bar seating available too. Restroom available. To enter the restaurant there are a few stairs down. Conveniently located - a short walk to Times Square. Looking forward to coming back for dinner soon! read more

See all

Unfortunately, we had a bad experience here and will not be returning or recommending this restaurant. It seemed like the bartender was also hosting. She didn't greet us and appeared annoyed when we asked for a table for four. She sat us down without saying much and then walked away waited 15 min until someone came to our table, while we were still eating our appetizers. At one point, I asked my 9-year-old to get cups from the empty table next to us. She stacked three cups, and a waitress who was wrapping utensils yelled at her, "Excuse me, those are not toys!" I found that response completely inappropriate, especially considering my daughter was simply trying to get cups for our table and there were only about 3-4 tables occupied in the entire restaurant. I spoke up and explained that she wasn't playing with them. Our server also left a glass water bottle on the table without providing cups or utensils, which added to the overall poor experience. The atmosphere felt like everyone working there was unhappy to be there, and unfortunately, that came across in the service. The pizza itself was probably a 7/10, but the dough was noticeably undercooked. Overall, the service and treatment we received were disappointing. Unfortunately, we will not be returning or referring anyone here. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - The unhappy rude waitress - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great place to grab a bit to eat before or after a Broadway show. The pizza is amazing. It is Detroit style but it is so good. We tried the Founders (the most popular pizza on the menu) and it includes pepperoni, jalapeños and hot honey. It is spicy so beware but it is quite tasty. We are tried the margarita pizza which comes with burrata cheese on top. The group enjoyed it. I didn't care for the buttata. The seating is limited so make a resy. The wait staff was friendly and fast. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Delicious pizzas and burgers. Centrally located on a side street near Times Square, cozy seating, staff were really nice but had to ask twice for a few things cause they were pretty overworked. The pizza has a really nice crisp and texture to it. No beers on tap, everything is cans or bottles poured into a glass. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Emmy Squared Pizza is delicious Detroit style pizza! All of options very tasty, you can't really go wrong with any flavor. I personally like a classic red sauce pizza. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Detroit in the city. Ordered the 6 slice Detroit pan pizza. Flew all the way from Cali to hit my usual pizza joints when we walked to one of my old favs to find a new joint in its place. Emmys apparently has been here awhile and we didn't even know it. Love the story about the couple who owns it. Pizza came out in 20 minutes and within 10 minutes there was no trace it was ever at the table. Devoured. Delicious. My hats off to this young dynamic couple with a vision. Solid choice for great pizza steps from Times Square. Crazy Bernie and Tammy the Tornado are huge fans. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - Sorry I didn't get this pic before the first 2 casualties were in our bellies. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great food, have been to four locations and they're all great. I recommend the Hawaiian pizza for the chili glaze.

We had the vegan pizza and it was absolutely delicious! The restaurant was small yet clean and quaint. And the service was excellent! The location was also great as we were also able to walk from our hotel. It was our best meal in New York! read more

Sooo Good!!! Taste: We loved everything we ordered. The chefs special pizza under promised and over delivered... truly exceptional. The brussels sprout salad was unique and delicious. And we loved both cocktails... the espresso and pear bourbon drinks. Service: The service was fine. Our dinner reservation was for 8pm and they closed at 9. Server was friendly and everything came out great, but we were not checked in on again after our food arrived. Would have otherwise ordered dessert. Ambiance: Very cute... even better in person than any of the pics. Was a little warm but great space nonetheless. Would have done four stars for service and ambiance, but the food was so good I gave it five. read more

See all

Let's start with the Service! Jack was hands down the best! We almost passed on it but his energy brought us back to reconsider and I'm glad we did! He was very knowledgeable about the food and the history of the restaurant, He made us feel super welcome from start to finish! The food and Drinks were A++ that was our first time having Detroit style pizza and Being a native New Yorker I'm happy to say it was Great! Clean Restrooms too! Sorry for the long Review but it's definitely worth a visit if you're in town...Look for Jack! read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

It was awesome! Jack and Charlotte were great and this was some of the best pizza I had in a long time!

A big group of us had an amazing experience at Emmy Squared before a Broadway show matinee. From the moment we walked in, Jack, the server and bartender extraordinaire, was so great! Extremely personable, knowledge and just so fun! He truly made our experience great. And the food was excellent! So many great pizza options! We will definitely be coming back. read more

Perfect for catching up with friends! The staff--especially Jack--are amazing, and the pizza tastes so good. Thank you! read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - Perfect for catching up with friends! The staff--especially Jack--are amazing, and the pizza tastes so good. Thank you! - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Laura took great care of us and the pizza itself was fantastic! We had a great time and will be back soon.

If you're looking for a great tasting, imaginative pizza experience, then Emmy Squared is a must. I've been to the one on 48th St. on numerous occasions, and I've never been disappointed. In fact, things always manage to surpassed my expectations. I strongly recommend the Colony pizza because the opposing flavors of the pepperoni, jalapeño's, and especially the honey, creates a flavor profile that is next level. I can say that all of their pizza options are amazing, and I don't think that you can make a mistake. The ambiance of the 48th St restaurant is relaxing and inviting, and the staff is friendly and helpful. It's a strong recommendation and I'm sure that you'll enjoy yourself. read more

See all

Great pizza and service. Thank you Saujan! Great music playlist too. Will be back for more Detroit style MVP pie with crispy chicken read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Best Detroit style pizza in the city. Good beer selection. Quick and friendly service.

Cozy ambiance but the pizza is De-lush. Just did basic pepperoni with mushrooms. True Detroit style crust. Recommend. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - This is a regular size. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious pizza, amazing salads, and a burger that I've never had but looks amazing. This is a fun bar / restaurant with a great vibe. I often stay at a hotel on this street and this is one of my go to restaurants. read more

Absolutely delicious. We had a show down the street and thought we'd get a quick bite and didn't realize it was sit down. We didn't want to keep looking so we sat at the bar and advised that we were in a bit of a rush and they were able to accommodate. We shared the Caesar salad and Detroit pizza and we were so glad we did. Both the salad and pizza were so so good. Highly recommend! read more

A solid Detroit-style slice -- they serve single slices in the afternoon but we stopped in before a show at Radio City! The MVP slice was great, crispy on the edges and fluffy in the middle. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - MVP Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Jack was attentive to everything we needed! The lunch crowd was not too loud or overwhelming, and he handled the whole room with ease. Gluten free crust was great and the Big Ang delivered!! read more

Loved it here! I had wanted to try this place for awhile. I was staying in the area, and it was conveniently located on the same block. I stopped in for dinner on a week night. There were other people dining, but there was no wait. We ordered pizza and the salad. The food was incredible! I was pleasantly surprised, even though I had read other great reviews on Emmy's food. I can't wait to stop back in and try more of their food options. If I'm in the area again, I'll definitely stop back in. I highly recommend this spot! read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Be sure Jack is there! Super friendly and fast service. Positive vibes only! Add to that, the Meatsiah pizza was great!

Great pizza here! Other food is fine but pizza is the star. It does get quite busy and loud so was happy to have a reservation. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious pizza, fantastic Caesar salad but it's a lot for one person. Very cozy place not far from Times Square on a pretty quiet street just off 8th. Friendly staff. Nice crowd- it's for anyone. I saw a young family, a group of friends, a couple and more small friend groups. Very good Detroit pizza with the delicious caramelized edge. So good! And while you think the pizza will be heavy, it's not. The dough is light and fluffy- with mouth watering caramelized cheese on every edge! Their Caesar salad might be one of the best I've ever had- it's fresh and seriously well made. But it's a huge portion and they wouldn't serve a half-portion so it was expensive and wasteful for me, dining alone. I highly recommend the pizza and yes the salad is that good. Too bad they don't size down the salad for a single person (or even just for two!). Go here. It's good. It's an easy vibe and accommodating for anyone. Very happy with my meal but wish the menu offered a smaller salad. read more

See all

Delicious pizza, try the Quinn with the cilantro ranch. Great service, nice atmosphere.

The staff here was so friendly! They had great recommendations The salad was delicious but the kale did come in giant chunks which was confusing. Had to chop it up a bunch ourselves. The pizza is what you come here for! It was outstanding. Crispy edges and a doughy center with quality red sauce and cheese. Can't wait to come back and try more The restaurant itself was cute and had ample seating good for big groups even read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - If Looks Could Kale - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We ordered a couple small pies to our roof nearby, slices were small, cute, dough was thick and fluffy. Delish. Flavor was really good- the spicy pepperoni was ACTUALLY SPICY!!! Pesto garlic had a great kick and the regular was excellent as well. It was a great starter for us to share at the beginning of our evening saturday night. The square slices cut into smaller pieces were great for passing around to a group of 15 of us. read more

The best pizza hands down!! Working on a ship I've always been obsessed with breakfast but I tried their pizza and now it's my go to every time I stop by!! read more

The pizza is square! It's a great place, the Caesar salad is awesome, the margarita pizza is perfect: You can share it with two people along with the salad and have a great meal. read more

I'm a little torn about this; Could've been a 5 star. I was pleasantly surprised with the pizza here. I really enjoyed the detroit style chewy center and crispy outsides a lot more than I expected I would. I love that you can get a large for only 5 dollars more which makes it so much more economical and family friendly. Check out the specials before you decide to order! We actually missed them and then had to change our order; props to our server for getting those last minute changes in. In any case the downside for me was the burger; in general we enjoy the Emily burger very much, and while not so much the west village emily, the burger just wasn't nearly as delicious as what we were expecting given Emily(brooklyn) burgers. In any case i'll probably be back at some point! read more

Thank you, Jack! Perfect pizza. Great margaritas. Great service. Stop in before your show! read more

The pizza was delicious and i especially loved the cheese on top. Supper fast service as we only had 30 minutes. Good house wine. Recommended for lunch :) read more

Was excited to try as a lot of people said great things about it but did not compare to Aces !!

I'll start by saying this review is for delivery so unfortunately I'm unable to comment on the ambiance or what the location is like in-person, but I did have an issue with the app I ordered through (Toast Takeout, the service you are redirected to when you click order for takeout or delivery on their website) and tried calling the location directly twice and got forwarded to voicemail after the phone rang and rang each time so my impression of the service isn't great given they couldn't be bothered to simply pick up the phone. That issue aside, the food that was delivered to me was a bit hit or miss. The pizza was out of this world good! Seriously, amazing flavor and texture- crisp crunchy edges and fluffy interior, the Big Hawaiian had just the right amount of heat and sweet to tantalize the taste buds! The pizza itself is small and so are the individual slices, but half of it fills you up quick so it's perfect to split with a friend or save for another meal. I completely get the hype now! The Chopped Italian Salad was a real let down. There were barely any toppings, it was essentially just a box full of chopped romaine with 3 grape tomatoes sliced in half, a handful of chickpeas, a few slivers of roasted red bell peppers, some flavorless pieces of provolone, and chunks of soppressata that personally I did not enjoy the taste of one bit. For a salad that costs $22 I genuinely expected something fresher, higher in quality, better in taste, and just far more than what I received, I'm genuinely astounded they would let this go out the door. For a salad this simple you, either do it well or don't do it at all. Overall, I'm torn. The pizza was hands down some of the best I've had and I'm looking forward to having it again, but I'd probably never order anything else off the menu so I think takeout might be the way to go so you can fix your own sides at home. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - Chopped Italian (remaining half after having eaten) - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

It was absolutely delicious! We had jack as a server and the service was great as well. The ambiance is very nice as well. Me and my sister shared a regular pizza and it was the perfect portion. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen - Half Miranda half classic pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York