Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Extra Space Storage

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open 6:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Updated 1 week ago

    Services - Extra Space Storage

    Extra Space Storage Photos

    Special offers for you

    Sponsored

    4.5
    (534 reviews)
    Movers
    Responds in about 10 mins
    New on Yelp
    Window Washing
    New on Yelp
    Junk Removal & Hauling
    Responds in about 20 mins
    Loading...Loading...Loading...

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Extra Space Storage

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Jonathan is so helpful and kind. He answered all of my questions with ease. The facility is super clean and organized as well.

    Business owner information

    Photo of Emily S.

    Emily S.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Extra Space Storage

    You might also consider

    Public Storage

    Public Storage

    3.0
    (22 reviews)

    Reaja very patient and answered all my questions thoroughly. She's a great asset for the company…read more It would be nice to have her at the hicksville location full time.

    For four years, I'd rented a space at the Public Storage on Hempstead Turnpike in Bethpage. The one…read morewith the lighthouse out front. I was happy with that place, and was sorry to leave when the rent reached a point where it no longer made sense to keep paying so much for a unit I could find somewhere else for less. That was a couple of years ago, and I'm once again looking for a storage space. The best deal I'd found online was at this other location, right by the train tracks in Hicksville. So I made a reservation online, chose my move in date, received confirmation by text, email, and voicemail. Everything was good to go, until I showed up with my tape measure in hand to check out the space. When I walked in, I waved hello to the guy behind the counter and said I was interested in renting a storage unit. He was not exactly friendly. "Do you have a reservation?" Without looking up from his computer. "Yes." "At this location?" Still not even looking at me. "Yes, but before we do that, can I ask a question?" No response, so I continued. "What's the easiest way to turn left into this parking lot? See, where that white car is now, coming from that direction?" (Old Country Road is busy, and there is a turning lane after the entrance, which puts you onto a narrow kind of alley, running between the building and the elevated LIRR tracks. While waiting to turn, you are facing cars in the oncoming turning lane. Then you go to the back of the lot, make a u-turn and come back, make a right and then another into the lot. It didn't seem ideal for making multiple trips with a van, and I wondered if this employee might have a helpful suggestion.) Wrong. "How long have you had a license?" Seriously, that was his response. Not said in a joking or playful way, but with contempt. When a customer asks a question, it is an opportunity to engage in conversation and make the sale, or just establish a friendly rapport. This guy didn't seem interested in any of those things. In fact, he seemed annoyed that I was standing there. So I smiled and said, "Thank you," and turned to leave. I figured I'd come back another day when there was a different employee working who might be more pleasant. Then I turned back. "What is your name?" "You don't have a reservation." Spoken as an accusation. "Yes, I do." I did, and would gladly have given him my reservation number, or my name, or my phone number, or whatever information he needed to help him find it, except he never asked. "You don't have a reservation. There is nothing on the board." I'm not sure what that meant, but it implied that I was lying. What was puzzling was that, even if a customer didn't have a reservation, shouldn't his response have been, "No problem, I'll be happy to help?" Isn't his job to provide customer service, with the goal of renting out a space? Also, there is a difference between, "You don't have a reservation," and "I'm sorry, I can't seem to find your reservation." One of those sentences blames the customer, the other admits the possibility that the mistake could be his. Again, I smiled and said, "Thank you," and left. It felt like his antipathy was personal. Acute. Focused specially on me, for whatever reason. At first. Then I heard from the two guys at a nearby storage company that they routinely hear complaints about him from customers who came from that place, to theirs. As I did. So perhaps it is just his manner, and he treats everyone with the same rudeness. To paraphrase Freud, sometimes a cigar is just a dick. About an hour later, the same salesman who left a voice message confirming my reservation called again to follow up on... my reservation. Which I clearly did have, or he would not have called. Twice. "Glad you called. Let me tell you what happened when I went there in person." After hearing a condensed version of the above, he said, "Well, he said that you were rude to him!" "Of course he did. Because I asked his name, so he knew I was going to complain and figured he'd get there first." By the way, Public Storage telephone salesman, "Our guy said you were the one who was rude," is not exactly sterling customer service, either. The proper response should have been, "We apologize for any rudeness you may have encountered from one of our employees." The point which ended the phone call was this: I'd made the reservation, scheduled the move in date, and was prepared to book the storage space. It was practically a done deal. Until that rude guy cost them the sale, and lost them a customer.

    U-Haul Moving & Storage Of Bethpage

    U-Haul Moving & Storage Of Bethpage

    3.1
    (14 reviews)

    When I realized I needed to rent a truck to move some furniture, I internally cringed as I heard…read moremany horror stories of friends and their experience renting one. They often complained of rude service, dirty trucks, and poor managed businesses. When I came here on a Saturday afternoon, there was none of that. I walked in and though the one and only worker there was busy, he assured me he would get right to me. Once he did there was a little bit of struggle pulling up what supplies I packaged with my online truck reservation as he told me the system was severely lacking. Since we didn't have many options, we went by the honor system and I picked up what I ordered. Going through the contract, the employee was polite answering and questions I had; he even helped me carry things to the truck as my hands were full. I was in and out of there in 15 minutes which was nice. The supplies pricing was very reasonable. The truck itself was very clean inside and out and was damage free. Driving it wasn't too difficult as it offers a variety of mirrors to help you maneuver around. When I returned the truck, it was hassle free since the employee was able to finalize the transaction outside with his cell phone. I would definitely come here again if I needed a truck in this area.

    Ok, as unfortunate as this is, we had to move again 10/1. I have to say, once again, the…read morefriendliest guy ever. Certainly hope I don't have to move again soon but would definitely come back if I had to. This is him below... he deserves the recognition! (This is so creepy...but I don't have his name and just googled the Bethpage location)

    Piece of Cake Moving & Storage

    Piece of Cake Moving & Storage

    4.6
    (2.7k reviews)

    This is the 3rd time I have used Piece of Cake. They completed my move from lower Manhattan to…read moreCenter City Philadelphia this past week. They had seamlessly loaded the contents of my 650 square foot apartment including large/heavy fragile furniture with glass (8 foot tall dresser with mirror weighing 250 lbs, and 50 galloon reptile tank) in about 1 hour. We promptly left via car to meet them at our new address in Philly, and they arrived at exactly the same time as we did. They unloaded the truck in about an hour again, and helped partially unpack and put items in the proper places, especially the furniture that would have been hard for me to move on my own later. I will continue to use Piece of Cake, and have recommended to several friends over the years that I have been using them. It was quick working with the customer support team initially to quote the move, make payment, and on COIs and confirmation. When we move again in a couple years Piece of Cake will be the only mover I call. My recommendation to others considering the service, be transparent and honest about the contents of your move, especially items requiring extra protection even if there is an additional fee involved. There were no surprise add-ons in my move because we carefully selected every single item that would be included in our move early on in the process, and made sure to reply in detail to the follow up emails regarding insurance, access to the apartments (stairs vs elevator, reserved elevator, etc.), and so on move-in day everything went off without a hitch. Piece of Cake are professionals and we love the service.

    I had an excellent experience with Piece of Cake Movers for my move from Albany, NY to Buffalo, NY…read more Moving such a long distance can be stressful, but the entire process was smooth and much easier thanks to their team. From start to finish, they were professional, reliable, and careful with my belongings. The movers were friendly, worked efficiently, and took the time to make sure everything was handled properly. They treated my items with care and made what could have been a very stressful day go smoothly. I really appreciated their communication and the quality of service they provided. If you're looking for a moving company you can trust, I would definitely recommend Piece of Cake Movers.

    Extra Space Storage - selfstorage - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...