A great traditional restaurant with authentic Italian dishes. Excellent service. Don't skip the Housemade gelato before you leave. They also cater. We showed up without reservations, and they found us a table, but I recommend reserving ahead of time. We took the waitress's recommendation on the pasta. It was outstanding. Complimentary bread and shallow dish of olive oil and vinegar brought to the table. This was also so good. We ordered: Gli Antipasti | Appetizers - BURRATA with ROASTED COMPARI TOMATOES - Burrata + pomodori Campari arrostiti + pesto + Olio EVO (Burrata imported from Italy roasted in wood-fired oven along with tomatoes + basil + EVOO.) Pesto is made with pistachios. Absolutely delicious - POLPETTE DELLA NONNA - Meatballs made with Nonna's (grandma's) recipe. Also very good! Pizzas - DIAVOLA - San Marzano pomodoro + mozzarella + salame piccante + Olio EVO (San Marzano tomato sauce + mozzarella + spicy salami + EVOO). Son said their pizza was amazing. Wood fired. Handmade Pasta - RAVIOLI AL BRASATO x2 - Con crema burro e salvia (Braised short-rib ravioli with a buttercream sage sauce) a subtle herbed rich cream sauce over fresh pasta filled with braised short rib. Great flavor and filling. I could tell the pasta was Housemade on taste. Le Insalate | Salads - PERA | PEAR - Rucola + pere + pomodorini + mandorle tostate vinaigrette al limone (Arugula + pears + cherry tomatoes + toasted almonds + shaved parmesan + lemon vinaigrette. Daughter loved this salad. Presented so well. Looked amazing. We had no room for dessert. We'll have to come back for some espresso and treats. Patio seating available or table and bar seating inside at a cozy spot that feels very welcoming. read more

See all

The food is EXCELLENT and FRESH. I love the fact, he imports all of his ingredients from Italy, so it doesn't have GMO or Monsanto poison in it like most foods have in the US especially the flour it doesn't cause gluten resistance issues. The owner is very friendly as is the staff. I drive 20 minutes past several pizza places from where I live in Surprise to get there. It's well worth the drive If you want quality Fire Oven Pizza. read more

From the first glance at the charcuterie board to the final bite of dessert, this meal felt like a celebration of classic Italian comfort food elevated with quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation. Service was exceptional - from wine recommendations to always having full water glasses. The evening began with an impressive charcuterie board featuring a generous assortment of cured meats, cheeses, olives, and antipasti. The variety was outstanding, offering everything from delicate prosciutto and salami to creamy spreads and tangy marinated vegetables. The board was beautifully arranged and encouraged sharing, conversation, and plenty of flavor exploration. The butternut squash ravoli were served in a rich cream sauce, it was indulgent and satisfying. The pasta was tender and well-filled, while the velvety sauce added a luxurious touch without overwhelming the dish. It was a hit. The orecchiette pasta showcased a more rustic side of Italian cooking. Combined with broccolini, spicy sausage, tomatoes, and a dusting of Parmesan, the dish offered a nice balance of savory, fresh, and earthy flavors. The pasta was perfectly cooked and hearty enough to stand on its own as a memorable entrée. The pizza delivered everything diners hope for from a traditional Italian pie: a beautifully blistered crust, vibrant tomato sauce, and generous toppings. The combination of olives, artichokes, mushrooms, and cured meats created layers of flavor, while the char on the crust suggested a properly hot oven and careful attention to technique. Dessert provided a fitting finale. The tiramisu was light and creamy with a generous dusting of cocoa, offering the classic coffee-and-mascarpone flavors that make it a perennial favorite. The diplomatico was a cream-filled pastry added a contrasting texture with its flaky layers and sweet filling, making it difficult to choose a favorite between the two. The atmosphere was warm and intimate, with low lighting that creates a comfortable dining experience. Portions were generous, presentation was appealing, and the menu demonstrated a commitment to traditional Italian flavors. This restaurant excels at delivering authentic Italian comfort food with quality ingredients and generous portions. The standout charcuterie board, flavorful pasta dishes, well-executed pizza, and exceptional desserts combine to create a memorable dining experience that would be easy to recommend for both casual dinners and special occasions. read more

See all

We didn't have reservation and went there on Saturday night, so waited for 45ish mins. Overall the food was 4/5, but the service was 5/5. The owner introduced the menu seriously and asked multiple times about our experience. My favorite was the pizza which I forgot the name but might be called "fabio" something... The burrata and mortadella was so good and the pizza dough was also amazing. The bolognese was ok, and margherita was good but not wowing me. They treated as a dessert and though we were full but still thought it was good, the cream was light and not too sweet. read more

See all

Fabio on Fire is a small, casual Italian spot offering pastries, gelato, paninis, and pizza. Unlike their other location, this isn't a traditional sit down restaurant with wait staff. You order at the counter, and they bring the food to you. The service is great, and the paninis are amazing. I love their pizzas too, but the paninis really steal the show. My favorite is the Piccante. The mild, creamy cheese paired with sweet caramelized onions and spicy salami creates the perfect balance of flavor. I highly recommend checking it out. It is so worth it. read more

Fabio On Fire - Piccante Panini - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

I love this spot! We have never had a bad meal at Fabio on Fire. From the pizzas and pastas to the gelato, nothing disappoints here. We always enjoy the ambiance, either inside or on the patio, and are always met with top-notch service. My favorite dish here is the bolognese. It is hearty and filling and I typically get two meals out of it thanks to their generous portions. We really enjoy this lovely local gem. read more

Fabio On Fire - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Went to Fabio s for birthday dinner 6 people all ages the food was excellent with great service !! Owner was present and saw him Visit with customers!! Martello our service with excellent food and wine suggestions!! Terrific place for special occasions or a casual dinner!!! Try this and check out weekly specials!!! read more

Felt kind of stuffy walking into this place... almost uncomfortable from the stares. The hostess finally came and asked if we had reservations...2x... to which I replied (both times) - no. Finally seated... waited about 15 minutes before someone came to greet us and take our order. Ambiance- honestly not my favorite cup of tea- was very loud.... could barely hear the music. Food: check out the pictures attached for what we ordered and what we rated it... average place... pizza and meatballs were the highlight of our order. Would I come here again- no. Feeling slightly uncomfortable can change the mood of an entire evening- including dinner. read more

See all

Great menu and great tasting food always. Service is always outstanding. Great Italian variety.

Their food was truly fabulous and took us all back to a nostalgic memory of Italy! Their food is authentic, their service is impeccable, and their restaurant is esthetic. I highly recommend you call to make a reservation to be sure you get a table! read more

Fabio On Fire - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

This place is a hidden gem. Amazing food and service, and such a quaint intimate atmosphere. Really loved everything about it. read more

See all

Amazing the selection of dinner items. We were a party of 3 and this was our first time trying their food. The server we had was so awesome. She wanted to know what food allergies we had at our table and was able to assist us with the food. Restaurant was very clean and staff was friendly and helpful. I loved my ravioli stuffed with short ribs and sauce. So delicious read more

Fabio On Fire - Ravioli with short rib meat and sauce - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Great food and service. Pizza as appetizers, lasagna short rib papperadeli great food and service read more

Fabio On Fire - Short rib papperadeli - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

We were craving Italian and found Fabio On Fire on Yelp. Since we'd never been there before, we decided to give it a shot. The restaurant has both indoor and outdoor seating, and with the nice weather, we chose to sit outside. The tables were a bit close together, and there wasn't much in the way of decor, but it had a relaxed vibe. Our server was super busy--seemed like he was handling all the tables--but he was still really attentive. We ordered the Calamari Fritti with Zucchini, Lobster Ravioli, Salsiccia E Funghi Pizza, and Capricciosa Pizza, plus some gelato for dessert. The calamari was a little small and crunchier than we expected, but everything else was delicious and nicely plated. Glad we found this place--definitely coming back to try more! read more

See all

Visited here for a weekend lunch with a friend. The atmosphere so cute, like a cafe in Europe. I just like the furnishings and decor. The food was wonderful. I really loved both the pizza and the pasta. The pasta was very rich and incredible. The tiramisu was gigantic and oh so delicious. The service was wonderful as well :) read more

See all

My buddy and I stopped by Fabio on Fire | Pizzeria Italiana for dinner. Located in a shopping center, parking won't be a problem. The name of their restaurant makes me think of the I Can't Believe It's Not Butter Fabio commercials back in the day. IYKYK. Fabio was definitely on fire. Service (4.5/5): We were seated close to the open kitchen and our waitress did a great job throughout. She was friendly, checked in on us, and gave us recommendations when we asked. She's also a Michigan fan so you know that's a winner in my book. Ambiance (3.5/5): Pretty much a traditional neighborhood Italian restaurant. What I expected in the 'burbs. There aren't a ton of tables but it's homey and welcoming. Drinks (N/A): I had an Arnold Palmer so not much to report here. Food (4/5): I had the braised rib ravioli which was delicious. The braised rib and the pasta were tender and the pasta sauce was creamy. They complimented each other well. My only complaint is that the portions size was relatively small and overpriced for what you get. But still delicious. I finished things off with the gelato where I was able to pick two flavors. I went with the watermelon and the cookies and cream. The watermelon was delicious and you can never go wrong with cookies and cream. Perhaps my favorite ice cream flavor of all time. If you're looking for a solid Italian meal in Peoria, get lit at Fabio on Fire! read more

See all

Great food and several menu selections and atmosphere is also good it's difficult sometimes to get in unless you have a reservation

Love the food. However 2 weeks ago we ordered Doordash and had our order cancelled 30 minutes after we placed it! The staff claimed they didn't receive it but door dash adamantly stated it was cancelled by the restaurant and they could see it on their end- I emailed about this and no response. Tonight we called ahead and asked how late they took to go orders And they told us 830. We called at 815 to place an order and they told us their kitchen was closed. Same person we spoke to 1 hour prior. We called ahead to make sure to plan our dinner time. I consider this poor service now that it's happened twice and I felt the first time we were lied to and it was never addressed. Food can be great but if customer service is bad, it makes the overall experience poor. Very disappointing - as we love the restaurant and we live right in this neighborhood and love supporting our local businesses. read more

Tried Fabio's for the first time. I definitely understand the hype. The artesian style sandwiches and bread were amazing. The serving size is also pretty large and very shareable. Really small restaurant mostly meant for takeout but definitely worth the trip. They also had a ton of gelato flavors which just looked amazing. Next time we're going to try dessert. read more

See all

Just went here for dinner by myself. It is a higher end place. I sat at the pizza bar, it has Italian vibes because they bring you bread and oil.I ordered the bolognese pasta and it was absolutely amazing. Sadly I can no longer eat inside the restaurant. Food this good I can't help but eat it like a pig. I must get take out from now on. read more

Authentic takes on Italian dishes that show a high degree of sophistication and understanding of this cuisine. The CA sea scallop and white bean purée was to die for. Grandma's meatballs were pitch perfect. Pasta was perfectly cooked. My highest recommendation. read more

Hubby was looking for places we hadn't tried in the area and found this Italian restaurant not too far from home. We arrived at 4...they open at 4...and were the first ones seated. When you first walk in, it doesn't look too big, but after looking around, there were a few different seating areas (including outside). The pizza oven is front and center, plus the kitchen is open, so we were able to see the chef cooking. When we sat down, we were immediately brought Italian bread with olive oil/balsamic for dipping. So good!!!! Our server, Maurizio, was funny and friendly. I ordered the Gnocchi Bolognese...the gnocchi were like tiny pillows, literally melting in my mouth. The sauce was wonderful and the gnocchi so light, it was delicious! Hubby got the Lasagna, which he adored. The sauce tasted like Nonna's been cooking it all day and the pastas were definitely so fresh. We decided to try one of the pizzas, so ordered the Salsiccia E Funghi Pizza to go. We each tried a taste of it after getting home and am so glad we did. Since it was an early dinner, have a feeling we'll be digging into the pizza a little later...LOL! We're really looking forward to coming back soon!! read more

I made a reservation for 2 of us for a Friday dinner. Best way to kick off the weekend and distress. It was so so hard to choose what to eat, everything looks so good from the menu. I showed up right on time for the reservation and they were not ready. I had to wait 10 mins, no problem. My friend was late anyways. When I sat in the other room with the bar, it was very cute and cozy. Read the menu again until my friend got here. I ordered an ice tea and beef short ribs raviolis and butternut sauce. They give you complementary bread & butter. Ravioli Al Brasato (Short-Rib Ravioli) - Braised short-rib ravioli with a buttercream sage sauce. WOW, I want a second order of this amazing dish. I got hazelnut gelato for my dessert. YUM! Service was ok. Friendly when you can get their attention. read more

See all

I conspicuously noticed that was indeed Fabio spinning pizza dough near the wood fired oven upon entering. I immediately had the sentient to know I wanted pizza. Quick glance at the pizza menu and we ordered the Americano pizza. I thought the pizza may have been a little undercooked. It lacked crisp on the outside, and was a little floppy in the core. I did enjoy the pasta dish. House made pasta is unequally always a treat. The sausage was flavoured delicious. Decent Italian food overall. Solid 4 stars imo. read more

See all

Great service, food, and atmosphere. We love the food at Fabio on fire. We decided to cater their food for a party after a few visits to the restaurant. It was a big success! read more

The food was amazing, everything felt so authentic. The menu is in Italian (with helpful translations), which added to the charm. I had the lobster ravioli, affogato, and tiramisu... wow. We'll definitely be back. Thank you, Fabio on Fire! TikTok: @alainaater read more

Fabio On Fire - Buratta & prosciutto - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

This was our third visit and we've been pleased each time! The food is truly authentic and house made which is hard to come by these days. We are big fans of the gnocchi bolognese and the tagliatelle bolognese. Our kids love the pizza of course. Service can be slightly scattered but overall everyone is very friendly and accommodating. Only reason not 5 stars is that the seating is a bit crowded and the consistency of the gnocchi has been variable - from the best I've ever had to moderately good. Nevertheless a go to spot for our family! read more

Fabio On Fire - Kids pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

This is our family favorite Italian restaurant---far above all of the others! We have gone here for many years and not had one bad meal!!

We have dined at Fabio On Fire twice now - and will be going again this Saturday! Reliably good food and great service. We highly recommend getting reservations for groups more than four persons. It can be a bit loud and the tables are close together. We had a margarita pizza the first time - sumptuous is too small a word! Not too pricey, and the staff is very friendly and very efficient. Highly recommend! read more

Came in for some gelato without friends. Their flavors are so yummy and elevated, without being too sweet. The cups are smaller, but they do not level the gelato across the top, but they top it off with a heaping mound of gelato. Service always just as sweet. Highly recommend their pizza and paninis. They will make you paninis to go so you may make your own creations at home. read more

Fabio On Fire - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Today was our first time getting pizza from Fabio's. It was horrible. The crust was burnt as well as the entire bottom of the pizza. I guess it's a good thing I didn't select well done when ordering or the entire pie would have been black. If that wasn't bad enough, when you picked up the slice to eat the crust was so flimsy all of the cheese and pepperoni fell off onto the plate. Save yourself the trouble and select a different pizza place. Save yourself read more

Fabio On Fire - Crust from pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

We came for the Pizza and were pleasantly surprised. I would easily put this near the top of the pizza and Italian restaurants in the Phoenix area. The server was very attentive and it truly was a great location. This will be one of our new favorite places for Pizza and Pasta. read more

Service was slow at first, but they corrected the issue relatively quickly. Food was good. My husband especially enjoyed the cannoli. Wasn't impressed with the charcuterie board. Pizza was good. We will be back. read more

We had a good server. They were busy so he overlooked our reorder for wine. He forgot to give us the specials menu but he was a very nice guy. I ordered pasta and it was fair. Next time I'll try something different. Not used to eating big meals that late at night. The weather was perfect and so was our company. read more

Went there today and I had the pesto gnocchi, as I always do, and it was good but quite a bit saltier than usual. The young lady they sat us could have been a little more friendly when she sat us. The waitress was just ok too, we had to ask to have our drinks refilled. read more

Fabio On Fire is one of those rare gems you almost don't want to tell people about--like a Michelin-star restaurant hiding in the most unsuspecting location. This was our second visit, and somehow it managed to be even more magical than the first. From the moment you walk in, you know you're in for something special. The open kitchen is a show in itself. You can watch the chef work with dramatic fire flares, a blazing gourmet pizza oven, and authentic ingredients that feel straight out of Italy. Every dish is made to order, and you can taste the care, skill, and passion in every bite. Dining here genuinely feels like taking a trip to Italy--without leaving the neighborhood or breaking the bank. And don't skip dessert. The sweets are just as impressive as the main courses: fresh, perfectly balanced, and absolutely delicious. The experience is elevated even further by the staff, who are warm, attentive, and treat you like family. It's telling that many regulars know the team by name--this place creates real connections, not just meals. Fabio On Fire isn't just a restaurant; it's an experience. A hidden treasure that rewards anyone lucky enough to discover it--and one you'll keep coming back to, again and again. read more

Came in on a Saturday night. Expected to wait. Walked up and saw at least 10 tables on the patio and 4 inside. No one waiting. They asked if I had a reservation and j said no and they told me they were not taking walk ins. Literally turned away business with at least 10 empty tables. Ridiculous! read more

Pizza is watery and flimsy and everything fell off when picking it up. Wasn't impressed. read more

Fabio On Fire - Wet and paper thin pizza crust. - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Saturday night and the place was full. Family style not super loud, but very busy. Service was friendly. The food WOW delicious! I got the lasagna and wow what a flavor. Pricy but worth it read more

Fabio On Fire - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

This place has the worst customer service in town. After the hostess sat us we waited at least 10 minutes for a busser to bring us water, then the waitress didn't come over for about 15 minutes. It took forever to get our drinks on top of that. We barely saw our server or the busser and were left with stacks of dishes(appetizers and little plates) at our 2 person table. I considered putting them on the ground so we could have our entrees on the table comfortably. After we finished our meal we couldn't get anyone to come to our table for at least 15 minutes. So we sat there with a pile of dirty dishes and no check. The food was about a 2/10. Pizza was undercooked and lacked flavor, although the sausage on the pizza was good. The bolognese was WAY over salted and the Italian Greyhound cocktail was gross. The service here sucks! We will not return. read more