Absolutely love this place. The pizza and wings are incredible -- easily my favorite pizza, hands down. Everything tastes fresh, flavorful, and consistently delicious. On top of that, the customer service is always great. Friendly people, great atmosphere, and amazing food. Definitely a spot I'll keep coming back to. read more

No way this "Pizza" place would cut the mustard in NY !!!! Ny'ers would have closed it for this guy Don. Man when you talk to him its like his first day man what a mess like a deer in headlights and day he was soo flustered he was getting a new drink dispenser and business took a far back seat that day..then next time a question about the menu while ignoring a paying customer in person to someone on the phone sent this guy overboard and training a new girl on the register- it was the worst!!! Been there 3 times and never got to order anything......very strange place and dirty seating dirty all around and again another place claiming NY and can't even make their own chicken cutlet in house shit Cisco garbage....this guy nor his pizza is from NY! read more

2 slices n hour after opening shouldn't take 30mins to wait for. I called 1050 my order sounded like it was made when I got there to pick up. 1125 I'm finally leaving with 2 slices. Guess I'll skip my lunch break...... Lesson learnt to not come here during work. read more

Don's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Always a hit. This last visit was medium heat wings, pizza slices, and breaded mushrooms. Yum. Still no complaints from me or my date. Same consistent clean facility, tasty food & friendly service. I no longer live in the area, but you best believe I stop by whenever I'm nearby read more

Change in ownership, change to doing it "their" way loses the reason why Don's was Don's Sadly I can only say it wasn't Don's read more

See all

I recently discovered this place that is only a few miles from my house. That's what I get for being in a rut and going to the same pizza place all the time. This place is nice. Standard pizza parlor atmosphere. The service was above average employees were friendly and courteous. pizza - 4 stars lemon pepper wings - 3 stars chicken marsala - 3 stars eggplant parmesan - 4 stars service - 5 stars read more

Don's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

I had been craving spaghetti for weeks so I found Doda's Pizza based on the stars here in Yelp. I'm glad I did!! This was in a plaza that I have driven past a million times. I would've never guessed such deliciousness would have been located there. We walked in hour before closing and the employees had the place looking pristine. They were kind and offered great suggestions. It reminded me of a good family pizza place it was just a little later in the evening so it was quiet. Their prices were great and the serving sizes were even better!! We are always planning our next meal here. Great choice read more

Not as good. It's obvious it's under new ownership. Not as many toppings, very sweet pizza sauce, the meatball topping tasting different- maybe not fresh. The ranch is totally different and too thick. The wings are soggy. $80 for a large pizza with two toppings ($5 per topping,) a large salad in a less deep container and soggy wings... sadly we will be ordering from else where. read more

One of the best pizzas in Peoria! Great calzones, too. Outstanding customer service. Highly recommend.

Came in with a party of 11 and everyone really made sure that we were well taken care of from helping us set up the tables to staying on top of orders and more! The quality of the pizza was very good and tasty, the welcoming vibes and super friendly staff created an awesome experience! read more

Very good pizza the crust is great. The delivery drivers are always polite. Very convenient, close to where I live.

Their pizza is always great but the pepperoni on this order is absolutely questionable. read more

Don's NY Pizza - So meat lovers looked good but the pepperoni looks sloppy. - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Good pizza and salads. Higher prices than most but you come back because the food is worth it. Great dough and good sauce.

Excellent calzones and pizza rolls. Staff is always extremely friendly and accommodating. An instant go-to when we're looking for a pick-up order. My girlfriend is very picky, but she adores the meatball sub. read more

DO NOT go here if you expect the Dons under the old management!! It is NOTHING like it used to be. Ordered a pizza roll I used to get all the time. It was nothing like a pizza roll; it was three pounds of RAW dough! I initially thought it was mozzarella, but it had no taste. I then realized it was all a blob of uncooked dough! Ranch dressing was store bought crap; not the stuff they used to make. Husband said the garlic bread with cheese only had a small amount of the obviously cheap mozzarella they use now. What a shame to see this place take such a nosedive. The only positive thing I can say is that they did refund the order promptly as they should have. NEVER AGAIN read more

Pizza good . Got to pizza by the slice and there were good . The only thing is I got a side of jalapeño and they were $3.50 ... lol yeah that was right . Service was super good and fast . I was here early so it was quiet. read more

Don's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Been coming here for years. Always amazing eats. My favorite! I can't post on socials that I'm here without my other friends wanting to join in cuz it's soooooo good! read more

Don's NY Pizza - White pizza deluxe, zucchini fries - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

I'm giving 5 stars bec I order from here a lot and it's normally the best pizza I have had since moving from east coast! But tonight's pizza was off, don't know if it's bec it's a weekend and I normally get during week... I ordered the Ny special like always, not as much toppings and crust was even a little different. If the big boss was there today tell him to stay home lol JK! But seriously. This is the best pizza out here if you like Ny pizza!! read more

Went to Don's NY Pizza earlier this week and it was super delicious the Cheese was very nice and tasty, salty and savory ... had the 14" pepperoni and sausage.. it was perfect... the crust was light and airy.. had the house salad as well - it was fresh and crisp.. you can tell they use fresh heads of lettuce instead of the bag kind places use to save money! I will say I will definitely go back for more.. can wait to try their sandwiches - hot and cold... ps.. I've been trying to come to this place for a while now, so glad I went. I knew it was going to be good!! read more

Since my last review, ownership has changed. While the quality of the pizza is still excellent, the delivery service has taken a hit. For reference, I live less than 5 minutes away from this location. Since the change, I've had an order be forgotten; I've had orders arrive extremely late (one almost an hour and a half late); and last time, my order arrived cold. The owner replaced the pizza and gave us a free bottle of soda with his apologies, and we gave them one more chance today. We were told 20 minutes, only for it to arrive 30 minutes past that time (due to the brand new driver getting lost). It wasn't hot, but warm enough to be appetizing. I really don't know what's going on with my favorite pizza place, but I'm really considering starting to make pizza at home from now on. read more

Margarita pizza was worst I ever had. New York supreme was watery. There is teenagers running the place, and don't seems to care about customer service or quality. read more

Twice in a row the pizza was below subpar for the price. $4 for each topping and there were literally like 10 sliced black olives, less than that with soggy (obviously not fresh) green peppers, and a Caesar salad (small) that was barely enough for a 10 year old. I used to love this place because it gave me a taste of home and is the closest NY style pizza that actually tatted good since Tocci's closed. Second attempt at allowing them to straighten up but will not be going back. Not worth the almost $30 even with a military discount!! Shape up Don's or you will continue to lose more business. read more

Don's NY Pizza - Pizza with $12 worth of toppings (soggy green peppers, a few sliced black olives and pepperoni). Way overpriced. - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Having just finished a long, hot morning working outside, I was hungry for some comfort food. Looked on my Yelp app and found this place, and I am glad I did. Ordered the slice and wings lunch combo, with a soda, plus added a side salad. If you're looking for good NY style pizza, their name and food deliver 100%. Chicken wings were perfectly cooked with a great sauce. Don't expect something gourmet here. Expect something delicious and served quick. What was unexpected was the super friendly young woman at the counter. She took my order, brought me my food, asked me if I needed anything, etc. Very attentive, great service, above and beyond your typical fast-casual spot. read more

Don's NY Pizza - Side salad - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Amazing food and friendly staff have to try it! I got meat lovers, Pepperoni and a cheese they say you judge a pizza place off of their cheese pizza and I normally don't eat plain cheese pizza but this place has gotten it down to a science amazing. read more

DON'S NY PIZZA. We used to love this place. Food and service went downhill after new ownership.

Busy but worth the wait. Friendly staff helped get order to my car. Good crust. Superior cheese

I just went here on a solo date and got the vodka pasta and salad and it was delicious. The girl that helped me out was named Chloe and she was amazing and very understanding when I told her about my olive allergy and made sure the cooks knew that as well for my salad. The whole environment was amazing and I felt like I was in my uncles house eating home cooked meals. Thank you! read more

Would not allow me to place an order for a medium cheese. Probably the cheapest item on the menu unless I secured my order with a debit or credit card prior to picking up my order. Wow. What a bunch of broke bums that they are acting like a medium cheese pizza is going to break them if I fail to show up. I'm going to try somewhere else more professional read more

This place is was my favorite pizza place and I hate writing negative reviews because life happens but here we go... Ordered a pizza to be ready by 3:01pm today. Showed up, young girl at the counter let me know it wasn't ready and they were backed up.... Okay life happens. I waited about 30 minutes and went to check on it and they said it would be ready soon and let me know when it's ready. Okay life happens... waiter another 20 minutes putting me at 50 minutes and they let me know it was being made and they would let me know when it's done. Okay life happens. Another 25 minutes went by putting me at an 1 hour 15 minutes or 4:16 pm when it was ordered to be picked up at 3:01pm. At least it was ready. Meanwhile the entire time I watched one man work making pizzas and about 5 people just standing around looking goofy. I watched every customer walk in, order and walk out with their food. They all kept checking on the food status as well and seemed upset meanwhile they all walked out long before me. The gentleman offered me a soda for my 1 hour 15 minute wait but I just feel like my time is worth more than that. Sadly this place lost a customer today as I sit here enjoying my last pizza from my favorite spot. And no one ever told me the pizza was ready after I watched the whole place clear out on my Saturday. Unacceptable. read more

Went there on Father's Day got there about 310. They had a Father's Day special and he wouldn't even give it to me.??!! very rude customer service he needs to learn how to respect his customers. I would never go there or recommend anybody go there. read more

My wife and I have been here before & loved this place. This trip, we had to keep asking for each item that we had ordered. I received my meal almost 15 minutes before my wife. I had to go up & ask were her food was, " we're working on it". She ordered garlic knots, she had to go back up and ask for them 20 minutes after she got her meal, she also had to ask for her salad, the Ranch Dressing was as liquidated as milk. Not satisfied. read more

We ordered a spread for the 2 of us because we eat like every day is our birthday. This little family-run place is near a Planet Fitness & ice cream shop. There's lots of parking. We dined inside. The seating is a little spaced out. They have Pepsi products for beverages. The food came out very quickly and was very hot. The fried zucchini was pretty standard with other places that have fried zucchini. No surprises and it was what I expected. The baby loved the garlic knots. The dough was fluffier than some places with garlic knots. Texturally it is very pleasing. I could handle a little more garlic flavor and salt/butter on it and then they would be perfect. I ordered the spicy chicken Alfredo and the garlic knots and side salad came with it. The salad was a fairly standard house side salad except I wasn't expecting olives. They probably had it listed somewhere and I wasn't paying attention. The ranch was not just squeezed out of a hidden valley bottle, so that was nice. It was thinner than some places with ranch but it's salad dressing so I really don't have a preference, except I wouldn't want it weirdly thick. The spicy chicken Alfredo was not spicy at all for me. I was hoping for more. The sauce kind of tasted like there was coconut milk in it, which I didn't really like that much. Idk if there was coconut milk but that's how my brain associated it. There was sausage and chicken as well as red onion and green peppers. I like meat so that was a nice surprise. Normally I don't go for Alfredo sauce but I saw another review that it was good so I thought I'd step outside of my normal food pattern. Nah bruh. It wasn't my favorite. (It wasn't "gross" it just wasn't what I was looking for in an Alfredo sauce.) And to be fair, it's possible they didn't hear me say "spicy" because I was speaking quieter than I normally do. Now for the pizza, we took it home, but the box was so big it didn't fit in either of my fridges. So it was a HUGE pizza. The crust was thin and couldn't handle the weight of the toppings. It was good, def not "the best" but definitely not "the worst". I felt like the pizza sauce was missing something, maybe some oregano. Toppings were generous. Four stars bc the workers were really friendly. The baby even said it to me too. They have tiramisu and I didn't order it and now I wish I did. Come with your appetite and leave with to-go bags bc the portions are big. read more

See all

After being told our delivery would take 45 minutes, we waited nearly 2 hours before even calling to inquire about our food. They still took almost 20 more minutes before the driver arrived with our old & cold food. $65 for pizza & wings is a joke as it is. We miss the old owners! read more

I go to Dons often. It used to be pretty good but lately the quality has gone down hill. I ordered two slices and they were raw. Mushy dough under the cheese and the bottom was floppy. Mozzarella seemed cheap. No stretch to it, it just kind of disintegrates in your mouth. read more

Don's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

We wanted some pasta and no cooking was happening on our end so we called up Dons for a pickup order. The guy that answered was super friendly and our order was ready within 15 minutes. The price is the pastas and the amount of food you get is an awesome deal. You get a side salad loaded with goodies and 4 garlic knots per meal. We got spaghetti with meat sauce and spaghetti with sausage. There was lots of garlic which we love and plenty of sauce for the pasta. Now this isn't gourmet Italian food but it satisfied the craving and everyone loved it! We have had the pizza from here in the past which was good as well. Definitely a good spot to get your Italian needs met and we will be back! read more

See all

What happened to this place got a med pizza deal with 10 wings.added pepperoni and they barely even added any of the topping plus wings were supposed to be honey hot instead received buffalo hot. For 42 dollars I could have gone out and had a better pizza and wings and a cold drink too. Sad I use to really like it here read more

Perfect neighborhood pizza joint. I came here for a late lunch and it was still surprisingly busy. I soon found out why. From the moment I stepped in you immediately get the mom and pop shop feel. They were polite and expedient while taking my order, and I went with the lunch deal which was a soda, slice of cheese pizza, and 6 hot wings for 10 bucks. The pizza was that perfect New York slice combo where it flops over when you hold it but the crust is golden brown and sings if you scraped the bottom of it. Sauce and cheese were also both on point. It's nice to see that they put so much effort into a lunch slice. The wings had a decent size and had a good crunch that gave me the indication they were probably deep fried. Buffalo hot was classic they didn't stray at all from the flavor we all know. Highly recommend. I can't think of many better neighborhood pizza shops on the westside. read more

Don's NY Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

hi.. been eating dons for years at one time i raved about the chicken ceasar salad NOT ANYMORE barely any lettuce some romaine i dont even know what the other was spinach? 6 croutons barely any parm cheez but it was packed with chicken probably 10-12 ounces way to much no balance like in the days when dons was great i disposed of the dry chicken im very disappointed the owner is a real nice guy he tries hard to please his customers i think he needs a new general manager for quality control good luck god bless read more

I went later at night for pick up, the staff were quite friendly and the food was absolutely delicious. I've tried other pizza places and this has been my favorite so far. Compared to all the other places I've been, the prices were quite reasonable for portion and taste. I'm a fan! read more

It's taken me some time to write this because Don's has always been our go to pizza spot. Over the last 6-9 months Dons has gone downhill. The first time we got something not so great, we just brushed it off as an off evening because we've NEVER had problems. Two visits ago our pizza tasted off, sauce was different, and it was $20 for I think 12 zucchini sticks(can't remember the exact amount but I thought it was insane that deep fried zucchini would be that expensive). Yesterday will be the last time we order at Dons. We ordered at lunch time, asked for well done pizzas like we do every time for them to be mushy. They honestly tasted like they were from the day before. The sauce has changed. The dough seemed off. A cook was eating his food where they make the pizza, and to top it all off I pulled 4 slices of tiramisu from their dessert cooler to give to them because they were covered in mold. The person who was eating behind the counter looked annoyed at me and said they must've missed that last night. These pieces of tiramisu had been there moldy for a longer than just the evening. Please bring back the old owners. read more