Faidley&#x27;s Seafood

150

277

302

4 years ago

Hands down best place ever for crab cakes! Little filler and lots of chunky crab pieces that has been perfectly seasoned. My partner and I also got the clam chowder (which like others have echoed that is is salty but I think it's pretty delicious), and the soft shell crab sandwich was PERFECT. Honestly the sides we got were equally as delicious as our mains which were the coleslaw, Mac salad, fries, and potato salad. You can't go wrong with anything on their menu and they were pretty busy when we came post lunch. They do have bottled drinks but also offer fountain soda (which includes Fanta!) parking here is a little weird but there is a garage right across the street. Faidley is being temporarily housed in a separate building from the Lexington market until their booth is completed but it's a super short distance. Overall great place and highly recommended. read more

Faidley's Seafood - Award Winning Jumbo Lump Crab Cake with Potato Salad and Cole Slaw and Clam Chowder - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Soft Crab Sandwich and French Fries and Macaroni Salad - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sandy N.

288

1077

6 years ago

I didn't know what a "real" crab cake was until I had Faidleys! My crab cake experience has been an over breaded flat patty but Faidleys was pure crab chunks shaped like a tennis ball. It was my first time in Baltimore so we of course had a crab cake crawl and Faidley's takes the #1 spot. I went on a Monday for a late lunch and there was only a couple others in the restaurant. I was able to get 2 crab cakes within 5 minutes. Cute spot and a definite must try in Baltimore. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kevin B.

1 year ago

Outstanding! I see why this is considered the best of Baltimore. It may be the best I have ever had and I've had. Perfect. Saltine cracker as binder. Not all sloppy and wet. This is the way a crab cake should be make. Don't give me a backfin "no binder" soggy old crab cake and pretend it's good. This sucker holds tougher. All you get is that jumbo meat. Add a bit of their hot sauce and you have perfection. The restaurant itself is in Lancaster market. Not a full service restaurant but plenty of tables to stand and eat at. While the crab cakes were the star, the sides were amazing. Had the slaw, beets, and cucumber salad. All awesome. Cucumber was the star there. The fries were bland and boring but I was there for the cake. Amazing spot. Now- fair warning. For anyone who knows Baltimore it's not in the best part of town and that's putting it kindly but it's all part of the experience! Enjoy! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeremy F.

2 years ago

Crab cakes were amazing! Service was great and quick. Ambiance is a cool vibe. Definitely a must try when visiting Baltimore.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Eric C.

854

702

4 years ago

I see this place on nearly every list of must-have crab cake spots. The crab cakes were OK. Just OK. They are pre-made and just sitting there waiting for someone to nuke them in a microwave. Expensive. The sticker shock was strong. But for an OK crab cake. For the platter, the portions of the sides were excruciatingly small - I get that they are well, sides, but come on now. The space itself is on the seedy side. I assume there aren't laws against strung out looking fellows prancing around the premises, so I'm not sure that's the owners' fault. Go. Get your expensive, pre-made, microwaved OK crab cake from the sketchy block. Cross it off your list. And then never go back. read more

Helpful 7

Thanks 1

Love this 5

Oh no 1

Ledora T.

Elite 24

183

142

3 years ago

Quick service. The crab cake was good and definitely a nice size. The deviled egg was average but tasted better with a little crab cake on top. The garlic bread was a hidden gem (it was written randomly on a paper sign so it might be new). Nonetheless, it was delicious and so flavorful but not salty. read more

Faidley's Seafood - Deviled egg bite. It was pretty good! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Josh S.

118

228

236

6 years ago

They have ruined crab cakes for me from anywhere else. Softball sized crab cakes that I would probably do some pretty unsavory stuff for. The market it sits in has a strange vibe (but hey it's Baltimore!). But the crab cakes, you take your fork and barely touch it to unveil massive pieces of lump crab meat. I swear to you that even if you have no desire or plans to go to Baltimore, stop what you're doing, if you're within three hours go! Oh yeah....and did I mention the crab cakes!!! read more

Faidley's Seafood - The best crab cake you will ever eat. Don't share!!! Order extra!!! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Chelsea C.

3 years ago

This place is just always amazing! Go and get the crab soup and crab cakes both are amazing! Kids also said one of the best Mac and cheese ever had! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tisa C.

Elite 23

359

3 years ago

Loved this spot! The raw clams were a bit off (perhaps the one I tasted was a bad one), but the oysters were delicious! The crab cake was worth every penny. Very cool historic location, kind people at both the food lines and the raw bar, and it was awesome to experience and taste a bit of history. read more

Faidley's Seafood - Award Winning Jumbo Lump Crab Cake - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Raw Bar - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kien H.

Elite 26 All-Star

168

931

5397

4 years ago

So I had been wanting some soft shell crab. So I made sure to step up for lunch to hit the Lexington market so I can do just that! I ended up getting the crab sandwich and also the fried clams. You walk in the market, there's a bunch of stalls and shops around you. The one in the center does oysters, you go to the right you can get crab, it just depends on what you're looking for. There's really not much seating but there's some standing seating only, which makes sense when you see it lol! I came in and did a lab, then went to the right, ordered my crab and clams and chowder down. The crab was pretty good, pretty flavorful. I feel like it was a smaller size crab but I guess that's not a big deal. That would honestly be my biggest drawback. I came for a crab sandwich and there was much more bread than crab... But the flavor was good on what I got. Came with lettuce and tomatoes... the sandwich was pretty solid. The fried clams are okay. I felt like they were more fried pieces and they were fried clams themselves. If that makes sense. You know how you get popcorn and you eat all the popcorn out of the bag and then you have all the smaller pieces and kernels, kind of like that. But they were good though. I had really no significant issues and I would definitely go back. I actually feel like I should have ordered the crab cake. They say they're the best around, but I have my heart fixated on softshell so that's what I did! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Angelica T.

1 year ago

Tanya was excellent!!! the food was incredibly delicious. We had the crab cakes! Loved every moment.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rosie T.

Elite 23

123

251

4 years ago

I perused most of Lexington Market and wandered into Faidley's last. The setup was a little confusing because they had many stands stamped with their name but the award winning jumbo crab cakes were way in the corner near its outside entrance. Picked up a tray and the process reminded me of a cafeteria style. We each ordered the jumbo lump crab cake platter (around $33 each) which comes with two sides. Unfortunately, the mac and cheese and Maryland crab soup didn't blow me away. The coleslaw was nice and light, bitter and peppery, and the fried corn on the cob was delicious, seasoned well. The crab cakes are AMAZING. So much meat which made it a filling lunch, the outside was flaky and seasoned perfectly! I can't imagine going down to Baltimore again without giving this place another visit. Worth all the hype! read more

Faidley's Seafood - Jumbo Lump Crab Cake, Macaroni & Cheese, Cole Slaw - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Menu - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Jumbo Lump Crab Cake, Maryland Crab Soup (Red), Fried Corn on the Cob - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Katya W.

216

238

427

4 years ago

I went to this establishment for the first time memorial weekend. To start the staff is friendly so the customer service was good. The crab cake was actually very good. Real crab meat not full of stuffing and flavorful. The cucumber salad is good too. However, that mac n cheese was not good at all. Crab Cake 5* Cucumber salad 4* Mac n cheese 1* But to each their own. Try it for yourself and make your own assessment. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kimberly H.

Elite 22

211

126

545

3 years ago

So I was on a quick business trip and I really didn't want to eat the food the company provided. And I really really wanted some seafood. So I went online, and Faidley's Seafood was the first seafood restaurant to pop up. So I told my husband let's head there right after the meeting. We found parking close by. When I got there it wasn't too crowded. The menu wasn't too overwhelming. The only overwhelming part was the price for the food. Lol! Which it is seafood.... So I do understand that's why it costs so much... So I ordered the jumbo lump crab cake with the french fries and coleslaw. My husband got the fried catfish with the same sides I got. We also added the cornbread, or was it a biscuit. I don't remember exactly... But I just had to have it, and it was a separate charge for it, too. The service was awesome and quick, too! They could tell that we weren't from Baltimore, too... lol! I don't know if that's a good or bad thing.. But they did explain the menu to us and etc. Our bill was about $65.00. I wish we had a little more time. Because I really wanted to sit and try the oyster bar. The inside reminded me of a fishing pier, and the decor was pretty cool. I'm definitely coming back and doing a weekend trip just for another plate of the jumbo lump crab cake. Oh! And parking is right next door. So you don't have to park far. Just make sure to read all the directions in the parking facility next door. There will be a machine that you'll have to pay at and collect a coin from, too. Keep the coin with you until you're ready to pay to leave. read more

See all

Helpful 7

Thanks 0

Love this 7

Oh no 1

Pierre' S.

3 years ago

Food was great with friendly service. Quick and easy in and out. Will be back again soon. read more

Faidley's Seafood - Raw Oyster & Clams - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeannie L.

101

4 years ago

Lexington Market is about 10-15 minutes walk from downtown Baltimore. Easier to enter from the south entrance door. 1 jumbo crab lump cake was $26.55 (market price) before taxes and tip. Definitely was full of crab meat and it was size of a fist! With the market inflation, I think the size of it justifies for the price. Cash or credit card payment is acceptable! High top tables without chairs are available for dine-in. They also have shipping options for uncooked, or frozen crab cakes. read more

Faidley's Seafood - Front sign - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Rachel S.

164

231

6 years ago

Wow, the crab cake I had here was to die for. On second thought, it shouldn't even have been called a crab cake, more like a heap of lump crab with a sprinkle of breading. The meat was mega-juicy and the flavor fantastic. It was served alongside a small salad with an acidic vinegar-based dressing which complimented the fat-forward cake beautifully. Faidley's is an indoor market with food serves cafeteria-style. The place is so rich in aroma, you will be left smelling like oil all day, but it's so worth it. It's also located in a fairly rougher part of Baltimore, so just be aware. read more

Faidley's Seafood - Coleslaw - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Matt O.

523

376

1158

5 years ago

What an amazing experience finally visiting the home of the crab cake. The lump crab cake was delicious and no wonder why Faidleys is the King. AJ was so helpful giving us suggestions for what to order and let us know the can't miss items. Make sure you ask for him next time you visit so you have the best experience possible! read more

See all

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Samantha C.

Elite 18

147

143

626

3 years ago

I was visiting Baltimore and was really excited to try this place that had rave reviews of their seafood! Unfortunately, I was left less than impressed and am unsure if I would make a stop in again. Let's start with the good! We decided to order the 5 fried shrimp and jumbo lump crab cake to share. Total cost for both was $33 which is pricey, but the food was well worth it! The crab cake is enormous, crispy on the outside, and has TONS of sweet juicy lump crab meat packed into it. It's gently fried and not greasy, and was so good. The fried shrimp were crispy and meaty and served with cocktail sauce. Both extremely satisfying. Unfortunately, the bad comes from the prep of our food. While they were prepping the crab cake plate, the woman prepping grabbed the lettuce for the side salad with her bare hands (without washing them prior) and put it on our plate after she was just touching her phone. To me, this is basic hygiene that was not followed and we immediately threw away the salad. She did not wash her hands afterwards either and proceeded to continue touching her phone. It was unfortunate because the salad looked tasty, and I also started worrying about the sanitation of the rest of my food. Otherwise, this establishment sells a lot of specialty meats to include escargot, gator, turtle, and a ton of other seafood. I saw a family next to us get some of their raw oysters which looked large and they seemed to enjoy them! The ambiance is very casual with community style standing tables. If you happen to be stopping by Lexington market, I say definitely make a stop next door to Faidley's and check it out for yourself! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 2

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Angela B.

Elite 25

130

135

491

3 years ago

These crabcakes are as delicious as I heard they were. Full of juicy, sweet crab meat. Very little fillers. I'd definitely go back if I'm Baltimore again. read more

Faidley's Seafood - Jumbo lump crab cake - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Regina K.

776

280

2191

7 years ago

I had been searching for the best crab cake in Baltimore and, lo and behold, I found it at Faidley's! The price is a bit hefty ($16.91 with tax) for one crab cake, but don't let that deter you from trying this amazing lump of goodness. They definitely don't skimp on the crab meat, which is one of the main reasons why I was so impressed by it. Certain places have some pretty questionable crab cakes with bits of meat that get lost in the breading. However, not at Faidley's. I felt spoiled by the amount of thick pieces of meat they put into it. Not to mention the super soft breading and the flavorful seasoning. These are what crab cake dreams are made of! read more

Helpful 9

Thanks 0

Love this 9

Oh no 0

Tiffany H.

451

118

707

4 years ago

THE BEST crab cake i've ever had. There are chunks of crab in the crab cake without being too overpowering. The outside of the crab cake is perfectly flakey. The sides balance out the seafood perfectly. Kinda in a sketchy area of Baltimore but still highly recommend. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Matt G.

222

318

1161

7 years ago

How do you review an institution? A landmark. An established cornerstone of a city? That was the dilemma I thought I was facing with Faidley. Let's get this out of the way. It was good. But was it "the best"? In a word...No. The crab cake was RIDICULOUSLY huge. Large lumps of meat beckoned the diners to eat it. Which we did. But we did have to add a generous amount of salt to up the flavor ante. Not sure if it was just that day's mixture or what. But claiming you have the best crab cake...in the world...then having to add sauce is like putting a mustache on the Mona Lisa to make it a "better" piece of art...it just doesn't work. The soup. It was a unique style of soup with a lot of crab...whisps in it. I wouldn't call it meat or lump meat. Instead it was like eating crab shreds in a tomato based soup. It was decent...just not what I am used to with crab soup. The deviled eggs. Just...yes...there is always room for deviled eggs. Buy some. Eat them. Smile. So...I guess that is how you review an institution. Would I eat here again? In a heartbeat. And maybe that heartbeat will earn them their last star. Rock solid 4 stars. read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Chiseko I.

201

558

4 years ago

The jumbo lump crab cake was made of large chunks of crab meat and the taste was great. The Maryland crab soup was a little bit salty for me but the taste was above average. The price was reasonable ($25 for the lump crab cake) partly because it was needed to keep standing while I was eating. Also, the neighborhood of the market did not look so safe. These 2 points are the reasons for 4 stars. read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Martin S.

Elite 25

286

3 years ago

Given its legendary status it's no surprise that the crab cakes are on the pricier side. They are good and the inside is something to admire so I personally found it's price justifiable. Even though this might not be my personal favorite crab cake in Baltimore. It's still a must try! read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Yvette M.

Elite 26 All-Star

315

639

2714

6 years ago

Wow, I loved the Jumbo Lump Crab Cake! So much crab and seasoned perfectly. We ordered the combo with two sides for $23. We tried the fries, coleslaw, cold mac salad, and corn on the cob. All pretty good, but the winner was the corn with the old bay seasoning. Also ordered the pick three assortment with blue crab, mussels, and snow crab. The snow crab being the favorite. If your ordering this one to go, make sure you have a crab cracker at home. We ordered ahead but had to wait for the pick three for about 15 minutes when we arrived. Street parking is crazy, but we spotted a parking structure across the street. Curbside pick-up available and and a few stand only tables located outside. read more

Faidley's Seafood - Pick Three Assortment - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Erin M.

Elite 25

126

201

4 years ago

I order Faidleys crab cakes to St. Louis for major holidays every year. My family absolutely loves them! And I would agree that they are the best crab cakes I have ever tasted. Not only are the crabcakes phenomenal, the ordering process is smooth and efficient. Time after time, the crabcakes make it to St. Louis in a timely manner with no issues whatsoever. If you are looking to order crab cakes from Baltimore, try Faidleys! read more

Faidley's Seafood - Our crabcakes are made with the freshest and finest Jumbo Lump Blue Crab meat . - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Horace G.

116

1 year ago

Service was great and they were very friendly. Good conversation with several of them. The crab cakes weren't as big as I would like and not as flavorful either. They were tender and meaty. The potato salad was pretty good and I enjoyed that. The Maryland Crab soup wasn't very flavorful and needs a kick. Overall, it's ok, but will try something different the next time. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christina W.

119

3 years ago

Of course the crab cakes are delish and the best ever! But I had to knock off one star bec they're so darn expensive! $25 for only one crab cake? We got 3 crab cakes, one shrimp stuffed crab, and a crab dip. They were all FANTASTIC! But it cost me $120. Like I said, nothing but love for the food but it really is so expensive I think I will go back if I win the lottery. So as of June 2023 they're still in the old Lexington market space. The newly remodeled Lexington market is bright and shiny but this location has all the charm of old Baltimore. We parked in the garage and had to walk through the sketchy part of Eutaw St. so be aware of which exit to use. Garage parking is really cheap. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael Q.

1014

110

295

4 years ago

I know Maryland is know for it's blue crabs , I grew up in Virginia therefore I know what the fuss is about . I had googled places with the best crab cakes. According to Trip Advisor , Reddit and Yelp This was the place to go. This was the best freaking crab cake I've ever had . Chunks of crab meat , it was fresh and good with some hot sauce and they deliver all over the U.S. the coleslaw and potato salad was bomb Diggity. The deviled eggs were one of the best I've ever had . There is space for outdoor eat and it's In the heart of downtown . Definitely recommend to try this place . I can see why it's voted Bmore's best read more

Faidley's Seafood - Front of the menu - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Some info about their history - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Cole Slaw Potato Salad Pick Three Assortment Award Winning Jumbo Lump Crabcake, deviled egg, Mini salad - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - I bought this mallet for 3 dollars , Deviled egg - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Other restaurants - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - View from a farther angle - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alex S.

469

2 years ago

Honestly....not worth it. It's not necessarily bad, but I wouldn't return. I got the jumbo crab cake and it was a rather steep price at $26 just for the crab cake and nothing additional. I did not think it was big so I'm not sure why it's called "jumbo". It tasted fine. I didn't notice any difference between this crab cake and any other crab cake I've ever eaten. The employee taking my order wasn't so friendly or patient. Overall, it feels like a tourist trap. You can find crab cakes around the city for less money and they're just as good. In fact, I got a crab cake sandwich with fries from a restaurant downtown for $25 and that crab cake was the same size and tasted just the same. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Apryl D.

142

666

4 years ago

Love their crab cakes they taste just like my moms. I got a Backfin Crabcake Platter with Fries, Collard Greens, Codfish Cake, Macaroni & Cheese with Cucumber Salad. I was satisfied with the size of the Backfin Crabcake. I also got greens which were delicious & tangy. Love the steak fries too. The cucumber salad was sweet so I didn't like it. I also got a Codfish cake which was delicious I ate it right in the car. Of course I will be returning. read more

Faidley's Seafood - Coddie (Homemade Salt Codfish Cake) - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Store Front - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Potato Salad - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Coddie (Homemade Salt Codfish Cake) the inside - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Cucumber Salad (I didn't like because it was sweet I like my pickled dishes to be sour & tangy) - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Backfin Crabcake Platter w/ Macaroni & Cheese & SteakFries - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Backfin Crabcake Platter - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julie F.

271

1020

109

7 years ago

I read about the famous crab cake here and had to try it despite my reservations and reluctance about Lexington Market being in a not-so-great area. Locals I talked to admitted there's good reason to be on guard and watchful when visiting the surrounding area. However, it was okay. As for the crab cake, it was a good size and tasty with lots of pure lump crab meat and very little filler. Some people complain about the $15.95 price, but I've paid much more in the past for crab cakes in Southern California and that price is fair for the amount of crab you get. If in Baltimore, you should visit Faidley's. read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Brad M.

2 years ago

Crab cake was excellent! My son had the fried shrimp, and while it was good, he agreed the crab cake was the winner.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Farah K.

100

509

1413

5 years ago

The only one star missing is kind of the location. Lexington Market needs a bit of TLC for sure. We came looking for the crabcakes that were featured on a show on Netflix and it was worth the nearly $30 roughly that was paid for the crabcake platter. No fillers in them and sized pretty huge, the crabcake earns its cred for being one of the best crabcakes in Baltimore for a long time, and believe you me they have enough media reportings of being the best crabcake in Baltimore all over the wall. (Not many after 98 though...who dethroned them? I want to try THAT crabcake too lol) read more

Faidley's Seafood - Potato Salad, Award Winning Jumbo Lump Crab Cake, Cole Slaw - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Doris Y.

376

274

995

5 years ago

One of the best parts of my trip to B-more. I'm so happy I found this little hidden gem. We were able to street park right across. We tried the famous jumbo crab cake- delicious, stuffed with crab. The oysters were HUGE. I've never seen oysters this big in my life. Don't forget to get some beer on tap. I loved the Natty! The staff here was very friendly and it felt very homey in here. I will definitely be back when I'm in town again! read more

Faidley's Seafood - Jumbo crab cake - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Oysters (local) they're GINORMOUS - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Liz H.

108

584

186

7 years ago

Raw bar, steamed crabs, fish from market cooked to order, and crab cake! The oysters and crab cakes are huge. The crab cakes won awards. They don't skimp on crab meat!!! I would have liked some Old Bay but I looked around and they didn't have any out. So I guess you are not supposed to eat them that way! The market is in a huge market but Faidley's is the best thing there. The rest of Lexington Market is a bit run down. The locals hang out and they are characters. I don't think you need to go out of your way to go here. The neighborhood is a little rough. I went within an hr of closing and it was dark, no tourists. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jose C.

Elite 26 All-Star

3726

1572

6913

7 years ago

After talking to a few people, they all said crab cakes were the thing to order when in Baltimore. I will admit I wasn't looking forward to trying a crab cake, especially at $16 for each crab cake. I've also tried a crab cake before and it wasn't the greatest thing so I didn't really want to spend $40 for two crab cakes. But I did. And I'm glad I did. The crab cake itself was very tasteful. Plenty of crab meat and had a nice buttery creamy peppery feel and taste to it. Next time I'm in Baltimore, I'll probably try a few other places, but if they're not as good as Faidleys is, I'll return back during the same trip. The Mac and cheese was also delicious, and also came with fries and a little salad. Probably wouldn't order the dinner again, the crab cake will be all I would be ordering to satisfy my needs. I also things it's pretty cool that they don't have seats and just standing room only seating. If you insist on sitting during your meal (like my wife) then they have seating upstairs in the mezzanine area, but I would highly recommend avoiding that upstairs to eat by yourself or with a family. Just eat standing up and enjoy the experience. read more

Faidley's Seafood - Inside the jumbo lump crab cake - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 10

Thanks 0

Love this 9

Oh no 0

Jorge S.

3 years ago

The Lump Crab cakes were delicious! probably the best crab cakes my wife and I, have ever had! Highly recommend a trip to Faidley's! read more

Faidley's Seafood - Lump Crab Cakes! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

Faidley's Seafood - Highly Awarded! - Seafood Markets Near Me - Baltimore, Maryland

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 4 of 37

119 N Paca St
Baltimore, MD 21201
Downtown
Directions
(443) 909-3981
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.faidleyscrabcakes.com/

Full menu

Hours

What time does Faidley's Seafood open?

Faidley's Seafood opens at 10:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Faidley's Seafood close?

Faidley's Seafood closes at 5:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday.Faidley's Seafood closes at 5:30 PM on Friday and Saturday.Faidley's Seafood is closed on Sunday.

Mon-Thu 10:00 AM - 5:00 PMFri-Sat 10:00 AM - 5:30 PMSun Closed

Payment methods

Does Faidley's Seafood take Bitcoin?

No, Faidley's Seafood does not take Bitcoin.

Does Faidley's Seafood take credit cards?

Yes, Faidley's Seafood takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Faidley's Seafood have catering options?

Yes, Faidley's Seafood does have catering options.

Does Faidley's Seafood have a drive thru?

No, Faidley's Seafood does not have a drive thru.

Does Faidley's Seafood have a happy hour?

No, Faidley's Seafood does not have a happy hour.

Does Faidley's Seafood serve alcohol?

Yes, Faidley's Seafood serves alcohol. Beer & Wine Only

Indoor Amenities

Does Faidley's Seafood allow dogs?

No, Faidley's Seafood does not allow dogs.

Does Faidley's Seafood have TVs?

No, Faidley's Seafood does not have TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Faidley's Seafood have bike parking?

Yes, Faidley's Seafood has bike parking.

Does Faidley's Seafood have outdoor seating?

Yes, Faidley's Seafood has outdoor seating options.

Does Faidley's Seafood have parking?

Yes, Faidley's Seafood has parking options. Garage Parking, Street Parking

Other Amenities

Is Faidley's Seafood wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Faidley's Seafood is wheelchair accessible.

Does Faidley's Seafood allow outdoor smoking?

No, Faidley's Seafood does not allow outdoor smoking.

Does Faidley's Seafood have free WiFi?

No, Faidley's Seafood does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Faidley's Seafood in Baltimore, Maryland ships their award winning all lump Maryland style crab cakes anywhere in the United States.

History

Established in 1886.

At 126 years and counting, Faidley's is among the oldest continually operated family businesses in America! Consistently demanding the highest quality local seafood and hands on management has kept this family business alive and strong. Currently, three generations of the Faidley family still operate in the same location today. We look forward to having your family visit ours.

Meet the Business Owner: Nancy Faidley D.

Nancy is the granddaughter of the the company's founder, She and her husband, Bill Devine, have been operating the business since 1965. She was the first to introduce a Jumbo Lump crabcake recipe and has been winning awards ever since. Many food writers have said that her recipe is the one that all others are compared to! She has appeared on The Food Network with iron chef Michael Simon, Travel Channel's "America's Best Sandwich", "Bizarre Foods America", "Seafood Paradise", The Today Show, PBS, and several others. She has also been featured in Gourmet Magazine, Southern Living, Coastal Living, The New York Times, USA Today, The Sun, and too many more to list. Come meet Nancy and Bill and see why people from around the world refer to Nancy as the "queen of crabcakes"!

More Info

Health Score

Faidley's Seafood Reviews in Other Languages

French
2 Reviews

Ask the Community - Faidley's Seafood

16 dollars for a small crab cake? Worth it?

I found cheaper crab cakes in Baltimore but they contain fillers, Faidley's crab cakes do not have any, the area and the market itself are very sketchy though

View 7 more answers

How does this place compare to Koco's for crab cake?

I believe that the Faidley version is more seasoned than the Koco version. The Koco version is just the crab meat. Both crab cakes contain no filler and if I only had one choice, I'd eat the Faidley version.

View 2 more answers

How many ounces is their jumbo lump crab cake?

6.5 oz

View 3 more answers

Are they open on Memorial day?

yes!

View question details

View All 5 Questions

You might also consider

Ministry of Brewing

4.5(241 reviews)

1.7 mi•Washington Hill

A+++ for ambiance. They have an amazing space that used to be a church, it is super cool. They…read moredon't have air conditioning, which isn't surprising but was a slight downside during the heat wave. They had a vendor with food, and you could also bring your own, which was awesome (no outside alcohol). My husband tried two of their darker beers, which were both different (did not fall victim to the "same flavor" dark beers trap). I got a Mexican coke (was a standard; they don't have a ton of non-alcoholic options, besides an athletic brewing co option and Jarritos). Trivia was also going on at the same time, which was fun. Is a great space for groups as well. We will definitely be back, if not just to hang out!

I've been here twice and had a blast both times. Initially upon walking in , I was taken aback…read morebecause I'd was a church at some point , I walked in and it was one of the coolest things I've seen . There were a nice amount of different taps to chose from and the prices were really good . Service was good and there was lots of seating . I love that food trucks came on site abd there was an outside area to sit at as well. Parking wasn't the best but worth it !

Beer flight.

Some of the charm of Charm City!

See all

Merchandise.

Max's Taphouse

4.0(724 reviews)

1.7 mi•Fells Point

When you're told that your ghost tour is going to meet at the square across the street from a…read moreTaphouse, you grab food inside it and savor some incredible beers. It's what you do1 and this led to me discovering just how much of a certifiable beer haven Max's is! For a Philly comparison I'd put Max's on the same caliber as Glory Beer Bar and Kitchen but with a beer bible on the same scale as Monk's. It's been a beer haven for going on four decades and it shows with their 100+ rotating taps, 1000+ bottles & cans, a 4 casks that feature plenty of local Baltimore brews alongside the finest from Belgium, Germany, and then some! They even have seasonal special events like a Sour Beer Fest in June, and a Rare & Obscure Beer Weekend in October. The bar interior was classic food, with a huge main bar that showcased the many brew and spirit options. The bartenders were also spot on with their service and spot on beer suggestions. For food being so close to the waterfront had me craving some seafood, and the rockfish sandwich delivered with its Chesapeake seasoning and remoulade dressing. Each day of the week has a beer special at Max's, and Thursday meant that I was enjoying a discount on full pint cask pours. I liked that Max's had transparent pricing available for 4 oz to large pours and growlers to go on their menu for each and every draft beer, and the 4 oz pours made it easier to enjoy the 11% abv barleywine beer from a Baltimore brewery that I was curious about without feeling some extra inebriated repercussions during my ghost tour. It was extra details like that which had me really enjoying Max's and dubbing it a must visit for any beer lover visiting Baltimore.

Amazing Baltimore vibes. Attentive bartenders who are open to recommending things per your tastes,…read morewhether they are timid or bold! Also have a really good variety of NA beers amidst the hundreds of other amazing beers across the globe. Food wise, the chili is really delish as are the wings. Just a good spot to hang your hat for a bit and enjoy the vibes with a nice brew.

Smoked Turkey Sandwich

See all

Outside

Peter's Pour House

4.1(340 reviews)

0.5 mi•Downtown

Great place for food and drinks. It was right next to our hotel so we decided to come here after…read morecheck in in December. The beer and cocktails were all great as was our fish (I think Rockfish) and burger (I think Tex Mex). Prices were very reasonable. Ambiance is nice and old school. Staff was fast and friendly.

This place provides exactly what it advertises. Medium priced beer and okay food. It has good…read moreambiance and terrific service, but you get better grub anywhere else nearby.

Hot Roast Beef

See all

From the alley

Baltimore Tap House

4.5(28 reviews)

2.6 mi•Canton

•$

We went to this tap house because their happy hour was over at 8pm. We really didn't need happy…read morehour prices because this place was affordable. They had so many beers on tap I couldn't make up my mind. The bartender was super friendly, they knew we were from out of town because the majority of the customers are regulars. The regular customers were friendly and giving us suggestions. I actually felt like I was at home. There is no food but they have snacks, peanuts, cheese balls and pretzels. So eat before you get there.

This was our first time here and I loved it. As a long time bartender the most overwhelming thing…read morewas how clean it was. No funky smells no flies, bathrooms were prestine for both women's and men's and the bartender and people were great! Def going back next time were at the dog park.

Tap list.

See all

Golden tee

Honeypot Cocktail Lounge

4.2(10 reviews)

2.5 mi•Canton

This is the former Kenwood Tavern that really was only open for a year, but it cemented itself into…read morethe history of bars in Baltimore. I think the ownership is with the current Landlord. I'm not actually sure but the cocktails are good. I think the vibes when I went was off. Granted I did go on a weekday where it was pretty empty. I did really appreciate that they were chips of ice in the cocktail, cause it was a really hot day, so I made sure that the drink stayed really cold and delicious. Water is self service. They shift their menu a lot which I think is really nice for the community. The cocktails are on the pricier side they think they start around 14 or 16 which I think is a little too much for a local neighborhood bar.

I have been on the hunt for my "cheers" and the hunt started here. I went one night with friends…read moreand grabbed seats at the bar. This place is so cozy and surprisingly easy to park. The vibes are right and the bartenders were nice and chatty, the only reason this place isnt "my" place and doesn't get 5 stars is because they dont make a very good dirty martini and thats like base level. I asked for it extra dirty and I could barely taste the olive brine, I actually had to have him pour more in front of me lol. Also service was a little slow. So for grabbing a quick drink with the girls sure, but staying as a regular nah.

Honey Pot Cocktail Lounge-Cocktails

See all

Nepenthe Brewing

4.5(164 reviews)

2.9 mi•Hampden

Nepenthe Brewing is a great place for vegans and non drinkers. Seem weird for a brewing company?…read moreMaybe, but they make it work well and that is why I'm a fan. Nepenthe Brewing has a rotating menu of inspired vegan dishes. This isn't your typical burger and fry brewery. We've visited for date nights, during vegan week, with kids and without. Each time, Nepenthe has not disappointed. Some of the dishes my family and I have enjoyed here are the Killer Tofu (top notch), Crispy Mushroom Banh Mi, Berry Smashed Mocktail, Lemon-Blueberry Cake and, for the kids, the fries with vegan pub dipping sauce. As long as Nepenthe keeps putting forth unique vegan food and mocktails, my family and I will keep it a part of our rotation.

There are many cute bars in Hampden. During my time there this past weekend I decided to try this…read moreBrewery. It is a great brewery. They have very tasty beers and cocktails. And they aren't too expensive. At the Brewery they also offer food, and they have games you can play while you are drinking. It is a great Sunday afternoon meet up spot. I was able to try one of their cocktails which was great. It had a good taste too it...not too sweet and not too bitter. It was a great time. I hope to be back soon.

CHIMICHURRI PATTY MELT

See all

Special: All beef hotdog with onion jam and fries with horseradish sauce

Peabody Heights Brewery

4.5(128 reviews)

2.4 mi•Abell

While in Baltimore, one of the side quests I went on was to figure out what its best brewery. And…read morewhen it comes to beer, service, ambiance, food, and things to do outside of drinking good beer, Peabody Heights is the brewery that checked off all of those boxes and then some! For ambiance, Peabody Heights is located in the old location of Oriole Park, and it plays to that history perfectly by having a mural dedicated to baseball players of the Orioles past. The main space is also HUGE, featuring tables of varying group size, two bar areas, an outdoor courtyard featuring their own food truck, a private party area, and even more that I'll feature in the fun section!. For beers, I was enjoying IPAs, pilsners, lagers, porters, stouts, and then some. I even had a sour beer that was a vibrant blue color!But them being partnered with Charm City directly across the street meant that I was also enjoying damn good meads, and they also had good cocktails and NA options. The food truck banged out Asian American fusion comfort food that you could order from either your phone or an indoor tablet with ease. And my shrimp scallion pancakes and Korean corn dog were absolute bangers! For fun, Peabody has not one but TWO awesome arcade spaces. The first one I entered was a huge and satisfying PINBALL ALERT, and I happily spent all the cash I was carrying playing the Quest and Pokemon pinball tables. But when I pulled back the last door I walked through around last call, I was also absolutely blown away by their HUGE arcade room that featured any kind of arcade game imaginable (shooting, fighting, car racing, MORE pinball, etc) and a second bar space. Toss in stellar service and a great selection of takeaway beers and mead, and Peabody Heights is well worth the visit!

What a fun brewery!…read more My brother had a birthday gathering here this year - we were able to comfortably seat a group of 15-20 people in the outdoor picnic section area. Highly recommend this spot for groups looking for a place to gather and socialize. The space is deceivingly large; there are multiple indoor spaces all within a quick stride from a long bar with dozens of beer taps. The outdoor space is even larger than what's available indoors; their vast street level patio/deck space is full of picnic tables and benches that are perfect for larger groups when the weather is nice. And yes, their outdoor patio is pet friendly. While the brewery itself doesn't serve food, there was a food truck (that looked to be there quite often) set up in the outdoor area that had several good options. I had their burger and fries which was exactly what I needed after an afternoon of brews. The beer itself was tasty; I had several of their hazy IPA's which I've grown to enjoy. They also offer a very solid selection of N/A beer options; some of the folks in our group enjoyed them and gave them great reviews. I didn't get a chance to check out the arcade portion of the brewery, but yes, this is a barcade as well. If you're looking for an inclusive, energetic brewery to check out, definitely keep Peabody on your list.

Outside

Pang! 3, Jubeat

See all

Order here

Wiley Gunters

4.5(221 reviews)

1.7 mi•Riverside

Went there with some friends on a whim on one of the first beautiful days of the spring in…read moreMaryland, IYKYK. Despite the flow of patrons, the staff was responsive and the food came out quickly. We ended up sitting inside by the windows which was completely fine, despite wanting outdoor seating. Plenty of indoor space and great people watching. I don't even want to preface with "for bar food," because this food need not be categorized. The portions were massive, i was able to take 1/2 of my buffalo cauliflower wrap home. As a vegetarian, I felt as though there were plenty of options for me. I also enjoyed a sour. I look forward to coming back here in the future.

Honestly, I should have just kept the issue I experienced to myself due to the response I was…read moregiven. I found a rock in my fry, my tooth is still slightly irritated. I addressed the issue with one of the workers or possible bar back who said that he would send someone out to speak with me. We waited about 15 minutes and no one came. I decided to go in and the general manager Dan came to speak with me. I felt very dismissed, he expressed that the rock probably came from the potato, honestly I was understanding that things like this happen as I also work in service. It was the way he responded to me, as he said "ok and what do you want me to do about it" there was no apologies or I'm sorry this happened. I wasn't asking for him to comp my entire meal, but the least he could have done was apologize and or discount the meal or one beverage. I mainly addressed this issue to make them aware, and I honestly wouldn't have written this review if Dan the general manager was one, polite and two the least bit apologetic. I walked out feeling dismissed and irritated. Better sub your fries for salad unless you would like an unexpected trip to the dentist.

See all

Union Craft Brewing

4.2(231 reviews)

3.3 mi•Medfield

Huge open space with tables, a bar, and small bites. There is also a beer garden outside space for…read morenice weather. Came here for a meetup with friends and had a blast! There are so many beers to choose from and I got the Zadie's Lager on draft (which was a delicious light beer). They have windows into the brewing area which looks super cool, and they brew a lot of the beers on site! I ended up getting a six-pack of Mountain Girl beers to take home. Staff was quick and friendly. It was busy for a Friday night and there were some kids running around and being obnoxious, but other than that we had a great time. This is the perfect spot for an event or meet up with lots of friends. The space is huge!!

i've been here several times and had a good experience during all of them. their take on a mule is…read morereally tasty and well balanced. i'm not much of a beer person, but their draft cider was incredibly dry (to the point it tasted like wine to me). not my cup of tea but could be someone else's. i also got the hummus and veggie wrap and soba noodle salad. the hummus and veggie wrap (not pictured) is pretty good and refreshing. i would say the same for the soba noodle salad. nothing mind blowing but for food at a brewery i'm not mad. their fries are cooked very well (though underseasoned). during the day there are far more kids that hang around, and it gets quite busy at night (especially on weekends). there is a really nice outdoor area to hang out in when the weather is nice. they have some fun activities, including a cute little vending machine with mystery packs in it. overall a fun time!

See all

The Brewer's Art

4.1(1.1k reviews)

0.9 mi•Midtown Belvedere

What an incredible spot on so many levels. My friend brought me here to enjoy their varied…read morewhiskey selection, craft beers on tap, and cozy architecture. We split a flatbread which was on happy hour special. The dough was perfectly worked, cheese was flavorful, as were the mushrooms on top. The sauce was a bit too sweet, but it didn't interfere with the overall taste of the flatbread which was a win. My Abbey Ale was cold, effervescent, and had a toasted biscuit finish - delicious! The dining room is beautifully appointed, intelligently lit, and the menu has varied options. I'd definitely come back for a full meal. The staff was engaging and friendly, the music was jazzy-hipster in an ambient way, and the downstairs "speakeasy" looks like the place I want to be on a Friday night with some friends. Check this place out, you'll be glad you did.

Before our flight home, we came here with a reservation so we could grab a meal before heading to…read morethe airport. When we arrived, we were seated right away, but it seemed like there were very few staff working--possibly only one waiter. It took about 10 minutes before we finally had to flag him down just to place our order. The food then took around 25-30 minutes to come out, which felt very long since we were on a tight schedule for our flight. When the food finally arrived, I ordered the macaroni and cheese, and unfortunately it was the worst mac and cheese I've ever had. I don't want to be mean, but it was very bland and really needed salt. My sister surprisingly liked it, but it just wasn't for me at all. The rest of my family did enjoy their meals, and I thought the fries were decent, just lightly seasoned. My mom especially liked the grilled cheese. The waiter himself was nice and kept our drinks refilled, so I don't think the long wait was entirely his fault. The restaurant is very cute inside with cozy, old-style vibes and festive Christmas decorations, which I really liked. However, between the long wait times, the limited menu, and my disappointing mac and cheese, I wouldn't recommend that dish. Overall, it's a charming place, but the service was too slow for us--especially when trying to catch a flight.

Dec 2007: Beacon, next to a few fallen Resurrections and St. Festivus

Dec 2007: rosemary garlic fries!

See all

July 2008

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

106 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

James S.

Elite 23

144

3 years ago

On our recent visit to the revamped Lexington Market, we decided to check out Faidley's Seafood, which hasn't moved to its new location just yet. With a great variety of food vendors available, we came specifically for the famed crab cake. The food was a bit of a mixed bag. My wife ordered the crab cake platter and was blown away, declaring it potentially the best crab cake she's ever had. The website claims their crab cakes are 6.5 ounces, but this one seemed larger, easily 8 ounces, with no filler and packed with lump crab meat. The accompanying slaw and mac & cheese complemented it nicely. Unfortunately, my fried shrimp and fried clams didn't quite live up to the same standard. Perhaps I've been spoiled by the Star Fish Seafood Restaurant in Cortez, Florida, but my dish seemed more like something from the frozen food section at Walmart. The potato salad was tasty, and the raw bar and steamer section appeared to be popular choices among other diners. Do note that there are only standing tables available, with no chairs or stools. The charm of this decades-old establishment is undeniable, but I'm personally looking forward to their relocation into the market. We did encounter a small hiccup with our bill: we were charged for a second crab cake platter. After bringing it to the cashier's attention, she promptly walked to our table to verify the order on our brown paper 'placemat' and admitted the mistake. We received a cash refund without any drama, which was greatly appreciated. In summary, Faidley's Seafood offers a charming atmosphere, fantastic crab cakes, and commendable honesty in addressing billing issues. While some dishes could use improvement, it's definitely worth a visit, and we look forward to returning once they move into the new Lexington Market. read more

Ebony L.

See more unrecommended reviews

213

295

2 years ago

My partner and I recently took a day trip to Baltimore, and of course, seafood was at the top of my list! Our first stop was amazing, but after some exploring, we found ourselves at the iconic Faidley's Seafood, located inside the historic Lexington Market. It's a name synonymous with Baltimore's seafood scene, especially their renowned jumbo lump crab cakes, so I couldn't wait to dive in. I opted for the soft shell crab sandwich with fries, and let me just say--it was incredible. This was my first time trying a soft shell crab sandwich, and it did not disappoint! The crab was perfectly cooked, crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, with just the right balance of seasoning. The portions were spot on, satisfying but not overwhelming. As for the fries? Let's just say they didn't make it to the photo--we devoured them immediately! The atmosphere at Faidley's is a vibrant blend of history and charm. It's not just a meal, it's an experience. Whether you choose to eat inside or outside, you're surrounded by the lively energy of Lexington Market. The service was equally impressive--fast, friendly, and efficient. You can tell they take pride in keeping everything clean and welcoming, which only adds to the overall appeal. Faidley's is a true Baltimore treasure, and I can see why it's been a staple for generations. If you're a seafood lover, especially a crab enthusiast, this spot is a must-visit. From the food to the ambiance to the impeccable service, it's an experience I'd happily revisit anytime! read more

Amanda W.

17 years ago

Me and my fiance just moved to Baltimore last month, so we went exploring the city. First I have to say that everyone we have met in Baltimore told us that we had to go to Faidley's at the Lexington market but NO ONE TOLD US IT WAS SO BAD !!! The parking garage ( if you dare go there) is the only place you should park, which is $ 3.00 for the first hour , and smells like pee ( Because all of the 50 bums we came across in the square mile, pee there! ) Also I would be doing everyone an injustice if I did not mention that ALL of the buildings around the garage are either scary little shops with bars on the windows or dilapidated buildings with "no trespassing" spray painted on the front. We were definitely afraid of being mugged, shot or stabbed while walking to Faidley's. We saw prostitutes, gangs and drug dealers, this is NO exaggeration. Anyone saying otherwise in this blog is lying. This is the definition of 'the hood'..... PLEASE FOR YOUR SAFETY DO NOT BRING YOUR CHILDREN TO THIS AREA ! This is not a safe area. I want to make people aware of the area of town they are going into so they are not surprised like we were. The Crab Cakes are good but not great , however the coleslaw is amazing! I recommend that if you really want to taste their food, you order it from their website. You will have to call them but they will ship to you, and you will not be mugged or shot. read more

Nia B.

10 years ago

Faidley seafood owner takes all the credit for the food that is prepared. When you go down to the main Lexington Market, you will notice it is the black people secret recipes that Faidley have used and learned from the old school blacks that was their deep south and African recipes !!! Faidley employee's are not being respect for their hard work and is always underpaid for their service. The white owners of Faidley seafood are the one to make the profit and are running to the bank. Those workers are modern slaves. There should be some type of benefits for them also beside being forced to depend on welfare and homeless shelters. The crab cake is not faidley personnel recipe. Just watch and allow the truth speak for itself. As planned, Lexington Market will soon be closed, so when the new market open up that crab cake recipe will change because some of the major food preparers will be replace or will find other employment. over time the recipe never remain the same. Faidley is no longer have the best crab cakes in Maryland. why ? The crabs are no longer fresh water crabs, the fish is mostly all farmed fish not freshwater seafood. People are paying higher prices ( which is far too over price ). In exchange receiving poorer quality food.* Plus, Lexington Market is extremely dirty and always smell like trash ! read more

Ellen N.

14 years ago

Definitely always have to stop by Faidley's every time I'm in Bmore. Don't get me wrong, the first time I visited, I was definitely paranoid. The neighborhood's sketchy and if you're not used to that type of environment, you'll definitely hold onto your purse a little tighter. But don't be too quick to judge, the people that hang around the market may look sketch, but they're actually really nice and helpful. Especially with the parking meters; they'll stop and help you out to make sure you DON'T get a ticket. Now, on to the food. The lump crab cakes is where it's at. Hands down. Get it as a platter if you want the 2 sides; I got fries and macaroni salad (YUM). And I also got the soft shell crab sandwich. I personally think they should offer just the soft shell crab alone too, but hey, that's just my opinion. Also, I recommend taking a stroll around the market to walk off your meal. It's neat to wander around the market and see what every station has to offer, regardless if you're going to purchase anything from them. read more

Thesoundof S.

2 days ago

my parents introduxed us to jimmy'z up dundalk and faidley'z at lexington market ~ sooooo..happy they are both still here doing business...yes..they introduced us when we were babiez..i am the baby girl of many older than mei have now been kurrently roaming thiz earth [21+38]yearz an ole promise to my mommie...that i would remain to be my adult age of course.. standing on that 21 while evolving to my heightz..it iz b'kauze she remained to stay [22]...the age when she got her license just a little light for the day so faidley'z haz been in my life since before my and their other children..since before [o]ur birthz i highly recommend the both of them:;faidleyz=downtown baltimore though [w]e are not from there...it iz definitely **my &&one of my brother'z sekond home..and jimmy'z iz up the **north**east side of bmore in o'donnell heightz .right adjacent to tge **dundalk** kommunity ~ stop by both..and enjoyenjoy yallz dayz ahead read more

Dan A.

Elite 16

198

368

119

15 years ago

Okay, so Faidley's is in Lexington Market, which can be a little intimidating at first... but seriously, the crab cakes here are worth the trip here. There's different types of crab cakes available here but to cut to the chase, just pay the extra money and go for the jumbo lump. Don't even waste your times with the others. It's huge, with very little filler, and is stuffed with huge chunks of sweet crabmeat. Don't bother with adding condiments or whatever to your crabcake... You don't want to mask the flavor of the crabmeat! And while the crabcakes can beat any of the other fine-dining hoity-toity crabcakes from fancy restaurants in the area, don't expect a fine-dining experience. Once you get your food, you'll make your way to a table (without chairs) and just eat standing up. But seriously... don't let that detract you. This is the Maryland crabcake at its finest. read more

Marylou F.

10 years ago

This place is literally unmatched for fresh seafood when considering quality and freshness. My husband and I stepped off the plane and went directly to Faidley Seafood, and that was the best decision we made the whole weekend! Start with a solid lump crab cake. I consider myself well traveled, and this was easily the best I've ever had anywhere. Since there aren't any fillers, you get exactly what you want when you order it: crab. Spend the extra few bucks and get the jumbo lump cake. Then hop over to their raw bar and grab some freshly shucked oysters the size of your hand. Literally. Their prices are so beyond fair, especially given the quality you'll get. And give it a shot with an egg on top. We were hesitant, but apparently that's a thing, and turns out, it's actually pretty good. I can't say enough positive words about this place. GO! read more

Stephanie L.

Elite 18

289

10 years ago

The jumbo crab cakes are awesome! Lump crab meat with minimal, creamy filler and perfectly broiled with the quintessential hint of old bay. This is my go-to Baltimore crab cake spot for guests. You can get the platter with 2 sides or the crab a la carte. I always go with the a la carte option since 1 crab cake can be very filling. If you like oysters, Faidley has premium fresh oysters. Shucked on the spot for a very reasonable price. If you like the subtle flavors of varying oysters from different regions, Faidley's oysters may not be your best bet. But if you just love oysters - large and fresh...this is your place! The staff are always friendly and willing to help. Hope you like Faidley's as much as me! read more

gloria g.

12 years ago

Who are you ridiculous people that dish out fifteen bucks for one lonesome crab cake, anyway? Not only is the cost unjustified but the "market" itself is an unmitigated dump. The toilets remind me of the third world at its worst. What filth! Cleanliness is clearly not a priority in the building. THE MARKET SHOULD BE CLOSED. And then lastly there's the obnoxious scum referred to by reviewers on this thread that swarm the sidewalks around the market. Where are the cops? For such an "institution" Baltimore authorities seem not to care at all about the public's health and safety, at all. It's certainly clear the market's vendors don't. What a travesty. Period. End of story. Eat somewhere else. read more

Stephanie Y.

6 years ago

This venue is awesome! The place is tidy, and it has a big space for the customers. They have great seafood. I usually get oysters (raw on the half shell), clams, shrimp, and crabs. These are what all adorers of crab cake should aim for when finding the finest. An order looks like some squished down dried out hockey pucks many too many times. But here you get a high cake, light and almost fluffy with excellent texture and real crab flavor. The accommodating employees always seem happy to welcome you with good oysters, cold, cold beer, and down to earth service. Baltimore, you're lucky to have Faidley Seafood in your area, a real keeper and a great way to go idle on a lazy afternoon. read more

Harold D.

171

19 days ago

We had a really good experience here. The crab cakes were amazing and definitely the highlight of the meal. They were flavorful, had a great texture, and actually tasted like crab instead of being packed with filler. I would absolutely order those again. We also tried the oysters, and they were good. I'm glad we tried them, but for me they were more of a "try it once" kind of thing rather than something I'd order every time. Overall, the food was really good and the crab cakes alone are worth coming back for. If you're a seafood fan, this is definitely a place worth checking out. read more

Harry S.

9 years ago

Was at U of Md and decided to walk to lexington market and try the famous Faidley's crab cake. I shouldnt count the walk in my review but I feel its important to know that walking there wasnt the best idea. There were multiple people asking for handouts and I was uncomfortable. Once in the market I stood in line and ordered my crabcakes. The servers were robotlike and expected you to know how the process worked. Got my crabcakes and.... meh..was dissapointed. G&M, Pappas, and Jimmy's have them beat easily. Eating there in the store was busy and uncomfortable. read more

Jessica M.

10 years ago

The standard of the Baltimore crab cake started here. Years later they still do a fine job, but the rest of the city is now able to make a crab cake that is just as good and probably better. Its nice to go here for the novelty of trying it out. You have to walk through an unsavory part of the city. Upon arrival to the market I was greeted by a guy who was selling prescription pills and there was someone apparently on the heroin nod by the produce stand. BE PREPARED. I'd go by myself again, but would certainly not take my family read more

Alesha S.

14 years ago

I would have given Faidley's 5 Stars after my visit on Saturday but when I got home and started eating my Lump Crab Cakes, I noticed that there was a lot more filler than on my previous visits. The lump crabcakes are becoming less lump crabmeat and more filler. For the price, $12.95/each, I want all of the lumps I'm paying for. It didn't take away from the taste though. They are still the best crabcakes I have ever eaten. read more

Savannah G.

8 years ago

Must try crab cakes. This is an old fashioned sort of restaurant where you can still get a well tasting and hot meal. Food was presented quickly despite their long lines and service was still welcoming. I could tell they were under stress but still managed to be friendly. Just to let out of towners know, the location is inside Lexington Market so it takes a little bit of searching to find it. read more

Lauren D.

15 years ago

My boss took me to Faidley's to eat oysters and a crab cake one afternoon for lunch. Oysters were great, the shucker (Lou) was entertaining and hospitable and my boss didn't seem to mind the price. Faidley's YES, the crowd that walks by NO. I felt the need to clutch my purse one too many times. I guess that makes the Food a 5 star and the location a 1 which helps you understand my 3. read more

Rose T.

7 years ago

The trip was well worth it. The lump crab cake was on point! It was seasoned just right. I had the soft shell crab sandwich as well. The staff was also pleasant. Mac n cheese was bomb too, you should definitely try it even if it's common! The location wasn't ideal but food was great. I would come again just to have those food again. read more

Kelly B.

6 years ago

Crab cakes are good, but the rest leaves a lot to be desired. Fries are bland, and crab soup often lacks a good amount of meat. It is close to my job, so I will continue to patronize...but I definitely wouldn't go out of my way to stop here. Service is overall good, too. You can tell the staff enjoys working here! read more

Chris C.

3 years ago

Not much to look at but they hit it out of the park with the food. It's hard to find haddock anywhere these days. They did not disappoint. Also, their sides are exceptional as well. Service can be a bit cranky; maybe because they were close to closing but they were professional; and even seemed to warm up a bit. read more

Faidley's Seafood - seafoodmarkets - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Faidley's Seafood also viewed

Koco's Pub

4.6

(929 reviews)

•$$$

On the hunt to try some of Baltimore's best crab cakes, I'm late to the party for Kocos. However,…read morebetter late than never. Given Koco's crab cake platter during their dinner service will set you back about $50, I've been hesitant to spend that amount of money for just one 8oz. crab cake. So I decided to give them a try during their lunch hours where you can get a 6oz. crab cake platter for about $30. I ordered in advance and popped into the brightly colored, tropical themed restaurant which was bustling on a Friday afternoon. My pickup was quick and the service was nice. I of course had to sneak a few fries while on my ride home, and they were perfectly crisp and well seasoned. Once I made it home I dived into the beautifully broiled crab cake and I immediately understood why Koco's is know as one of best crab cakes in the area. Full of lump crab meat, seasoned to perfection, and not wet in the center. All things I consider in a good crab cake. Now that I've had a taste of Koco's I'll definitely be saving a few coins to splurge a little for a crab cake.

If you're in Baltimore and looking for authentic Maryland crab cakes, Coco Pub is absolutely worth…read morea visit. The 11 oz. lumpy crab cakes were the star of the meal. Packed with large, tender chunks of crab and very little filler, they were cooked perfectly and let the quality of the seafood shine. The atmosphere was welcoming, the staff was friendly, and the overall experience made for a great meal. If you're a crab cake lover, this is definitely a spot to add to your list. I'll be back the next time I'm in Baltimore.

Sal and Sons

4.3

(284 reviews)

I will be coming back!!! When you think about seafood prices, nothing beats the value this place…read morehas. I was able to quickly find street parking on a Friday afternoon. Sal is super nice and will strike up a conversation with you! This spot is located in a food hall where many people look to take their lunch. I got the crab cake sandwich meal which comes with fries and a drink -- SO DELICIOUS! I can't wait to try more of their other items

Wow what a steal!!! The owner is super nice and the food tastes fresh. Seriously, come here for a…read morequick and easy lunch. You won't find another crab cake sandwich for the same price that tastes good. I do wish it was seasoned slightly more but I'm aware of how much salt I prefer on my food over others So yummy and a good quick lunch!

Rusty Scupper

3.8

(1.5k reviews)

•$$$

We had the most amazing dinner at Rusty Scupper this evening! Patty did an amazing job waiting on…read moreus! She was so personable and made our experience there a dream! Our food was phenomenal! I had the Blackened Shrimp and Grits and a Jumbo Lump Crab cake. My husband had the Baltimore Fish Fry! We shared the Warm Butter Cake! SOOOO GOOOOOD! We'll definitely be back next visit and hope we have Patty again!

Best Views in Baltimore. Always a staple in Baltimore for the seafood and atmosphere. Pattie…read morecrushed the service, as always. With a grand piano to set the tones.

Baltimore Seafood

4.1

(406 reviews)

Bri (host) and Leah (server) were incredibly nice and attentive. Bri took me and my friends…read morepictures and Leah has the best smile and service. the food was delicious I got head on shrimp and snow crab.

My family and I were visiting Baltimore for a short vacation. This restaurant was a find on Yelp…read moreand it did not disappoint! My son and I shared the Captain's Catch seafood boil with the house blend seasoning... which included 3LBs of seafood (Dungeness Crab, Shrimp, and Mussels, and potatoes and corn) The portion was plentiful and the taste was AMAZING! You can also customize your own boil which is what my son's girlfriend did... also with the house blend seasoning... also AMAZING and FULL OF FLAVOR!! Leah our waitress was so helpful and walked us through the ordering process. Leah made our experience even more memorable !!! My family and I will definitely return to Baltimore Seafood when we visit the Baltimore again. The whole experience was fun for all. We recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants a great seafood boil

Conrad's Crabs & Seafood Market - Parkville

4.1

(323 reviews)

OMG, the crabs. I'm a native Marylander and daughter of a professional crabber. I'm very picky…read moreabout seafood. Conrads crabs are fantastic. Hot, perfectly steamed, heavy and perfectly seasoned. This place has made my favorites list.

Not impressed. We've been here before and it's never consistent. This time we ordered 2 backfin…read morecrab cakes (fried) an entree. It comes with 2 sides. We got onion rings and coleslaw. I tried to pay cash but the cashier counted only $30 so I paid on my credit card. Before I even had the opportunity to use the touch pad to put in a tip she immediately hit enter several times so it bypassed all the options for tip, text receipt etc.... I was thinking ok, not wanting a tip I guess. It seemed rather rude. While we waited I counted my cash and I did have $40 so I'm not sure what was up with her math. Food came out really fast. Our drive was not far so our food should have been hot. Instead the small racquet ball size crab cakes were cold. I don't even think they were cooked thru. I had to stick in air fryer to get them warmed up. The coleslaw which on previous visits was good lacked any flavor besides mayonnaise. My poor wife cracked down on a sharp pointy shell in her crab cake. Needless to say we were both disappointed and still hungry. I'm not sure what happened but we won't be going back anytime soon. I think we'll stick with Pappas.

Peter's Pour House

4.1

(340 reviews)

This place provides exactly what it advertises. Medium priced beer and okay food. It has good…read moreambiance and terrific service, but you get better grub anywhere else nearby.

Pappas Restaurant

3.6

(568 reviews)

Wanted to leave an updated review since we had our rehearsal dinner in the private dining room here…read morea couple weeks ago. From the first planning conversation through the actual event, everything went so smoothly. Our guests couldn't stop talking about how great the food and service were. DJ took amazing care of us all night. He was super accommodating with drinks, checking in on the music, and making sure the timing of each course flowed perfectly. Highly recommend Pappas for hosting a special event!

My associate and I went to this place for the first time, today (8/14/26)…read more First thing I noticed was how the greeter ( a blk female ) treated me, when I entered first....NO GREETING. But she had no issue with greeting my male associate ??? And she repeated this same rude behavior as I walked out first, and my male associate walked behind me. The crab cake was 5 out 10. It was very most; almost soggy. I will not return to this place.

Duda's Tavern

4.0

(230 reviews)

Justine is the ABSOLUTE worst bartender I've ever met in my entire 33 years of being a legal…read moredrinker. From calling us "dicks" walking in, to insulting us while drinking, to urging us for zero tip due to her terrible attitude, what a time. The fact this bar lets her represent them is telling enough. No wonder this place was empty when everywhere else in Fells was packed says it all. Avoid this place at all costs if Justine is there. And don't dare call her Jessica on accident. She gives ZERO cares about anything at all.

I wish I had the confidence of the terrible people in politics and workplaces who either lie about…read moretheir skills or are too ignorant to even be aware of their many flaws. Maybe I take Yelp too seriously. But it's a bummer when I see a review that praises the food, service and decor then rates 3 stars. (To re-use my joke, "3 out of 5 on Yelp isn't good, it isn't a work performance review). I have struggled with my Duda's review since August since I would strongly recommend it but I'm also price-cautious. To make matters worse I don't remember the exact crab market price but it was possibly $31 or $32 for one and low $50s for two (fact-checkers welcome). The crab cake was superb. All killer, no filler. The potato salad was very good. While I didn't love the price/volume I can't claim expertise on market prices and If you look at the drink prices this is clearly not a ripoff place. Possibly it's a better deal if you're with a group and can split some apps. In line with my slow education that Baltimore has more than the Inner Harbor, Duda's had a spectacular sense of place. It was a rare experience in feeling like a true locals place that is friendly to tourists. There's no record scratch and "you ain't from around here." The waiter was excellent and was impressively emphatic about the crab cakes.

Dylan's Oyster Cellar

4.3

(214 reviews)

I came here to eat raw oysters for the first time in my life. And i was happy with my experience…read moreand the man shucking them in front of me making sure i wasn't displeased i got good cocktails too. But if you're eating here, plan to spend. I did not notice my dozen of "Poseidons" (that's what they called them at the time) were $42.

Excellent place for oysters, my favorite raw bar choices are from up north where the water is…read morecolder. Dylans has a variety of northern oysters that hits the spot, they also have a menu for some tasty bites too. The menu isn't very large but adequate for a bar with seafood. The seating is quaint and I like the loud vibe of the bar atmosphere there. I wish they had more menu highlights and choices, since I don't drink much. The parking was not too crowded on the street and very reasonable in cost. A small town location in a nicely lit neighborhood with a main street feel. If I am in the area, I will stop by again!

Nick's Farm & Crab Market

4.5

(94 reviews)