What an absolutely delicious dinner. The hospitality from the moment we drove to the valet, to the proper entrance with the hosts and throughout the entire meal was purposeful and thought out. The employees here care about your experience. My wife and i have only lived down here since January. We've explored restaurants from Red Bank through the shore. This was #1 so far, I would actually look forward to dining here again. Alan, our server, you're very good at what you do. Thank you for that. Get yourself a nice bottle of wine, head here. Order anything and sit back and enjoy the experience. It was absolutely beautiful inside for my 45th! read more

Falcone - Italian Near Me - Lincroft, New Jersey

Falcone in Lincroft is basically what happens when someone spends 95% of the budget on interior design and 5% on the actual food. The restaurant itself? Beautiful. Gorgeous lighting, trendy aesthetic, romantic atmosphere. If your goal is taking photos for Instagram or pretending you're dining in Manhattan for the night, this is your place. The food, however, was wildly underwhelming for the prices. I ordered the "short rib" bolognese and spent half the meal trying to locate the short rib. It looked and tasted more like regular chopped meat sauce than slow-braised short rib. I've honestly had pasta dishes from local pizza places with more flavor and authenticity. And the candles... there are approximately 47,000 candles in this restaurant. So many that at one point a waiter leaned dangerously close to one and I genuinely thought his vest was about to catch fire -- meanwhile he had absolutely no idea. That pretty much summed up the overall dining experience: chaotic but aesthetic. Also, why is there forced valet in Lincroft? Even when you self-park, they still ask for your keys like you arrived in a Bentley instead of a Honda Pilot. Another strange touch: it's BYOB, yet they keep your wine bottle off to the side somewhere instead of leaving it at the table. The whole point of BYOB is being able to pour your own wine whenever you want without having to flag someone down every time your glass is empty. It felt unnecessarily pretentious for no reason. The biggest issue was that the restaurant never actually felt authentically Italian beyond the decor. For a place charging premium prices and branding itself as an upscale Italian dining experience, there should be a stronger sense of Italian hospitality, personality, culture, and presentation throughout the service experience. Instead, the whole thing felt more staged than genuine. Communication around the specials was difficult, nothing was written down, and the service lacked the polished confidence you expect at this price point. Ironically, the teenage valet outside gave more authentic Italian restaurant energy than the dining room itself. My suggestion? Lean harder into genuine hospitality and authentic Italian dining culture instead of just the aesthetic. Right now it feels like a beautifully designed movie set where the food and service never quite match the image. Overall: probably a nice place for cocktails, dessert, and ambiance before or after a night in Red Bank. But if you're going specifically for an amazing Italian dinner worthy of the prices, save your money and hit a really good local pizzeria instead. I promise if you change the wait staff to people who have a little more command of the English language... the word on the street would probably improve. read more

Incredible experience! Delicious food, wonderful atmosphere, beautiful decor and chinaware, great service by Gabriel. read more

Falcone - Italian Near Me - Lincroft, New Jersey

I had forgotten about Falcone and then remembered it could be a nice option for a pre- Valentine's dinner. Ambiance is elegant and the softly lit interior makes for a nice dinner feel. Service was good throughout the evening. Appetizers Arancini- special's menu- excellent Eggplant Napoleon Mid course Beet salad - Entrees Spaghetti with shrimp Balsamic Pork We opted out of dessert this time. We enjoyed our meal and evening at Falcone. A true byob gem in Lincroft. read more

See all

Hard to find, it's like a speakeasy restaurant, but once you're inside you're brought into a whole other world. The atmosphere is top notch. The service is so attentive, Michelin quality service. It's BYOB, but there is a liquor store not far if you didn't come prepared. I had the branzino and really enjoyed it. The clams were also tasty. The cannolis were fantastic. I'll be back. Definitely make a reservation. It was really busy even at an earlier hour. Food tips: Cannoli read more

See all

Went here for Christmas Eve and was amazed by the ambiance, service and food. Everything was delicious and the attention to detail on the service made this an enjoyable experience beginning to end. I will definitely be back. BYOB is a huge plus too read more

See all

What an amazing experience. Set in an old church, they transformed it into an upscale dining experience. Service is great and the food is top notch. It is byob and they offer valet parking. read more

See all

My husband brought me here for my birthday. We had reservations for a Sunday night and were seated right away. All staff were friendly and welcoming. The restaurant is absolutely beautiful! There are multiple chandeliers and the space was dimly lit. It was a very romantic vibe. The food was incredible! We shared the burrata & prosciutto and polpo. I had the Pappardelle as my entree. We shared the brownie and gelato for dessert. Everything was delicious. We had a lovely evening and look forward to our next visit! read more

See all

Amazing! Delicious food, an our service was so good! Beautiful dining area. The calamari and burrata were great appetizers. Everyone loved their meal and love that it's BYOB read more

Falcone - Dining area - Italian Near Me - Lincroft, New Jersey

See all

What a visually stunning restaurant! Who is your interior decorator? Love! Love! Love! the ambiance! Restaurant located in a restored building that used to be a church! In Lincroft, NJ. Love the brick walls and all the beautiful and intricate details from the dry flowers, candles, clocks and books! Love the vintage floral china. The various chandeliers are WOW! Service was fantastic! Our Server Alan was attentive! Masterfully prepared and presented cuisine! Highest compliment to the Chef and Kitchen Brigade‼ Sparkling Water Tiramisu- fantastic sweet treat Polpette Di Ricotta- hot honey was perfection! Caesar salad- well seasoned and lots of cheese! Pappardelle with short rib- so flavorful Agnolotti- loved my entree! Balsamic Pork Chop - tender and moist Everything was delicious! Even the seasoned oil served with the complimentary bread! Yum! It's BYOB Valet parking Recommend making reservations! Got to meet the Manager Nick Who checked in on us twice! Thank you for your gracious hospitality. Looking forward to returning real soon! read more

See all

Service and ambiance are top tier but food was average, especially for the prices. Great spot for a special date night, just not for an unforgettable meal. read more

5 stars across the board! I hate sharing this review because I'm worried I won't be able to get in once people realize how amazing it is, if they haven't already! From the moment you walk in you're presented with a ahhh moment! The vibe is sexy,sophisticated and welcoming. We were greeted with numerous hellos and greeted by a gentleman (sorry, didn't get his name) that looked up our reservation and immediately took us to a great table for 2. Our server, Alfredo (*sp) was so attentive. Let's talk food! We shared the Pappardelle ragu pasta as an appetizer, perfectly cooked!! Hubby had the veal chop, he said it was like butter. I had the pork chop, I did a chair dance and a happy hand clap when I took my first bite! I was full but couldn't stop eating! The love in the food is real! I actually asked if I could see the kitchen because when I was looking around there was a positive energy pouring out of the kitchen. I was escorted to the kitchen and got to speak directly to the owner. No yelling, no loud banging of dishes, no mess. The kitchen was impressive! Bravo to everyone involved! Thank you for such an enjoyable evening! Highly recommend! read more

See all

Food and ambiance were wonderful! definitely will be going back ! entire experience was a delight.

Excellent Italian restaurant in central Monmouth County. While it may not look like much from the road and parking lot, this gem is one of the best Italian restaurants I've been to in the area with service to match. Highly recommend. read more

It is very hard to get 5 stars out of me. From start to finish. The service, food, ambiance were all top notch. If you were thinking about coming book the reservation! You will not be disappointed. read more

This was my first time visiting Falcone and for me it was a 10/10. Loved the interior space. It's so warm and inviting. Perfect for a romantic date night. The service is truly wonderful. Very friendly and attentive staff. This truly was an amazing dining experience from start to finish. Love the fact that it's byob as well. For starters we tried the calamari oregante. It's out of this world! I highly recommend. I don't think I will ever eat fried calamari again. lolThis was so much healthier and flavorful. I would return to Falcone just for this dish. The complimentary bread is so good! It tastes like an everything bagel and the herb olive olive is great! For the main courses we had the veal saltimbiocco and the spicy rigatoni. The veal was chef's kiss good and the rigatoni was delicious as well. The pasta was cooked to perfection and so flavorful. We had an amazing time dining here. I almost want to gate keep because I want to be able to get a reservation without waiting weeks. lol. Bravo to Falcones and their entire staff. Thank you for making our night special. read more

See all

We enjoyed a sensational dinner at Falcone. It was our first, but definitely not last, time in this gorgeous remodeled church building. It was well worth the 2 hour round trip from North Jersey. Our servers Eddie and Rubin were exceptional. We enjoyed a crispy skinned whole (deboned) branzino; delicious pistachio crusted lamb chops in a sweet mint puree; fantastic calamari oreganata with an excellent sweet and spicy sauce on the side; clams oreganata; sweet corn agnolotti with grand marnier, grana padana, and sage. We took home cannoli for dessert. read more

See all

Falcone can be easily missed because it is in an old church and doesn't have a big sign. Nonetheless, this small restaurant offers quality food for a decent price due to it's location. It's complementary valet parking in a gravel lot in the back with a couple of parking spots to the side. The entrance to the restaurant is on the side of building and you enter into a uniquely transformed restaurant. It's a small space for a restaurant but it gets the job done. The servers are friendly and knowledgeable of the menu. The calamari are good but the jam on the fried ricotta balls were a hit for me. Although I didn't taste the hot honey in the jam. I had the roasted beet salad as well which was good since all the flavor profiles worked well together. The pappardelle was great as the short rib was seasoned. A lot of times from my experience the meat isn't really seasoned. The pasta, cheese, and short rib ragu all paired well together. I had to try a dessert so I went with a classic brownie with vanilla gelato. They didn't miss on the brownie and vanilla gelato combo. This place is a must try if you are in the area. read more

See all

My husband and I went there in April for our anniversary. The service was fine, the meals were okay but the interior would have been more enjoyable if not so dark. Really difficult seeing the menu and even our dinner companions across the table. My husband almost tripped in the entryway. Needs better lighting! Nice young man outside with the cars. read more

This was our first time trying Falcone. We were so excited to try this "hidden gem". When we arrived, we were shocked by how dark it was inside. The ambiance was elegant but much too dark. While the service was impeccable, the food was subpar. The bread tasted like a salt stick. The meatballs were cold, tasteless and crumbly. The eggplant parm app was the best thing we had. So delicious but portion was small. We ordered the octopus app as well. It was thick and overcooked- super chewy. We then shared the spicy rigatoni entree , that came out 5 minutes after we finished our apps. I hate feeling rushed. Unfortunately, the rigatoni was extremely hard. So needless to say, we probably won't return. But, glad we tried it! read more

This was our second visit to Falcone's, and once again, the food was exceptional--but what truly set the evening apart was our waiter, Alfredo. From the moment we were seated, Alfredo elevated the experience with his warm, intuitive service and deep knowledge. As soon as he saw the Amarone on our table, he knew to decant it--no need to ask, no hesitation. That level of expertise and attentiveness told us we were in excellent hands. His recommendations throughout the night felt tailored to us, as though he instinctively understood our tastes. Every course was timed perfectly, and his presence was gracious, never intrusive--just the right touch at every moment. We started with the sweet and hot calamari, the sautéed artichokes in lemon sauce, and the beef and pork meatballs--each dish bursting with flavor and beautifully prepared. The bread served alongside the meatballs was warm, crusty, and impossible to resist. For my entrée, I had the Parmesan-crusted chicken in a lemon-caper sauce with broccoli rabe--tender, bright, and perfectly seasoned. Our friends enjoyed the scallops over creamy risotto, while the men both ordered the veal chop, which they said was one of the best they've had. While the food was truly excellent, it was Alfredo who made the night unforgettable. His professionalism, timing, and instinct turned a wonderful dinner into a memorable experience. Falcone's is now one of our go-to spots--not only for the food, but because of service like Alfredo's. We'll absolutely be back--and we'll be asking for him by name. read more

Falcone is the spot everyone's been waiting to eat at. The vibe is intimate, perfect for date night or a small gathering. The service is on point, and it's BYOB, so bring your favorite bottle. I started with the ricotta polpette--so unique and delicious--along with the clams and meatballs. For the main course, the chicken limone was tender and zesty, the spicy rigatoni had just the right kick, and the shrimp risotto special was rich and satisfying. And trust me, make sure you save room for dessert! Watch my full video on IG: @foodaholicnj read more

See all

What a great find. Great atmosphere, service fantastic and the food was great. We will be back!

Stopped here with my GF on the way home from the Jersey Shore outlets. We loved the ambiance & food. Overall we had a great time together which is most important. I would recommend Falcone to anyone, and I consider myself a picky foodie who isnt overlly impressed unless the food (especially Italian food since im Italian) is really delicious. read more

The restaurant is excellent. The room has a great vibe. Service was excellent from the start to the finish. We shared the octopus and tuna special- both were delicious. I had the Parmesan crusted chicken- the crust was crispy and the chicken was juicy. My wife thoroughly enjoyed the branzino. I highly recommend Falcone read more

Amazing fresh pastas, appetizers, main courses and desserts. BYO is a plus and great espresso.

Driving down the Newman Springs road you would never know there was a fantastic find right beneath your nose. If you blink you may just miss it. This old converted church, now painted black looks simple and non descriptive from outside , having no identification by name nor grand entrance, yet once you enter POW! " we're not in Lincroft anymore Toto" Falcone is the name of this gem. Upon entering there is feeling that you have left lincroft and you are now in an old loft like Soho building with beautiful bare brick walls and a soaring ceiling. Giant chandeliers add a soft dim light and very cool upbeat music gives this space a modern yet elegant feel. The staff here are just delightful. The tables are a bit small given the beautiful tableware which gives little room for any extra plates on the table but the glassware is of high quality Ok let's get to the food. The bread on the table was very crusty and fresh accompanied by a seasoned olive oil. The menu is pretty straightforward Italian Our table opted for the napoleon eggplant and the rigatoni with spicy tomato sauce which I must say was quite unique and very delicious. I would return just for this alone it was so delicious. Prepared perfectly al dente, (as so few restaurants knows how to do this ). I think it's a house speciality The Bronzino was Devine! With a crisp outer skin, gently flavored but extremely tender flesh it's one of the best I've had. Served with an arugula and fennel salad which compliments it perfectly A side of garlic mashed potatoes was delicious albeit could have been warmer as they were barely hot enough They are gracious though as they split our dish for us in the kitchen The olive oil cake here cannot be missed ! It's perfect. I do wish however that they had an herbal tea. Yes the cappuccino was delicious but sometimes a camomile or mint tea is desired after a meal. It surprised me that it wasn't available Prices are above average high but considering it's a BYOB I understand the need to be profitable A fantastic find for this sleepy community! Go now as I think once the secret is out it will be harder to get in read more

Falcone - Side order of artichoke sautéed franchase - Italian Near Me - Lincroft, New Jersey

See all

Can't say enough about the food or the staff. You can't go wrong with dining here. A little pricey but you get what you pay for. BTW, their lamb chops are super read more

We would not consider going back. Food was ok for most of us. my scallops over risotto was very bland. I had to ask for salt and pepper to flavor it. Also very overpriced at $210 a couple when it's a BYOB. Small and dark inside. Service was good. read more

Falcone exceeded my expectations! The restaurant decor is stunning with exposed brick and dimly lit chandeliers, which made for a perfect environment for our 21st anniversary dinner. The service was amazing. Upon arrival, we waitied in the beautifully decorated lounge area to be seated. We were greeted by a server who.opened up and poured our wine, and then we were seated. The service remained just as professional and attentive throughout the evening, too. On to the food.Everything we ordered was divine. From the octopus appetizer, on to the lemon pasta and the veal chop which we both shared, every bite was filled with complex flavors that only a skilled chef could create. We skipped dessert as we are both trying to cut out sweets, but the overall experience at Falcone was A+. We both can't wait to go back again with friends to taste more of the delectable food. read more

Haven't been yet, so can't rate but don't want to hurt their overall rating, so will give 4 stars. While everything looks wonderful, I do wish the menu was more original. That would be a draw for me. read more

Great looking space. Patrons in their nicest wears Tables full all night. Food was good. Fennel salad a surprise. Entrees staged nicely apart from the apps. Nice spot. read more

2nd time here and food ambience was great. This review is for the service. Nick the mgr maitre d sort of guy was very personable. Hostess was great! Server was 2 stars! His thick hard to understand accent was frustrating. We were all shocked that management has not caught on?? He was also very rushed and disengaged, looking around as he's telling us the specials made it even more difficult to understand him:( After entrees arrived he didn't return to ask how is everything and only showed up after 7/8 minutes of us staring around looking for him. We would have ordered desserts but didn't want to wait any longer. read more

Beautiful decor!! Deceiving from the outside, inside is spectacular. Great food very good service Very good and interesting food optiona Definitely impressed and will be back read more

Nice ambiance, music could have been a bit lower. Food and service was good. Burrata and Shrimp Risotto were stand outs. read more

See all

What a fantastic dinner we had last night at Falcone. The food was outstanding! The service (Blake) was so professional, and the ambiance was so romantically beautiful! We had a special appy to start (parm encrusted calamari- the most tender and tastiest we've ever had). I had the chicken Lemone, and my husband had the pappardelle with braised short rib. All dishes were large portions yet perfectly prepared and delivered reasonable fast! Total bill was around $100 (plus tip). It's a BYOB which is ideal - they obviously concentrate on the quality and flavors of their dishes. We will certainly be returning again soon! Valet Parking only. read more

See all

This is a gem. I am also apprehensive to share as I may not get a reservation so easily. But it actually wasn't hard. The service and the ambience is unique and special. The food is absolutely to die for. I love a BYOB that is absolutely first class. Great job by ownership to give this neighborhood a chance. Love it. read more

Ambiance was cool. Wait staff wasn't fully organized. I requested a corner table during my reservation and had to ask again when we got there - when you book two weeks in advance, not ideal, especially for a special occasion. Prices were outrageous for a BYOB. I never mind spending the price when it's good, but the food quality does not match the price tag at Falcone. Apps were better than entrees overall. Comparing this restaurant to other up scale Italian BYOBs in the area, it's over priced and not worth it. read more

Great atmosphere and nice folks but not really great food. Service folks don't know what each other are doing, 40 mins between app and main. I'm sure they will eventually figure this out. When main was served the fish was raw and had to go back for a redo. Again chef will figure it out. I think the kick in the balls was the price and as a previous reviewer stated ...they didn't care enough to take anything off the bloated bill. Aside from that the food was OK but IMO the entire experience was not worth the cost. $50 for an OK chicken parm (w/ $15 add on pasta) because it doesn't come with anything is egregious. On a positive note the Olive oil cake and cappuccino were very good. Sadly, I'm in no rush to go back...and they are so close. read more

Loud, dark, and overpriced. It's literally Aleo's food in a different setting. Nothing to brag about and likely will not be back.