The pizza was good and was great for when you are drunk and need something to eat ... The guys where chill in assisting and just readily to help.... Love that they have beer there but has to stay in that little learning spot .... read more

See all

Pies the size of your soul! That's large! They taste amazing you definitely fold your slice here or be like those who don't know a fork an knife hehehe! The sauce is great. Servers sometimes are known to bet you that they'll cover your entire tab if you can polish the largest pie ALONE. This spot has the below restaurants Atomic cowboy- Bar Fat sullys- pizza Denver biscuit Company- breakfast read more

See all

Popped in to get food after a day party in the area and OMG, so good!! We ordered the largest pizza on the menu, wings and fries and everything was so fresh and delicious!! Mr. Duffy was working in the kitchen and is a true gem, we had to personally thank him for all the good food! Our server Ryan had the best recommendations and was so friendly and accommodating to our large group! 10/10 would recommend!! read more

When we walked into Fat Sully's, there was no host on duty so we seated ourselves at the only table available. The very first issue was that it was so dark that I needed my flashlight to read the menu. Things just went downhill from there. We each ordered a "big ass slice". I ordered mine just with cheese, my husband ordered anchovies (yuck). The pizza was obviously premade and then just reheated and that's exactly what it tasted like. The sauce tasted like a packet of seasoning was added to a can of tomato sauce. The bottom of our slices were burned. We both ordered a beer. Both beers were flat. I could have told our server but we didn't see him again until he handed us our check. Maybe this is drunk pizza, it's definitely not sober pizza. Whatever it is, it sure was lousy. read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - Big ass slice with anchovies - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

I had the most disheartening experience this evening at Fat Sully's/Atomic Cowboy. I generally visit for their late night special of a slice and pint and will commend them for this inviting offer. I am personally not much of a drinker and not particularly craving pizza this evening, explored their menu for an alternate late night satiating bite. I resolved myself to their Chicken Sandwich for $11, which arrived sparsely dressed with pickles and mayo on a brioche bun. (Not being a fan of mayo, I had requested this on the side.) When it arrived, I politely requested any condiments to dress it up and was offered lettuce and tomato and "stone ground mustard" upon request. My server did not deliver my sandwich, so I repeated this request when she checked in with a squeeze bottle of yellow mustard. She returned after some time and a stop at her register with a small cup of shredded iceburg lettuce, without tomato, and a significantly overfilled cup of stone ground mustard. Registering this I resolved I would not inconvenience her again, even considering, maybe they did not have any sliced tomatoes and I would not want them to waste a whole tomato at this hour for a slice or two, though it would have greatly improved my sandwich. As for the mustard, I considered the waste, as they could have provide one quarter the amount to generously spread on my sandwich. While tasty, I considered I could have spent half the price for an equivalent sandwich at any of several fast food restaurants, or less at Denver's moat popular chicken sandwich restaurant, but attempted to convince myself it was fresher and relieved my late night hunger. Upon receiving the check, I had the overwhelming feeling there was an attempted theft on the part of the restaurant. I was charged $1.00 for "lettuce and tomato" - the bit of shredded lettuce delivered without any tomato, and $0.50 for "stone ground mustard." The lack of concern by the server was escalated to a manager with the whole experience escalating in overwhelming disappointment. I was offered "a credit for the lettuce as it did not include tomato, but the 'restaurant policy' was to charge for the stone ground mustard, along with anything that did not come on the sandwich." Evidently, the yellow mustard, in a squeeze bottle was not charged for, but my preference for stone ground mustard, which "cost more and came from the kitchen" still had to be charged for. The manager's representation of the restaurant's policy was that, "If they included these condiments, they would have to charge more for the sandwich." Suffice it to say our positions remained irreconcilable. I considered I have been culturally biased by the "Have it your way," programing that probably few can presently identify to, while trying to respect the restaurant's position to make a profit and "cover expenses." I remain resolved that you do not charge for traditional condiments that compliment and should be included on a sandwich! To do so, in my perspective is a theft and utter disrespect to any customer in an attempt to profit exponentially off of a penny's worth of these complimentary items. Keep your ketchup and mayo, which I do not consume, and please have the courtesy to substitute a small portion of mustard, without additional charge, to make my dining experience and provide the bare minimal of consideration for customer satisfaction. Compounding this negative experience is the mere fact that neither of two servers who fielded my trivial condiment request suggested or offered that there would be an upcharge for this. If you are resolved to charge for condiments or anything which the average customer would expect to be included, Please disclose this, as there is a right to know and make an informed decision. Personally, it remains my intent to respectfully patronize, on occasion, this Fat Sully's/Atomic Cowboy for their late night slice and pint special, but I am left with such distaste for their flagrant upcharging policy, I would not consider any other menu options until this practice/theft is reviewed and eliminated by the owner(s) and upper management. read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - Receipt - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Solid pizza to get to go for a game night, movie at home, or if you're like me sitting alone in the dark contemplating on how to take over the world. Recently tried the garlic knots and they are amazing. Solid pizza. read more

A native New Yorker, Fat Sully's is my go to for pizza since moving to Denver. It is occasionally inconsistent, but always at least good. The problem comes when you order a pound of wings. It is never a pound. The wings weighed in the box with the carrot and celery sticks usually comes in just over 12 ounces. If my math is correct 12 ounces is 25% less than a pound. This time the side dipping sauce was also missing. Will continue to get my pizza there, but will go elsewhere for my wings. read more

Came here with a free 26" pizza coupon and had a great time! I got a strawberry rhubarb mule at the recommendation of the server, and really enjoyed the drink! Just the right amount of alcohol and non-alcohol parts. The pizza took a while to come out, but the service made up for it and they acknowledged and apologized for the wait. They ran out of white sauce but the regular red sauce was yummy (from someone who doesn't love red sauce). I was also really wowed by the size of the pizza! We have plenty of leftovers....haha We also lucked out on getting seating at the last open booth and really enjoyed a casual date night dinner! read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - 26" red pie with banana peppers, pepperoni, and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

I ordered a Fat Sully's pizza online at AtomicProvision.com; I selected the Broadway location near my house. It was easy to use their website to choose my pizza, veggie & protein toppings. I received an email with my receipt and a text msg indicating the time I can pick it up. I ordered a 10 inch gluten free cauliflower crust pizza with mushrooms, jalapeno, bacon and pepperoni. The pizza was made with red sauce and 1 cheese before additional toppings. The pizza was ready at the indicated time and was hot when I picked it up. I had no issues at the takeout window. I added Pex Peppers hot sauce to spice it up. read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - Takeout window and outdoor waiting area - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

$6 beer and shot on a Sunday afternoon is a necessity. Their wings and smash burger are absolutely delicious as well. A great vibes pretty slow night. Their caesar salad is delicious as well. The pizza was perfectly done. Super crispy. Best location out of all of them imo. read more

See all

It was okay.. we went before closing so maybe that's why the experience wasn't the greatest.. but the Sando I ordered which I am a big fan of pickles.. & since it said they made their own pickles so I was even more excited.. to my surprise.. the pickles were missing as well as the chipotle mayo!!!! And I didn't check before leaving so I ended up eating a piece of chicken in between 2 buns. Super sad.. read more

Excellent and huge pizza from a fantastic establishment. Get on down there and gobble it up.

If making pizza at 11:30 is a problem, then close at 11. The order was for a band and the crew, and it could've been a great late push. We took our $500 order else ware. My apologies asking for ranch, the manager had to close early. . read more

Long time local, but never had been here before. I loved the taste of our biscuit sandwiches. Super delicious and super hearty, so plan to take a nap after eating here. But the best part was the fantastic service and vibe. Ryan was one of the friendliest servers I've ever experienced and was super attentive. We asked him to surprise and he definitely hit the mark. read more

See all

Where else can you go in Denver and have three different restaurants /bar in one place? Start off in the morning at the Denver biscuit Company, slide into lunch and dinner, and Wala you turn into Fat Sullys! Slide the atomic cowboy in for drinks and You have pretty good concept. Since we're focusing on fat Solae's, let's just say you have to get the large pizza. When I say large were talking a 26 inch pizza. Unfortunately you can't get this to go but I don't think I would wanna eat this pizza anywhere else. Pair it with a salad and you're set to go. read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Quick review when credit is due. Hey, that rhymes! Fat Sully's has been a reliable option for me since moving to Denver. I mean who doesn't love a 20" slice of pizza? It's always a fun vibe inside and the pizza is consistently great. In a COVID-world, their online ordering system is quick and to the point. I actually scheduled and paid for a pickup order a few hours in advance. I showed up at 4:00pm on the dot, walked to the outdoor pickup counter, stated my name and was handed a beautiful pizza pie. Boom. Done. Yes. This is one of those pizzas that caters to everyone. The gargantuan size is always a conversation starter. Hey, get your mind out of the gutter! Thanks Fat Sully's for always being there in my time of need. My hungriest state, my inebriated state, my pretty much anything state. Sending good vibes your way during this crazy time! read more

Got a 20" to go which feeds 3 adults just right My normal artichoke and sausage was great We got one with pepperoni and bacon. For some reason it lacked the sauce that the artichoke and sausage one had so it wasn't very good We got a pineapple pizza- ham and pineapple. I'm not a fan but they enjoyed it Don't order two 20" pizzas for 3 people :) it was good for two meals but obvi the crust isn't great when reheated the next day read more

Delicious food. Fun ambience. Logan was amazing with suggestions, quick service, and had a great personality. I've found my new favorite place to eat in Denver. read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - Three slices. Great value for the price! - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

I love this place. The 24" pizza is huge and 2 slices is more than enough to satisfy. I've never tried DBC and my understanding is the Atomic Cowboy is the bar but I'm not entirely sure. My uncle from out of town loved it too. They even have games to bide your time while waiting on food. It's reasonably priced and when we went was a slow period so the food didn't take long either. Their slices also reheat well. Parking at this location can be a pain too. This was my first time at this location and it did not disappoint. read more

See all

On Broadway delicious quick healthy pizza vegan options and full beer menu. Walk up window is helpful when you're running around town. They are located off the main drag and also in a residential area so bring the dog brings friends and split a pie! Walk run or bike accessible! read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - Vegan Pineapple pizza - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Online ordering was easy. Parking on Friday evening was difficult but was able to find a spot. The pizza was ready upon pickup. Order a variety of different pizzas and everyone agrees it taste just like a slice you'd grab if you were in NYC. read more

See all

Ordered our 1/2 & 1/2 pizza and a burger to go. The service was quick, pizza was huge, food was good. There's a Walk up window with some outdoor seating, it's a vibe, though I personally would not hang out there long. The Lights Out Burger was very good, though I'd like to see more smash in the smash burger - seemed more like a regular thin patty. Absolutely will be back! read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - Lights Out Burger - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

This place is pretty good. I'm a sucker for a good Caesar salad. I ended up getting a big slice of pizza as well as a Caesar then two drinks as well. All the food was good and the atmosphere is cool. Only down side I would say is that our food took FOREVER to come out. I think we had been there for an hour before we even got our food. Total of my meal came out to about $30 which is decent for a slice of pizza, a big salad, and two drinks. read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Extraordinarily overpriced. Wait time for a single pizza was almost an hour after ordering. Pizza was mediocre at best. Total for one pizza and 2 drinks was $70. Insane. Definitely do not recommend. read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - 26" with green peppers, onions, and garlic - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

If you are a fan of NY style pizza, Fat Sully's has some of the best in Colorado. If you are really hungry, they will make you a 26" pizza which is about the size of a manhole cover. This time we decided to get a 20" to go order with basil, onions, and mushrooms which was great. We really like how they oven roast their onions and green peppers before throwing them on the pie, it adds a little smoke flavor to the pizza. They can be really busy so go early or call ahead. read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - 20" pie - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

The pizza is great, but wings leave something to be desired. Not sure why they weren't given a sauce and they're pretty small. Next time I'll order a pie but skip the wings and salads. read more

Been coming here for years. For a long time, it was my one and only pizza place. But it has been a death by 1,000 paper cuts and I've slowly given Dough Counter more and more of my pizza $. It used to be that at Fat Sully's on the 1/2 and 1/2 20", if you got an ingredient on one half of the pizza, you paid half (i.e. Pepperoni was $3.25 on the whole pizza, $1.63 on half of the pizza). Seems like they changed that so whether you get a topping on 1/2 the pie or the whole pie, you pay $3.25. I called to ask about that and their guy said 'sorry, can't do anything about it - you can go somewhere else if you want.' Cool, I will.... AND they raised the prices of the veggies to be the same as the meat toppings. So our normal 1/2 and 1/2 pizza (pepperoni/mushroom and bacon/black olive) that used to be under $25 is now ~$35. No thanks. If you ever find me paying more for Fat Sully's than I'd have to pay for a superior Dough Counter pie, I'm probably wasted. Won't be coming back (unless I'm the aforementioned wasted + in need of pie + can't get a ride to Dough Counter). read more

A new go to! We were craving pizza one day and searching around to what we could order. Fat Sully's offered free delivery with no crazy fees, I was SHOCKED. For that alone, I would order from them again. They have classic thin crust pizza and it perfectly hit the spot. 10/10 recommend for your next delivery needs! read more

Great food! We enjoyed eating here! Pizza was hot fresh and delicious! Great list spot in Denver.

Update; they gave us a free pie to make up for it and it met expectations! We will be coming back. read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - Half cheese half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Biggest pizza I've ever had in my life. I could only eat one and a half slices and I'm stuffed. read more

See all

Their pizza Never disappoints!!! Great big 26" thin crust NY style pie with high quality toppings, my fav topping combo is mushrooms and pepperoni or pepperoni and fresh basil! Fast and friendly service. Pizza heats up great for leftovers next day too!! read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Absolutely amazing pizza! This place totally hits the spot. They have a large selection of toppings to pick from to customers your slice to perfection. The chipotle ranch is AMAZING. I order a side of it every time I get a slice. The service is pretty quick for making custom slices fresh. The walk up window is excellent when you're strolling down Broadway and want a slice on your way to find a beer at a local drinkery. Or, stop in and get a drink here! They have a full bar. The employees are always friendly and helpful. I've been coming here for years and the food continues to be consistent time after time. Don't change anything! read more

We door dashed this the other night. I ordered a cheese with only feta. Pizza arrived shortly thereafter. I took the first bite and thought to myself "omg this tastes JUST like NY pizza". We devoured the entire box. When I went to read the box, sure enough it said "Sully's NY pizza." Omg I will always order this pizza. They are open late and one of the only places in Denver that still serve food at 1am. read more

This is exceptional New York style pizza. This is by-far the best pizza I've had in Colorado. It's certainly a significant upgrade to Blackjack and Old Chicago from up in Greeley. The crust is cooked perfectly. I find the marinara sauce to be succulent and savory. The toppings were fresh and flavorful. The white mushrooms used were freshly sliced. I highly recommend stopping at this place on Broadway St. read more

See all

We went there for hamburger week, because their burgers got hide ratings. What a disappointment. The burger was very dry and tasteless. Since we went at lunchtime, I'm wondering if the burgers were left over from the night before and just reheated. read more

Outstanding service and good. The pizza is very good and huge. You have your be ready for it if you order the big one! read more

Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Broadway - A nice pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

absolutely horrible customer service, Paul the manager got the order wrong after trying to make up for a previous mistaken order on the past visit, then had one of his staff say I should be fine with what I got because it was free this time anyways because they messed up so bad the last time... terrible service 0/10 would not recommend read more

the service was lacking the person taking orders looked like he hates his job and rather have bamboo put under his finger nails than be there. After waiting for awhile heard someone call his name josh. Josh try and look a little more enthusiastic you were a real downer. read more

Fantastic pizza, so far this is the best I have found in Denver. They offer pizza by the big slice or an enormous New York style whole pizza. I love being able to buy a couple slices at the window outside customized how I want. I'm not sure why others have left poor reviews unless it's just the cost but that's the price of getting something delicious, people need to calm down. They are open super late and do not leave without getting chipotle ranch. As a regular degenerate pizza by the slice eater my suggestion is 1 chipotle ranch per big slice because if you are getting it with a significant other they will steal some of your sauce read more