Always biked past here on way home so thought I'd give it a shot. Burrito is huge - so amount is good, but if you're looking for flavor or they extra oomph, it's not here. Tasted okay but nothing special - Chipotle, sadly, has better flavor. read more

I lived in southern Cali for college and always missed a good simple fish taco. After ordering from here about a dozen times and trying everything on the menu, this is my hands down favorite place for fish taco and guac. The rest of the dishes are solid and OK, but personally, the fish tacos here ridiculous delish and addictive!!! I think about it at work and crave it on the way home. Highly recommend this place for a quick, fresh, delicious fish taco fix! read more

Chips and guac 5 out of 5 full of flavor Steak tacos tasted like the ones I had in San Diego - perfectly seasoned and cooked steak (5 out of 5) Didn't like the texture of the chicken taco so much Fiancé liked the grilled fish Would return and they deliver! read more

Amazing! As a native Californian I take my Mexican food VERY seriously and this place does it just right. I work nearby and usually get the lunch special of two very filling tacos and a drink for $10! The fish tacos are amazing and come with a special mayo based sauce that will fill you up. Not too many ingredients just fresh and yummy tacos. They make a burrito style bowl as well that will fill you up for a few meals a definitely recommend! read more

I've ordered from here a few times when I'm in a bind and need a quick Mexican fix. I really want to like their burritos, I really do, but the rice tastes very bland - think plain white takeout rice - and the cabbage/lettuce used throws the flavor profile off. For takeout, wrapping the burrito would also help maintain the "structural integrity" while you eat, instead of putting it in an aluminum tray like they do. I eat like a beast who doesn't know where his next meal is coming from, so it tends to fall apart as I get to the end. Their meats are pretty tasty though, and they have decent fresh ingredients. I've never had a greasy meal, and their extra meat offer gives you a burrito weighing in at just over a metric ton. read more

Really delicious tacos to go. Their tacos have some kind of green sauce and a good quantity of cilantro which makes them to special. I have had their tacos a few times for lunch and they are finger licking good! read more

My son came here with my sis and spoke highly of this place. So my husband and I had to try it out. Grilled steak and guacamole absolutely yummy. Prices were bad but the joint is small. ppl need not stay and eat here if claustrophobic. Did not check out the dessert menu cuz I was in a coma after dinner. Will come back! Oh and nice people work here. read more

These tacos are great for a quick bite. The fish tacos with the chipotle mayo is amazing. Make sure you get the lunch special. Just has a heads up the al pastor tacos have no pineapple. Please try all the tacos....great service read more

First and last time ordering from this place. Food is greasy and low quality. Guacamole is small, flavorless, and actually very small (plus I think is mostly done with some kind of avocado mix instead of real avocado). I ordered also a steak quesadilla that was just bad. I won't order from this place ever again. read more

Ordered: Steak taco and Mushroom taco Pros-- The tacos were made fresh to order and I liked the fact that they kept the ingredients simple. Cons-- The seating was very limited and packed together, making it an uncomfortable place to dine-in. Also, the taco shells were mediocre. read more

Tasty!! Al pastor quesadilla was delicious, delivery was early, and we would definitely order again.

Love the tacos here! Awesome fish tacos & spicy stewed chicken tacos. Decent prices & you get a lot of meat/veggies for the price. The place is rly small so better to take your food with you! read more

Went here as a suggestion from Grub Hub and I'm glad I did because it was the bizzzomb!! I ordered the lunch special, 3 fish tacos and a drink. The fish was nicely seasoned and meaty, no skimp there. I ordered gauc on 2 tacos and they didn't skimp there either. I practically scarfed dem tacos down, so I was surprised that I actually tasted them to even write this review. The price was definitely not bad at this place since I ordered two tacos with no guac or drink from another spot and the prices were close. It was delivered quickly and even though the food was a little cold, it wouldn't complain being that the delivery girl, was on a bike and it was like 27 degrees outside. So great that I can add another eatery to my list and the name is so cute and catchy!! read more

Awesome quick mexican. I had the stewed chicken burrito, chips and guac. Everything was so good. The chips had the right amount of salt. Portions are big. read more

Tacos are bomb - come here for the lunch combo if you're looking for a good deal. I usually order the chicken burrito with sour cream and guac, if I'm lucky enough for them to not mess up my order. Why do you break my heart Fatty Daddy?! It's hard to check if my order is correct until I bite into my burrito at home :( Why do I keep coming back if they keep messing up? It's just that good. On the bright side, I've gotten to try some different flavors/meats from their mistakes. Food is served quickly and with a smile! read more

I've had a limited experience with this place, but so far I haven't been disappointed - it's just above average (warrants 3.5 starts but rounds up to 4 and not down to 3). This place is essentially one notch above Chipotle. I say that with the understanding that I go to Chipotle for whatever you'd like to call their burritos and NOT for "Mexican" food. This place has the same kind of Chipotle-esque taste with ingredients that taste fresher and less mass produced. To be fair, I've only had burritos from here. I should probably try their namesake taco, but I'm picky with tacos and I'd rather not set myself up for disappointment. The burritos were solid each time. I like a packed burrito with rice and guac and lettuce and beans. Fatty Daddy does all of the above and pretty decently. I've had friends tell me they hate this place because they got things like the quesadilla and it was really greasy, but honestly - it's tons of cheese in between a tortilla. What more did you expect? Maybe one day I'll try something else on their menu to try, but for now when I'm in the mood for a solid burrito, I'll come here. (For tacos I'll be at Country Boys, but thanks), read more

Food is great, Space is limited... Surprised I was charged extra for sour cream that usually comes inside a Burrito.. read more

Fatty Daddy Taco - Fish tacos and chicken burritos. - Mexican Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

What a great find in Brooklyn. I was hungry for Mexican food and several places in the area are closed early on a Sunday. I was about to give up, but the smell of grilled steak caught my senses. Fatty Daddy is a small burrito/Taco place that serves humongous burritos and tasty tacos. There is very limited seating available inside and only street parking is at your disposal. They whip up your orders fresh and it doesn't take long either. The grilled steak burrito was huge in size. The steak was not dry at all. Same goes with the grilled chicken burrito. They were both delicious and satisfying. I will most definitely recommend them to everyone out there. read more

See all

Love love love. Can't describe how yummy their tacos is! The Only thing I dont like this place is that I can't bring the stroller in when I was working, because this place is so tiny. Not really for group to hang out, but it is good to catch a solo lunch. Btw, I know they have so many business and don't care about customer service, but one time they let me stood there for a least more then 5 mins... I know they are busy, so I didnt disturb them for a looong while. They had no eye contact with me or any sign to comfort me, so u know I need to order too... so I speak up and they shush me to give them a min..... this made me to take out a star from this place.... plus that night, I want fish tacos and they sold out of fish.... =( read more

Fatty Daddy Taco definitely runs by the name. First and foremost the place is immaculately clean!!! The workers are friendly and assist you with you taco needs. I decided to order a chicken stew burrito with some extra spice, and stay in to devour the burrito. Not only the cashier guy delivered the meal on the table but they also offered me hand sanitizer for my hands. Furthermore the burrito was ginormous and super delicious!!! I could not ask for more it was on the money. Will be back again when I am in the slope area. read more

Fatty Daddy Taco - Mexican Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Holly guacamole batman, tacos that taste non commercialized by corporate America. The best part they taste delicious. I had the fish taco that came with a spicy aioli sauce....yummy. the chicken taco took me back to Cancun. Nice to see an authentic place with original taste read more

See all

Amazing food, highly suggest letting the employee know of what you would like word for word. Missing out on a detail might leave you upset at what you didn't really want. (Ex. If you don't want beans, make sure you mention it that you don't) Other than that, the prices are fair and for what its worth, i rather go here than my local Chipotle. read more

Damn good tacos. I went there twice in one day. The services wasn't as quick the first time there was a crowd (as there should be) but the guys were nice. i had the burrito the second time around and it was delish!! They need a liquor license so they can serve beer and margaritas. IILL BE BACK!! read more

Average taco place. Ordered delivery from Seamless and got fish tacos, grilled chicken tacos, the chips with guacamole, and the chicken strips. The fish was a little oversalted, and the taco fillings barely had any flavor. The chicken strips were average and also ENORMOUS. Which would've been awesome of they were really delicious, but they weren't particularly. The guacamole was bland and the chips were thick and barely crispy. Also, my delivery came with zero sauce. No ketchup or barbecue sauce or anything. What do I eat my chicken strips with?? Maybe I'm just expecting too much. I would order again if I was starving and unwilling to leave the house, but only because the food is edible and I don't have many other options that aren't crazy expensive. read more

After the bf and I picked up some killer records (for cheap), our appetites were raging, a 2 hour peruse will do that to you, on top of a 5 mile walk. I spotted Fat Daddy a few months ago, with the intent to go in. Glad we did, incredible fish tacos and tostadas, on all counts, and the cooks are brilliant. They listen to substitutions and omit the stuff you do not need (mayo) Great Food, Cool Vibe, Great People. Can't wait for the next trip back read more

We really liked this place. Between the three of us, we had spicy stewed chicken and grilled steak (what they call the asada) burritos, and the stewed chicken, asada, and chorizo tacos. Both the steak and the stewed chicken were well seasoned. The chorizo taco was not dry like they sometimes are. Everything was delicious, down to flavorful tortillas. I'd rate these tacos with 5 stars even in San Diego. read more

Great tacos, got 3 al pastor with cotija cheese, my girlfriend got a portobello burrito, chips and guacamole, 1 jarrito, 1 diet Pepsi. All of it was really amazing. It was surprise when it cost $34 I would go back. read more

Fatty Daddy Taco - Tacos - Mexican Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I'm not sure why this place doesn't have a solid 4 or higher stars. Staff and Decor: Lovely! A little shop that makes you feel like you are in another place. The staff were friendly and helpful with suggestions. Food: We tried their chicken and beef tacos and the vegetarian tortilla soup. The soup was awesome! Piping hot, flavorful broth, chunks of veggies and of course plenty of tortillas. I didn't miss the meat, it stood on its own. Would totally order again. The tacos were very tasty as well! The tortilla was light and airy, the chicken seasoned well and yummy salsa sprinkled on top! The beef tacos were for my daughter, and while I enjoyed them...she was put off by the peas included in the mixture and it had a bit of heat to it. I enjoyed it though. I would order from here in a heartbeat and can't wait to try their other menu options! read more

I wish this place was closer to me. Get the tacos, forget everything else on the menu. Fish, steak or chicken, can't go wrong. In addition, you can get flour tortillas if you ask them, the default is corn. Only criticism I have is when the place is packed, they may forget ur order, so just remind them. Craving these tacos as I'm writing the review! read more

i cant even explain how much i love the fish taco they have in any language. i was here two weeks ago and i'm still thinking about it def def def highly recommend. this is my first time ever writing a review because thats how good they are omg. read more

Fatty Daddy Taco - Mexican Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Small place, looked inviting. The food was over priced. It was not authentic, more geared to "American" cuisine. It was worth a try, I didn't enjoy it so I wouldn't go here again. read more

Rude Staff. My dad called to place an order and was told they do not deliver to our location then they immediately hung up. He called again and they told me it was the wrong location. My dad asked for the other phone number and the man on the phone told him to Google it and hung up immediately once again. I called back and told him his behavior was rude and inappropriate and he conveniently had no idea what he had done. We have ordered many times from the Smith St location and have always had a lovely experience. I would NEVER again attempt to communicate with the 9th Street location. read more

Got a bunch of tacos delivered via takeout, and was pretty disappointed with the preparation, quality and flavor. All the tacos had those cheap, limp taco shells with kind of a fake corn taste. So right off the bat, you know they are cutting as many corners as possible, and that you're in for a real treat. While the sauces were decent, the steak and chicken options were far too overcooked, resulting in a rubbery, chewy meal. It was clear that no care was put into making this food. To top it off, when I called to politely let the restaurant know that we had a disappointing experience with the food, in an almost comic display of poor customer service, they proceeded to tell me that they "didn't know what to do with that information". Here's thought - try a little harder at making your food enjoyable to consume. At one point this place was good, but it has fallen far too low to be worth coming back. read more

If a "Chipotle burrito" stands as the absolute average for what one can do with that particular food choice, then I would have to put a Fatty Daddy burrito just under the mean. This isn't to say it's a bad option. However, it's not that good and I probably will never find myself going again. Perhaps the ingredients were a little stale, or the burrito-makers didn't really care that particular ten-minute stretch while they were preparing my food, but the meal was a bit too tasteless, plain, stale, etc -- whatever word you wish to fill in. Perhaps their executive chef has yet to find that perfect ingredient. I had the chicken. So maybe the fish options are better. It doesn't really matter. If you can't succeed with chicken, then why would the fish be different? This disappoints me because the two people at the counter were very friendly. Even as I left, the man who took my order asked me if everything had been good. Of course, I nodded and said that it was fine. I couldn't exactly fault him for how average the food was. He seemed extremely jolly and proud to work there (Or maybe he was super stoned?), and it seemed that it would be a bit too cruel to take him aside and explain why it wasn't up to par. There are many quick-serve burrito options that I would prefer to go out of my way for. Yes, none of them are in Park Slope. (There appears to be a considerable lack of either Mexican-Americans and/or Mexican-American culture in this neighborhood.) Granted, I'm not in Park Slope too often. Still, perhaps I would go out of my way up to Maya's on Vanderbilt Avenue if I found myself in the area and specifically wanted a Mexican Sandwich? Yes, I believe I would.) Frankly, despite the service, I cannot give this place anything more then two stars. It's a quick-stop establishment and if you can't deliver good food then what would be the point in returning? read more

Portobello burrito tasted like boiled peas and lacked any kind of fat - no cheese or avocado. I found a chunk of beef in my vegetarian tortilla soup. read more

Great food! Fast and tasty, the steak taco was a wonderful surprise not dry at all! My new favorite. The chicken was tasty to, and the Guac sauce on the tacos, Winning! This place is super small and easy to miss, Make sure you spot it cause you won't be sorry. read more

Super nice counter people. Space is a little tight. Large portion for a regular burrito. I wish they would figure out how to round it down to get it under $10.07 that returns a dollar full of change in my pocket. Seemed like the staff was handling a lot of requests and walk-ins easily and without getting flustered. Overall, it works if you happen to be in the area. read more

Great food... people that work here sucks though. Bad customer service/attitude/rude!!! Hire better people until then 3 stars for the food

I ordered a couple steak tacos the serving size was very little for the expensive pricing. I added Sour Cream and I was charged 1 dollar. Varrios 408 a few blocks away is better. read more

This was one of if not my favorite spots in Brooklyn a few years ago. unfortunately, the quality of food during my most recent trip wasnt great. I dont know if it was a one-time fluke not so Im not opposed to going again. read more