It felt so good to FINALLY find a place near home with great food and service. My daughter and I wanted pizza so I came on yelp and saw this place had great reviews. So I decided to give it a shot. I called in for pick up and the young lady who took my order was very helpful and polite. Food was AMAZING. We order a pie half pepperoni and it was soooo good. Chicken wings, buffalo sauce on the side as our daughter won't eat spicy stuff, but also because we like our wings crunchy. They were PERFECT. We also ordered mozzarella sticks in which I also loved and the marinara sauce was definitely good homemade quality sauce (I'm big on marinara sauce). We were all very happy and will definitely be ordering again. Plus they have a rewards point membership as so my husband says. read more

Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen - Two slices were already gone. My two slices have pepper flakes and I like mine well done so the crust is crispy. - Pizza Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Placed a delivery order for 9 pies in advanced to feed my hungry work crew. Pizza arrived perfectly 10 minutes before the boys went on break. Order was accurate, pizza was hot and most importantly DELICIOUS! Would order from them again. read more

Fantastic pizza reminds of New York style from my old neighborhood in New York .we have tried a few things from there menu everything is hot and fresh and delivered on time . The food is great you must try this place . read more

Just moved to Rutherford and this is the best Pizza place I have been to in awhile. They use great ingredients which most places don't anymore. The pizza comes out perfect. Crispy and cheesy. The staff is all super friendly and very welcoming. read more

See all

This place is a great choice for those looking for quality pizza. Restaurant is on the small side with only about four tables to choose from so a big party should definitely order their pies to go. Ordered the meatballs as an appetizer (recommended by the waitress-but were minimal in flavor , hence the reason for the dropped star ) Customer service was friendly and over all experience was great. Would cone back for sure. read more

This is my absolute favorite pizza place!! It is so much more than pizza though. Everything Ive ever order- Chicken dishes, Pasta dishes, Italian subs, salads, and desserts are always AMAZING!!!!! My favorite is the fried eggplant (pretty much on anything) and the cannolis!!! read more

See all

The place has great pizza and closes late. I had the pizza and meatball hero. The pizza was great and cheesy. The meatball parm was ok I wouldn't order it again. I feel they could add more to the menu. The employees are nice and friendly. For now just sticking with the pizza read more

Decided to give this place a try for their Christmas pizza. Honestly, pizza from a microwave is better. Taste like they use cheap ingredients. Surprised how many people actually gave this place 5 stars. Super super disappointing. Oh and they charged my card 3x for the order. read more

Worst pizza in the neighborhood. Simply put amature pizza from the dough to the sauce to the cheapest restaruant depot mozzarella. I ordered a Sicilian and the bottom was burnt and the cheese never got hot enough to bubble... So I tried I regular pie and found it was very lackluster as well. My 7 year old who loves Sicilian pie gave it a 4 out of 10... I was not as generous. We buy Sicilian pie from franchesca's in lyndhurst now and it's great, the guy there is a real Sicilian, and the pie tastes accordingly. (But they will take a while) P.S. the prices are garbage especially for the overcooked dry dough... they charge 18 for a pie and it is worth about 8.50 to 9 dollars in queens. If your Italian avoid this place at all costs you might have a melt down. read more

Excellent family restaurant! We catered from here in July for my son's birthday, and let me tell you - all my guests were raving about the food! Ordered a spicy chicken dish (not on the menu, but made especially to our liking by the brothers), fresh mozzarella, tomato & basil salad - bomb! And eggplant parmigiana. They did an amazing job, delivered it piping hot at the precise time we needed it and great pricing for so much food! Me, my husband and little boy frequent this place so much and tried so many dishes, they never disappoint, and the portions are great. My favs- chicken sorrentino, mussels with red sauce, shrimp salandra (HUGE shrimp!) and they have thee BEST vodka sauce ever! Must try the penne vodka! Nice casual restaurant perfect for kids too! read more

Pizza crust was like cardboard. Average pizza at best in my opinion. Possibly because I ordered reheated slices as the other reviews seem better? read more

Let me start this off by saying that I've had a lot of pizza, like drive 45 minutes away for it. This place was right in front of my parking spot and this was a "walk by, what the hell let's have a slice" type of experience. So we went in and were greeted by these two exceptionally sweet, nice guys! I cannot even begin to say how nice they were. Like not "I'm being fakely nice because I want your money" like legitimately nice guys!! The type of nice that is only naturally taught from a good family. So now the food. I needed 1 slice for the boy I babysit and there was 3/4 of a plain pie already sitting out on the counter. So I thought okay they'll warm it up and it will be tasty. But the guy said just hold on a minute, I have a fresh pie coming out in a minute. I was so amazed! The fact that he gave me a piece from a fresh pie when he could just have easily taken one of the cold ones and thrown it in the oven made me feel truly cared for. Not to mention, the boy I babysit is so unbelievably picky, like rips off the cheese picky and he ate it, steaming hot fresh out of the pizza oven, cheese and all. NOW THAT IS HIGH PRAISE, TRUST ME. We also ordered a slice of BBQ Chicken which was honestly to die for. Like I already made dinner at home to be warmed for later and I was contemplating whether or not to be like "screw it" and bring my boyfriend for dinner there tonight. On a side note, their garlic knots are the best I've ever had. I might think about them when I fall asleep tonight. Lastly, I paid by card $9.58 and I didn't get the talk about spending another 50 cents so they could meet their credit card limit. They also gave me a free ranch just incase I wanted some for either slice of pizza! Now that's service!! When I walked out, I walked out with a smile, more than happy to give them business. I will MOST DEFINITELY be coming back!!! read more

We enjoyed a late afternoon meal here on a Saturday. The Ferazzoli brothers all introduced themselves and made us feel like family right away. They brought us our menus and also offered to make us anything we wanted. The meal started off with a couple of bottles of Pellegrino water to compliment the bottle of red wine that we brought to enjoy in their chilled glasses. We were given complimentary garlic knots and a marinara sauce to start. The knots were warm and well seasoned and textured. The sauce was a perfect balance of fresh tasting tomato with aromatic seasoning that was neither too salty, too sweet, or too earthy. We also sampled a slice of pizza that had an expertly baked crust and also featured their tasty red sauce under melted mozzarella. Continuing the appetizer portion of the meal, we enjoyed green salads with tomatoes, olives, red onion, cucumbers, and croutons. The salad was seasoned nicely with a very light dressing, enough to stimulate the palate without being overwhelming. Additionally, we ordered escarole and bean soup which featured a delicate homestyle broth enveloping fresh, yet mild escarole and tender beans. By the time the main course came, we were nearly full but the beautifully presented, abundant dinners were enticing enough for us to continue eating. I enjoyed chicken sorrentino which featured tender chicken, eggplant, and mozzarella with a tantalizing sweet and smoky sauce. My wife enjoyed meatball parmigiana covered in slightly browned fresh mozzarella in a tomato and basil sauce. My sister-in-law had a delightful dish of chicken piccata over pasta with a zingy lemon and caper sauce. Her boyfriend had penne with vodka sauce that was the perfect balance of tomato and cream over al dente pasta. Grilled chicken was able to be added to his dish. As a group, we enjoyed more escarole, this time sautéed with garlic, specially made for us by the chef. The food was outstanding, but with full stomachs and good portions for the price, we were all able to take home leftovers. Ferazzoli's provides affordable food in a well-designed yet non-pretentious setting. They were just as happy to serve you a quick slice of pizza as they were to serve a full course meal. This is a great place for people of all ages and of all palates. In addition to great food for dining-in, you can get take out, get cold cuts by the pound at their deli counter, and order the delivery. Catering is available as well. read more

Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen - Contact info - Pizza Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Massive improvement over the clowns that originally opened in this location. Pizza is top notch and the guys here are friendly and genuinely give a shit that you walked into their restaurant. And they are actually Italian... Go figure. Give this place a shot. You won't be disappointed. read more

Hate to be posting this bc I always support local businesses especially in times like these however I just ordered from Ferazzoli's this afternoon and when I went to pick up the order NOBODY cooking the food was wearing a mask. The kid at the register had a mask pulled down so his nose and mouth were exposed. He pulled it up quickly when he saw me standing at the front. The guy in the back making pizza had no mask on. Really Ferazzoli's??? Would've thought you'd have more consideration for your local customers. read more

We originally planned to go to a nearby Chinese restaurant but we were diverted and ended here at Ferazzoli's. The servers were friendly, helpful and went the extra mile to make us happy. The food was fantastic. We had the chicken francese and the antipasto salad. Both were delicious. So glad we accidentally found this place! read more

I walked in expecting this to be a regular pizza place and was pleasantly surprised to see a full menu as well as some specials on the board. Since my first visit I have gone back 4 or 5 times and each one has been better than the last. The pizza and pinwheels are great, salads are fresh (and huge), and the lasagna special with homemade noodles was delicious. On top of the great food, the service couldn't be better. The guys that run the place always greet you with a warm welcome and always go out of their way to make sure you enjoyed your meal. It's great to see how much these guys care about this business and their customers. If you haven't tried Ferazzoli's yet, you are missing out! read more

The slices are delicious and don't not miss out on buffalo chicken slice or vodka penne. You know these are Italians bringing the home right to you! read more

See all

I LOVE this pizza! Let me start by saying pizza is not as simple as it seems, getting it right is not an easy feat. My husband and I have been searching for a good pizzeria for a long time! We finally found one in Rutherford... Ferazzoli's, at just a year old, they are doing it right! We discovered it last week and have eaten there twice since. We started with complimentary toasty, buttery and pillowy soft garlic knots served with tomato gravy. Then we each ordered a personal pizza. And let me tell you there are a lot to choose from or ask them to make it your way! The crust is thin and the edges are so crunchy. The sauce is sweet the toppings are excellent and baked to perfection. But there is more... Excellent espresso and then there are the Nutella pinwheels to die for. So next time you need are craving pizza head to Ferazzoli's! read more

Got 5 pizzas last night. We picked them up to go. They were delicious! The crust was light-not chewy. The sauce and cheese were top-notch. The pepperoni had the right amount of spice. While we were waiting, we were given a Pepperoni Pinwheel to sample. I had never had one or even heard of this. It came with a side of Marinara for dipping-what a treat! I would highly recommend the pizza at Ferazzoli's! read more

Best Italian food ever!! Great owners that take care of their customers. Love their eggplant parm! Best I've ever had! Right down to the salad. Everything I've ordered is delicious. So happy they have arrived!!!!! read more

I don't know Rutherford very well but I knew I could rely on my Yelpers to help me decide where to take a 4 and 5 year old for a little inpromptu birthday dinner. I missed my God daughters bday party so I picked her and her sister up to hang a bit. Of course the first thing the 4yr old says she wants is mussels ( what kinda kid request mussels? Lol ). Just when i deemed the little one high maintenance the 5 yr old imformed me there was a sushi place not too far (these kids live GOOD lol Dad is a Chef so thats prob why ) I asked for a second choice and they both yelled out pizza . ( Thank God haha) . This is where my yelp peeps said was the best and they were RIGHT. The pizza is BOMB ! Crispy just like I like it, the sauce was not too bland OR too seasoned what I would call a perfect canvas . The place was pretty empty but it was a Monday so maybe that's typical. Upon entry the staff was very friendly and the pizza did not disappoint. Perhaps because it was so empty in there they only had us to concentrate on because they asked every 2 mins if we were ok. I rather be over asked than ignored though. The guy (presumably owner) definitely inquired about where we were from I hope it was only because he sensed we were first timers and not because he was trying to size me up (When people randomly ask me where I'm from it can sometimes be a loaded question solely based on appearance !!! ) .Anywho! They did give the kiddies some complimentary cookies so all was well. Overall Good pizza, and when in the area next I will return and order from their Italian kitchen. read more

Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen - Nice and crispy slice mmmm - Pizza Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Was looking for a place to have a quick bite with friends after an event we Becton Regional so we came here. Delicious food and accommodating staff in the small dining area. The salads were fresh and the pizza was great. I wish this was my neighborhood joint. read more

The service from the 3 brothers was impeccable. They were so attentive and friendly, it really made me want to like this place more. However, the pizza slice was not as crispy as I like and the sauce was a little sweet for my husband. The antipasto salad was a good portion, but just okay. I had the chicken parm with penne vodka on the side which was really good. My husband's favorite was the pepperoni pinwheel. Because of the good service, I'm willing to give them another shot, especially because they say that they deliver cold cuts! read more

It's amazing!!! This is my favorite pizza place in town. Their marinara sauce could only be described as genius. This place has become our Sunday funday take out day. The three brothers are super friendly and always make you feel welcome. Keep it up, mark Matt and Mario. Great Job!!! read more

Saw that Ferazolli's had 4-1/2 stars and 176 reviews so taht was enough to motivate me to visit. Icame for pizza, that's all. Been to numerous piizerias throughout northern Jersey and so I am always looking for that 5-star place and although Ferazolli's was not bad it wasn't a 5-star either. I rate it a 3-1/2 and by no means is that bad, just a little above average in my book. read more

The best! Always consistent food, excellent service and fresh made to order dishes! Can't go wrong with anything on the menu and love the Nutella slices! read more

Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen - Just had an amazing lunch! Great way to celebrate! - Pizza Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Great pizza and the meatballs are just like the ones I make at home . I will be back everytime I am out rhis way. read more

Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Alright! I just moved into the neighborhood and was just for a new pizza joint to make our go-to-place. Glad I landed on Ferazzoli's! We ordered two pies, and both were absolutely perfect. The dough was not too thick, not too thin, literally just perfect. The toppings were top notch, the sauce was very good and the cheese was the perfect amount. Will definitely be ordering from here again, curious to try some of there other dishes. read more

The food is great and I used to love this place! Ordered from there tonight and the employees and other customers were not wearing masks. When asked why no one was wearing masks, the employee said she and the restaurant were "over it". Not a fan of this attitude read more

The grandma's vodka is unreal!!!! Great local neighborhood spot for take out and delivery of pizzas and sandwiches.

My fiancé and I ordered two dinners from here for delivery. The food was fine. The issue I have is ordering at 6:53pm and getting the food at 9:20pm. We patiently waited but at 8:15 called the restaurant and was told on the phone the food was on the way. Keep in mind we live about 15 min from the restaurant. 8:45 comes along and the food is still not here. I called again and the women working assured me the food was on the way. I know it's a Friday night and they were probably busy but the lack of communication is just completely unacceptable to me. If they had let us know it was going to be longer delivery than usual I would have just gone to pick it up. The only apologetic person throughout the entire process was the person delivering the food. To be honest I definitely will not be ordering from here anymore. Horrible experience. read more

As a pizza nut, I definitely had to try this place after seeing the glowing reviews after just opening. We ordered one plain round pie and two slices of white pie. The service here so far is stellar. When calling for the pick-up order, I asked if they had any white slices and they were courteous enough to make a fresh pie and cut two slices for me! Keep in mind this wasn't exactly early in the day where they were guaranteed to sell the rest of the slices. How often does a pizza place do that for a first time customer?? They were also very nice when we went to pick up the order. Now onto the food. The regular plain cheese pizza was just decent at best. One positive was the sauce-to-cheese ratio was spot on, but the flavor did not stand out to me. The white cheese slices were solid, and this is what I would recommend if you were to come here. The main issue with both pizzas was the pizza dough. It quite frankly tasted like a frozen pizza dough, which really turned me off. Perhaps if they change their bread and pizza dough I would consider going back for that white pie, because the cheese was nice and promising. read more

Prob the best garlic knots in JERSEY!!! They were so fresh, tasty, and were perfectly soft on the outside and crispy on the outside. We had a family special which was well priced and fed us all. The chicken parm was yummy and the portions were very generous. Finally, most staff appeared to be high school students but ALL were VERY nice and attentive. read more

Wonderful place to grab a bite to eat! The staff (the owners I think) were friendly and helpful. Went there for a late lunch on Sunday and street parking was available. Kid friendly place, they even found a movie for my son to watch. We ordered a whole pie, half plain and half meat-lovers... go good!! It wasn't soggy and the ingredients were fresh. Will definitely go back and try other items from their menu. read more

Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen - Half regular and half meat lovers pie. - Pizza Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Ferazzoli's is an absolute landmark in Rutherford. It is a must have! The employees and the three brothers that own it are always very kind. Their pizza slices are very unique (chicken bacon ranch, french fry and chicken, penne vodka slice, and more). In addition, their soups and salads are delicious and inviting. It's a great place to stop by for a quick bite to eat or to order for a party. Always a crowd pleaser at parties. read more

I can't believe it took me so long to find such a good italian restaurant / pizzeria. After multiple visits they finally started making a salad pie with whatever salad I wanted and it was delicious. I wouldn't look anywhere else for my go-to pizzeria. read more

Ferazzoli's Italian Kitchen - The salad pie is delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

This place is great! Excellent quality food and customer service. I ordered to Metlife stadium and the person on the phone was very patient when I gave him specific instructions and directions. I ordered the nutella pizza with vanilla sauce and crushed oreos. AH-MAZING! I would definitely recommend Ferazzoli Italian Kitchen. read more

Im from Ohio, we decided to stop and get pizza, on the way back to our hotel. Let Me tell you, we made a great choice in going here! Their pizza is great and their baked ziti was AMAZING, loaded with cheese. I'd definitely recommend stopping in, even just to buy a slice! The establishment was clean and cozy and they were very friendly and welcoming. Thank you! read more

Meat lovers pizza!!! Delicious!!! I will definitely order again and try different items on the menu!!