The food is so good here The manager Anna is amazing at her…read morejob your very lucky to have her Can't wait until delivery starts. You guys will definitely be on our lunch list.

Tried this place out, as I was intrigued while in Humboldt. As someone who has eaten way too much…read moreNY pizza when in the city, I wanted to give it a try. Got a slice, but it was expensive. Slice was alright. Wasn't anything crazy, for the all meat. We also ordered a pie to eat, choosing a classic pep so we could try compare it to a NY style one. I was pleasantly impressed. It had thin and supple dough, robust enough for folding slices in half. Crust was thin style and had the crisp. It was really greasy, and the flavor was reminiscent more of NY than I expected. Was it a perfect NY slice? No, but it brought me further east than California. Best to eat it warm and heat it up. The cold version of the slice wasnt reminiscent of cold NY pizza I've had in the city. When hot, an interesting effort at doing NY style. It was just lacking an extra oomph that would make it 5. For those with extra pizza, I'd strongly recommend heating it up rather than eating it cold. I say that, even though I'm a big supporter of cold pizza. This pie needs to be warm.

So this place is always packed opens at 3 PM because you know people don't want pizza at lunch,…read morewhat kind of psychopath would want pizza at lunchtime you know. The normal wait time for a pizza here is one to two hours, sometimes even three hours to get a pizza to go. This last visit it was a two hour wait so what I did was pay damn near double and just buy eight slices of the pizzas that were made to be reheated. Instead of paying about 30 bucks for a pizza I ended up paying over $50. That's not even what the complaint is about the cashier was about to give us eight plates for eight slices of pizza when I wanted to take my pizza home. While we were waiting my friend and I got two beers and we were finishing our beers. While we're drinking, our beers here comes the pizza and two small pizza boxes. When the person giving us our pizza boxes saw us drinking our beers he asked do you want me to keep these pizza boxes in the warmer to which my friend and I both replied no thank you we're going to eat some. To which the worker responded extremely rudely and unprovoked wow if you're going to eat it here why would you waste the boxes? Maybe because my friend and I don't wanna eat a whole pizza. We don't wanna wait two hours for you guys to bake a pizza that takes 10 minutes to bake. Maybe if you guys weren't so slow. We could've ordered a normal pizza and got a normal pizza box. Or maybe we should've just got eight plates for eight slices of pizza and juggle them the out of the store to please you guys?... the dude was an absolutely rude, you act as if we're stealing from your children's mouth because we got two to go boxes for eight slices of pizza? I wish I could use the choice words I want to use to describe that worker but yelp will just take the review down. I immediately lost my appetite after the person was so blatantly rude in front of all the other customers. Seriously what is wrong with your employee there what is his issue? The place is constantly packed like a sardine can you cant move around or even sit. The only reason I tolerate the horribly crowded chaotic atmosphere is because their pies are decent, but theyre not decent enough to be belittled and talked down to like a theif for getting two to go boxes from the cashier, the guy was literally pissed off that we were taking up seats in the store and had the audacity to have to go boxes. If you're that upset or worried about people occupying your store, maybe buy yourselves a bigger location or rent a larger location instead of making your customers feel so unwelcome. Or better yet dont hire A holes to work for you and make your customers feel welcome. I loved headies pizza but I wont come back and ill tell everyone about how rude your employee was and it being the reason I refuse to be a patron any longer. DO BETTER. EDUCATE YOUR EMPLOYEES ON HOW TO PROPERLY TREAT YOUR CUSTOMERS. To dump on someone over 2 to go boxes, get yourself a horrible review is pathetic... i guess 8 paper plates woulda been the more eco friendly choice.... Or is it the money your business is so concerned about losing? Maybe if you're struggling so hard to provide to go boxes to your customers, you should charge people for to go boxes. That way you don't have to verbally abuse me in front of other customers when I come to eat some food. Its not my problem anymore as again I wont be coming back. 60 dollars and a 15 percent tip to be defecated on by your worker over some to go boxes. What a fabulous dining experience....

Really pleasantly surprised by this pizza spot!…read more We were coming down from the Redwoods and saw this place on Yelp. Thankfully, we decided to call an hour ahead. The wait was around 1 hr 15 min when we called around 6 PM, which gave us enough time to check in to our Airbnb and grab some groceries next door. We ordered the Garden Grove vegan pizza. It was my first time trying a vegan pizza, and I thought it was delicious. The pizza was hot when we arrived, the crust was thin, pizza was loaded with toppings, and was flavorful and filling. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Would recommend ordering out as there is little space inside for dining in. Would definitely recommend and come again.

Aaaah! Best pizza EVER! Try today!!!…read more Drop by take her home or have delivered! . I've had MM at two locations!

Yum, the Vegetarian Spicy Himalayan Pizza is SO good. Nice atmosphere for dine in, everyone working…read morehere is always really fast and friendly. Great local pizza place feel with top notch food.

Great pizza. Got a nice crispy crust even with a gluten-free crust…read more Quick service. Nice back patio among the trees. No notes, 5/5.

Do yourself a favor and stop over for a meal at this delicious local spot…read more We tried a bit of everything and came away satisfied. The panini was excellent. The pizza was excellent. The pulled pork was delicious. The service was warm, kind, and homey. The atmosphere was one part cozy cafe, one part DIY and we were loving it.

This is the best pizza I've ever had!! Love this place! Super cute area, kind staff, the pizza…read morequality is to die for! Came here 2 years ago on a rd trip and knew I had to come back when I was staying shelter cove again! Thank you always!

Excellent pizza and homemade soups. We got a cheese-free pizza for our lactose-intolerant guest…read more And they were out of the Hungarian Mushroom soup!! Other members of our party got the boneless chicken wings and a salad. No complaints from anybody. It's great to have such a wonderful, reliable place in a remote town like Shelter Cove!! I made sure there were no leftovers and slept like a baby after gorging on the last piece. Hallelujah Delgada!!

Smashburger recipe seems to have been changed, long island ice teas have chnage... think it might…read morebe under new ownership.... needs to get back to original recipes

First time here in about 1 1/2 years. Did the $24 special which was filet mignon over garlic mashed…read morepotatoes with a mushroom sage cream sauce. Included a glass of wine, soup or salad, and Jersey Scoops ice cream for dessert. Server was very friendly and food was very good. Would recommend for locals and visitors alike.

Our family visited the Eureka area this week, and on our drive back home, we decided to follow the…read moreAvenue of the Giants. If you have the time and you are in the area, I would not skip it. It's amazing! While we were going through, we decided to stop for lunch and stopped in at the Avenue Cafe. What a great experience! The food was great and the staff made us feel welcomed. When we arrived, we walked in the front door and found it packed. So packed, in fact, that we had to eat at their outside tables. We chose the fully outside table (versus under the cover) and found that it was a mistake...when it started raining on us. Trisha didn't even mind that we resat ourselves in the covered area. We will definitely stop there again even when we don't drive the Ave itself...the food and service was that good!

Excellent food! Stunning redwood theme throughout the restaurant. Super friendly staff! I really…read moreappreciate being able to sit and watch the pizza being made while sipping local craft cider and watching the game on tv. The ingredients are consistently fresh and the dough is from scratch! Even when the place is packed we still get our order in a timely manner and made exactly the way I wanted. Ten stars!

My husband and I were on a road trip and staying in Eureka for the night and decided to eat here…read morefor dinner, which also happened to fall on Father's Day. The place was pretty busy at 8pm and we sat outside since we had our pup with us. I ordered 3 oysters as an app. I had just read that Humboldt Bay provided a large percentage of the oysters consumed in CA and NV so figured I should order some since we're so close to the source! I was surprised when I slurped it down and it was warm but they were delicious and the sauce on top was very flavorful. (That was my fault for not reading the description well enough; I'm just accustomed to eating oysters chilled) For entree's, I went with the Polenta Veghie lasagna and my husband ordered the Italian Mac n cheese. Both dishes were very good and very filling. I loved the crust of the polenta and the eggplant and cheese filling was delicious. The staff was very friendly and helpful and I was impressed with the coziness and warmth of the interior. Great spot for dinner, I'm glad I chose this restaurant!

I was visiting Eureka and decided to check this place out. So glad I was able to try this…read morerestaurant and the delicious food they serve. My wife and I ordered the Italian Mac and cheese, beef bolognese, seafood soup (almost like a cioppino) of the day , and mushroom cobbler. All dishes were amazing and so flavorful. It was hard to pick a favorite but the beef bolognese and soup stood out to me. Our servers were so delightful and incredibly friendly. The ambience is great too; lively and homey. If I am back in town this is the first place I am coming back to. I wish I had this exact restaurant in my area!

Every thing was perfect. Great company, service, food and…read moredrink. It's a brewery with a restaurant it should be great right? It was. Super crunchy fish and chips with what I think was house made tartar sauce and cocktail sauce with a good bite of horseradish. Sitting outside was cool but the propane heaters made it pretty cozy. Service was engaging and enjoyable... nice. Every one enjoyed their food without a single gripe. Last word... returning.

So I had to post an update. We just finished a grueling drive. We were starving and it was 9:30pm…read more Eel River was a logistical choice. Our service was 5 star which helped since we were exhausted. I have a super strong recommendation for the Cali 101 sandwich. It might be one of the sandwiches I've ever had. The fried parmesan on the tops of the bread sealed the deal. My wife asked for a custom burger. Mind you, the kitchen was closing but chef pulled off a beautiful dish. I don't normally photo food but wish I did. My wife goes bun-less and they served the dish on a bed of spinach (which she requested and they had to dig for it). To do all that as the kitchen is closing says something. They could have just thrown it on top. I am completely stealing that one. I love amber ale and they make a good one. I hope we can squeeze one last visit in before we leave.

Tasty pizza. Fresh salad bar. Great service. What's not to love?…read more I understand there are pizza preferences. Babe's is medium-thick crust, perfectly baked, topped with just the right amount of cheese and speciality toppings, flame broiled to melt and lightly toast the cheese. You won't need a pack of napkins to eat one slice, and the toppings will stay aboard the whole time. Plus it's delicious.

My son was craving pizza and pasta for dinner so I found this place on Yelp. It's located in a…read moreresidential neighborhood away from the main business streets, but kind of near the local zoo. Babe's gives me mom and pop Shakey's vibes. There's a big party room for meetings or parties, and a game room with arcade games off to the side - accessible by stairs only so my son couldn't go in. In addition to pizza and pasta, they have sandwiches, calzones, and a fresh salad bar, not a ton of toppings but enough of everything I like to make me happy. My family and I ordered a large pizza w/ half sizzling bbq chicken & half Babe's Combo, a spaghetti and AYCE salad bar. The pizza was amazing, I loved the bbq chicken and the crust was super yum. Even my husband commented that the pizza was good and he doesn't usually make comments about pizza unless it's really bad. However, the spaghetti was missing some salt/herbs so it was bland for my personal taste. Salad ingredients were fresh, and I went back about 3 times as my family kept wanting more. The best part about Babe's was the people working here. Everyone was nice, but especially the lady who took my order, she was so so nice! Actually honestly, everyone I've come across in Eureka has been so friendly and kind, from the gas station, to the Target...it's been a great experience interacting with the people here. But the lady at Babe's just made my day, and unfortunately I didn't catch her name, but Babe's is so lucky to have her! There needs to be more Eureka kindness in this world.