Their pizza left me dreaming about the leftovers the follow day. That says something. Excellent find for us while visiting Trinidad!

So this place is always packed opens at 3 PM because you know people don't want pizza at lunch, what kind of psychopath would want pizza at lunchtime you know. The normal wait time for a pizza here is one to two hours, sometimes even three hours to get a pizza to go. This last visit it was a two hour wait so what I did was pay damn near double and just buy eight slices of the pizzas that were made to be reheated. Instead of paying about 30 bucks for a pizza I ended up paying over $50. That's not even what the complaint is about the cashier was about to give us eight plates for eight slices of pizza when I wanted to take my pizza home. While we were waiting my friend and I got two beers and we were finishing our beers. While we're drinking, our beers here comes the pizza and two small pizza boxes. When the person giving us our pizza boxes saw us drinking our beers he asked do you want me to keep these pizza boxes in the warmer to which my friend and I both replied no thank you we're going to eat some. To which the worker responded extremely rudely and unprovoked wow if you're going to eat it here why would you waste the boxes? Maybe because my friend and I don't wanna eat a whole pizza. We don't wanna wait two hours for you guys to bake a pizza that takes 10 minutes to bake. Maybe if you guys weren't so slow. We could've ordered a normal pizza and got a normal pizza box. Or maybe we should've just got eight plates for eight slices of pizza and juggle them the out of the store to please you guys?... the dude was an absolutely rude, you act as if we're stealing from your children's mouth because we got two to go boxes for eight slices of pizza? I wish I could use the choice words I want to use to describe that worker but yelp will just take the review down. I immediately lost my appetite after the person was so blatantly rude in front of all the other customers. Seriously what is wrong with your employee there what is his issue? The place is constantly packed like a sardine can you cant move around or even sit. The only reason I tolerate the horribly crowded chaotic atmosphere is because their pies are decent, but theyre not decent enough to be belittled and talked down to like a theif for getting two to go boxes from the cashier, the guy was literally pissed off that we were taking up seats in the store and had the audacity to have to go boxes. If you're that upset or worried about people occupying your store, maybe buy yourselves a bigger location or rent a larger location instead of making your customers feel so unwelcome. Or better yet dont hire A holes to work for you and make your customers feel welcome. I loved headies pizza but I wont come back and ill tell everyone about how rude your employee was and it being the reason I refuse to be a patron any longer. DO BETTER. EDUCATE YOUR EMPLOYEES ON HOW TO PROPERLY TREAT YOUR CUSTOMERS. To dump on someone over 2 to go boxes, get yourself a horrible review is pathetic... i guess 8 paper plates woulda been the more eco friendly choice.... Or is it the money your business is so concerned about losing? Maybe if you're struggling so hard to provide to go boxes to your customers, you should charge people for to go boxes. That way you don't have to verbally abuse me in front of other customers when I come to eat some food. Its not my problem anymore as again I wont be coming back. 60 dollars and a 15 percent tip to be defecated on by your worker over some to go boxes. What a fabulous dining experience.... read more

Waited for our pizza for 1.5 hrs, and it was a mediocre one! No, I wouldn't recommend this place!

Really pleasantly surprised by this pizza spot! We were coming down from the Redwoods and saw this place on Yelp. Thankfully, we decided to call an hour ahead. The wait was around 1 hr 15 min when we called around 6 PM, which gave us enough time to check in to our Airbnb and grab some groceries next door. We ordered the Garden Grove vegan pizza. It was my first time trying a vegan pizza, and I thought it was delicious. The pizza was hot when we arrived, the crust was thin, pizza was loaded with toppings, and was flavorful and filling. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Would recommend ordering out as there is little space inside for dining in. Would definitely recommend and come again. read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

See all

Calling ahead wins the day! Our family came from out of town and were looking for a good bite to eat on the beach at sunset. Having been to Headie's before, we knew that they have delicious pizza. We ordered the Trinity and the Club along with some sides of ranch and the hot honey. We rode on down to Trinidad beach to watch the sun go down. I tell you, nothing beats hot pizza at sunset on the beach! read more

My wife and I picked up a pepperoni pizza with black olives and garlic knots. Being from the east coast, the crust was a bit thinner than we are used to and the cheese was a bit less, but we both agreed it was a good pizza. The garlic knots were quite good. Both were improved with a bit of salt being added. read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Pepperoni pizza with black olives - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

See all

Wonderful, all of it. The staff was great, helpful and the pizza was even better. Solid choice.

During our trip to the Redwoods, we decided to stop somewhere for food and I can confidentially say that stopping at Headies was the BEST choice we've made. The cashier there was really nice and also gave us great recommendations. I even discovered a new favorite cider to go along with my pizza. And the place was so good, we even visited there twice! It's impossible to leave leftovers when the slices are so good. City of Trinidad...you surprised me! read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

See all

Some of the best I have had. Dough made in house, fresh and made to order. Called in around 5 and was ready by 630 so plan ahead they get busy. I have had pizza all over the world. read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Dub pep add sausage well done. - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

See all

The pizza was good considering where you are and what is available. We did a build your own with multiple toppings. They were all fresh and tasted delicious. The customer service was amazing from taking the order to accepting our payment. The ambiance, l cannot speak on as it was a To Go order. read more

Best pizza I've found since moving to the west coast, easily the best pizza in NorCal!!

This is some of the best NJ pizza I have had on the west coast and if you have read any of my other posts on pie you know I usually get it plane. My motto is if you can't make a good cheese pie, then anything you put on it is just making up for bad or mediocre pizza. This place needs no toppings and we will defiantly be back. The service was helpful and atmosphere is small with only a few tables so best to plan on taking it to go. The sell pies by the slice or whole and only make 16" to go. read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Dripping with flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

Delicious pizza and amazing service! Thank you for accommodating our allergy requests.

Loved grabbing dinner here during our trip to Redwoods National Park. Everyone was so friendly and the pizza was great! We tried a Club, Trinity, and Bonfire and all were excellent. The cashier even gave us helpful beach recommendations for where to take our 17 month old daughter! Thanks for the excellent service. read more

See all

We've been known to time our outings just to catch Headies Pizza for a couple slices during their hours. They open at 3 and for a bonus, it's also Happy Hour for a buck off each slice! So that's our goal when we're hungry for real hand crafted pizza. The pizza is the most delicious, hands down. The crust is tasty, hot, bubbly, and thin which I prefer. A perfect portion of a delicious red sauce permeates your senses. The toppings are fresh, the cheese is gooey; there's an ample amount of everything good in this pizza. There aren't so many choices that it's overwhelming. Just enough choices to leave a lasting impression. The staff is friendly, the service is quick. Although it's small, we've always had a clean table. I recommend it to anyone, lover of pizza or not. It's that good! read more

BEST PIZZA IN HUMBOLDT COUNTY PERIOD. Never gets old! Great dipping sauces as well like hot honey ranch ;)

Absolutely loved this little pizza joint! We waited a bit for them to open at 3pm.. But while we were waiting we chatted with a local who assured us it was worth the wait. Then they put the special slices of the day in the window and quickly we knew we wanted the wookie and the luau. It's tiny inside, maybe seating for 12 people, but most people get their pizza to go. We ordered the wookie and the luau slices and they were so good we ordered a cheese and a pepperoni too. You can tell they put quality ingredients and love in every piece of pizza.. and yes it was worth the wait. read more

See all

I got two larges, the Trinity (all meat) and the veggie. In my opinion, not sure why people gave it 5 stars but I thought the pizza was just ok. Nothing stood out, the veggie was not good at all and the all meat was good. Didn't have a ton of flavor. Was a little disappointed but that's just one opinion. read more

Talk about some tasty pizza and everybody working there was awesome. It's a super small place but we were able to get a table and enjoy a beer while waiting for our pizza. Would absolutely eat there again when we come back to the Redwoods read more

Stopped in while visiting the area for the first time. Staff was super friendly and kind. The place is small but we managed to find a table. Wait time was long, but it worked for us. I can see how takeout might be the way to go! Pizza and garlic knots came out nice and hot!! Only wish that the pizza came in more than one size - we had way too much for leftovers...and found the pizza tasted better the day of. read more

We came up here on a mini-vaca to see the redwoods and do some hiking, super happy when we saw a sign that said "pizza" headed over there and we were amazed at how good the pizza was.! Absolutely to die for and highly recommend and take advantage of their single slices as well.! We r during the off season so no line, but spring and summer good luck.! Still a must have in Trinidad read more

We love Headies, consistent good pizza, wine and great service. I know owned by same people as Lighthouse, but for whatever reason this place is working. Lighthouse is not. read more

The place is "okay" but NOT worth the wait. We only go there in a pinch. The chicken is tasteless, not sure what to say without totally hating on them. Good luck- read more

We ordered a pepperoni pizza with hot honey last night and it was delicious!!! The hot honey ranch tasted like honey mustard that we got on the side. Would have preferred just regular ranch but the pizza was so good!! Lucky for us we for the last dough ball of the night! read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Pepperoni pizza with hot honey - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

See all

We really liked the salad with the Fig Balsamic Vinaigrette but we didn't like the pizza, a, "Simply Vegan with red sauce: artichoke, red onion, black olive, basil, vegan mozzarella on an olive oil, garlic & herb base". The pizza was supposed to have artichoke but we there were barely any parts of artichoke at all. They said they couldn't do 'no onions', had to take it 'as is'. The pizza was lacking flavor, freshness, and veggies. It smelled up our car and then later, our hotel room. Why was it so stinky!?!! That salad, though.... YUM! read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - vegan pizza... didn't like - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

See all

Yummy pizza in this tiny town or Trinidad, the inside of the building and seating area is a bit small, They have pizza by the slice and whole pizzas, they also have a few drinks on tap and some in cans and bottles. They cook the pizza in a oven and its yummy!! read more

Came here for pizza while on a weekend bike ride. Ordered by the slice - two margherita, one pepperoni, and one special (forget what was on it but I think artichoke?). Each slide was better than the last. Very tasty and soft, doughy crust that makes your mouth water. Food was fairly priced, prepared quickly, and the cashier was extremely friendly. Would recommend Headies Pizza & Pour! read more

I really didn't want to do this, but .... we have a party of 7 and enter at 8:30 (they close at 9 ) , we were informed they wouldn't make anymore new pizzas but we could order by the slice already made (who knows how long they'd been there ) , we were hungry so that's what we ordered plus a couple beers- all going well up until now (I wasn't happy about not having a fresh pizza but still woulda been a positive review up until .... ) we get the reheated slices and gotta admit - they were very good ( plus we were hungry) ! 8:55 my cousin orders another beer and a guy comes from the back and tells our server that no more beer was to be served , ok still on the positive star rating , 8:58 the lady that reheats the pizza (cook? Owner ? ) comes to our table and says 9pm is a hard close and that they've been here since 1pm so we need to leave at 9pm on the dot , I had not finished my slice yet so how do you think I/we felt ? In other words, scarf down your food or else ! My family owned restaurants, and I can tell you this is not how you treat customers . You've been there since 1pm and now it's 9pm ? Oh wow ! A whole 8 hours ??? Oh my !!! You coulda handled this differently- I woulda respected you saying at 8:30 we'll be closing our doors and you'll need to leave then , not be notified 2 minutes before 9 with food still on our plates that we need to go ! So, to my fellow travelers , if you are hungry after 8pm - this is not the place to go, but to be honest if you're hungry at earlier hours you'll have a pretty good slice here . And this folks is how a 4+ star establishment becomes a 1 star in my eyes . read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

This little pizza shop is a good stop for pizza. We stopped after a long day of hiking and the need for some food. Despite calling multiple times with a busy signal we just stopped by. Luckily we got our order is but had to wait 30 mins. The good part was it was well worth the wait. We went with the half margarita pizza and half wookie...( cause why not) ! The had the wookie with the red sauce but overall a good NY style pizza. Good thin crust with a nice taste. Here the thing... we also got a salad ... and OMG this was a big surprise as it was amazing. Loaded some really great tomatoes, pine nuts, pumpkin seeds, black olives and more. The lettuce was a nice array mix greens ... honestly an amazing salad and a large serving . I would definitely recommend stopping here for some good food. The wait was a bit of a drag which would have been easier if I could have called my order in. Otherwise would have been 5 stars. read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Half margarita and half wookie with red sauce - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

See all

Pizza was mid but more importantly, everyone that works there is severely unhappy and unpleasant, especially the big boy in the back that brings out the pizza. Learn some people skills dude read more

the people there were really nice ! pitcher of beer is always a plus. the pizza was okay not the best but decent

Amazing East coast style pizza! My husband and I are from Pennsylvania and Virginia respectively. We struggle to find good pizza on the West coast. Imagine our surprise to find it in Trinidad, CA! Staff is super nice and accommodating. Prepare to wait for a fresh pie. You can sit in your car and they'll bring it out when it's ready. read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Old growth - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

Bbq Chicken Pizza was incredible!!! The best ... We called the order they had it ready for us 45 minutes..... Soo Sooo good read more

Super solid pizza place! Ordered an 18" half plain cheese half ricotta roni pizza ahead of time for takeout. They quoted me 25 minutes and sure enough, when I walked in 25 minutes later they were boxing up my order. They require masks and only allow one person inside at a time due to Covid, which made me feel super safe when picking up. Everyone working there was super friendly. I like that they let you do half and half with their specialty pies just as long as the sauce base is the same. As for the pizza itself, I definitely enjoyed the ricotta roni. The crust is pretty thin but I'm a fan of that. I thought the price point was reasonable too for an 18" pie, especially considering the area. If you're driving through and craving pizza, check them out. read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Half plain cheese half ricotta roni - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

Delicious Pizza just how I like with a thin crust, service is outstanding and location is great, yet hidden, so the vibe is welcoming.

I am an old fart and definitely not prone to superlatives. But here I go: If you have or have not tried gluten free crust, you just gotta give this place's crust a chance. My wife wanted one and i decided to share it, in my style. We got their real cheese, my side had black olives and mushrooms and their red sauce. It was remarkably delicious! True, being a geezer means I've had far too many pizzas to remember them all but I can remember some especially good ones. This blend on this crust came together to form what may be an orgasmic moment . . . Gustatorily speaking!!! read more

Deliciousness in every bite of the Old Growth Gluten Free pizza. Crispy crust holds firm when lifted. Flavors of sausage and fresh basil ring true with a sultry fig balsamic drizzle that makes it all dance so well together. The Garden Salad was large enough for two and filled with fresh greens, cherry tomatoes, crunchy croutons, sunflower seeds and topped with fig balsamic dressing. We thought we would take some home...but, nope, we ate the whole pizza and salad, too. Great combination. The beer on tap offers choices, like Golden Ale, which I highly recommend. Seating is limited, but if you can stay, you'll enjoy the music mix which changes daily. Local artists are featured on their gallery walls. Service is expected speed for fresh made pizza crafted with care for you. We enjoyed the entire staff commitment to service. Say hello to Kaydee who is the pinnacle of good service and offers up great insight and stories for every pizza. read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Golden ale inside Headies - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

A year later and we are back! Still loving the pizza and this time, the salad, too! Service was a little wonky... with the COVID-19 craziness, they are relying on take out exclusively, no dine in. There were multiple signs out front warning customers that there is only one register and only one cashier taking orders and payment, so relax and be patient. Not sure what kinds of crazy-customer blowback they have gotten, but I found the signage off-putting. I would recommend phrasing it differently so the first impression you get walking up is more, "Hey, we are so glad you are here to give us your business! Thank you in advance for your patience as our small shop works around these new health regulations to keep everyone safe!" Instead of, "Look, we are doing the best we can so don't be an asshole to our cashier, alright, and get ready to wait a long time." Just a suggestion. I dont mind waiting, but the system of taking orders did seem off. I phoned in from my car in front of the restaurant and was asked to be put on hold. I didn't mind and assumed there was another customer on the other line ahead of me. But then a group of 4 guys came in and I watched the cashier take each of their orders, ring them up, grab their beers, all individually one after another, while I sat on hold. Then she started putting to-go boxes together for a couple of minutes before picking up my call again. Not so great. I get that all hands on deck means you have to manage a lot, and it can get chaotic and disordered, but generally, I expect customers to be handled in the order they arrive. Our wait was good, though. It took 30 minutes on the nose to prepare our two whole pizzas, a slice, and two salads--totally reasonable. The cashier was very friendly ringing us up. And the food was tasty! My mother LOVED the salad (it had a lot of toppings), hubby and dad enjoyed the meaty Big Wave pizza, and I adore the Goathaven pizza. We will come again, but we will phone order much more in advance next time. :) read more

Headies is still making some of the best pizza around the bay. Called it in with this new era, prepaid too so you don't have to do the payment there, it will be about 35 minutes - cool perfect timing to make the slow roll up to Trinidad. There is no interior area and a max of two inside as stated at the door, masks are required for entry otherwise its business as usual with people waiting (6 foot or more apart) fortunately the wait here is a great one nestled up next to the old growth redwoods. Make your way inside and let them know you are there and someone brings you your piping hot, made to order with the freshest of ingredients pie - when its done, our wait was about 5 minutes and all considering a meer moment in time to enjoy the ocean air, sunshine and giant old trees. Our large Old Growth less bell peppers pizza was delivered to our car in literally no time at all. We made the slow 8 minute roll back home around the left edge of the continent - this is a huge pizza and definitely enough for a family to share, we had leftovers. Excellent thin crust with just enough char to make it extra flavorful, fresh basil and tomatoes, sweet diced red onions and ground sausage this is a delicious house special pizza. Worth the drive up to Trinidad - a very good hole in the wall pizza joint thats still here post pandemic that makes a really nice pizza. Order in advance and save yourself the wait. 4.5 Stars - rounded up for making the most of a tough situation 00690 read more

See all

YUMMY!! This Pizza is thin and crispy. The store is adorable and the staff was friendly read more

Headies Pizza & Pour - Pizza Near Me - Trinidad, California

See all