Used to be our go to restaurant in Brewster. No more. Last three visits were huge disappointments. Service was simply lousy; very slow, rude, uncaring. Food looks and tastes like it is microwaved. Only good part is the guacamole prepared in front of you. Lastly, we always walk out reeking like over cooked, rancid fried oil. Bottom line, we walk out feeling lousy. Who needs that? Make the trip to Hacienda in Brookfield, CT. They do Mexican food right. read more

Amazing enchiladas suizas and guacamole! The service is always on point and Victor the bartender makes awesome margaritas! If you're in Brewster go to Fiesta Mexicana! Great food, great service and you'll always leave satisfied. read more

Been to this Perez several times great margaritas also great table side Guacamole ever made Also on the weekends they have a live band walking around making music great place to try out read more

We were in town visiting some family, when this place was recommended to us. The guacamole was tasteless, and had no flavor. Not worth the 10 dollars I paid for. The food was also extremely bland. The chips and salsa was average. You have to pay for a refill on the soda, which I hardly ever see except for in small restaurants. This place doesn't seem small and was exceptionally busy. So either people think it's good or have no where else to go. The only thing good about the place was the service. They were very friendly and attentive. Although they didn't even ask if the food was good. If you're not into spicy or flavorful food this is the place to go. read more

I love this place! Hidden tuck away but the food is really good! I recommend everyone to try this

FANTASTIC SANGRIA and the guacamole is incredible. Although I am not a local in this area, I hope I find myself back at this restaurant very soon! read more

I have been to Fiesta a lot and again just last night! Never disappointed! Great atmosphere, Was seated immediately (a Friday Night), got my drink and dinner fast and they were both Soooooo Good! I Always get the frozen strawberry margarita and got the steak fajitas! DELICIOUS!!! Highly recommend this place! read more

Food is ok, very over priced. For the $13 you pay for guacamole it's about the size of a spoon. I order the combo, my wife ordered cheese and mushrooms, we each had 1 drink and it was over $70. Staff not very friendly, place is kinda clean I guess. Gave them another shot, sat at the bar and we were ignored for 20 minutes. When I asked the bartender who was standing around doing absolutely nothing he got snarky with me. Thank you because you saved me a lot of money on cheese and flour. read more

Gucamole was sooo good! Me and my family all loved our food. I definitely recommend it to anyone who enjoys Mexican food. read more

Fiesta Mexicana - Excellent guacamole! - Mexican Near Me - Brewster, New York

I think this is the best and authentic Mexican food I have had in the state of NY. Located in an unassuming strip mall, this Mexican fiesta is filled with life. Mexican fiesta streamers fill the restaurant, a mariachi band serenades diners and soccer streams from the bar's TVs. At 7:30pm on a Friday night there were no other tables available. The large portions will leave you feeling full and satisfied. If you are on a drive to upstate NY, this is a great place to stop on your way to your destination. Thank you Yelp for this awesome find ! read more

I will preface by saying that we arrived at 2pm so it was between lunch and dinner. The waiters paid closer attention to their smartphones than the few guests that were present. Had the service been better, I would consider 4 stars rather than 3. Having come from the southwestern states, I really like strong spice (cumin, chili pepper, cilantro, etc) and I was disappointed that the food was bland. We asked for the hot salsa and it wasn't hot at all. Safe even for children. Had the chicken enchiladas and beef taco combo. Chicken was good (no fat or skin) but bland. The taco was heavy on the tomato base. Just not to my liking. read more

I consider myself a Mexican food snob and this place was a winner. The salsa was fresh with just enough onion and cilantro to make us ask for several refills. Normally, I order enchiladas, but I noticed they put mushrooms in their fajitas ( have never seen that before) so I decided to give it a try. It was delicious! I would have given it 5 stars, but service was a bit disappointing. We barely put our forks down and they were taking our plates away reaching across the table and completely interrupting our conversations. It was almost rude. That being said, the food was good enough to go back. read more

This place is soooo over rated its ridiculous. The food is terrible. Overcooked, and not authentic at all, Taco Bell has better food than this! Avoid avoid at all cost! read more

Love this place. Best Mexican food I have ever had anywhere. Wait staff is pleasant and atmosphere is always fun!

I'm a little torn how to rate this place, the food is more a three (I'm not a huge fan of Mexican and it's not anything amazing here). However, the drinks are a five! I am absolutely in looooove with their mango margaritas!!! I could drink them all day long, so delicious! They are really inexpensive also so when me and my girlfriends go there we stick around for a while! Great place for happy hour, or to drink and eat some authentic salsa and chips. read more

This place has some great mexican fare. You can expect all the expected americanized mexican fare - delicious housemade salsa, beautiful handpainted decor (I remember them saying a local artist did everything, which was really great), delicious guacamole (I hate guacamole, but my coworkers loved it the times we have been there) and some great food. There isn't much lightfare to enjoy here, but if dietary restrictions and limitation of your cheese, fat, dairy, beans, carbs intake isn't your concern...well, do it up and enjoy it at this place! It's a great place to break a diet :) because the food is so great. Not my favorite Americanized Mexican restaurant (mole' mole' in Poughkeepsie takes that title!) but it comes in a close second :) read more

I have eaten here many times and it has always been terrific. Prices are very reasonable and you always leave full. The guacamole is the best ever. Try it. read more

This place is great. The owners are always there and they make great recommendations and have daily specials. We love the guacamole (made table-side) and the margaritas. read more

Their fish tacos are on my favorite food list! Seriously, order their fish tacos! They also have excellent guacamole made in front of you. The service is also awesome. The waiter that I usually have always brings us lots of chips and salsa refills. read more

Our favorite go to spot!!! Food is always delicious, and the margaritas are amazing!!!! The freshly made guacamole is so yummy!!

There is a reason why this place is always packed - it's truly a great Mexican restaurant. The food is delicious and fresh. The ambiance is festive with streamers and pinatas hanging from the ceilings and big colorful murals on the walls. There is a Mariachi band that walks around playing classic Mariachi songs as well as other songs (The Beatles) in Spanish. They make excellent margaritas. When you go; you must absolutely get the fresh guacamole that they prepare table side. Until I tasted this; I never ate avocados or guacamole. Now I am a fan and that is thanks to this restaurant. I should also make mention that it's quite inexpensive which is always a plus. You won't be disappointed if you check this place out (unless you want a quiet dinner - then don't go). read more

I stopped here recently for lunch. The service was great with plenty of help. The food was fresh and flavorful. Everyone was getting the table side fresh made guacamole and it looked great. The restaurant starts you with fresh made tortilla chips and salsa which was delicious. When I asked for the football game to be switched on in the bar they were very accommodating and changed the channel. Prices were reasonable. $3.75 for a Corona not bad. I used the restroom and it was clean and well stocked. read more

Awesome hearty salsa with the right amount of balanced heat, complimented with warm chips! Table side guacamole made your way with perfection. Inviting atmosphere with an entertaining and non-intrusive mariachi band! Great service with a smile to top it off. My new favorite Mexican restaurant. read more

Went for my birthday to have big avocado chunks in an oily guacamole and a chimichanga stuffed with frozen vegetables as authentic as freezer food not as good as their food from earlier years Las Mañanitas is at least up to par with food quality. read more

Vegetarian burritos were awful! Contents tasted like they were out of a can. Decided to just eat the rice and beans, but then immediately felt sick. read more

Absolute favorite spot! Me and my boyfriend love love love coming here!!! Delicious fresh food, excellent prices, and live music!!! Great fast friendly costumer service... Super tasty huge drinks!!! Only downfall is sometimes there's a wait and there's no good waiting area besides the bar and that area is usually packed also but that's only because so many people love this place! Chances are your leaving full happy and a little drunk!!! Go and enjoy!!! read more

We have been going to this restaurant since it was in downtown Brewster. So much has changed. Our waitress was sub par, the drink order came incorrect, our appetizer didn't come before our dinner so we told her not to bring it, our medium rare steak arrived medium well, service and food was slow in coming, second order of drinks was slow in coming, and coffee never came with dessert so we cancelled it. $85 later, we have decided this was a waste of our time and money. The owners used to come by and visit each table, there was always music and now there isn't even the great service or food. We can spend $85 plus tips in many local places and have a very decent meal with pleasant customer service. Sorry that they weren't able to keep up with their previous performance. read more

LOVE this place...great chips and salsa, options for people who are trying to eat healthy, great drinks. Loud, happy, fun and the staff is very nice and attentive. read more

Always busy for a reason, amazing food. I'd recommend to anyone looking for quality Mexican food. Prices are good for the portions and quality. read more

the greatest bargain around! The food is amazing, and I still can't believe how inexpensive it is. Two People can have a nice dinner for $20, and I'm not exaggerating. Guacamole and just about everything I've had is great. read more

Advertises late night hours however kitchen closes at 9pm. Surprised to have been pushed out twice now by staff irritated by late diners. If you want quick Mexican dive food it's fine but otherwise you're better off going to Las Mañanitas - elegant restaurant where being hospitable isn't a grave inconvenience to staff read more

I enjoyed the Mexicana sincere @ restaurant when you first walk in there no waiting for sitting. They make guacamole right in front you as appetizer. The is great. read more

Bad. Not close to authentic. Food tasted like it was made hours before. Creamy guac makes me think it's not 100% avacado. Soggy corn tortillas in my chicken enchiladas makes me think it was made that morning. My friend's fajita plate was so bland he asked for salt and pepper. Margarita served in a red plastic cup like I was at a party for a group of 11 year old kids - and it was $10.00!! And the waiters are all 20 year old boys who barely pass the politeness test. Why bother? Not coming back. read more

Very good place for above-average Mexican food and good service. Excellent location. We've never had a problem and have been going here for over 5 years. They make guacamole mild or spicy (which I didn't find to be that spicy) right at your table. They offer the usual courtesy of fresh chips and salsa. The drinks are good. The food is never a problem. I am not a big fan of the desserts, and did not like their flan. The rice and beans are average. The main meals are what I prefer and find to be best. They have recognized us as recurring customers and given us free appetizers and drinks throughout the years. read more

Solid 4 stars for this hearty little mexican restaurant. I am not from the area, but it looks like a hole in the wall from the outside and you can tell many locals visit here. They had a pretty good crowd on a summer Friday night which was a good sign. We were a party of three celebrating a birthday and I have to say food and drinks were very good as was the service. Waitress and bussers were attentive and were close by if we needed more of something which was nice. We ordered the frozen margaritas - pomegranate and mango, to be exact, and they were tasty and refreshing. Guacamole was great, although we ordered medium heat, and I didn't taste any heat at all (guess everyone's taste buds for spice is different). Dishes are priced fairly and I would definitely return here. read more

I just edited and added another star because they've renovated and stepped up their service.

Solid Americanized Mexican food. Fun setting, good service and tableside Guacamole AND serenades! A fun time for sure, this place has warmth. read more

Excellent Mexican food! Perhaps not extremely authentic, but well-suited to American tastes. Guacamole prepared table side to your spiciness level, and very good. I had Suiza, corn tortilla enchiladas w/the most deliciously prepared chicken filling. Seasoned to perfection. Hubby happy w/steak and shrimp fajitas. Attentive and pleasant service. Less noisy and less crowded than the sister restaurant Las Mananitas, but food just as good if not better. Highly recommended. read more

Small bar, good mexican food! I never really consider Mexican food fine dining so I Don't understand the 1 star review. This is a nice place with a great owner who runs it with family and friends, which is why I feel they always try to keep the customer happy. oH AND THE mARGERITAS ARE AWESOME. read more

It was cute, it def. does get crowded because it is small. The guac was awesome but the actual entree fell short, Idk it was just lacking. Yes they do have Mariachi band, cute kinda--annoying more so. Would be cute the first time, but do u really wanna hear that the whoooooolllle time, i personally dont. I read more