Mannnn, it pains me to have to say this because I'm a HUGE supporter of small independent businesses. Down here in the Outer Banks and especially in Corolla, that's pretty much all you're going to find anyway when it comes to places to eat...which is FANTASTIC. Hail all indie establishments!
But when I see a place like this not take advantage of what they have and what I think imo they could become with even just a little bit of effort and elbow grease, I smh. Maybe it's just me not "getting it" - maybe what people like about this place is it's divey interior "charm" - ? Maybe it was just that it was a crappy, cold, rainy off-season weekday at lunchtime when we came - ? The place was empty except for us the whole time we were there. It was a little bit weird.
In the Timbuck II shopping village centrally located in Corolla, this place is in the PERFECT LOCATION. I mean, certainly during busy season, if you have an eatery in this shopping center, you're raking in the dough. I tried coming here last summer and the wait was insane for a table. But that was pretty much the case for anywhere we went.
But this time around, I got to see and experience this place. And I wasn't impressed. In fact I would say I was more disappointed than anything. The place has the potential to be a really cool, trendy spot if it were updated and renovated even a little bit. It wouldn't take much, really. It looks like the inside hasn't been touched in yearssssssss. Maybe that's the charm - ? It's dark and dingy. Also the place is a lot smaller on the inside than it looks from the outside. A big bar area takes up a good part of the back of the place leaving not a ton of table seatiing so, even when crowded, I now understand why the long waits. Truly, this place has dive-bar vibes inside - don't expect anything more. Not that I was expecting Sanderling Inn - but I was hoping for something less....divey.
Ok maybe who cares, you say? If the food is to-die-for, right? Agree. Ambience certainly helps but it's not the end-all-be-all. I've given 4 or 5 stars to places that could use a serious facelift. Thing is, the food wasn't to-die-for. At least not what we ordered (bfast biscuit sandwich, chicken salad sandwich and a cheeseburger). I would say a notch below average. Case in point, look at all the food shots posted - anything there look appetizing and delicious?
I WILL add in all fairness that the service was good here - our server was super friendly. And prices were decently reasonable and not tourist-gouging. The menu does have a lot of interesting, original options on it including a section of First Light Favorites and all day bfast items.
All in all, for us at least, nothing to write home about, I'm afraid. Nothing that can't be fixed though, that's the thing. This place already rocks a great location. Some sprucing up on the inside and kicking the food up a few notches and this place could be a year round winner. As it stands now, I can whip up a better breakfast and burgers back at my rental, save some bucks and dine in better ambience.
I'm so sure that, making no improvements at all, this place will still make a killing in the busy season because there just aren't enough eating places in the Corolla area to compete for people's business.
But status quo has never really been a smart way to run any kind of business. read more