This is a very small shop. But the cookies are delicious. PB &J cookie was my favorite. It was a nice soft cookie, with a lot of peanut and jelly. I wish this is available everywhere. I also went for a s'mores cake. That was delicious as well. read more

Fish Wife Sweets - PB&j cookie - Desserts Near Me - Half Moon Bay, California

See all

Pretty mid, surprised at the high reviews tbh. Our brown butter chocolate chip cookies tasted dry as if they were a couple days old, and the flavor was nothing memorable As a comparison, we really like batch 22 for cookies read more

Small bakery on Main Street with an unforgettable name and gimmick. We finished eating lunch and wanted to wander around before heading back home. This was one of our first stops to bring a little sweet back for dessert. Founded in 2015 by realtor Moriah Bettencourt, Moriah baked for fun and opened this bakery in HMB. On the website it says if she represents you as a buyer or seller you can get up to a year of free baked goods! Interior is very cute, I love the old aged floor and the nautical adn baked themed decorations, pretty unique for a baked good shop they also have some cut stickers and magnets made out of wood for sale. We got cookies and cupcakes. The variety of flavors they have for both is amazing and I really liked how neat the packaging was. We don't eat that much so we were happy the sizes are more standard and not too oversized. read more

See all

We loved the Minecraft themed birthday cake that we ordered this year. It was absolutely delicious. The business was very accommodating to allow pick up on a day when it was closed and the communication was very fast and efficient. Highly recommended. read more

Locally owned and baked, with a great mix of cookies, bars, brownies, and cupcakes. There's a dedicated gluten free section, and they serve warm cookies as well. The employees are great and offer great suggestions! We were recommended to try the peanut butter and jelly cookie. I don't even eat PB&J but these cookies are a delectable, crumbly peanut butter cookie with a light sugar crust, finished with extra peanut butter and a spoonful of jelly in the center. If they're in stock, they're a must try! The Twix cookie is also great- it's a shortbread base, caramel, and chocolate, and the lemon bars and pop tart bars are also worth grabbing. The gluten free chocolate chip cookie is impressive. Small, welcoming space that is well worth the stop. read more

See all

Would come here weekly if I lived nearby! Loved their warm brown butter chocolate-chip cookie pies. Such a smooth, gooey, creamy brown butter inside with just the right amount of salt and sweetness. Served warm and heavenly to break apart. Also cookie pies are a genius idea! Can't wait to come back and try the cowboy and all their oatmeal varieties. 5 stars!!!! read more

Fish Wife Sweets - Desserts Near Me - Half Moon Bay, California

See all

I love having a cookie here as a treat when I'm in half moon bay. They have the best selection of warm cookies with amazing flavors like s'mores, Nutella and dark chocolate sea salt. The cookies are not gooey and soft like crumble cookies. They're a bit crunchier but tasty nonetheless. This local shop is right in the downtown and they sell cookie bags to go and other knick knacks. read more

See all

Adorable pint size sweet shop, with all kinds of baked goods, e.g. cookies and cupcakes of different flavors, plus little curios. Before we went in, I thought they might have bins of candies that you select in cellophane bags and gets weighed. Not. It's just baked stuff, which if you like the sweet profile on your palate, are good. The prices are reasonable for freshly baked stuff and Parking can be tough. read more

See all

Favorite spot for treats!!! They did my daughter's first birthday with a daisy theme and they were absolutely perfect! read more

Fish Wife Sweets - Desserts Near Me - Half Moon Bay, California

See all

I stumbled in here because it looked like a cute gift shop. My timing also was great because the cookies were just put out and lucky me! The owner started her love for baking as a hobby and made it into a business to share her love for baking (you can tell by each bite). One of the features are they offer warm cookies. I tried the Nutella cookie and it was amazing! I even had it the day after and it was still good. I regret not getting a second cookie, but that's a reason to visit Half Moon Bay! As I mentioned, there were some cute gifts and picked up something for a friend but pick up a cookie or brownie for yourself. read more

One of the best cookies I have ever had. The store was full of fun sweet treats for Super Bowl and Valentine's Day. Small and intimate space. Service was friendly and welcoming. Will return when in the area. read more

Fish Wife Sweets - Desserts Near Me - Half Moon Bay, California

I just went in here randomly and these sounded good. Got home. Tried them. so good! I ate them so slowly... made them last a few days. Got them to share with the kids but did not. I saved them for after their bedtime so I could enjoy their goodness in peace. I've been thinking of them every day... mainly because I saved this empty bag and I keep seeing it on my counter. I wish this place wasn't so far away. Service was meh... the lone person there didn't really acknowledge my existence but I don't care. I'm rating solely on the cookies. I'll make the 45 min drive again some day... just tried to look and see if it was possible a chain... but no such luck. I'm having second thoughts about posting this because what if next time it's sold out due to my rave review... make sure you leave one bag behind in case I show up! read more

Fish Wife Sweets - Desserts Near Me - Half Moon Bay, California

Truly terrific. We stopped in and had some amazing peach cobbler. Wow. Sorry there is no photo because you can't capture the amazing flavours and textures of the bars. Really good. really homemade. You might find them a little pricey. But they are worth it. The shop has something for everyone and the staff are great. When in HMB you must go home with some Fish Wife Sweete. read more

This bakery is amazing! Everything we got there was delicious: s'more bars, salted caramel brownies, lemon bars etc. I can't wait to go back when I visit HMB again. read more

A cute little bakery to get delicious baked goods! I learned it was called Fish Wife Sweets because the owner is the wife of a fisher who had always wanted to open a bakery store and her dreams came true with this bakery! Everything is made from scratch and I loved that you order get warm cookies. I got the dark chocolate and pistachio cookie and it was perfection on a colder cloudy day. Just enough gooey-ness from the chocolate and texture from pistachio was the perfect combination in every bite. It was also not too sweet which my preference. I would definitely order this cookie again or try another flavor when I come back, possibly in the fall for the pumpkin festival at HMB! read more

Fish Wife Sweets - Warm pistachio chocolate cookie - Desserts Near Me - Half Moon Bay, California

What started out as a cottage kitchen operation in 2015 has turned into a full-fledged brick-and-mortar in 2022. Fish Wife Sweets specializes in all the guilty pleasures of the sweet kind, including cakes, brownies, cookies, and cinnamon rolls, just to name a few. The Good: The cookies were why we decided to pay them a visit. They had some really intriguing flavors, but the sea salt brown butter chocolate chip cookies were calling my name. Carissa opted for the more exotic PB&J. Both were delicious, but the PB&J cookie was really outstanding, and I loved the unique concept. The Meh: *Parking in this "Downtown" section of HMB can be difficult, but as long as you're willing to walk a bit, you can usually score a spot. *Only open Thu - Sun The Ugly: *Pricing at $12/4 cookies was a bit rich, but since they were good, I'll (kinda) allow it. Conclusion: Great cookies and can't wait to come back and try some more goodies. read more

See all

Great little sweet shop. We ran across this shop while spending a few days in HMB. We actually went back the next day and made another purchase. Needless to say, my family liked their sweets. lol They have a cookie warmer as well, with hot cookies available. I had to indulge and try one on our second trip. We ended up buying a bag. My kids really enjoyed their treats. I truly enjoyed the peach pie bar. I could only ate half as I was so full! Lol I brought the remainder home. I really could have bought even more things on day 3, but we already over indulged. Ha ha read more

Fish Wife Sweets - Peach pie bar - Desserts Near Me - Half Moon Bay, California

Fell in love with the "Cowboy Cookie " a few years ago. But the bars are tasty too. Have bought cookies for Christmas Stockings and everyone loved them so much, each year Mrs. Claus has been asked if they are getting one. But this year, I have to say her exceptional service almost out weighs the baked goods (not really). There was a second page on my order that wasn't caught. When we went to pick up the order a couple things were missing. So asked about them. Luckily they had an extra pie, but the dozen of Cowboy cookies she would have to bake. We said no problem, we will come for them. Instead she delivered to our house 1/2 hour away. That is what we call, up and beyond great service. So Fish Wife, KEEP ON BAKING!!! read more

We LOVE coming here. We've never had a cookie, bar/brownie, or cupcake we didn't love (our favorites are the s'mores cookies - especially from the warmer, birthday cake cookies, caramel apple oatmeal cookies, lemon crumble bars, chocolate cupcakes, cookies & cream cupcakes, lemon cupcakes). You really can't go wrong with any of the warm cookies - they are SO good. We have ordered custom cakes for birthdays, and recently ordered a variety of mini cupcakes for our baby shower. Ordering is easy and fast, and everything has always been ready as expected. Moriah is the best, and we are customers for life! read more

Mmmmmmm warm cookies and milk?!?! Yes please!! Cute little sweets store on one end of Main Street in Half Moon Bay. You can get warm cookies, as well as a bunch of other baked goods like brownies, pie, cupcakes, cookies, etc.. also can preorder larger sizes! Cashier was informative and helpful and friendly. Quite yummy, happy with this new find! read more

See all

Omg now I am going to have to make the drive on a regular, for the lemon bars and Carmel snickerdoodle cookies. They were so moist and perfect. This place will get me in trouble. Woman there was very helpful it was super busy and they still made sure they were available to answer questions and fast check out. Small shop but big flavors let me not forget about the pumpkin butterscotch blondie! Man oh man read more

Fish Wife Sweets recently did all the desserts for my daughter's bat mitzvah party at Long Branch Farms. She was a dream to work with! We had a western theme and we brainstormed flavors for a pie and cobbler bar for the event. It was a highlight of the evening! We had individual cherry, olallieberry and peach pies, and lemon, brownie and caramel apple cobbler bars. Everything was SO good! She also made a smash cake for my 4 year old niece whose birthday was that day. It was great to be able to brainstorm and customize everything to get just what we wanted. We also appreciated that jumped right in when we needed a little extra help with set-up - a true team player! Would highly recommend, and will definitely be using again! read more

Such a cute shop! There's so many varieties of cookies and other sweets I couldn't decide! But the warm cookies caught my eye. I got the s'mores one and it was so yummy! The peppermint brownies were also really good. I can't wait to come back and try other things! The worker here was also very nice and sweet. read more

See all

They were able to accommodate my very late order for a custom color wedding cake to fit the theme of our wedding. Mariah saved my day! She was very flexible about incorporating my ideas and sharing hers as well. I couldn't have been happier. Their cookies and pastries are also super yummy! Thank you! read more

See all

We got a warm cookie and it was so delicious. I forgot which one but it was really good. The brownies are pretty good too. The staff is nice. read more

Rarely can you find baked goodies that rival the cakes and cookies you grew up enjoying. But Fish Wife Sweets definitely serves a wonderful variety of delicious baked goods for every taste. Friendly people and stellar customer service. read more

The warm S'mores cookie was one of the best cookies I've ever had in my life. Gooey marshmallow, melty chocolate, warm soft center, crisped outsides, and just the perfect hint of salt. I'm still dreaming about it. read more

We've been following this place on IG for years and are so excited to see their storefront! Tried a Cowboy Cookie at Breakwater BBQ when the owner was baking out of her home kitchen, the stumbled across a breakfast cookie at Dawn Patrol. This place is a must-try! Their S'mores and birthday cookies are absolutely delish and the customer service is super welcoming. Great location - old Garden Apothecary building on Main, next to the feed store. Love that they're also LGBTQ friendly! read more

See all

Fish wife sweets did an excellent job with our wedding cake! We were so pleased with how everything turned out! Our guests really enjoyed the cake and complimented how beautiful it was with the flowers they arranged on it. Thank you so much for meeting and exceeding our expectations for our special day, we appreciate it so much! read more

See all

I love, love, love Fishwife Sweets! Moriah is a true gem and sweetheart to this community. I started following and ordering from her during the pandemic. Her treats are made with so much love and sweetness she definitely earns her name. I was even more excited when she opened her brick and mortar here on Main Street. Now I could have access to her treats whenever my heart desires it. First let's get into what got me following her in the first place. The very first cookie I ever had was her s'mores one. She sells them at Spangler's Market in El Granada. It's a beautiful idea. What kid or adult doesn't like s'mores!!! This brought memories of making them over my mom's stovetop. Lol. It's delicious! Another time, I was given a sweet treat from Breakwater BBQ while I was waiting on an order. This one was her Cowboy cookie and let me tell you, it's one if my favorites. She also makes biscuits, brownies and cinnamon buns. You can always find a themed cookie, cupcake or pie during the holidays. She has an incredible way of making treats more fun to eat. Her treats are super creative. The shop is filled with her treats but she also shares her heart with this community. You can find unique gifts from other local vendors for your pets, family or friends. Everything is locally made and one of a kind. If you're ever in town, stop by. It's the building that's the color of the ocean. read more

Super cute and loved the S'mores cookie! They are so thoughtful to have a certain number warmed up, so you can enjoy it immediately in all of its gooey, marshamllow-y chocolatey glory. You can also take home sealed ones for friends/family. They also have bags of cookies for 12 dollars for 6 I believe. Love the wealth of flavors to try. I was particularly curious about the strawberry dipped in chocolate, so will have to try that + the Peppermint brownie next time! Along the main street in Half Moon Bay, great to walk this tiny strip because there's a lot of wonderful shops, restaurants here. read more

Fun options. Loved the Ginger Molasses White Chocolate cookies. Cute shop. Friendly staff.

Cookies are delicious! Wish they sold more individual ones separately but the packs are great too! Staff is friendly and parking is pretty easy although it is in cute busy downtown Half Moon Bay. read more

Mariah made my daughter's wedding cake this weekend. 3 layers, 3 flavors, and there was hardly any cake left. That says it all. read more

Fish Wife Sweets - Wedding cake from the Fishwife in HMB - Desserts Near Me - Half Moon Bay, California

HANDS DOWN THE BEST SWEETS IVE EVER HAD. My husband and I are from Charlotte, NC. We came out to California for vacation in May 2023 and were driving down Hwy 1. We stopped in the town to see the shops and stretch our legs. Needless to say we stumbled upon fish wife sweets and HOLY MOLY. I wanted to buy one of everything. We settled on the smores cookie and the churro bars. I remember them to this day and dream about eating them again. Planning the next time when I can fly out to get more haha. read more

See all

THE. BEST. brownies and chocolate chip cookies. They have many cookie flavors, cupcakes and other sweets as well. Everything I've had was delicious. The lemon blueberry cookie was less lemony than I expected/hoped but still very good. First tried them at 2nd Saturdays on Harvard and have visited the store several times since. It is a small and fun little store with cute little knick knacks and trinkets. Everyone is nice and helpful. Once, I went to choose an assortment of cookies for an ice cream sandwich bar and they gave great suggestions for cookies that wouldn't just squish the ice cream out. read more

I have sweet tooth and stepped into this little shop ... there's a variety but I just ended up w a box of " Choc Chunk Brownies " . So delicious and they even get better the next day as the top gets a little crispy keeping the middle moist. The best secret is to cut in quarters as you eat ! Yummy yum read more

Best banana cupcake ever. Friendly fast service. My husband went back in for a second cupcake

Great treats, great workers, lots of cool trinkets to buy on the side!! Love the vibes here

I really wanted to like this place since I love giving my business to local businesses. I just didn't like it. The s'mores tasted very salty and weird. I don't know if it was just an off day or what. I also got a cupcake which was extremely dry and not tasty. This was the day of the pumpkin festival, so maybe they were just overwhelmed. I don't know. But it was not a pleasant experience, and was a waste of money. read more