Reign offers Shrimp, Mussels, Crawfish, Snow Crab Legs, and much more…read more We had never been to this establishment and probably won't be going back. Normally I give a place a second chance before writing a negative review however, not this time. The waitress was very good, helpful, and as attentive as she could be with the manager hovering around like a buzzard. The food and drinks came out relatively quickly. The soft drinks were flat. The food was cooked decently I've had better seafood boils and I've had worse. The negative review is based on the unprofessional management and overall decor of the restaurant. The paint was peeling, fixtures were coming off the walls, they need to clean the floors and fix the seating area. The benches and chairs are dated. The red velvet ropes made me feel like I was being separated from a group in a low-budget strip club. The waitress could have been more attentive if the manager would have stopped holding her up and bothering her about a bill someone dined and dashed on. If you are the manager and you are posted by the door maybe you should watch the customers better since the wait staff is back and forth between the dining area and the kitchen. Because of the rundown, dirty condition, and the unprofessional demeanor of the manager I recommend you find another establishment for Seafood.

Highly recommend this place. Seafood is fresh and delicious. Would love to go back and bring my…read morehusband to try it.q

Ok, so I found this place as we were heading back to Philly from Virginia, and it was definitely…read moreworth going to. I usually don't like chain restaurants but this spot was on point. They have a lot of parking because it's at a mall and it's very spacious inside. I was the only person at my table to order a drink and I will say this. I really slept on this drink until it hit the spot and I was like oh wow! The frozen berry grand margarita was on point! I would definitely order that again! So my sister and my nephew both wanted crabs so that's what they received. If you been to red lobsters lately and got their crab in a bag, it has nothing on Juicy Bucket ‍, just saying. I will admit I wasn't too pleased with the serve, you could just tell that this wasn't his career choice he belongs behind a computer somewhere or in a science lab anything that doesn't deal with ppl. He was very forgetful, and just seemed overall uncomfortable. However, he only made one mistake so you gotta admit he did well. I will definitely go back but I wouldn't suggest that you order the calamari it tastes like it's prepackaged. The oysters were tasty, along with the fried shrimp. Oh and don't let me forget, their french fries were delicious, I love a good batch of fries.

Frozen, old seafood. The crab and shrimp bag... Old,…read moretough, tasteless... Hard to get out of the shells, tough texture. The sausage had a strange after taste and heavy salt upfront! We could feel our feet swell as we ate it. The corn was frozen and had a corn flavor. The potatoes were cooked just right. They were the hit of the experience. Ordered fried scallops... Same situation... Tough, tasteless and too lightly battered. They may have been better if they were fried a little longer to make them crispy. Our wait staff was very pleasant and on point

Went here this past weekend as part of a crab feast/ casino trip . Upon arrival, the establishment…read morefrom outside appears to be big. Once inside the restaurant, the tables are long and very close together. Not too many table are just 4-tops of which means you'll be seated with others most likely . It was a tight squeeze to get up from the tables due to them being so close . They dump all the crabs and corn on your table which leaves lil space to actually eat them. There are three bathroom stalls for a really big restaurant of which causes a long line every time you need to use the bathroom. Now the crabs themselves were a mix of small & mediums but they were really juicy and had a good taste. The servers were pretty cool although they seemed overwhelmed with the large groups of people. Overall the crabs, corn, clam strips, and fried chicken thighs and shrimp were good. I would come back again just not on a trip so I can get a better chance if not being seated with people don't know .

I had first caught wind of Old Mill Crab House about 10 years ago, when a group that included…read moreseveral of my coworkers took a charter to go eat at this location. The next day everybody was talking about how good this place was. They talked about the all you can eat crabs, that same with fried shrimp and chicken that was just out of this world, and it just sounded incredible. I had actually looked it up, and told my wife about it, but it was just to far of a drive without having a day planned around it. We don't really go out to this area, and so after a while it just kind of fell off of our radar. Fortunately for my though, I was invited to a conference at Salisbury University through my employer. I was talking with a friend of mine about the food ion the area, and he brought up a name that I hadn't heard in some time, but it clicked right when he said it. I did my googles and found that we were only 20 minutes from here, and I knew it was now or never. I told 2 of my coworkers about it, and gave them the backstory on how I've been wanting to cone here for years, and they were down. The only thing that came as a drawback was that we had just been given blue crabs at our conference the day before, and I didn't want to sit through another crab picking session, so AYCE wasn't going to be an option for me, but luckily it didn't end up being a problem. When we got here we were seated immediately, that staff was friendly and it smelled amazing as soon as you opened the door. Our sevcer was very accommodating seeing as we had to split the bill 3 ways and she put the alcohol on 3 different checks for us. Anyhow, The food! I got the Snow Crab mini feast, which came with 4 Clusters of Snow Crabs, 1 Piece of Fried Chicken, 1 Ear of Corn, Boat of Fried Shrimp, Boat of Clam Strips, Boat of Hush Puppies. Which was more like 3 pieces of chicken, and shrimp flowing out of the boat. I also got a pitcher of Blue Moon and a Tito's Wildcat which was really good. I could've done without the powdered sugar on top of the hush puppies, but it didn't ruin how good they were. It almost gave off a beignet vibe, they were lighter and fluffier than a lot of the more dense hush puppies I've had, and were still the best hush puppies i've had in a minute. Needless to say I crushed this whole meal, and I was actually considering not even eating the corn. Then I figured I should atleast take a bite, because why not. Best decision ever! I pealed the corn and drizzled melted butter with Old Bay on it, and holy smokes! The best corn i've ever had in my entire, whole, full, complete, total life! Even without the fixings it was sweet and juicy, just good. I would fircking come back from a Corn on the cob mini feast if they had one...lls The only real downside is that on a hot day this place and get pretty stuffy inside. We spoke with our waitress who said the A.C. has a hard time keeping up once the place gets packed, so hopefully thats something they fix in the near future. Definitely glad I got to check in here, and see what all the hype was about, and they delivered! Old Mill Crab House is the TRUTH!!

Went with a group of 8 to Ocean City for a golf trip and were recommended to check out Delmarva…read moreBoil company, Couldn't have worked out better. Called in the order on the drive out. Will (who ended up being the owner) made the ordering process so simple, guided us through what went best in the boil order, and even recommended we slim the order to 7 as we added a lot to it. Boil flavor was legit, shrimp, sausage, clams, mussel's and crab legs was our combo. Also added some pulled pork (which blew us away flavor wise), slaw and corn bread as additional food. For a group setting, this was tough to beat, would def do again. Also, I believe it was Grace who handed off our order when we showed up, couldn't have been a nicer person, explained how to dive in, gave us extra sauce. A+ hospitality and food, easy for a group like ours.

Not bad taste but too expensive for what was offered. We ordered two sea food boil and it only…read moreincluded shrimp as a protein, in order to get snow crab legs/ lobster you need to pay the same price as an add on and you need to have a minimum of two boils to place an order. Scam imo

They moved to this new location some years ago and Lo and Behold, they never lost a beat. The…read moreseafood boils are to die for! Seriously, it is really good. They have a variety of menu items, the snowboarding legs are my favorite but they have clams, shrimp, muscles and so much more. Oh, they also give you a bib and lots of paper towels, you will need them!

Great experience at this restaurant. They have amazing seafood boils and service! Highly recommendread more

Since discovering this place through a friend. I have nothing but positive vibes. Location in Rear…read moreof Johnny Jonaski red building door 3, the employees are welcoming, the prices are extremely reasonable and the food is great & the cook it. Excellent place for all seafood

The food was terrible, the Mac and Cheese literally Stouffers. Also the service is terrible,…read morebecause of the inexperienced employees. The pictures on the menu are not his food at all. They just opened a cheap dining room and calls it luxury. Maybe the owner shouldn't claim to be a master chef to the women and make crap for food.

Great seafood. Easy to prepare. Just need to follow the…read moresimple instructions. Would recommend for in easy delicious meal at home.

This was the biggest waste of money. $140 for a very small amount of food that fed 3 people, and…read morethey don't even steam it for you. I added in my own two lobster tails in addition to the 2 provided. Most of the seafood was inedible and of poor quality. I steamed the extra lobster tails together, and they were delicious. The ones from Topsail, however, were inedible, and we wound up throwing them away along with the clams. The only things in the pot worth eating were the ears of corn. Unfortunately, I will never order from them again. It was a total waste of money, and we were all still hungry.

Great food and fantastic service. Go there as soon as we get to ocean city. Crabs are always…read moreheavy, and the spice on the crabs is out of this world. When in ocean city, one place you need to visit.

We had plans to eat at another crab house today but they didn't open until 4pm and we wanted to eat…read moreat noon. We found On The Bay Seafood and decided to give it a try. Rob and Rose greeted and welcomed us. We ordered the Medium steamed Crabs, Crab Cake Sandwich, Crab Bisque, corn on the cob and Hush Puppies. Wow! What a treat so early in the season. The Bisque was excellent. It's not too spicy but they give you extra seasoning and spice to add according to your personal taste. The Crab Cake was just as advertised. No filler, fresh Crab, Eastern Shore style and delicious. The medium crabs were very good. Some establishments would be seeking them as Large. They were seasoned and steamed perfectly. Heavy and sweet. The sides; Corn on the Cob, steamed in the Husk was very good and the Hush Puppies were a perfect pairing. My apologies for lack of pictures, we ate most everything before I started taking pictures. Rob and Rose were very attentive. They told us their story and shared a scrap book of their off season home in New Mexico. They were in the process of training and orienting their summer staff while we enjoyed our meal. The attention to detail, customer first, quality service and passion for excellent food was on full display. The dining is beach rustic and perfect. There's a good amount of parking and it's easy to find them right along coastal highway. What initially seemed like a disappointment today turned into a wonderful discovery of a new favorite. On The Bay Seafood is a must try if you're at the shore this year.

Excellent. Clam chowder…read more , and the shrimp salad is fresh and delicious me daily. And wonderful other seafood specialties. Great service.

Place may have closed down recently sorry Their answer machine said they.were.have technical…read moreissues. This was a very good delightful seafood place with amazing French fries too