Consistently good pies…read more The dough has a wonderful yeasty flavor. This is our go-to place when we want to call for a pie for dinner. They have two locations on the island and the food is consistent at both. Good hot subs also. Also, if you are a weekly renter waiting to get your keys at 2pm on a Saturday, this is a good uncrowded place to wait.

beware if you have food allergies or restrictions - they can't read the comments in the slice app.read more

Very good pizza on the island. Also had a nice ceasar salad. I went to order take out. I'd love…read moreto eat there next time seating permitting. Not a sit down location.

Grandma pie worth the wait and the price by a long shot. That crust is unbelievable, sauce is…read moreoutstanding and they put down some fresh basil leaves and grated some real nice parmesan right before boxing it up. Everyone was impressed with their slices ... doesn't matter if you're a corner , edge or inside type of person you will be happy. Substantial weight to that pie too. Not greasy at all. We will try the fig poppa next time.

Amazing, and vivacious people who knew how to keep us unbelievably happy and safe.!!!read more

Great time with our family. Food was amazing, well prepared and really fresh. We enjoyed some…read moreappetizers which were so delicious, some did not want to share. Lol. Staff were super nice, making our night perfect! Thank you Russos!

If you want a quick and delicious slice of pizza this is the place to go! The location is great for…read morea place like this.

The service was fine, when you order your slice at the window, there's a rack with 15-20 pies…read moregetting cold and waiting to be served. The pizza man puts the slice in the oven for about 35 seconds and with his pizza.peel, slides the Pizza onto the counter from his pizza station. All fine and good if the pizza had any taste. Minimal amount of tomato sauce and minimal amount of cheese, so after 35 seconds of reheating cold pizza in the oven and taking the first bite was extremely disappointing. you're eating a piece of cold spongy pizza dough for five bucks. I give it one star for the service. Sorry, Bay Village pizza is a one and done for me.

This pizza is legit. I ordered take out as there are no tables and therefore no service. The…read morelocation is a small spot on the east side of Long Beach Avenue. The crust is chewy and crusty - the way it should be with great flavor. The sauce is flavorful and thankfully not sweet. The cheese is great. The B&T is basic and good. The Margarita is excellent and I recommend getting the Margarita over the B&T. We will not be getting pizza from anywhere else.

I almost don't want to leave a review bc I'd rather this place stays a hidden gem. FREAKING…read moreDELICIOUS! We grabbed three pizzas on our first night of vacation and they did NOT disappoint. I can understand why this may not appeal to big groups on vacation as the pizzas are small little 10" individual pies. But omg was the crust amazing. And the toppings were delicious. Yummmmm! Can't wait to grab some again this week while we're here.

Another solid experience at Isola. Food was very tasty and the service was excellent…read more Unfortunately, once again we could only get a table on the porch. And there's little atmosphere out there. They should add some votives or something to cozy it up a bit - especially during the winter months.

Nice vibe. Pleasant service. Small portions. I was excited to try the grilled octopus which I…read morealways do when it's on the menu. Epic fail. The beans and sauce was flavorful but the octopus was tough as shoe leather!

Great pizza HORRIBLE service…read more Came this evening and ordered 6 slice and a pie. Everything was ordered together. Slices came out in 5 minutes. The pizza after 20 minutes of waiting asked where it was we told still on the way there were tickets in front. Asked to at a minimum get a slice for our 1 year old and 6 year old and was ignored. Threw tickets in my face showing me other pizza that were put in at 6:27 and ours was at 6:31. I explained how he further proved my point as those came out of the oven 5 minutes earlier. He continued to not care and decide to open the public trash is as customers and how wrong we were. A shameful respect for customers.

Solid take out large cheese pizza, reasonably priced, lots of cheese good crust…read more Friendly takeout counter help

I've stopped here a couple of times. The pizza was pretty good. Nothing outstanding but worth…read morerevisiting. However we ordered one night late apparently right before closing. The person on the phone was kind of rude, but it seemed like she just wasn't hearing us so we really didn't think anything of it. When we got there to pick it up, she was very rude and said she told us she was closing and basically walked out the door, handing us our food. It was unbelievable.

We stopped in at Anthony's on a day trip to Beach Haven. We have found that pizza on the beach is a…read morewonderfully easy way to enjoy the day. Anthony's was easy on and off of 72, we ordered ahead and our onion and sausage pie was cooked to perfection. It was ready when we arrived and it made for a wonderful day.

We love the pizza and the garlic knots! We make sure to stop here every year. The cheesesteaks…read moreare a hit as well!

KEEP THE PICKLE BOMB!!!!…read more We love this place. BEST PIZZA .. Nothing bad to about the food service or the place.

What a great little find! Stopped in and had the hot honey pizza, it was fantastic! Highly…read morerecommend trying it out!

Staff have been extremely rude and dismissive on multiple occasions. We order from here at least…read moretwice a week, so we are regular customers, but the staff often act as though we are inconveniencing them rather than appreciating our business. They are frequently on their phones or involved in personal conversations while customers are waiting. We've literally sat there watching our pizza get cold while employees finish their conversations instead of attending to customers. They weren't even busy -- they were just being nasty and dismissive. I always go out of my way to be kind to people in the service industry because I know it's a tough job and that not everyone is nice. That's why it's especially disappointing to be treated this way when we're simply trying to order food. On one visit, a girl working behind the counter was having a very loud conversation about how her boyfriend had pulled a gun to her head. Regardless of the circumstances, that is an extremely inappropriate conversation to have openly in front of customers. We have been loyal customers and order at least once a week, but enough is enough. Between the rude attitude, employees being on their phones, letting food sit while they finish conversations, inappropriate conversations, and lack of cleanliness, we've had enough. We won't be coming back.