I've stopped here a couple of times. The pizza was pretty good. Nothing outstanding but worth revisiting. However we ordered one night late apparently right before closing. The person on the phone was kind of rude, but it seemed like she just wasn't hearing us so we really didn't think anything of it. When we got there to pick it up, she was very rude and said she told us she was closing and basically walked out the door, handing us our food. It was unbelievable. read more

We stopped in at Anthony's on a day trip to Beach Haven. We have found that pizza on the beach is a wonderfully easy way to enjoy the day. Anthony's was easy on and off of 72, we ordered ahead and our onion and sausage pie was cooked to perfection. It was ready when we arrived and it made for a wonderful day. read more

A late night arriving to the shore for the weekend. Coming from work, long busy day and not wanting to cook-stopped in to pick up a slice of pizza. Two slices left but the person offered to make me a fresh pizza slice-to-go if I didn't mind waiting 8-10 minutes. I appreciated the kindness and care more than they knew. I have ordered from them for other casual family meals-to-go. Good people, good grub! read more

White pie with vegetables is excellent. Service is always friendly when getting takeout. Garlic parm wings are also very good. read more

The pizza here is so good. Crust is perfectly thin and very tasty. We have also tried the chicken cheese steaks which are delicious. This pizzeria deserves 5 stars, every time we come in service is so great, friendly staff even when understaffed. We will definitely be back. read more

The chicken wings was so salty after the second one I had to throw it out and the chicken parm was not good , the sauce was so sour your ears pop. read more

Previously the best Pizza around. Now, the large pie is noticeably smaller than it used to be, flop jallops aka no crisp, and cold by the time you get it home. I was a big fan of this shop, so it pains me to write a poor review. If you don't believe me, try it yourself - order a large pie and take it home. read more

I was so excited to get Jersey pizza for the first time, but was not blown away. While the staff was friendly and the restaurant was authentic, I didn't love my pizza. read more

Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Plain pizza - Pizza Near Me - Manahawkin, New Jersey

Frozen Ellios pizza heated in a microwave is higher quality pizza. Trust me. Tomato paste- that's not sauce! Little to no seasoning. Go margarita pizza- the cheese was uncut & rubbery, why would someone want to eat that?? Expensive / OVERPRICED. Service: SLOW! Ambiance? It was a pizza place. That's the best I can say. Find another place read more

This place is awesome. Food is excellent and the people couldn't be nicer. Ziti and broccoli in oil and not over garlicky and the white pizza with spinach and Cesar salad was great. They use fresh broccoli and spinach and added grilled chicken to the pasta dish. Tremendous value! read more

Great pizza and food in general. They are always busy for a reason! We drive to LBI from NY state and always stop here. Must try!

Great local pizzeria in Beach Haven West Pizza is delicious, there chicken parm is yummy & there wings are great too! read more

I have nothing bad to say about this place. This is some of the best pizza i have ever had in my life. I've been coming here since i was young and never found a better slice. I recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza. It's DIVINE read more

Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Manahawkin, New Jersey

Good ingredients, not the cheap stuff , reasonable prices, excellent food, and friendly staff.... read more

Haven't ordered pizza here recently because last couple of times was disappointed. Wanting to support our local small businesses, I tried once more only to be disappointed again. Pizza was dry, tasteless and all pieces were burned on the bottom. Hate to have to go elsewhere as I am a long time customer. But all I want is an edible pizza. What has happened to Anthony's? read more

Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Burned crust - Pizza Near Me - Manahawkin, New Jersey

I heard from a friend that Anthony's pizza was on par with Northern NJ & NYC pizza (thin crispy crust with great sauce) so for takeout we ordered a large half pepperoni pizza and a lasagna dinner. Well, it was awesome! As an added bonus the owners and workers were so nice and appreciative of the business and tip. Looks like our new go-to. read more

The pizza here was amazing. We got our 4 pies to go and I still thought the service was fantastic for some reason. The pizza is well balanced and would be the perfect leftover in the morning for breakfast. Or lunch. Or dinner. Or breakfast. Price wasn't bad for what you got. read more

Best Pizza around since the 80s, they never go wrong, doesn't matter whose's making it and your always treated like family, even stays open a little longer just cuz your running late. read more

Excellent pies and Chicken Parm Sandwiches! Highly recommend on a Sunday afternoon or evening when you don't feel like cooking. Friendly people too! read more

Passable cheese steak, decent flavor and fresh roll, they just need to melt the cheese into the meat a little better. Friendly staff though.

Our new go to in the area. Pizza is top notch as are the wings and chicken parm. Highly recommend!!

"Okay" food Just a tip: always check your order to make sure they actually got it right or that they even gave you the correct order in the first place. read more

Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Half cut into, nice! - Pizza Near Me - Manahawkin, New Jersey

Great take out plain & pepperoni pizza and oily delicious garlic knots... mmmm mmm mm! The crispiness, cheese and sauce balance is superb. A really well prepared, delightful smelling and perfect texture pizza. read more

Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Garlic Knots, so good and buttery! The marinara sauce is a great compliment. - Pizza Near Me - Manahawkin, New Jersey

My first time there -they couldn't be nicer and the pizza Is awesome! Terri loves!! read more

Pizza and their crispy wings are amazing. My husband loves the cold antipasta salad. Summer weekend's, it can get busy and have up to 1.5 hours to get your order but I recommend. read more

Food this gem by chance...and WOW! Food was amazing! pizza, cheesesteaks and subs...all incredible! We will definitely be back

The pizza really is the best. Always get plain pie well done. From crust to cheese reminds me of pizza from north jersey. I think $14 for the large plain pie. Ive never had anything else from here and prefer takeout due to the place doesnt look so good inside. read more

Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Manahawkin, New Jersey

The pizza is literally the best!!! Wish they delivered though. This has always been my summer spot for years and years. Since moving here permanently I went all the time. But the last year or so I moved out of BHW and delivery is usually what we want when we get pizza since we think of it kinda last minute. But seriously the best around. It's delicious. Highly recommend. read more

My husband, dad and I went here for the first time 2 nights ago. I was a little hesitant on how good everything would be but we LOVED everything we had. From the chicken parm, to the baked ziti, to an eggplant sub, everything was delicious. We loved it so much we ordered take out the next night as well! The staff are so friendly and helpful. We already can't wait for our next order! read more

New to the area. Looked at Yelp for the highest rated pizza place. Anthony's had the best ratings. I gave them a shot with a meatball pie. It was bland. They put the meatballs under the cheese so you can't taste them as well. My friend, my wife and I all at the same time rated it a 6. Not bad, just wouldn't go back. Tried Joey's the next night. Lower rated place but that pizza was an 8. Only problem with Joeys is it is more expensive, but they do deliver. read more

Called and was placed on hold but with the phone on the counter. After helping a handful of counter quests and taking other phone orders I'm asked to hold again. Won't be holding for this place again. read more

I have eaten their Pizza many times before (very good) but just didn't feel like Pizza so ordered 2 meals, Lasagna and Linguini in a vodka sauce with chicken. We will never do that again. The Lasagna was pretty bad, i could have done better in 20 min by myself, tasteless, I threw half in the garbage. The linguini was just OK but the chicken was way over breaded, and I don't think it was all breasts. The place is clean and the staff friendly but for being Italian they certainly can't make good Italian dishes. Looks like we will be just ordering pizza for now on. 5 stars for the pizza and staff, 1 star for the dinners. read more

I have been coming for about 6 years; excellent pizza, plain, Sicilian, grandma you name it. By far the best in the area and close to an 8 nationwide. Give it a try you can't go wrong. read more

When I'm down in Manahawkin this is my favorite pizza joint. I found this place in high school as it was located close to an ex's house. She is long gone, but this joint still holds a place in my heart. The Sicilian pie here is the best I've had. The cheese is perfect, the sauce is tangy and just right, the crust is wonderful. They also have awesome cheesesteaks. The meat is so tasty. Their fries are good as well. For a small local place, they sure do taste big time. read more

I've been eating pizza here for probably close to 20 years. I've never been disappointed. The pizza is delicious. Great crust, great sauce and loads of cheese. Has that old time pizzeria feeling. The sandwiches are great too. Love this place. read more

Terrible pizza..Crust tasted like saltine crackers. Place is dirty and pizza sauce and cheese is kept uncovered in the soda cooler that is open to the public read more

Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria - The burnt pizza in the box when we got home. Right in the trash can - Pizza Near Me - Manahawkin, New Jersey

Always great pizza. Had a chicken cheesesteak hoagie tonight with hot peppers and it was delicious, the best I've had in years. Love that they have actual hot cherry peppers!! Kids can't get enough of their garlic knots either. Consistently good! read more

I was visiting Jersey for the weekend. Randomly found this place while in town and I'm so thankful that I did. Hands down one of the best pizzas I had in New Jersey. We ordered a large pepperoni extra crispy pizza and it was made perfectly. I couldn't put the pizza down, almost ate the whole thing by myself. It's been two weeks since I was there and I can't stop thinking about that damn pizza! read more

Pizza Pie with extra cheese is best pizza in ocean county call el prez the pizza guy. Subs are substantial. You can split the large one and be very satisfied. My favorite takeout in the area. Good old school NJ pizza joint, always good food and portions are more than fair. read more

Good local place. I got pizza and a chicken parm sub, both of which were solid and well-priced. Not extraordinary, but a good option if you're nearby. read more