Fratello&#x27;s Pizzeria

I ate at this Sorrento's about a year ago and the pizza was pretty good. So, I decided to not only…read morego back, but to also try their store in Pulaski as well to see if they are consistent. The pizza ordered in Adams was a half meatball, half hot peppers 18" pie. The crust was inconsistent with thicker, chewy parts towards the outer part, and very thin around the center, as if the dough wasn't stretched out enough. And, what was once a nice looking orange pie has become a soupy amalgam of gooey cheese and ok sauce. It was the exact same problem in Pulaski, way too much cheese that was concentrated around the center of the pie that gave the sauce zero chance of poking through. The cheese was not put on very evenly either. There was no magic between the sauce, cheese and crust. Just an average pizza by NYC standards. More like tomato fondue.

The greens and chicken riggies were very good. The service was excellent. Very efficient and kind…read morewaitress. Tired looking place but enjoyed the experience of this little town Upstate NY.

Cheese taking over the center of the pie like a tidal wave

Slice of hot peppers pie. Very cheap in the peppers

See all

Lost sauce hidden by too much cheese

Caffe Maya

3.5(8 reviews)

4.3 mi

The service was very good. Although we waited quite awhile for our food, everyone enjoyed their…read moremeal. I had a swordfish special that was excellent. It was a little noisy but they did adjust the music level.

Make sure you make reservations. Only have like 8 tables. But they fit us in. I chose chicken…read moreparm, it was $22.95, an extra $2 for spaghetti on the side . Ever hear of such a thing. But I purchased since no salad came with dinner. I received a spoon full for $2 . A box cost .88. We also purchased olives and cheese. Very salty. Was given free bread, very good Sauce was a sweet sauce. I personally do not like. But chicken parm was good. My husband ordered frog legs. He loved them but only got 4. I knew he was still hungry so I gave him the rest of my chicken parm. I was not taking home anyway. The ambiance was nice. The white curtains on main window with yellow water stains were not pleasant. Glad we tried the place but will not return.

See all

Trattoria Calabria

4.9(36 reviews)

7.5 mi

Trattoria Calabria in Utica was an experience from start to finish. Everything was amazing. The…read moreowner serves you family style and comes out to talk to you between every course, which made the whole night feel so personal and unique. The food was incredible the soup from the first course was actually my favorite, and then they just kept bringing out mussels, eggplant, meatballs, sausage... literally SO much food I could barely breathe by the end There were 17 of us and every single moment was a great experience. I will 100% be back and will be telling all my New York friends about this place. Definitely one of the most unique dining experiences I've had!

The chef is amazing. The food is beyond anything I have ever had. Especially the soup. This was…read morean eight course 5 star meal. I also like that you BYOB, so we brough a couple bottles of wine from home. This can really help you save a lot of money. The food was endless. It was like you are having Sunday dinner at your Italian grand mother's house. You need to make reservations a few weeks in advance. He is only open on Friday and Saturday. I really can't say enough. If you're in the Utica area consider yourself lucky to be able eat here. Great food in a unique setting.

Like walking into someone's living room.

See all

Ventura's Restaurant

4.4(96 reviews)

8.3 mi

First time patrons. 6 of us, we ordered everything from…read morepizza & shrimp, to veal & stuffed shells. EXCELLENT Service, Atmosphere, Food, Drinks & Desserts!!! I can't wait to return! We loved sitting at the round table, it definitely made our dining experience more pleasurable. Thankyou to all Ventura staff for the EXCELLENT time we had.

Good food. Good Service. Good Ambiance. Recommend asking to…read morebe seated in Francesca's section. Enjoy!

Tortellini alfredo

See all

Bocca Osteria

4.2(367 reviews)

24.9 mi

I had a very good lunch with a Salsicci panini. I was in town for a wedding and had spare time…read morebefore the fun madness begins. Great crusty ciabatta, nicely seasoned sausage (not spicy hot, well not for me! your mileage might vary), tasty chipotle sauce. It came with a house salad with a yummy lemon dressing. Discount for paying with cash!

We were in Cooperstown for several days and dined in Boca Osteria one evening. We had a salad &…read morepizza. Good food and quick service.

I don't usually take photos of restrooms but this was was quite nice! Super clean, great appliances, cool wall treatment.

Fiorentino Panini

See all

Crostini

Joe's Restaurant

4.8(28 reviews)

8.1 mi

I have not been to this restaurant in over 20 years. The atmosphere was just as I remembered. Same…read morebar, decor, same menus on wall. I literally felt like I stepped back in time in the best possible way. They are only open Tuesdays & Saturdays. I went with a coworker for lunch and the place was packed. Not a spot at the bar and only a couple tables open lucky for us. Everyone was the NICEST! Service could t have been better. We ordered the spaghetti & meatball which comes with a whole loaf of breads with 2 cokes for $24. Sauce was outstanding and we ate most of the bread. Can't wait to go back to try the vodka riggies & eggplant parm!!

This restaurant and bar has been a Utica staple for many years and is also fondly known as…read morePellettieri Joe's, thanks to its location at the corner of Jay Street and Pellettieri Street. Dating back to 1910, calling this place an icon is truly an understatement. I've been coming here for years, although I have to admit it had been a couple of years since my last visit. With my upcoming move out west, this was at the very top of my Utica bucket list. There are just some places that hold too much history and too many memories to leave town without visiting one more time. A little heads-up: While the bar is now open multiple days a week, the kitchen is currently open only on Tuesdays and Saturdays. Nothing fancy here, but you'll find good Italian food steeped in history, tradition, and a genuine love of food. I do have to admit, though, that I miss the family who used to run this restaurant. The granddaughter was the server, another family member ran the bar, and two elderly gentlemen handled all of the cooking. It was truly a family affair. Back in the day, they even sold meats by the pound from the basement. Those days are sadly bygone, and unfortunately, the restaurant has changed hands several times over the years. While they have kept many of the traditions and familiar touches intact, I do feel the Italian gravy/sauce has changed. Personally, I'm not a fan of the new sauce and definitely miss the old recipe. They still bring a partial bag of fresh-baked Italian bread to the table ... no butter, and don't bother asking for it! Cash is still king here, so come prepared. It may have changed over the years, but if you want to experience a little piece of Utica and enjoy a meal steeped in Italian history and tradition, this is still a place worth visiting. Some restaurants are more than just a meal, they're a piece of the community's story.

Bar

Antipasto

See all

Peppers

Ripepi's Restaurant

4.6(16 reviews)

18.7 mi

In the area for a few months helping out family, they suggested Ripepi's for a birthday dinner…read more Reservations are preferred since it is a small place with few staff. Very friendly staff, however, and nice ambience (old-school but comfortable). Had so much food-the fried zucchini were absolutely delicious, baked lasagna was huge (and came with soup and salad), special of the day was lemon parsley haddock with lots of side options, and a birthday treat of cannolis and strawberry rhubarb pie. Be aware they are a cash only place. Will go again, have to work through the menu!

Buddy and I were headed to Watkins Glen for the NASCAR weekend and stopped for dinner off the…read morerecommendation from a nice local we met at a brewery and we can both honestly say it was some only the best Italian food we've ever had! Highly recommend if you're in the area!!

Homemade Italian

All that's left

See all

Stuffed Peppers~

Nicolettas Italian Cafe

4.1(169 reviews)

24.4 mi

The restaurant had an inviting interior and good jazz background music. The food portions were…read morequite large and came out quickly. The Italian bread was fresh, warm and very tasty. There were many shrimp in the Scampi along with fresh asparagus, broccoli, spinach, capers and garlic. The chicken was cooked perfectly and tender. The sauce was delicious. The owner was very pleasant and nice to deal with.

Very nice ambiance, great service, good wine list. Solid Italian meal…read more I had the chicken Marsala wich was plentiful and well done the wife had linguini with clams also very well done

See all

DeSalvo's

4.1(27 reviews)

22.9 mi

This is such a great spot. Everyone was very friendly and we had great service even tho we had a…read morevery large party. The atmosphere is good and the food is amazing. I've never seen mozzarella logs so huge or delirious in my life. My burger was perfectly cooked and juicy and the bacon on it was huge and so good. Highly recommended. I look forward to returning.

Few choices of Italian in Rome NY - picked this one on a whim while staying here for USPHL HOCKEY…read moreNATIONALS. Lovely greeting and recommendations from Margaret our waitress- forgot to take photo of gigantic meatball and salads that we had for appetizers. Enjoyed house wines with friendly service. Solid dishes at a local Italian joint. They have 28 beers on tap. I say try it for yourself and definitely ask "what would you recommend?" Chicken Sinatra was the winner of the two dishes both were very tasty!

Bar

Sandwiches

See all

Entrance

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jessie W.

2 years ago

I debated leaving this review, the only reason I'm giving a two is because the food was still good. I don't ever leave restaurant reviews, and I am not trying to ruin a small business by any means. I've been eating at Fratellos for years but I think I am done now. I've never felt so unwelcome in a restaurant. But the waitress/bartender Kayla really needs an attitude adjustment. She acted so bothered at the fact we even walked thru the door. And was complaining that people were even coming in to eat because of the heatwave. We were out of drinks most of the time, never checked on us after we got our food, didn't even give us plates for our apps. We had to eat them over napkins. We didn't even wanna ask for plates because of her attitude. When she brought the check, didn't say a single word, not even a thank you. I still feel like the $3 tip was being too generous. Do better Fratellos! read more

Joseph A.

2 years ago

Where do I start of why I love Fratellos! The food, the pizza, the wings, the everything is just what I want in a hometown joint. But what really puts the icing on the cake for me is the owner Brian and the entire staff. They are the nicest, most welcoming people you will ever come in contact with. They make you feel at home, which in turn just makes the food even better! read more

Jane D.

12 years ago

best pizza and wings in the county . we order from them almost every Friday. my kids love there pizza. we give them 5 stars !!!!!!!!

Fran S.

2 years ago

The Chicken Riggies and Chicken parm were great, gotta get back there to have it again

Emily L.

100

12 years ago

Dishonest owners rude and would not honor a gift certificate I had

Fratello's Pizzeria - italian - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Frankfort, New York Things to Do near Fratello's Pizzeria

BEST of Frankfort, New York Restaurants near Fratello's Pizzeria

BEST of Frankfort, New York Desserts near Fratello's Pizzeria

BEST of Frankfort, New York Coffee near Fratello's Pizzeria

BEST of Frankfort, New York Pizza near Fratello's Pizzeria

BEST of Frankfort, New York Dinner near Fratello's Pizzeria

BEST of Frankfort, New York Shopping near Fratello's Pizzeria

BEST of Frankfort, New York Breakfast near Fratello's Pizzeria

BEST of Frankfort, New York Wineries near Fratello's Pizzeria

Best of Frankfort

Things to do in Frankfort

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Fratello's Pizzeria also viewed

Lombardo's Pizzeria Plus II

3.3

(15 reviews)

Had a couple of cheese slices. Let me start by saying that our uncle owns a pizzeria in the Bronx…read morethat I have loved since before I married my husband. I compare all pizza to his. This compares! The pizza was thin/medium with the crust perfectly crunchy with soft fluffy dough in the center. Met the owner Joe and he was so hospitable and welcoming. We had a couple good laughs. It was my first time here and I had no idea how big this place is! He showed us around. I wished I lived closer because I would definitely consider this place for parties like graduation etc. my sons going to school in Utica so I'm sure he'll be back with a bunch of his friends and big appetites! I found out about this place through some camp friends who frequent this place. I better thank them. I forgot to take a picture before. I only got the after and the since we got to go!

My family and I arrived here after a trip on Erie Canal Cruises and at the recommendation of my…read moresis's bf, who had heard fantastic reviews and that the majority of his co workers went to. I ordered a chicken club with bacon, my sister got her and my Dad an upside down pizza, my sis bf got chicken wings with hot sauce and we all shared from a sampler platter and garlic knots. The food was absolutely fantastic. My order was accidently given to another patron on accident and a whole new order was made. Hey, accidents happen and I purposely was calm and had no intention to adding to the service industry woes of bad customers being entitled and treating wait staff like shit during these pandemic times. The woman repeatedly apologized and my patience was rewarded as the server brought over my sandwich she said she overstuffed it, especially with bacon...so much so I only had one half of the sandwich and saved the rest for another dinner! The food was absolutely fantastic...the garlic knots, the platter and the wings got rave reviews. My Dad thought there was too much tomato sauce...can you imagine an ITALIAN saying that...my sis and her bf liked the leftover slices so to each their own In any event, the service and food were absolutely impeccable. The server was attentive and nice. I highly recommend!

North End Pizza and Tap

3.3

(23 reviews)

My first time visiting North End Pizza since it changed from Leo's. My order of a large sausage,…read morepeppers, and olive pizza was perfect--delicious seasoning and a crisp crust just the way my family likes it. I could not have made a better pizza in my 750 degree oven at home...and I have made a bunch of pizza in the last 30 years for friends and family.

Crappy pizza, ok wings, terrible service/atmosphere. The bar area is tiny and they like to serve…read moreonly their regulars. I've been before and it took 15 minutes to get a new drink while some drunk old guy just yelled at the bar tenders and got served several times. They also like to mess up order and sometimes, just simply not make pick-up orders. Not worth the money, don't bother.

Parkway Pizza

3.5

(22 reviews)

It taste very good but sadly it closed down I had a great time all of us loved it i think that it…read morewas a 5 stars

Parkway Pizza is a shop with plenty of selection in a good location in East Utica. Parking lot is…read moresmall but plenty of seating inside. Unfortunately we did not have the greatest experience on our visit. We ordered two pizzas and wings "to go" for 6pm. We arrived on time our food was almost 20 minutes late. Makes me worried that they forgot about our order and us arriving and asking for it reminded them they had to make it. The taste was also lack luster. Wings were a disappointment and pizza did not have the Utica charm we were looking for. It was overly greast and frankly just boring. I did notice they had a drive thru which was very unique! They had a hard ice cream booth down the hallway which was dark and filled with supplies... not sure what is going on with that. My experience is one that will not drive me back as a customer. However, not terrible enough to tell others not to give it a chance.

Pizza Plus

3.6

(14 reviews)

We just had a great fresh haddock fish fry and it was delicious!! It was our first one from this…read moreestablishment and it definitely will not be our last.

A go to several times a week and the food is always great! Best pizza place in north Utica area IMO!read more

DiCastro's Brick Oven

3.5

(120 reviews)

Absolutely delicious! This time was just antipast with Jimmy's homemade dressing along with…read morepizzas...Bee Sting pizza highly recommended!!!! Dough is so good, everything homemade and out of this world!!!!

Should not be a pizza place. But if you want the best Italian food this side of the Atlantic, go…read morehere. All the pasta and sauces and well everything is made in house and sourced locally. The best Italian food I've ever had outside of Italy itself. I've had many dishes here and it's my go to spot on date night. I don't know why they try so hard to turn into a pizza place. It doesn't make sense to me when they should stick to what they are best at. Highly recommend the lobster Mac, beef stroganoff, gnocchi, and anything with the homemade pasta. The chicken parm is out of this world and the portions are huge!

Slice Pizzeria

3.1

(107 reviews)

Had a friend stop over with a pizza and it was horrible. I wouldn't feed that to a dog.read more

New to the Utica area for work wanted some pizza and got HUGE slices. Cheese and purple cow (think…read morebuffalo chicken) problem is purple cow was LOADED with chicken very fully and good, cheese was very good too. Young lady at the counter was great at helping me figure out what purple cow was and even told me I may want just the one slice as they are big and loaded. Wasn't kidding. Good food and will be back!!

Lorenzo’s Pizzeria

3.2

(6 reviews)

Ordered a large garlic pizza and medium wings for take out. Said 25-30 and it was ready as…read morepromised. The place was super busy but friendly service. The garlic pizza had great crust and perfect garlic flavor. The wings were crispy and had plenty of sauce. Decent amount of meat on each. Not sure if celery and blue cheese is included or not as my Dad who picked it up declined thinking it was an up charge. Will definitely be back!

Great food and freindly service. When we arrived we were…read moregreeted with a smile and even though they were quite busy they took the time to explain their most popular menu items!

Franco's Pizzeria

3.2

(23 reviews)

Food is very good service is very good I get all my food delivered on time with friendly people…read moreI've been getting my food from Franco's for a very long time will for many more years to come !!!!!

What happened to this place? For real! It used to be hit or miss, but these days it's just miss…read moreafter miss after miss. Attention to detail is completely lacking. Subs with missing toppings, wrong toppings put on pizzas. Today they forgot my toppings and had to rebake the pizza, and it was so late and not even an apology.

Venice Pizzeria

3.5

(110 reviews)

We went for lunch today and had no problem finding 2 seats at the bar. The place is clean and…read morecomfortable, with a small dining room, too. I ordered the half portion of chicken riggies, which are some of my favorite in the area. The serving size for even the half was big, and I had enough leftovers for another meal. The garlic bread that comes with it is also excellent. My dining partner ordered some medium wings and reported they were also great; they came with a decent amount of sauce. I noticed a fried bologna on their menu, which I was tempted to try, but that'll just have to be for next time!

The cheese pizza was good, unique flavor. Place itself was not super clean. I saw a few people…read morestruggling to find a place to eat and finding a table that was decent.

Pizza Boys

3.2

(103 reviews)