This is and will always be my favorite/ best pizzeria! They make such good authentic pizza and their grandma slice is out of this world. The people that work here are so kind and welcoming. Can't wait to go back! read more

I was in my hometown after taking care of some personal business. I was in the mood for a slice, so I stopped here. It's a REALLY small establishment with just a few tables, & most taken up by Massapequa HS students, just a very short distance away. Cut to the chase, they serve a really nice & large slice at an average price for 2025. I would come back. read more

I stopped in at Fredo's today for a couple of slices for an early dinner. As usual, they did not disappoint. I got one Sicilian and. E regular slice, asked for just warm. It was taken out to perfection. The Sicilian slice is thick but not overly bready with an excellent crust and cheese layer that stays on the slice while you eat and not sliding off. The regular slice was just right, crust with just enough crunch and great cheese and sauce ratio. While there I noticed a stuffed slice that looks amazing and will def be going back for that. So many great options on their menu as well from sandwiches to meals. I would def recommend Fredo's for some quality Italian food and friendly customer service read more

We had a post holiday family gathering this past weekend. We ordered full tray of chicken francese. It was absolutely delicious. 20/10 would absolutely order again! Thanks guys, it was a hit! read more

Best pizza or anything you order. Everyone is very friendly and is a pleasure to go there, have a chat and witness great food.

Not only do they have gluten free but the first pizza place to give a designated pizza cutter declaring its GF, and in a metal tin to not cross contaminate with the cardboard box as it has gluten in it. Absolutely amazing. They did more than the bare minimum to keep those of us with the allergy/intolerance safe read more

Fredo's Pizza & Pasta - 12" Gluten Free Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

I won't even take the time to leave a detailed review. There were bugs in my salad.... Multiple BUGS. I do not even want to know how unsanitary this place is along with their food. They need a health inspection immediately. Fyi; wash your greens before you serve it to customers. Disgusting. read more

Fredo's Pizza & Pasta - a bee on a piece of fabric - Italian Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

The garlic knots are to DIE for. Pizza slices are so good and love the sesame crust. I come here often and like it. read more

Best Pizza this side of the Mississippi - delicious & the garlic knots are outta this world, outrageous ! Mostly take out business & high schoolers lunch/locals Massapequa. Parking is not the greatest though read more

The wait time is very very long and they promise you five minutes and you end up being there at least 20 minutes. I noticed them being very rude to an Uber delivery driver also. read more

Just meh. Pizza was okay but not very warm when I got in only 30 seconds after leaving oven. Pasta was decent. Man working the counter was snarky, and one slice with an order of pasta with marinara was over $20. read more

Fredo your my pizza & I love you but don't ever make me pick slices against the family again! One of the best cheese slices in Massapequa & the square slice was crispy not doughy & I love that! read more

See all

Ordered half a regular pie, half chicken Caesar pie. The regular half was pretty average. The chicken Caesar half was good but I'm not crazy about too much ranch because it makes the slices soggy. read more

Fredo's Pizza & Pasta - a pizza in a box - Italian Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

I'd recommend not ordering from here unless you're ready to lose money and be berated while doing it. Today we called to request a special order wrap which was my first mistake. They asked a million questions and we answered everything single question they asked and was very clear about what we wanted. When we brought it home the wrap wasn't cut in half so I cut it myself. Once I cut it the whole thing fell apart and had dressing when they insisted the dressing would only be on the side. It was a mess. So we called and spoke to the manager, Henry, who was less than accommodating. The first phone call my husband made and Henry refused to remedy anything, instead just said "I'm not taking the loss," and hung up. I called a minute later so speak to him and all Henry said was I always complain and have problems with orders there which isn't the case. 2 weeks ago I ordered a pie "well-done" and it was burnt but did I complain? No. But this was inedible. Instead, we just brought it back and left. Out almost $15 because Henry was too prideful to admit the kitchen messed up or because he expected me to eat a wrap like a burrito I guess. read more

Fredo's Pizza & Pasta - Wrap after I cut it that I was told wouldn't have dressing in... - Italian Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

First time trying Fredo's . Speedy delivery and the pizza was warm & delicious. Caesar salad very fresh and dressing was quite good all in all will try again !! read more

Fredo's Pizza & Pasta - Caesar Salad - Italian Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Inconsistent is the word. I've ordered pizza here and was great but this past Saturday was not so good. Didn't seem like a fresh pie. With so many options around, I was hoping to find my goto spot for pizza. I guess I will keep looking... read more

The sesame seed crust is my absolute favorite. Sandwiches are good and delivery is always quick and the people are nice. read more

I have ordered from Fredos's many times. Today I was hosting with my family over. We ordered hero's and pizza. We were told that the order would be done in 25 minutes. My niece gave them 10 minutes more than that and waited in the store for over 30 minutes. People here were anxious and hungry. I did something that I normally do not do. i called to complain. I was handed to the owner who gave me a lame excuse that some of the slices took more time than usual. The sad thing is the my nieces said that these old fashioned slices were COLD!!! I used to LOVE Fredos. Now it is doubtful that I will order from them again. My name is Jim. They know who I am. read more

There are few guarantees in life. Death, taxes, and the delivery guy from Fredo's won't have a pen with him. It's a shame cause it's the best slice by me but they go to hand you the pie and you gotta go get a pen. Get a clue. read more

Got delivery with a group of friends, came on time and the pizza was excellent. We got a chicken bomber pie which has a couple different cheeses, chicken, bacon and a thousand island dressing. It sounds overwhelming but is very tasty. Really good stuff, going to try some other slices soon. Impressed thus far. read more

Just ordered for the first time and it's delicious! The pizza was cooked perfectly and the dough was soft and not burnt . The panini was so fresh and the bread was delicious. Highly recommend ordering from here ! read more

Best pizza place on Long Island everything is so good the caprese hero rice ball parm and pizza are delicious and also the penne alla vodka with shrimp their salads are delicious as well definitely stop by here if you have not been!! read more

Stopped here after a soccer tournament - got pizza (personal and individual slices), chicken calzone, and pasta with chicken & broccoli raab. All were delicious, portions were generous (even too large - especially the calzone). Excellent friendly service, clean inside. If we were local we would definitely return! Thanks Fredo's!!! read more

I ordered a anti pasta salad and it was nothing but a garden salad with cold cuts American no olives no artichoke no peppers nothing but ham and provolone the worst anti pasta salad ever I had to add all my own stuff this should me called a Cobb salad at best read more

Fredo's Pizza & Pasta - Italian Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

My son in law bought us a Grandmas Pizza for the New grandma after the birth of my new grandson . It was super delicious . We also got a dozen garlic knots that were to die for . Finger licking good !! Cant wait to go back to visit them on Long Island . We will definitely be getting more of that !! yumm read more

Im all about supporting local businesses but These guys will rob you blind and so rude. Pizza is so bad as well. 100 pizza businesses that do the right thing with better pizza in the area, trust me and stay away from here PLEASE!!!!!!! read more

Can't say enough about this place it looks like a simple Pizzeria they do have a limited seating, but it's more than just a pasta heroes and pizzas they have full dinners and everything was delicious fresh tasty very good Italian food gave this place 10 stars if I have to, you are such a nice guy that he gave me some complementary pepperoni garlic knots , Stop by you won't regret plenty of public parking in the back I regret I didn't take any pictures read more

Very impressed. Last night I came across Fredos pizza on google trying to find a new pizzeria to get from. Decided to try it out. My girlfriend and I got a regular pie, garlic bread, fried ravioli and rigatoni alla vodka. Alla vodka was incredible. Pizza was one of the best around that area. Ravioli was crispy and hot still when I brought it home, and the garlic bread was perfectly spread on. The dipping sauce was pretty good also. Most places their sauces taste like burnt caned sauce. Can't forget about the employees. The gentleman that helped me in the front was very nice. He saw me looking around at the house pies they had and probably realized I was a new customer and handed me a menu before I left with my order. Great service. Definitely will be back read more

I got the margherita pizza and it was amazing! It had such great flavor. The only reason I'm giving 4 stars and not 5 is because it was a bit in the salty side. You can clearly taste that someone accidentally over salted the sauce. I'd still order it again. read more

I like Fredos! We get the dinners. Happy with baked clams, chicken piccata and Parmesan. Comes with nice bread. Not as much money as other Italian spots. read more

A must for anyone seeking great pizza and a fair price. They have their specialty pizza's that are an entire meal for under $5/slice. A chicken bomber will have so much chicken you can barely see the bread and it is great quality. Just as important, the staff treat their customers like family. read more

Best pizza in town hands down. The regular pie is cooked to perfection, not too much not too little. Its got a great soft crust while packing a powerful flavor on the pizza side. Sauce is really tastes and the pizza is great and cheesey. I also recommend any special slice. They do a sesame crust which creates for something a little more. Chicken rolls are huge and totally affordable for a great meal. Garlic knots are also big and very flavorful. All in all this is the best pizza spot around. They always seem to be rolling out pizza, tons of orders to be filled. They manage to do it all within a reasonable time as well. Usually 15 to 20 mins my pizza is ready to be picked up. The pizza maker, Henry, is also unbelievably friendly. I am a frequent visitor and recommend you all become the same. read more

The pizza is great perfect mix of cheese and sauce, the dough is crispy. They have specialty pies as well. They also have soups of the day the potato is amazing. They have pasta dishes that average but still hit the spot. Seating in minimal this is defiantly a take out or delivery spot. read more

I don't love fredos pizza but I order it bc my bf likes it - well after tonight never again. The delivery boy spoke down to me and was extremely rude. He yelled at me and spoke to me like I was a complete idiot. Called fredos to let them know and they didn't care. They've lost my business. read more

Best tasting pizza on the island... flavorful robust sauce melt in your mouth cheese... oh wait you aren't craving regular slices well they have specialty slices for just about anything you are craving. Personal favorite eggplant ricotta slice. Don't want pizza well then get yourself a hero or an extremely generous pasta bowl. read more

My go to place for old fashioned slice which is like a grandma but sauce on top and crispy crust. Yum!!! Their garlic knots are encrusted in garlic just how I like them. Check them out! read more

Fredo's is a great pizzeria!! Their grandma and regular pies are family favorites!! The staff is friendly and so generous. Fredo's is a staple in our house! read more

Love this place. My friend recommended me to go this place for pizza if I'm ever nearby. It was totally worth the experience. I only ordered the cheese slice but if it's regular slices are this good . I can't imagine what the rest would taste like. Wish I could give more then 5 stars. read more

I work across the street and we get lunch here almost everyday. The vodka sauce is delicious, I usually get it on the rigatoni al la vodka. My other favorite is the white slice, the crust is just better than anywhere else. Service is usually pretty good, we get delivery and there always here pretty quick. read more

Seriously AMAZING !!!! I have never had a pizzeria make such 5 star food ! Literally everything in this pizzeria IS DELICIOUS !!! Small , super clean and such a nice staff . Highly recommend Fredos on Merrick road in Massapequa for take out or eat in . They also make THE BEST GRILLED CHICKEN SALADS !!!I'm hooked read more