Probably one of the cheesiest pizzas I've ever eaten! They really pack it on. We went with the house special pie. This thing was loaded with toppings. It's like they took an entire bucket and just started pouring it on top. Generous portions of sausage, pepperoni, peppers, onions, and mushrooms on a nice, flavorful sauce base. Everything was buried under a giant layer of cheese. The crust had a good chew and crisp edge without being too doughy or thin. Everything tasted fresh and well-seasoned. The toppings were fresh, the sausage had good flavor, and the meatballs added a nice texture. It was a hearty, classic "everything" pie that easily fed two of us with leftovers for at least a day or two. The chicken roll was tasty too. Crispy on the outside, with juicy chicken and cheese inside. Came with a side of sauce that was perfect for dipping. Portion size was satisfying for the price. Friendly service, quick pickup, and overall a reliable spot for good Italian food and pizza. I'll definitely be back to try more of the menu. Highly recommend it if you're in the area! read more

Bella Vista Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

Not bad, not great. Good when a better pizzeria is closed, if you live close by it a fine pizza to pick up for a lunch or dinner.

The food is always good. The shop is good and they deliver. It's a friendly pizza place.

Their pizza crust and the sauce is tasteless . if you add red hot pepper, that is mild and tasteless as well. Atmoshere not inviting. Sadly we have experienced the owner humiliate customers and his staff. Our friends and I will never return. The son never learned to follow in his dad's foodsteps. He wa a gentleman and a gem. l read more

Look at the pic. The drippy pizza had me all googly eyed. The crust was good, the pepperoni some of the best I have ever had. And at $28 for the pepperoni pizza, it's not a bad price. Why only 4 stars... the cheese. This was the worst quality cheese. I still had 1/2 a pizza left over 2 days later and that never happens. I just couldn't get past the cheese. read more

Bella Vista Pizza & Pasta - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

Personally don't think this is the best pizza around but good if you get a fresh pie. Oftentimes get reheated slices from the front and those are nothing too special especially for the area. Ambiance is not great either but fine for a quick slice. read more

Best all around consistent slice in the area. By far. Not to belittle the competition. There's a lot. Many very good. Some even better, sometimes. However this place does it again and again. read more

Made me wait for 30 extra minutes without so much as an acknowledgement that they were behind or where they were with my pick up order. Dude laughed when he noticed i was waiting. Disappointed. read more

Pizza is always doughy. Same with chicken rolls. I go for convenience but nor any more

One of the first places l went to moving in the area. No daily specials offered that l can tell, but l never hesitated to run in for a delicious pie when in the area read more

Hands down one of the best grandma pies I have had. The sauce and the crust and that fresh mozzarella. Well down Bella Vista. Keep up the good work. read more

Bella Vista Pizza & Pasta - Grandma pie - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

You know what pisses me off? Work trips to New York. I barely eat anything that isn't green or healthy but then I come here and boom! Somethings gotta be in the air cause I end up eating naughty food. I been bloated since I arrived it was like my body knew I was going to feed it pizzas and bagels. Anyway this isn't about me and my bagel hips it's about this spot, I inhaled the eggplant sub AND the grandma pizza slice to myself. It was cheesy and soft and the bread had sesame seeds . It's a cute little spot in a plaza with plenty of parking great amount of seating and the staff appears friendly along with their prices. 5 stars! read more

Bella Vista Pizza & Pasta - a sausage and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

I honestly think that they were OK. They seem like the epitome of small business doing their best doing to serve their customers and doing what they love. I like that the most about their establishment. I'd say their pizza is good enough to warrant a repeat visit. I would definitely like to try their pasta and other dishes, since it smelled really good. I wish the owners good luck and success. read more

Big shout out to Bella Vista for always supporting so many clubs in our community year after year. POBots and Plainview Little League appreciate your support! Great place to visit for pizza and other Italian specialties....and btw, thanks for the zeppoles. They were terrific! read more

It's very hard to be wowed by pizza as a New Yorker and I can't help but notice that old school pizzerias have gone downhill. Bella vista was so good and authentic. One of the best plain slices I've had in a really long time. read more

Ordered a buffalo chicken roll after one of my friends highly recommended it. I'm not sure exactly what makes a perfect buffalo chicken roll, but this wasn't my favorite. Their roll is good, very filling and very heavy. The dough in the roll I think wasn't fully cooked, which gave it a great texture but a lot of thickness and heaviness. If you're looking for a rich buffalo chicken roll, this roll is for you. read more

Bella Vista Pizza & Pasta - Buffalo chicken roll - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

We've been trying a few pizza places in the area looking for a solid plain and grandma pie, Bella vista had the best. Hope they can keep their quality standards high so we can keep getting good pizza! read more

Very hearty slices Not to thin or thick Real New York pizza Great taste Awesome white slices read more

The Za at this pizzeria is highly average. Crust is chewy, not crunchy; cheese is tasty and thick; sauce is nothing to write yelp about. There is an Umbertos down the road, way too close to choose to eat here. Had I known this I would have chosen differently. read more

This is a hidden gem! It doesn't have a fancy dining room. But you should absolutely try their pizza. 18 inch pie. Great flavor. My kids love it. My new go to place for pizza night. read more

Bella Vista Pizza & Pasta - Pepperoni pie. Kids stole a slice before pic :) - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

Love this place. I live right across the street. I'm in love with their grandma's pizza. The food is delicious. Shrimp scampi is my favorite. And their garlic knots are so garlicky. I usually get a dozen and eat them all myself in way under 2 days. It is my go to place for pizza and pasta. Check it out. You won't be disappointed. read more

Easily one of my favorite buffalo chicken pies around. They use BIG chunks of chicken. Always cooked perfect and the right amount of spice. The crust is soft yet crunchy. Never disappoints! Their other pizzas are good too but I keep coming back for the buffalo chicken. I used to work in the area and every Sunday I would stop in, get a "personal" buffalo chicken pie and head to work. One of my fondest memories of working there haha. I say "personal" because you could probably feed 2 people with it. For $12 or so it's an incredible deal. If you're looking for a great buffalo chicken slice I highly recommend this place. read more

See all

Good service. Great food! Store also has enough space for a few families or individuals to sit down and eat.

With so man, the pizzerias are Long Island. I always return to Bella Vista. The food is fresh and well prepared, their pies never disappoint whether regular, Sicilian, or anyone of their specialty pizzas. We especially love the eggplant and broccoli or, if you're more adventurous, ask for the house special. if you want something more substantial, the heroes are fantastic, especially the veal Parm or the meatball. The staff is great and their owner, George, will always take care of you. read more

Tried them for the first time this evening and the pizza was absolutely delicious. Guy who answered the phone was super patient and very helpful as well... Figured we'd start slow ... basic pizza and then got a pasta with garlic and oil. The portion of pasta could have fed an army !! Was delishhhhh. Pizza was perfectly cooked and crust and sauce had amazing flavor. I'll def def be back !! read more

Bella Vista has the best specialty slices, in my opinion. Every time I have ordered, our pizza had been prepared fresh and served hot. Their specialty slices are loaded with ingredients and giant. A slice by itself is a meal. Our favorites are the eggplant ricotta, buffalo chicken, and the chicken penne ala vodka. All of them are amazing, and when you order a pie you can do half and half if you want more than one kind. read more

This pizza was so delicious! I loved the thin crust and all the cheese. I also had the mozzarella sticks and they were just like the ones I used to get back home. Very yummy! read more

Amazing, extraordinary pizza! My son who eats very little wishes there was a Bella Vista on every corner so he could have it all the time! The owner is super nice! read more

Bella Vista has basically existed since the beginning of time, started up by a former Mario's employee who boasts of practically inventing the buffalo chicken ROLL. For seven bucks, you can get a doughy log stuffed with juicy buffalo chicken and plentiful amounts of melted cheese. f you're the least bit skeptical, I dare you to order one and not scarf down every last bite...heck, I've been doing that since 2001. Chicken awesomeness aside, this pizzeria is pretty OG with some damn good slices. The formica tables, tiled floor, and fluorescent lighting will bring you right back to high school, but the pizza will keep you coming back for more! read more

See all

We have ordered take out many times. Good food and great service. George is the best.

A standard small Pizzeria. I ordered a Grandma slice and my husband a pin wheel. I did ask for extra sauce which he put on. We brought our food to the table. To the side were plastic forks and knives. There were some larger garlic shakers there also. The salt and pepper shakers were on some of the tables. The Pinwheel was so overdone that my husband could not cut into it. But he struggled through as to not make a complaint about it. The pizza slice I had, was to say, ok. We bought (plastic) bottled drinks. The two men behind the counter were pleasant enough. Nothing else notable to say about the place or the visit. As my husband wanted to cut his pinwheel- Tip: ask at the counter if they have real forks and knives The man in the back got me one of each. Tip: anyone can make a mistake- make sure to count your change. read more

See all

The food was very underwhelming. The penne vodka tasted like canned sauce with sprinkling of cheese. And it taste like it was spoiled. No seasoning what so ever. The pizza was also very disappointing. Like how can you go wrong with pizza. This restaurant did. The salad looked like someone threw the whole ingredients on a chopping board, closed their eyes and began to chop the salad. Insane presentation. The chicken parmigiana again taste like all the ingredients came out of cans. Maybe it was the selection I was given. But I definite won't be returning. The garlic bread was nice tho. read more

Great food and a really good menu. Service is very good. They continue a tradition of good food from Bella Vista.

Best pizza, pasta & salad in Plainview & the prices are a little cheaper than the bigger pizzeria down the road. It has a very neighborhood feel about it like I remember when I was a kid. Their Greek salad is as good as any Greek restaurants! I'm addicted to their Grandma Pizza! read more

Bella Vista Pizza & Pasta - Always quick counter service! - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

What else to say but old world family style Italian dishes. Customer service is consistent each time im. Up in. this area. The baked pastas are phenomenal. Garlic bread, pizza, rolls and salads are made fresh daily and to. Order. Allergies?no problem. They got you covered. Ample parking, coupons in local fleet and they deliver! Try the sausage roll! Nonna would like it too read more

A true 3.5 star rating here, but I'll have to round down based on comparable pizza joints I've reviewed. Don't let that stop you from coming here. It fits the bill nicely if you're looking to satisfy a slice fix. The Good: -Yes, that buffalo chicken slice rocks. Get it. -A nice plain slice -Always a nice variety of slices available -Friendly staff -They mastered the art of keeping the slice in the oven long enough for it to be served hot. Why other places can't execute this is beyond me. The OK: -Lot's of slices means many of them have been around for a bit. Still good, but def not fresh. -The interior prob hasn't been changed since it opened. Not like you need a fancy place to crush a few slices, but still. -Parking lot is always full I always find my way back here and I enjoy it when I'm in the area, but do I go out of my way to dine here? Nah. read more

Bella Vista Pizza & Pasta - Buffalo chicken and eggplant veggie slices. - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

Super friendly , reasonable prices , large portions and good food . My family is never disappointed with Bella Vista , they are also very generous with the community sponsors , donating food during COVID and just being an all around great small business to support . Their Buffalo chicken rolls and penne a la vodka are the go to choices . read more

Amazing people and pizza Had the FORTUNATE experience of having car trouble while outside Bella Vista, greatest place to spend some time and munch on buffalo. Owner was amazing food was amazing ! They're charitable and it's always busy no stake slices sitting around. I love this place and you will too! read more

More of a solid 3.5 star pizza joint. Located in the Manetto Hill Shopping Center. Very good chicken marsala slice.......huge chunks of chicken makes it almost like biting into a hero. Regular pizza is good too. They have plenty of specialty slices to choose from. There are about 8 booths to sit down but it's not a huge interior and it seems like they run a very busy delivery service. read more

Bella Vista Pizza & Pasta - Chicken marsala slice. 8-12-2016 - Pizza Near Me - Plainview, New York

See all

This is near my work. Food always great. Typical very good NY pizza place. I have tried the pizza & other dishes. All were very good