Finally got to stop by this local ice cream shop. It was nice not having to track down the truck…read morethis time. The store itself is simple, with no seating inside. There's a small merchandise area where they sell hoodies, T-shirts, and even a toy ice cream truck. I noticed they had a large selection of ice cream and really appreciated the assortment of cones available. The prices were a little higher than I expected, but the customer service was good. They also offer a BOGO sundae special on Tuesdays, which I definitely plan to take advantage of in the future. For such a nostalgic company, though, I do wish they had some seating so people could sit, talk, and enjoy their ice cream with family and friends. Overall, it's a fun stop for a sweet treat, but adding a small seating area would really make the experience feel more complete.

Came for a late night sweet treat to celebrate my moms birthday! I was surprised how small the…read moreselection of ice cream is considering this is an ice cream shop. I went with the ice cream burger which comes with 4 kinds of ice cream so I did Cookie Monster, biscoff cheesecake, chunky monkey and I forget the last flavor but it's sandwiched between two waffle cone 'pattys' dipped in chocolate with sprinkles-it was huge and very tasty! My mom went with the ice cream nachos which was waffle cone 'chips' ice cream and she chose peanut butter sauce. This was just ok-the pb sauce tasted like skippy pb-it does not compare to Ralph's peanut butter sauce at all. There's no seating so we took it to go but the prices seemed ok for what we got.

Coyle's reboot!…read more Beautiful atmosphere - clean, open, and fun. A great place with plenty of room to sit and enjoy your cones. Homemade ice-cream with more flavors than I could count. I went with my favorite, coffee. Super fresh, creamy, and filled with flavor. The kids had milkshakes, chocolate ice-cream, Oreo ice-cream, and a ton of candy! I finally have a new favorite ice-cream shop!

The new space is so nice!!! Clean, wide open, just feels fresh. Service is still solid, and the ice…read morecream selection is always on point. We went with one of their sundae selections - Candyland. More my daughters speed, but I can't wait to get back and try some of the others.

Milky Ways is a dessert lover's dream! Not only is the ice cream top-tier, but the endless array of…read morepossibilities makes every visit feel like a new adventure. With so many cereal mix-ins, toppings, and flavor combos, you can get as creative as you want--there's truly something for everyone! What really makes this place special, though, is the fantastic staff. From the moment we walked in, they were welcoming, patient, and super helpful in guiding us through all the options. You can tell they genuinely love what they do, and their enthusiasm is contagious. The ice cream itself? Absolutely delicious. Whether you go for a classic combination or something totally out of the box, every bite is packed with flavor and nostalgia. If you haven't been to Milky Ways yet, you're seriously missing out. Great treats, amazing people, and endless ways to customize your perfect dessert--what more could you ask for?

My daughter absolutely love Milky Ways, if you not familiar with their style of ice cream let me…read moretell you. You pick a cup, cone or shake. Then you pick an ice cream, next you pick a cereal, which they blend the ice cream and cereal together after it's blended you pick a topping then a drizzle. The Staff is super friendly and very nice. Sometime the service can be slow but that's because they making the ordered to perfection. The store is very very clean. And each table has a game on it like, Guess who, connect four, tic tac toe and uno. Which makes the wait extra fun. It's not too pricey. Oh, and for my non dairy peeps. I was told today that they have a non dairy vanilla options.

Pretty good ice cream - my daughter got the strawberry cheesecake and I liked that more than my…read morewhite chocolate raspberry - I didn't know it had dark chocolate pieces inside and it was a bit too chocolatey for my liking. The waffle cones taste delicious highly recommend you get one. No complaints on the chocolate ice cream my hubby got. The prices are insane $9 and change for one scoop of ice cream in a cone or a medium in a cup.

There was wide selection, although I wish that there was some soft serve ice cream. The kids had a…read moregreat time sampling and trying the different flavors of ice cream and gelato.

I've been coming to Papa Mia's since I was a child (it was the closest spot we could safely ride…read moreour bikes to and spend our $5 weekend treat allowance) it was always here, Wendy's, or an ice cream truck. So every time I get to come back (which isn't as frequent) it's a throwback to my childhood; but the water and cream ices still hit the same. My go to is the mint chip. I mean for a couple bucks you can get a taste of youth. It's a small hole in the wall style shack off Montauk Highway across from the golf course, with outdoor only seating if that, but just has this must stop at vibe to it. There's always some high school or college students working there who are fun to talk to and have great personalities (and they have to with being in a non air conditioned shed for hours at a time haha) For what it is, a simple ice hut, it's exactly what you need it to be. The furthest thing from fancy, but the closest thing to the 90s.

Big ass bomb ices yo this place slaps always has always will classic ass flavors water backed ices…read moreso know they orginal as hell!

We Love Ralph's ! Usually always great experiences. I usually get chocolate fudge brownie with…read moreextra brownie. Only once did I get the extra and it was very stale. We sometimes get mint cookie crunch, peach, chocolate, cookie dough and all are great. They offer sundaes which are also very good. The staff is always so friendly and quick.

My daughter and I own stock in this Ralph's. They cannot keep the chocolate cookies and cream and…read morerainbow ices in stock.

My son and his friend wanted to go for ice cream and we usually go to Old Fashioned Ice Cream Shop…read moreon Straight Path. But they don't have indoor seating and I just got a new car 2 days ago. No way was I letting 3 teens in my car with ice cream. His friend recommended Coyle's off Sunrise Highway. I can't believe we've never stopped here before! It was all decorated for Christmas and had friendly old ice cream shop / diner vibes with plenty of booths and counter seats. It was empty because it was 5 pm on one of the coldest days of the year. They have a wide selection of homemade ice cream flavors, plus soft serve, waffle cones, waffle bowls, their own sundae creations, and ice cream cakes and other treats to take home. I got a cannoli and Irish cream cup, my son got pistachio, and his friend got mint chip and Nutella. My daughter got a hot chocolate that she also enjoyed. I'd say it's easily comparable to OFICS, but the seating and atmosphere takes it to the next level. We will definitely be back -- ideally when the weather warms up!

Coyles is a lovely old-fashioned ice cream shop that my kids and I love coming to! It's clean, tons…read moreof flavors, great friendly employees!

This is a nice little shop with fudge, candy, and ice cream. The latter is what brought us in (it's…read moresummertime), and they've got some slightly surly teens that are not excited at all to give you surprisingly large tastes their selection. You'll find your standard favorites, and a couple I've never heard of as well. I have to ask though...in what world is a "small" two scoops? This is the smallest size you have available? It's impossible to only scoop once in this shop? You're going to FORCE me to get both cookies and cream AND moose tracks? Obviously in a cone, because I'm not some sort of animal that eats ice cream with a spoon. Is this some sort of evil conspiracy to make me fat? Just so you know, if you did offer single scoops for slightly less money, then my wife and I would've gotten a cone each (more money for you) because I don't want to share anything with her ever. As it is, you probably ruined my marriage, Ice Castle.

The nicest place on the island! The girls working here are amazing, very friendly and helpful. I'm…read morenot a huge fan of ice cream so I was mostly focused on the fudge options. I tried a few options of the fudge and decided to go with the walnut fudge since it was the most delicious option. My friend got the birthday cake ice cream and said it was really good. They have a pretty big selection of ice cream flavors to choose from. Like many places on the island this place is cash only, the prices were pretty reasonable considering the quality. Overall this was a super cute spot with some amazing customer service, will definitely come back on my next visit!

A solid ice cream spot, lots of flavors. The ice cream had just the right consistency, creamy and…read morenot too icy. Pretty standard in terms of service and atmosphere. I will say the ice cream did seem a bit pricey relative to the size of the scoops and the quality. This was a bit more of a grab and go spot, since there wasn't really seating available, which seemed a bit weird for an ice cream shop. There was a bit of room outside, but that wouldn't do much good for half the year!

5 years ago I wrote a review for this place when it was Granny's and gave it 5 stars, raving about…read moreamazing it was. I moved away and just came back and went to stop in and get my favorite only 8 yogurt. I am honestly shocked at what a bad experience this was. I got a medium only8 chocolate frozen yogurt. I included the picture of what my ice cream looked like, it was soup, and didn't peak over the top of the cup. I even said to the girl who made my ice cream is this what it's supposed to look like and she said yes. I honestly asked again and she said yeah, this is the machine and what it is. The best part was when she told me it was $9.75 for this cup of soup with no toppings that didn't even swirl like normal ice cream. I actually said outloud omg are you sure that's the right price and she said yes and asked me if I was paying with a card. Really disappointing experience and I guess I'll have to find somewhere else to get my favorite yogurt.

If you're having trouble finding street parking keep a look out for free parking lots you can park…read morein. My friend and I were welcomed wonderfully by the staff. We got a table fairly quickly and were greeted by a wonderful waiter Dennis! He was sooo happy and greeted us with a smile! The food was DELICIOUS! The Troffolini was incredible! What made the sauce special was the sweetness of a pair. The baked clams were incredible! Not only did our main dishes look beautiful, but they tasted fantastic! A perfect place to catch up with a friend or go for a date! Thank you to everyone at Americano Pie Bar for their great service!

Attentive service and great value with generous portions. Perfect for casual dining and large…read moregroups. Excellent cocktails, and a huge beautiful bar. A neighborhood staple. Love the gf pizza options.