Awesome late lunch at Bella Napoli. I'm stuck with celiac disease but Bella Napoli has both pasta…read moreand rolls in gluten free options. I had shrimp parmegiana, steamed shrimp, and wow. So so good. Hubs had a small calzone ant it was nearly as big as his head. Great waitress. Nice casual vibe. Go there!

Stopped in here late on a Sunday evening. My fiancé and I got a large Stromboli and shrimp Alfredo…read morewith a crab dip bread bowl as an appetizer. Food was AMAZING, portion sizes were HUGE, and price was CHEAP! Our server Seth was 10/10, very friendly and polite! The entire experience and setting was perfect! Will be talking about the place to everyone I know!

This was a great afternoon stop for some yummy Italian food. Pizza was delicious and it was done in…read morea fire burning oven. We sat downstairs the stairs were a little narrow. The bathroom was clean too.

Stopped in while driving between home and my kid's college. I was super confused by the parking…read morelot and trying to figure out where the front door of the restaurant was. I don't know if it was the day (the day before Thanksgiving) or if the place is just that popular but it was pretty busy. The restaurant is in a converted home, so there are all these little rooms. We were seated in a "front" room with the bar space behind us. The dining room was tight and full of people but warm and welcoming and didn't feel too crunched. Our server seemed a little flustered. She was busy but was attentive. I had the chicken parm sandwich, my son had the chicken parm entree. The chicken was pounded evenly and not too thin, breaded and crunchy. The red sauce was a little sweeter than my tastes prefer but it was enjoyable, on good bread and I demolished it. The kid's pasta was a little softer than I usually make it. Overall, it was a good experience. Their location makes it likely that we'll stop here again.

Waiter was on top of his game and respectful of the fact I was there catching up with a friend I…read morehaven't talked to in quite some time. The food was GREAT! I had a blue cheese burger and some hot wings. Very tasty! The lighting was just right and everything very clean. Will definitely be back!

Stop in for lunch. It's on Main Street so you do have to find parking. The restaurant was fairly…read moreempty when we arrived. We ordered wings, fries and onion rings for the family to share. The food was fine, average but the staff definitely could have been more attentive to our table.

This is a pure takeout, which wasn't obvious to me up front but is fine. Cumberland has plenty of…read morenice areas to eat outdoors. They promise Buffalo style pizza, and I can't say I've ever been to Buffalo but there is a bit of an interesting spice mix going on in the pizza sauce, and they do offer a lot of bleu cheese, including as a salad dressing. A medium pizza was quite substantial and I struggled to finish it. The vegetable options for toppings were respectable and some were marked as locally sourced. The peppers I got were lightly pickled but the flavor worked well, and some mushrooms added more substance. Even the small sized salad was a pretty good size and it came with their house bleu cheese as well as some generic croutons. I probably got the best order I could here, and it was distinctive in quality and generous in portion enough that I could see why the place is a successful local institution.

Great food, great service, best subs and pizza shop in Cumberland. Simply a good choice.read more

What a difference since our previous visit. Service was outstanding, the food was served hot and…read moretasted delicious. Our server was friendly, kept our drinks filled, and checked on us often. The burger was fresh, hot, cooked perfectly and had a good amount of toppings. Furnishings are typical, they have a large tv showing "oldies" which I like. The atmosphere is pleasant and not noisy.

Stopped here for an AYCE pizza and wings buffet on a Friday. Was a large group, and only had a few…read morethings. Their wings looked large, and plenty of sauces - I tried the pepper pepperoni pizza, and the Buffalo chicken ranch pizza. Solid pizza - sauce on chicken was very spicy and had a nice kick. Service was good - they handled the large party well. Very friendly staff as well. Would like to stop back here and try more food.

Love that they serve pizza by the slide and full pies. Very much NY style pizza. Other great…read morepasta options on the menu!

I had little to no expectations stopping here for a weekend getaway, but this was some of the…read morebetter NY style pizza I've had in some time. The woman working the counter was not the nicest upon originally checking in (I was too early for the pizza and she made that clear to me), but the food made up for the dry attitude. I don't normally go for white pizza as well, and thought their version was spectacular and full of flavor.

One of the only pizza places in a large net that I haven't had. Doesn't look like much driving by…read moremany times but I like divey looking spots. Called ahead and ordered a pepperoni and philly steak pie. Somehow when it was all said and done I ended up spending $46 and I still have no idea why. Whatever. Upon opening the box I was pleasantly surprised. I usually can tell if a pizza is going to be good or not on first glance, and this passed the initial eye test. In terms of pizza - this is a VERY HEAVY style - fresh dough style - and reminded me of a homemade added pizza item on a bakery menu. The steak pizza was the same - made with ranch as the sauce and covered heavily with steak. With taste, the pizzas were good - I didn't have a really issue with them whatsoever. Very heavy and hard to really put away a lot of Slice's as I am known to do. I can tell you that the large is very filling and switching between the two I would say the pepperoni was my favorite, and the steak was a close second. The main issue to me was the pickup process and the confusion with charging me over the top.

My GPS map routed me through Salisbury for some reason. I've never been here before and never heard…read moreof the town. I happened to drive by this restaurant purely by accident. I thought to myself, "it's pizza, it will be fine." But wow! It was amazing! The flavor was outstanding and I had the choice of a thick crust. I could not believe how delicious this was. I would recommend visiting Salisbury PA if for no other reason than to get this pizza.

We're from out of town and recently bought a property in Berkeley Springs, so we've been working…read moreour way through the local restaurants. Honestly, most have been underwhelming, with only a few exceptions. Mythical Pizza was a very welcome plot twist. We happened to drive by and pulled in on a whim. Even from the outside, the place has personality. Inside, we were greeted warmly by who I think was either the owner or manager. She explained how everything worked, gave great recommendations, and immediately made the place feel welcoming. The decor is quirky in the best way: Bigfoot, aliens, cryptids, paranormal touches, and a little gift shop. It sounds like it could be too much, but somehow it works. If a pizza place and a roadside folklore museum had a charming baby, this would be it. The menu is surprisingly broad, with pizzas, specialty crusts, pastas, salads, folded breads, strombolis, wings, desserts, and more. Since there were too many interesting pizzas to choose from, I ordered the "Flight of the Squonks," three 5 inch signature pizzas. We tried "The Alabama White Thang," "Attack of the 50' Meatball," and "Sprout Man and the Masters of the Pizzeria." All three were genuinely very good, creative without being weird for the sake of weird, and the crust was excellent. We also had barbecue wings. The wings themselves were juicy, meaty, and well cooked. The barbecue sauce was fine, though next time I'd probably ask for sauce on the side and try another flavor. The place was packed, which felt like a good sign, and the energy matched the food: fun, unpretentious, and better than expected. After a disappointing meal elsewhere the day before, where the price point really wasn't justified by the food, Mythical Pizza felt like a small-town restaurant win. Great vibe, warm service, creative menu, and very solid food. Definitely coming back.

Visiting from out of town and hubby wanted wings and I didn't feel like cooking so we found…read moreMythical Pizza here on Yelp. From the second we walked in, it felt very welcoming and friendly. I've never seen so many wonderful pizza options on one menu. I wanted all of them! He had the Alfredo Parmesan wings and he said they were delicious. I chose a pepperoni roll (I hear it's a West Virginia thing) and it was very tasty with a boat load of cheese. I personally like a spicer marinara for dipping but it was still very good. The staff was super friendly and helpful finding me the right souvenir t shirt with the Mothman on it. Oh and we tried the tiramisu and boy howdy! It was Dee-LISH!!! Def worth a try.

Stopped here on a road trip from Ohio to Virginia with our vegetarian family of 8. We ordered the…read moreveggie pizza (with some customizations) and cheese pizza and both had a generous amount of toppings and cheese . Wonderful, honest staff who took time to understand our dietary restrictions. Added bonus, they self caught an error on the bill (that we would've overlooked) so we really appreciated the honesty. If you're in the area and in the mood for pizza, be sure to give them a visit!

Wife had the chicken parm sub and said it was the best she's had. I had the 1/2 lb meatball and…read moreseasoned fries. The sauce is very flavorful and the meatball was tender and delicious. Highly recommend!