Mythical Pizza

This was such a highlight of our visit to Berkeley Springs. We ended up spending hours here with…read moreour 5 year old twins, who just loved this spot. Located right along the river, it's a scenic place. The inside is equally as relaxing. We visited on a chilly day so my kids wanted to sit inside. We ended up getting a table, where they enjoyed drawing and using all the art supplies from the station inside the room. This unique business is a little grocery store with unique wines, gifts, snacks and other items you'd never imagine you could use, but suddenly seems like you need them! My kids were hungry, so I ordered them 2 personal pizzas. These were incredible. While they were frozen pizzas, the pizza was some of the best I've had. It was classic Neapolitan style with a delicious crust, cheese, topped with mico greens. My kids had a few bites but I feel like I ate more of their pizzas than they did! Inside the main dining room, they have a comfy couch, plenty of art supplies and other great toys to distract the kids. I'd highly recommend this spot. It will definitely be on our list of places to revisit when we come back to Berkeley Springs.

What a great discovery! Small but mighty selection of wine and beer. Super cute gifts and books…read more Sandwiches were really good! Service was welcoming and friendly. Great vibes!! Feel very lucky we found this excellent little cafe. Can't wait to visit again!

Salad with a scoop of chicken salad

See all

Lighthouse Latte

4.4(40 reviews)

Bread bowls. Amazing service and really kind people. Nothing more to say. J/K!…read more We ordered two breakfast sandwiches with sausage, egg and cheese, two bread bowls, one with sausage gravy and the other with egg, bacon, cheese and green peppers, and scrambled eggs, which came with toast. A green tea and a dirty chai latte. It was all super yummy!! Only change I would have made would have been a bit of a cheese sauce to help bind the eggs to the bread bowl. The staff were all so, so kind and checked in on us regularly The food came on little, cafeteria plates, cutlery in a little brown paper package with a plastic table covering that lets them set the holiday tone by putting a heart shaped tablecloth underneath just fit. Really a perfect small town brunch experience.

Happened to come across this place while going to the springs near by. This place is amazing!…read moreEverything is made to order. They have everything you could possibly want. Coffee,tea,boba, truffles, pies, breakfast and lunch. We had a blt sandwich, tomato soup, pie and some cookies. If you are in the area you should definitely stop by.

See all

Proof on Washington

4.7(66 reviews)

Absolutely stellar experience. The atmosphere of the restaurant is nice, our food came out quickly…read more(without feeling rushed). Our server was absolutely fantastic, she kept our waters filled and checked in just frequently enough without hovering or having us feel deserted. I feel terrible for not getting her name, but she was amazing. The food itself is absolutely delicious, my steak was perfectly cooked as was my husband's salmon. The vegetables and mashed potatoes were divine and the Brussels sprout app was perfectly crispy. I had the Liberty Lavender Lemonade as well - it was delightful. It was strong (which I prefer - kudos!) but well balanced and not overpowering. We're already looking forward to our next visit and I'm excited for our kids to come - it's rare to see a restaurant offer a kids menu with real food on it (not just frozen chicken tenders, Mac and cheese or pizza). My 6 year old loves real food - steak, salmon, shrimp, etc) so I'm excited to see how he likes the kids steak on the menu.

No-frills American restaurant with both indoor (including both dining room and bar) and outdoor…read moreseating The place is a little grimey, and when I came here for lunch out waiter was very odd as well Food is fairly strange. For example, my fiance got a chicken sandwich, but it came with ham and ranch as well. Also, I got a reuben and it came with bacon Fries are pretty good and kind of a mix between french fries and chips Water tasted funny as well

Bourbon pecan pie with ice cream

See all

Pork belly tacos

Morgan Tavern

3.6(32 reviews)

1.7 mi

I really enjoyed our family dinner at the Country Inn. A few years ago, we ate here and I thought…read moreit was just okay. On this latest visit, I really enjoyed our time. The restaurant is cozy and only has a few seating options in the main bar area. It's a nice atmosphere and we loved the booths. I ended up ordering exactly what I had when I visited a few years ago, which was the Chicken Christy. It's a delicious dish of chicken, topped with ham, cheese and heavy cream. The sauce is great, and the meal comes with multiple sides. I ended up getting sweet potato fries along witn a delicious salad and blue cheese dressing. My partner got the Philly Steak and Cheese. It wasn't quite as good as the real deal of a Philly cheesesteak, but he still enjoyed it. Our kids loved their meals, which was basically cheeseburgers. We were a little surprised they couldn't just do a basic pasta with sauce. But apparently, they don't have any tomato sauce at this place. Lastly, we enjoyed the great price on the wine. We ended up getting a bottle of red wine from Paso Robles, California. We love Paso. While we never heard of this particular wine from the region, it was really tasty and worth the price which was really reasonable. We would definitely come back. Just make sure you have a reservation in advance!

I had the fish and chips and my husband had a steak. The food was very good and the atmosphere was…read morecozy and relaxed. It is a small alcove outside the main restaurant in the hotel with a bar and wood paneled walls. The waitress was wonderful. We were definitely the youngest patrons but everyone was very friendly and welcoming!

Chicken Christy, a must order

See all

Cauliflower

The Naked Olive Lounge

4.1(106 reviews)

We were out on the motorcycles today and needed lunch. I figured just park and wander around until…read moresomething struck our fancy. We happened to park right across the street from this place. Looked at the menu and decided this was the place. We ordered the Imperial Crab Balls to start. They were perfectly cooked and loaded with real crab, sitting on top of toasted baguette rounds. Then we ordered the Shrimp Salad with Bacon sub. Roll nicely toasted, tons of shrimp, bacon with lettuce and tomato. It was almost like a po' boy, except the shrimp were sautéed not fried. And the garlic truffle potato chips! I would eat a whole bag of those gems. Our server was top notch and the ambience was perfectly funky. We will be back, next time with our whole crew!

The Naked Olive Lounge in Berkeley Springs has a lot of character, which already puts it ahead of…read moremany places trying very hard to have character and mostly achieving exposed brick. The space has a cozy, slightly speakeasy feel, with plenty of seating at the bar and tables for dinner. The music area is separate from the bar and dining area where we sat, which makes the layout feel lively without having the music sit directly on top of your entrée. There is also a related shop next door, The Naked Olive, where you can buy olive oils, balsamics, tapenades, and other dangerous things you convince yourself are "for later." By the time we were leaving early Saturday evening, they were getting ready for live music, which added to the local, come-stay-awhile feel. We started with a classic martini, and it was excellent. Perfectly balanced, cold, briny, slightly sweet, and served with blue cheese olives. A proper martini is not just a drink, it is a small personality test. We also tried the monthly special, the Dirty Devil, which I believe had bourbon, Coke, and salted caramel. It was good, but the classic martini was the clear winner for me. Service was friendly and helpful. I believe our server was James, and he helped us work through the menu without making us feel like we were preparing for a graduate seminar in small plates. They also honored us with a military discount, which I sincerely appreciated. Food wise, we ordered the Truffled Mushroom Pizza, which was genuinely good, with mushrooms, onions, peppers, and mozzarella. My only note is that the truffle was very subtle, maybe attending more in spirit than in full costume, but the pizza itself worked and I enjoyed it. We also had the Chicken Chesapeake, a sous vide chicken breast topped with crab and Chesapeake sauce. It came with a house salad and house vinaigrette, which was standard but good. As chicken breast goes, the entrée was well cooked, tender, and nicely finished. The crab and seasoning gave it some personality, which chicken breast often desperately needs. The mashed potatoes were hearty and solid. The vegetable du jour was the one underwhelming part of the meal; I am still not entirely sure what it was, and I do not think it was sure either. Overall, I enjoyed The Naked Olive Lounge. It may not be in my top three Berkeley Springs restaurants thus far, but it is definitely a solid entry in the local rotation. The ambiance is warm, the layout is comfortable, the service is friendly, the martinis are legitimately excellent, and the food is good, even if a few details could be stronger. The price point was reasonable, and I would happily come back, especially for a classic martini and live music.

Bar area

Side salad

See all

Classic martini

Fairfax Coffee House

4.1(216 reviews)

1.8 mi

This is a gorgeous spot, right in the center of Berkeley Springs. You'll find spacious seating…read morealong with local artwork inside. When it comes to their menu, it's truly extensive. You'll find some great coffee and tea options, delicious food, including great bagel options. My kids liked the regular bagels topped with peanut butter. I ended up getting an everything bagel, topped with cream cheese and tomato. My husband of course got the BLT bagel, which was an everything bagel with bagel, lettuce, and cheese. We really enjoyed this space and the great artwork on display inside. We look forward to coming back.

Welcoming! Expensive for a small town but still very good! Coming from DC I didn't expect my coffee…read moreto cost more here. Still it's a very cute stop with good coffee and sandwiches. Lots of flavors if that's your thing. Vegan options which is great for me. Happy to find this spot. Would recommend.

Cafe features local artists and makers to support

New York State of Mind add Lox. Everything bagel, cream cheese, tomato, onion, capers and smoked salmon

See all

Stubby's Grill

4.2(11 reviews)

2.0 mi

First time stopping in and we will be back! The wings were really good. We had the Taco and Salt &…read moreVinegar, they were so unique and great! (Forgot to take a pic.) we also had burgers and beers. The fresh cut fries were delicious! We topped it off with an ice cream cone for dessert. Stubby came out to chat and Beth, our server, was so nice. Everything was great. Place is super clean, bathrooms, tables, floor, etc. This will be a usual stop for us!

So I've only been in here once for a philly cheesesteak, so my opinion is limited however I have…read moreran doordash a couple times for them. Pros: - Inside is nice and well put together with a nice bar to sit at even - Staff was very friendly and kind - Food was very good, one of the tops of the area Cons: - Pricing was very high for the amount of food received - Really no parking next to the building - It seems they get overloaded/behind pretty easily with minimal customers present

Greek salad

See all

One patty smash burger, fresh cut fries. Delicious!

Canary Grill

3.4(198 reviews)

0.8 mi

All the food I have tasted has been good…read more If you have a large group. Getting your food can take more time

Had a great meal there today. The host and waiter were excellent, the food was great and the…read moreambiance was terrific. We had four adults and an infant, and it was no trouble at all. Arrived at a fairly busy time (mid-afternoon) but were seated immediately and served very quickly. The food was prepared perfectly, and we had quite a variety. Definitely on our list for a return visit soon.

Indoor seating area is light and bright

Chicken Alfredo

See all

Good spot to watch a lunar eclipse

Ravenwood Pub

4.8(52 reviews)

1.5 mi

This is a uniquely intimate restaurant in Berkeley Springs and an unexpected find thanks to Yelp…read more We sat side by side at a little antique chest of drawers fitted into the bar. There is a written menu in chalk but we got the idea that is only a rough guide. Listen to what the owner suggests and feel free to ask for modifications. Now that COVID restrictions are eased there was a large group in the middle and another two-person table occupied. We did not feel cramped. My wife had a small charcuterie plate and I the chicken salad on a bed of greens. Both were excellent.

Had awesome meal experience! Chef Regina was perfect hostess. She makes her own bread & some…read moreentrees. Loved her elk and wild boar bratwurst. Carrot cake to die for! Plus she serenaded us with a few great songs on her guitar. Limited seating so make reservation. Definitely well worth it. Thank you Chef Regina!

Carrot cake

Salad

See all

Cheese plate

Lot 12 Public House

4.5(162 reviews)

1.6 mi

•$$$

Lot 12 Public House is, thus far, the crown jewel of dining in Berkeley Springs. Housed on the…read moreoriginal Lot #12 of the Town of Bath, the restaurant embraces its history without feeling like a museum where dinner happens to be served. It is warm, intimate, and genuinely connected to the town. Lot 12 offers a seasonal three-course prix fixe menu Friday through Sunday, and reservations are highly recommended. We were fortunate to be served by Betsy, Chef Damian Heath's wife. She was warm, knowledgeable, attentive, and clearly invested in the experience. The service was excellent, with thoughtful pacing and the kind of attention to detail that feels effortless when done well. In a historic home, it would be easy for the setting to do most of the work. Here, the food and hospitality more than hold their own. The menu reflects a chef who is classically French-trained but not afraid to have some fun. We added an extra appetizer because choosing only one seemed unreasonable. The Southern Picnic included deviled eggs, pimento cheese bruschetta, candied bacon, and house pickles, essentially a Southern church picnic that went to culinary school. The fried green tomatoes were crisp and fresh, served with marinated mozzarella and basil aioli. The bread, baked on-site, came with olive oil infused with rosemary and herbs from the restaurant's garden. It was a small touch, but one that reflected the care behind the meal. The lobster bisque, one of the evening's specials, was exceptional: rich, silky, deeply flavorful, and unmistakably lobster, not merely lobster-adjacent. It may have been the best dish of the evening, although choosing a favorite felt unfair given how consistently good every course was. It was the kind of bisque that makes you consider ordering a second bowl, then resent the social conventions preventing you from doing so. Between the appetizers and entrées, we were served a bright, refreshing mango and ginger sorbet as a palate cleanser. For the entrées, we had the BBQ spice-rubbed duck breast and grilled cold-water lobster tail. The duck was beautifully cooked and paired with smoked confit duck hash, tart cherry demi-glace, and fresh fruit salsa. The lobster was sweet, tender, and finished with garlic herb beurre blanc. My only minor complaint is that I would have happily traded some of the mashed potatoes for more lobster. This is less a culinary critique than a personal philosophy. Dessert was equally strong. The upside-down pineapple cake with coconut sorbet was warm, nostalgic, and refined without becoming fussy. The individual Key lime pie leaned a little sweet, which worked for me, although those who prefer a sharper citrus profile may feel differently. The attention to detail was evident throughout the meal. The dining room is charming and thoughtfully decorated, the service polished without being stiff, and the food refined without becoming pretentious. There was no weak course, no service misstep, and nothing we would hesitate to order again. Lot 12 is not merely very good for Berkeley Springs; it would hold its own in a larger and more competitive dining market. We have been exploring the local restaurant scene, and so far, nothing else has come close. We will definitely be back. And if Chef Heath ever decides to sell that lobster bisque by the gallon, I already know where it is going in my refrigerator.

If you want to go someplace special that will leave you thinking about your next trip, this is the…read moreplace. This is our go-to place for special occasions because we know that the food will always be excellent, the service will be great, and we can relax and enjoy our meal (and maybe one of their exceptional desserts!)

Pallett cleansing

See all

Mango sorbet intermezzo

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Ralph F.

0

4

0

4 years ago

I've been enjoying Mythical Pizza since they opened in July. At first, it was crazy. Not only were there lines out the door to the street, but it took nearly an hour to get a pizza. I understood that they were super busy, and I wasn't upset. Overtime, once the initial push of business slowed, I started making it my regular place. At least once a week, I grab a pizza from them making my Thursday or Friday night absolutely wonderful. About two weeks ago when I was in, I was told they started serving a lunch special. Two slices of pizza and a drink for less than $7. I can't even get a sandwich from a corporate fast-food place for that price, so I was hooked. Then they one-upped themselves again, offering a daily special pizza and now slices all day. Every one of their special pizzas that I was afraid to try before really was easy for me to figure out if I liked it or not with just buying a slice. Now, I've found that the Back to The Basilisk is one of my new favorite pizzas, which I never would have thought I would have liked since it's made with sour cream, corn and black beans. It's a completely unique mix of flavor that I wasn't expecting. read more

Jonathon B.

81

31

7

4 years ago

Truly unique place in Berkeley Springs. This bigfoot/mothman themed restaurant brings fun back to pizza. The unlimited combinations of toppings much a huge impact as well. Definitely a great place for pizza! There's also a huge selection of cryptid-themed merchandise available for sale! Oh, and if you're looking for cheesy garlic bread? They have the absolute best. Amazing flavor and texture. read more

Andy H.

0

1

0

3 years ago

The pizza and salads were good. clean establishment with some quirky art work. The staff was helpful and worked swiftly to provide me with my order. I'd recommend this place to others and will return when I'm in the area. read more

Robert H.

0

1

0

10 months ago

Great employees and great food. the restaurant has amazing decor, and the merchandise is so cool. I will always come here when in town. I love how unique this place is read more

Roxy C.

21

1

2

1 year ago

Sooo good best pizza my husband ever had it great!!!!!!!!!!¡!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Mythical Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Mythical Pizza also viewed

Montese's

3.4

(57 reviews)

Another awesome dining experience! I highly recommend their Sicilian pizza! It arrived exactly as I…read morehad ordered and was delicious!

Pizza buffet is great, it's good pizza and lots of options, has salad bar and some pastas! Will…read moremake any pizza asked for. Would come back when passing thru, great location off the interstate and near a Walmart.

Al's Restaurant Pizzeria & Grill

4.3

(88 reviews)

We had a delicious lunch & the staff was so friendly and polite. Bathrooms were clean & stocked up…read more The HOMEMADE burger buns really caught us by surprise!! The food was absolutely delicious & reasonably priced. This was just a roadtrip stop for us, but if I lived locally I would definitely be coming back!

Get the pizza. Any kind, sauce is on point with perfect acidity, the best mozzarella cheese you…read morecan buy. Airy soft and delicious crust. They must use soda water in the recipe. Simply amazing!

Kings New York Pizza

3.5

(57 reviews)

I go primarily for the pasta specials which I really enjoy. The pizzas are good - nothing gourmet.read more

My favorite chicken cheese steak restaurant I love these restaurants. The cheese fries with bacon,…read moresubs, drinks and service. We have tried just about every menu item. All was very good and worth the money. It's pricy but, you get what you pay for.

Tommeez Pizza & Sub

4.7

(3 reviews)

Excellent service! we had a great experience there and will definitely go back again!read more

To avoid confusion, this has reopened where the old Tommy's was (old owner passed). We were…read moreinitially confused! New owners, Rick and Kim, are passionate about quality pizza and homemade crust and sauce. Rick is a local who worked at Tommy's as a teen. We had cheese pizza, which in my opinion, is the best way to test quality of pizza. It was fantastic. Baked to perfection. Really good fries as well. You could tell from the locals streaming in and out of this place, it is quality. Highly recommend.

Kings New York Pizza- Hedgesville

3.7

(71 reviews)

We heard great reviews about this local restaurant! Since we were in the area for an Airbnb…read moreweekend, we decided to order ahead. The menu is extensive, think Paisanos with options of salads, subs, pizza, sides, and pastas to choose from. We ordered the chicken parm and asked for angel hair instead of spaghetti. It's rare I find a place that doesn't skimp on the portions or cheese! I loved it and for one of my favorite dishes it was executed very well. Only comment I could make is that the sauce is a little on the sweet side. The Greek salad was filled to the top of feta! Cucumbers, onions, tomatoes, olives, and crunchy iceberg lettuce were all in the mix. The house dressing was yummy with this salad! The caprese salad was plentiful too! My husband loved the pizza, very cheesy and full of Philly steak. He described it as very flavorful! Prices seem fair and we got a lot of bang for our buck. Highly suggest this restaurant. Our food was ready on time and ready to go! Packed well and in an easy box to take out our large order for the weekend.

The food here is top notch! We've never ordered anything we didn't love. Portions are more than…read moregenerous and the food is delicious. Prices are comparable to other establishments. All the staff are friendly and attentive. We love eating here!

Rocky's Pizza Spring Mills

3.6

(8 reviews)

We enjoy Rocky's in Spring Mills. It is always spotless, and the servers are very attentive. The…read morepizza, taco pizza, and Italian dishes are all great. I like the Greek salad, too. We have enjoyed several of the appateizers, too. There is a large TV in the dining room area, but it isn't always on, and even when it is, it isn't loud at all. This is a great stop on the way to a Spring Mills Hugh event.

Terrible first time experience!! Pizza had very little to almost no sauce!! Sorry Rocky's but I…read morewon't be back!!

Mountainside Restaurant

3.6

(5 reviews)

Server was kind however the owner of the establishment, the greeter of the restaurant was very rude…read moreto both my family and others being seated. The owner was talking about customers at the front counter as they were leaving and belittling customers for seating themselves when they were unaware of how the business operated. The greeter / owner was also very rude to the server who was brand new and learning still how to perform his job. Multiple customers while we were seated got up and left due to poor service and were treated poorly upon paying for their drinks. Food was good for the price. Maybe best to get food to go from here... personally I will not return and I don't recommend anyone else to! To anyone needing a job don't come here. New staff was treated poorly while putting obvious effort forth and treating customers kindly unlike the owner.

Cold beer and hot , tasty pizza . Place is no frills , probably a local place for an after work…read morebeer and app. Service good ! We came here after hiking 10 miles at State Park. Delicious lunch !

Dino's Pizza

4.2

(20 reviews)

Great food, great people. Small hidden gem to say the least, no other pizza joints can matchread more

Dinos' has one of the most delicious pizza's ,my favorite is Dino's special with all kind of meat…read moreand veggie's . And the prices are great , Great pizza great Price . Come on by and order your pizza you can't go wrong,

The Vine Trattoria

3.1

(22 reviews)

If you're looking for a break from pub food in Berkeley Springs, this is the place. We had a…read morefabulous dinner. Do not miss the fried calamari - it's perfection and there is lots of it. We had two dishes (a salad and a pasta) with grilled shrimp and they were beautiful and delicious - almost like eating small lobsters. The interior of the restaurant is lovely and the staff were friendly, attentive and efficient. It was a really fine dinner.

The outdoor seating was peaceful and gorgeous. However, the pasta both my sister and I got was…read morebland and didn't have enough sauce. The meatballs were ok, but nothing to write home about. My Mom's fish was undercooked- raw in the middle. Our server took so long to take our order, I think she forgot about us. I wanted so much to like this place, but alas, the food was overpriced for the quality you got.

Kings New York Pizza- Martinsburg

3.7

(127 reviews)