Stopped in from out of town and hands down had the best experience! Interior was clean, so that's always a good sign. Mike was the best with recommendations and absolutely took care of us!! Southwest egg rolls were unexpected menu item and we will definitely order again. We created our own deep dish pizza with pepperoni, bacon bits and extra sauce and it is by far the best pizza we have had! We have decided next time we are craving pizza, we will make the drive all the way from Memphis just to have it here at Gary's. That's saying something! Can't wait to try the calzone and pasta too! Thanks for such a great experience and awesome food! Valerie & Gary (the OTHER Gary. ) read more

Gary’s Pizza - Make your own pizza. Deep dish, pepperoni, bacon bits and extra sauce. Best pizza ever! - Pizza Near Me - Osceola, Arkansas

See all

Visited for lunch, ordered a medium supreme, plenty for 2 people, service was excellent, service is friendly, country music videos playing TVs, pizza tasted good, read more

During lunchtime, this old-school pizza joint has a phenomenal special. From a list of around seven or so food items to choose from, you can get one food choice plus a drink for only $10.99 (plus tax). I opted for the calzone and unsweetened iced tea. My ham, bacon, and cheddar calzone was massive and delicious. (They offer three different flavors of calzones.) The iced tea was extraordinarily refreshing on this hot and humid day. The dining area was probably about 60% filled at 12:30 p.m. with lunch patrons. I didn't hear anyone complaining. The thing is, Osceola has a deficit of good dining choices. I take my victories where I can. There's nothing outstanding about the service, as a few of the waitresses acted as if they'd have rather been anywhere else but helping customers at a restaurant. The interior is decorated okay, and the kitschy wall hangings at least break up the monotony. The men's restroom was surprisingly well-kept, and atypically had zero malodor to it. If in the area, I would return again, if only because there really isn't a variety of choices in this area. read more

See all

It was okay but nothing more. The waitress was a dud and had no personality at all. She had a few people at our 7 top table order and then says is that everybody, knowing everyone didn't order. The didn't even refill the drinks completely. The Southwest rolls are bland, no flavor to them. Spinach dip was good but the bowl was literally half full. Wings had a sprinkle of sauce, not even covered. Calzones are huge & pretty good. Pizza was a fair pizza place. It could use much improvement & do better! read more

The wings were okay. They could have been fried a little harder. But I couldn't quite understand out of 2 orders of buffalo wings you get no dipping sauce (ranch). I was charged a dollar for each order.... I didn't ask for anything extra..... The server Michael A. Total 17.98 for 2 orders of 6 buffalo wings and then charged additional 2.00 for 2 cups of Ranch. Which made total 21.98 for 12 wings. Just giving more information on costs. read more

Service and food were great! Manager super friendly! We love their ham and cheddar sandwiches and they are always Great! read more

Went to Gary's for lunch last week with work colleagues we were the table of calzones lol. I've had zones all over the U.S. these ranked up there with ones from Chicago. The service was great the young gentleman that waited on us was polite and kept the glasses full of tea! Thanks again for a positive experience. read more

It was just ok. Nothing special but nothing bad either. The pan crust isn't what I consider pan crust.

What in the world happen to the place. Lazy employees, half sized portions, toast instead of garlic bread, filthy restaurant and more. What happened to the atmosphere it used to have. It felt more like a dump. I walked in, a woman sitting in a booth (where they used to folded pizza boxes) with her boyfriend, husband or whatever, yell across the restaurant if it was dine in or carry out. It was dine in. Found a clean table among the ones that were not cleaned yet. As I waited, noticed the floor was dirty with straws, paper and other trash. The server, a guy came to my table, no smile, acting like it was a bother to wait on me. Asked what I wanted to drink so I told his back since he immediately turned around before I could respond. I asked if there was meat in the Lasagna, told there was, so I ordered it. He brought the salad, then asked what dressing I wanted. Should have brought them both together. When I got it, the first thing I noticed that it was more of a soup than Lasagna so I asked for a spoon. Then I noticed the portion size was half of what it used to be. No longer in big bowls but in the smaller oval shaped ones they used for sandwiches. And Where was the meat??? And not even half of a Lasagna noodle and no layers??? Come on now, that was not Lasagna. Garlic bread was not garlic bread, it was just a lump of crunchy bread without any butter or garlic flavoring. As soon as the Lasagna was dropped off, he went back and brought the receipt and never came by again. And here I was thinking about getting a dessert. Oh well... read more

Their food is always fresh and hot. Delicious food and very generous portions. Your order is ready when promised.

The calzone is amazing to say the least. Gary is there to greet you and he makes sure everything is done right. AWESOME place for pizza.

I tried ordering a pizza for delivery from Garys since im partially disabled. They told me i had to call door dash. I looked and couldnt find them on door dash. It looks like ill probably have to call Papa Johns for delivery. read more

I called last minute to serve 18 because another local restaurant couldn't accommodate. Pizza was hot and ready on time. Staff was so friendly. We arrived early and gentleman taking care of dine in area was talkative and personable. Very refreshing. Made minor wait fun. He made us feel welcome. Will definitely use again when in town. read more