An amazing Italian restaurant just on the edge of town. Gotta rely on your GPS to make sure you're there though. Our waitress was running the whole show except cooking and you could tell she loved her job. We loved her service! It's a cozy little restaurant and gets packed quickly. Ordered their Twisted Tater pizza and that was different, not in a bad way. Waffle fries drizzled with ranch dressing toppled with lots of cheese, almost like a loaded tater but on a pizza. I definitely plan on a return trip to try their pasta menu as well as try one of their amazing desserts from their display! read more

Geraldi's - Twister Tater pizza - Italian Near Me - Cassville, Missouri

Wonderful, cheerful service! We got there, after a day of driving, 45 minutes before closing. The waitress was still happy to see us, and there were a couple occupied tables. Lovely paintings that form a panoramic country scene decorate the walls. We ordered a large Meat Lovers Calzon and it was delicious! The crust was outstanding. The bread appetizers were so good the wife said she could make a meal with them. We'd definitely eat here again! read more

Love this spot! THE best food in town. The ONLY Italian place within 30 minutes. Great tiramisu, spicy fettuccini Alfredo and pizza! read more

See all

Ordered a supreme pizza, what we got looked more like a meat lovers pizza. No vegetables, only black olives and meat. Very little sauce. The pizza was very dry. Would not recommend this place. read more

What can I say my old review needs updated. I would not recommend any longer. Food was commercial grade at best nothing tasted made in restaurant just microwaved from frozen. Ambiance, please. Service annoying. read more

Small dine in or carry out Italian. Excellent service! We chose to dine outside in the cute courtyard. Our server was quick to take our order, return with drinks and complimentary garlic bread! We ordered 2 Large pies - both came out piping hot in a reasonable amount of time! Way above your average Midwest Pizza place! 3 hungry boys + mom & dad and we have almost a full large pizza to take home. Will be back! read more

The majority of the food was microwaved and still cold inside. Prices wee very high for what you get. Our server was friendly and efficient.

Amazing trays of lasagne and chicken fettuccini made for us for a family gathering yesterday. Salad and bread and everything we needed. Carefree way to celebrate the holiday time with ease! Thanks to everyone who put our order together. All our guests raved about the food! read more

Geraldi's - Great pizza! Very cute place!!! - Italian Near Me - Cassville, Missouri

Service was slow. One girl was running the takeout counter, taking phone calls, and waiting on all the tables. The spinach and artichoke dip was good, but had cold spots because they didn't microwave it long enough. My wife got the chicken parmesan, and was VERY disappointed. She said it tasted like they took a frozen, breaded piece of chicken from the grocery store then covered it with very bland spaghetti and marinara. The breading on the chicken was mushy, she did not enjoy her meal at all. I got the spicy fetuccini alfredo with hot links. Flavor was good, meat was scarce. My wife and I are foodies and really enjoy finding local places with good reviews. This place does not deserve the high reviews it has received. Service was poor, food was poor to average. Will not be going back! read more

We had excellent service and food. The pizza we ordered was one of the best we have ever had.

Stumbled upon this place while in the area for a trout fishing weekend. So glad we did! Extremely kind staff and amazing food! Started with a toasted ravioli appetizer that was possibly the best I've ever had. Cooked to a slightly charred perfection with the creamiest cheese filling you could ask for. Next out side salads - again home runs! Good size, fresh ingredients. Delicious! Garlic bread was perfect and would have been amazing with the salads had we not woofed them down so quickly! Pizza arrived quickly and made to perfection. Crust is light, crunchy. Ingredients don't take a back seat to sauce. Pure deliciousness! Personal size (10") is big enough to split between two people or one really hungry person. I had been fishing all day so I polished it off myself! Pumpkin Cheesecake was the perfect amount of spices, sweetness and fall. Yum! All in all a great experience and I'd highly recommend! read more

See all

What an outstanding experience! The server was very friendly and very genuine. We had the spinach and artichoke dip, not yo mamas cheese bread, and the spicy Alfredo and hot links. The complimentary bread was sensational -- definitely homemade and very delicious. The spinach and artichoke dip was the best I've ever had. The dip actually had artichoke flavor and was very tasty. The cheese bread was very rich and unctuous. Finally, the alfredo and spicy hot links really impressed me with the perfectly cooked noodles and flavorful sauce. We finished with an Oreo cheesecake that was equally mind-blowing. If I'm ever in the area again, I will make a point to come visit for dinner again! read more

(This review is for Shell Knob location) The food is very good. Nice fresh salad and a pizza with lots to take home. We had a meat lovers pizza and it was perfect. Crust was great. The dishes I observed look good. This location is fairly new so consider that as you read. Ambiance: I'd say home style. Short on wait staff. But service wasn't too bad, considered. The parking lot is rough and not very big. I'd recommend it. read more

We were camping in the area and found this great gem of a restaurant. Fantastic pizza! We had the meat lovers, the pesto veggie, very veggie pizza and cake. The crust was chewy just the way we like it. The garlic on the pizzas was strong and pungent. So stuffed we had to take most home. If in the area stop in. read more

Geraldi's - Dessert case. - Italian Near Me - Cassville, Missouri

See all

We stopped for dinner when passing through. It was fantastic! They brought garlic bread to the table with the drinks. We had pizza, salad and a sandwich. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. The bathrooms were clean. I would highly recommend and will make sure to come back when in the area! read more

Geraldi's - Pepperoni pizza and salad. - Italian Near Me - Cassville, Missouri

See all

Antipasto Salad is the best ever ! Friendly service and clean ! Definitely recommend going !

Delicious food; loved the cauliflower crust Garlic Geraldi pizza. Loud, so not good for conversation.

We found this place a couple years ago, and now have to come back every time we are fishing at Roaring river. This is definitely our new favorite restaurant in town. Great food and great service every time we have been. read more

This is one of my favorite places to eat in Cassville. I've never had a bad meal from Geraldi's. There are several options available for vegetarians. The Very Veggie pizza is light, crisp, and delicious. There are also several pasta, salad, and sandwich options available for vegetarians. The only downfall is that Geraldi's service can be a bit slow during peak hours, and that they don't have a liquor license. Then again, most restaurants in Cassville don't have one, so it's really not a huge deal. It's definitely a great place to eat, and the prices are pretty inexpensive. read more

Geraldi's - Italian Near Me - Cassville, Missouri

Service was great , pizza was so good greasy veggies . Concern atmosphere very pleasant experience Prices are great well worth it . This is a must try if you are cassville read more

This review is for their new Shell Knob location. Excellent. I had the personal pan Hawaiian pizza and my husband had the pepperoni. We also ordered a salad. Everything was fresh and very good. And our waitress was superb. She served the whole crowd with a smile and graciousness. read more

The service was great and the food was good. However, we wanted to sit away from the crowd, my dad is 84 and Covid aware. The only table available was a larger one made up of 2 smaller tables. We pulled them apart and sat down, allowing for other guests to use the other table if needed. The owners wife rudely told us, as she shoved the tables back together that it was reserved for groups of 5 or more. We did stay but felt terribly uncomfortable the entire time. We will not be back. read more

Our family of 4 was accommodated with outdoor seating and enjoyed the wonderful traditional Italian food served quickly and with small town friendly charm! Excellent cheese pizza for the kids and very good Mediterranean pasta and chicken parmesan for the adults. read more

Pizza is outstanding! So happy we visited on our antiquing day! Service was friendly and efficient. I will definitely be back!

What a hidden gem! Delicious lunch or dinner spot. We loved it. The lasagna was delicious, the sandwiches are great and the dessert was the perfect finishing piece. We will be back! read more

Short version: Geraldi's had some of the best Italian food I've had in a very long time. Each dish hit the mark perfectly. Very authentic Italian. Great service. Long version: My girlfriend and I was in Cassville to go fishing with her parents and we were feeling a little too lazy to drive far to eat. After a Google search and a little bit of a discussion we settled on Geraldi's. The inside looked okay but they had a very nice patio so we decided to sit outside. We went to other places in Cassville and we do not have the best service so we were expecting the same, he was pleasantly surprised that we did not receive bad service. The meal started out great with some sweet iced tea that my girlfriend absolutely love. And they started us out with some garlic bread that we could tell was straight out of the oven and super delicious. I ordered the lasagna and my girlfriend ordered the chicken alfredo. The lasagna was super feeling very flavorful and had some amazing red sauce. I was surprised by how much cheese was in it and how good it tastes. The chicken alfredo was mild was still very flavorful. Each meal was great to get the garlic bread in. This is our first time but I can guarantee not our last, we look forward to visiting again. read more

See all

This is THE best place in Cassville fo sho. Their pizzas are amazing and the prices seem oddly low. We come here every time we pass thru, and are never disappointed. read more

Love this place. The white pizza with spinach is a family fav. The staff is great as well

Oh my gosh! Saw prior yelp reviews and knew I had to carb load here prior to my trail race. So so good. Had the antipasto salad with house dressing - delish! Husband had the cauliflower crust mamma Mia pizza. He enjoyed it! I had lasagna and bread. Yum! And then I bought a piece of chocolate cake for a post race treat! All the prior reviews have it right - very good!! Service was also good. We took our meal to go as we went back to our camper! read more

This is our go-to spot when we visit Cassville. We love the pasta dishes and the pizza. Fast, friendly service even when they are busy. See you next time! read more

Pizza is simply outstanding! Calzones are HUGE! Place is hiding on a little back street, but well worth finding. Service and staff are very friendly and the bread with the meal is great. We are FANS! read more

This small business restaurant has something in the menu for everyone. Pizza and Chicken parm sandwich is my families favorites. Make sure you get some of the garlic bread. Along with great service I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Great Italian food at a reasonable price! Great atmosphere and customer service. Goes to show the best restaurants are the little family owned businesses that are tucked away. read more

Geraldi's - Great Spaghetti & Meatballs. HUGE portions, very flavorful. Everything made from scratch. - Italian Near Me - Cassville, Missouri

See all

Great good. Owner and waitress are both super! We've been coming to this area for several years and just found out about them. Food is really, really good and the service and atmosphere were top notch. read more

Found this little out of the way place on Yelp, very pleasantly surprise. Small dining room,a little loud due to customers talking and babies crying,but not owners fault. Not much on atmosphere, just a typical small dining room. Service was very good and very friendly. Owner came by every table several times and interacted with every table. Owner and wait staff were terrific. We had an antipasto, great. Had a pizza, great. Left very full and satisfied. My girlfriend and I really enjoyed the place and have added it to our must return again list. Highly recommended. read more

I ordered the Lasagna and my sister ordered the Chicken alfredo, and it was SOOOO good. The waitress was so sweet and quickly got us taken care of! I recommend the toasted ravioli appetizer it was so good as well. I will definitely eat here again next time i visit! read more

This place is amazing I loved it I will eat is for life delicious you're getting a five star rating I like the service I like the food I like everything about it in the store beautiful so that's pretty much all I have so I guess I'll see you later bye-bye read more

Geraldi's - Just me hanging - Italian Near Me - Cassville, Missouri

We just happened to stumble on this place while driving through Cassville. I was pleasantly surprised at the quality of the food and friendliness of the staff. I would highly recommend giving them a try. read more

This place used to be pretty good, but I haven't been here for a while, we came tonight and I ordered the house salad with blue cheese dressing and and I ask if they have grilled chicken they say yes, when my salad arrived, the chicken was boiled and cero flavor, pretty bad. My sister ordered the alfredo pasta and it was the most sad alfredo pasta I ever seen. She had to put lots of salt and extra cheese and pepper to make it a lil better. To bad. Used to be pretty good. Not coming back read more

Really great food and good service!! People are friendly and they have a good selection of Italian food. One of my favs!