The pizza was okay, but I would not visit again based on the hours of operation. I'm normally in…read morethis area in the morning and early afternoon, and they do not open until 2 pm. One time I was parked out front because I forgot that they only opened after two, and the gentleman walked from across the street and unlocked the doors and turned the lights on at 2:01pm and I did not see any pizza ready. I was already crunched for time, so I did not even bother getting out of the car to ask if they had any slices ready. So it probably would not be best to go when they first open. However, I do think it's great that they stay open for late night eats. I placed my order online about 20 minutes before I arrived, but when I got there, it was not ready. The gentleman only put my slices in the oven after I told him that I placed an online order, which kind of defeated the purpose of me ordering ahead because I did not want to wait. But it did seem like he was there solo, and he very was nice. I ordered a slice of the "SPICY SALT AND PEPPA-RONI" and the "RANCH IT LIKE IT'S HOT." I would have liked more of the toppings on the "RANCH IT LIKE IT'S HOT" slice and a thicker dough. The base sauces also didn't have much of a presence. I tend to prefer my sauce on the sweeter side, or at least savory with a hint of sweet, but I could barely taste it. The crust was also a little too thin. I ordered two slices and still had room for more, whereas I'm usually full or at least more satisfied after two slices. One of the pizzas, I believe the SPICY SALT AND PEPPA-RONI, was spicy, and I was not a fan of that. I honestly just wanted a regular pepperoni slice, but went for whatever pepperoni option they had listed. I love the originality of the pizza names! When I ordered online, plain pepperoni was not listed as an option, so I just assumed they didn't have it. However, when I went in to pick up my order, I saw that they did have regular pepperoni slices available. I probably would have preferred that over the SPICY SALT AND PEPPA-RONI. Personally, I would not revisit, because I think there are better pizza options along Easton Ave.

White pizza slice was ok, def wish it had more garlic. And if shrimp could be added as a topping…read morewould be awesome! Otherwise I liked the thin crust and ricotta on it for very good price. Oh! Also could sides of marinara be offered on delivery? Would be awesome!

Went to a party today the food architects catered, the most delicious food the potato salad was…read moreunique and delicious, pulled pork was tender melted in your mouth. My next party I will absolutely be calling on them.

Their chicken bacon ranch pizza is heavenly. My only complaint is that I miss when their storefront…read moreused to have the blackened chicken sandwich available.

This is a mainstay of Piscataway and we need to support this place! It's been years since I've been…read morehere, but my new coworkers and I started ordering here every other week. The prices are unbelievable and the food is abundant. The free bread that comes with the pasta is bigger than the pasta itself, and it's very good on its own! The staff are so friendly and greet you like an old friend. The ambiance is super outdated, but that's part of the charm. The food, the service, and the place is the definition of "comfort food." Please continue to support Stelton Pizza so that it can stick around for years to come!

I've been popping into Stelton Pizza for the better part of 15 yrs, and the quality has been…read morerock-solid throughout. Whether I'm grabbing a quick slice or settling in with a full meal, they never disappoint. My two non-negotiables: the buffalo chicken pizza and the eggplant parm sandwich. 1) The buffalo slice is always on point with the perfect flavor, and you can almost always snag one on the fly. 2) The eggplant parm is a total winner, and here's a little secret why: they bake all their sandwich rolls fresh in-house! You can absolutely taste the difference. Most of their pizzas have a perfectly crisp, thin crust, and that audible crunch you get when you take a bite is just unmatched. This place is a true local gem that knows exactly what it's doing.

Fast and friendly service. There's several tables to sit and eat, but most people get takeout…read more Pizza was good, but it has A LOT of cheese on it, so it's very filling.

If you want large quantities of good, basic Italian fare at reasonable prices, this may be your…read morespot. We ordered takeout which was ready on-time with a cheerful and prompt checkout: * Chicken Parmigiana: Breaded chicken breast with mozzarella cheese in a light red sauce with Ziti and Salad. * Chicken Piccata: Chicken breast in lemon wine butter sauce with Penne and Salad. You can select your preferred pasta and salad dressing with these dishes. The Chicken Piccata was very tasty, light and lemony. The chicken was very tender. It was better than the Chicken Parmigiana which was a little too fried and not nearly as tender. I'd definitely order the Chicken Piccata on my next visit. The Ziti and Penne were plentiful and good, and the salads were surprisingly good with fresh, crisp lettuce and ripe tomato slices. Overall, a good takeout, 3.5 stars rounded up to 4 stars for the tasty Piccata and piping hot food!

The pizza was solid. The crust had a nice crunch, and the pepperoni slices were a great size with…read moregood flavor. Pickup was quick, ready on time, and the service was smooth. The interior felt a little worn down, but overall, a good local pizza spot if you're nearby.

When I pulled up to the place I thought it was out of business when I went inside to get a slice…read moreall the slices looked 3 days old pizza was mid I just wish there was a good pizza spot in town I don't know how this place makes any money to keep business up and running

Service is bad. Placed an order online it said 20 minutes I get there 20 minutes later. The guy…read moresays 25 more minutes. I have to work I didn't have time. He was not friendly he said the pies take that long. The grandma pies. Someone needs to teach him time management and efficiency. He spends too much time running around pizzas never make it in the oven. I was in there for like 15 minutes and he never got one in.

I ordered here for pick up and it was ready within 15 mins!! Super quick. The food was absolutely…read moredelicious. The wrap is huge and the fries are cooked to perfection. It was only $13 for all of this food!!! I like how they gave Cesar dressing on the side and didn't saturate my wrap in dressing. They also gave plenty of ketchup packets for the fries. I will definitely be returning!!!! Thank you for this great lunch.

Feels like a classic old school Jersey pizza spot the second you walk in, cash only, the owner John…read morewas really great and chatted with me for a few minutes while the pizzas got ready. Got the pizzas to go and the entire family enjoyed it including the kids. Not on door dash or Uber Eats but worth taking the time to pick up or eat in.

I love this pizza! We ordered a whole pie. Two slices had pepperoni, two slices had sausages, and…read morethe other half pie was plain. Quick service, too 10 minutes. We ate in and ordered a 2L Coke. The pie was so hot! It was perfect! The cheese was perfect! Not over cooked like other restaurants! The crust ends were soft. The under crust had some scorching! The sauce has a slight sour! I love when the sauce is not sweet! Brought the family for dinner tonight! No ice small restaurant!

Excellent service and the food was phenomenal. Food is an…read moreextension of our heritage, reminiscent of our grandparents. This restaurant, from the moment you sit at your table, you realize the food represents the authenticity of our Italian culture.

this spot is a family owned and operated Italian restaurant. They are a well-oiled machine here,…read morethe service is so swift and polite. Lots of seating in the restaurant between booths and tables. We started with olive oil and bread, had soups as an appetizer (soup or salad included with each pasta meal), and then our main courses arrived. These plates are massive! We all needed boxes to take it back with us, because the portions were so big and it was so delicious. We had chicken parm, lasagna, and one of the house specials. Great experience here! They also have a parking lot!