Went there for first time yesterday Picked up lunch to go. Staff was friendly. I ordered 2 plain slices, one white slice, eggplant parm sub, and mozzarella sticks The slices were cooked good and tasted good The eggplant sub was excellent and a whole sub for a good price. The mozzarella sticks were mid to be honest and the sauce wasn't the greatest read more

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant - 6 Mozzarella Sticks and Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

See all

Thank you Tonys for always having fresh yummy food and incredibly kind customer service. Huge portions made to your liking without it being so expensive. So good food great service great prices open late enough for an after work meal on the way home fresh and hot and ready ... Been coming here and always will for years to come read more

Solid pizza joint. Nothing fancy but nice enough to dine in. We order weekly for ourselves, sometimes for the office. Friendly staff, great NY style, thin-crust pizza! I haven't tried the chicken parm hero but it is another popular item with our team. read more

I have nothing bad to say about Tony's in Planfield. I flew home from LA and wife was craving good Italian. We got penne a la vodka, cold anti pasta plate, fried ravioli and my son wanted fries. The sauce they make for the ravioli was spicy as advertised. Pasta was great. The plate of cold apps had fresh mozzarella, sharp provolone, cucumber, peppers, olives, salami and soppressata. Definitely added to our list of local family owned Italian restaurants to eat at. read more

See all

DoorDash Pizza Diaries Stop #1: Tony's Pizza & Restaurant -- South Plainfield, NJ Rating: Elite Slice The Stop Pulled up to Tony's during a delivery run in South Plainfield. One of those classic Jersey spots you can tell has been doing this a long time. No flash, no nonsense--just pizza and people who know what they're doing. The Rule If I deliver it, then I've gotta try it first. The Order Plain slice. Always. That's the lie detector test. The Breakdown *Crust: Solid with a light crisp and still foldable. Holds its shape--no mid-slice collapse. *Sauce: Balanced and flavorful, not overly sweet, not heavy-handed. *Cheese: Even melt, perfectly portioned. No cheese slide, no grease puddle. *Slice Integrity: Passed the fold test with flying colors. Clean bite all the way through. The Verdict This is straight-up Jersey pizza done right. Nothing fancy, nothing forced--just a slice that knows exactly what it's supposed to be. The kind of pizza you grab once and immediately think, "Yeah, I'd come back here." After delivering food all over New Jersey and stopping at more mom-and-pop pizza spots than I can count, Tony's earns Elite Slice status. I'd recommend it without hesitation--and I'll definitely be back, probably mid-dash, probably saying "just one slice" and meaning at least two. DoorDash Pizza Diaries Rule Applied: Delivered it Tried it Approved it Next stop, next town, next slice. read more

Love their pizza. Who would have though getting a decent oie in nj would be so difficult.

Food Excellent pizza always made fresh. Square pie & also the calzone. Meatballs extra sauce on the side. I travel just to pick it up. Every where else is sloppy. No menus! Asked permission to take pics of the board. All good now. read more

I love coming here for cheese pizza , literally from the sauce to the cheese! It was amazing and fast service! The environment was so pleasant, always a pleasure to get food here ! read more

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant - Best plain pizza around! I drive 20 mins to get it ! - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

Was staying in the area and this was a great delivery option via Door Dash. The pizza is superb, as well as the salad and desserts. Highly recommended! read more

just plain crappy food. ordered 4 pasta dishes and they all tasted like crap. wife and i got sick from the food. save yourself the trouble and find a better place. BLAND ASS FOOD. read more

This was some really good pizza! It had the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Will definitely be ordering a pie from here for our next pizza night! read more

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

I know I only ordered a pepperoni slice and ran out but If I was speaking to Tony himself, my goodness... This slice of pizza... as a New Yorker, You are NJ's table 87. This was incredible. I will be back. True Italian pizza read more

Tony's has been a neighborhood favorite for many years amongst my friends and family. Surprisingly I tend to get sandwiches here more often than pizzas. The meatball parm sub is my go to order and is consistently good. Good meat to sauce to cheese ratio. I've gotten some of their steak sandwiches as well over the years which are also yummy. A great spot for a quick bite! read more

Good pizza here. Pizza a bit on the oily side but otherwise crust is nice & crispy and pizza was piping hot. Also they did not skimp on the pepperoni. A full slice of it. Bravo. Only ordered pizza so can't comment on the sandwiches or the pasta dishes. Cash is king here as they do have a sign stating that they will charge a surcharge for using credit card / debit cards. FYI. Good pizza here. read more

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant - Plain & Pepperoni Pizza slices. - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

I love the staff and the pizza always hit the mark. I like the Buffalo chicken, white, grandma, chicken parm, and Sicilian slices. I could eat here every day. read more

Visit from Naples Florida. Perfect NJ pizza. Was the start of a perfect golf weekend. read more

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant - 2 perfect slices - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

Very disappointing sometimes it is very good but they need to stop burning the bottom very unappealing to have black pizza. read more

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

I ordered 2 plain pizzas and received 1 cold and 1 hot. I was on time and showed up earlier than the time they gave me. Seems like they are making pizzas in bulk to meet demands and then giving them. They r also short staffed, which I u see stand due to covid reasons. But if a customer orders fresh pizzas, don't give them cold pizza. read more

Pizza the best around but sometimes depends on who's making it. Usually spot in though. Lasagna was good. Sauce is really good not too chunky or sweet. read more

Always gotta love Tony's Pizza! It's local favorite amongst the competing rivals around town. Tony's is always fast and satisfying for a quick bite. Just pop in for a quick slice, a min or so later, bam you're enjoying your mouth watering NY thin slice that'll be gone in seconds. I'm an east coast woman, so i will tell you that thin crust pizza from Jersey or NY is the best, especially the mom and pop restaurants. But I gotta say Tony's has a little piece of my heart. I've grown up eating their pizza after I was old enough to span my horizons from Pizza Hut and Dominoes (the parental favorites) LOL. Staff is always welcoming and the store environment is always friendly. read more

It's tough to find good meatball subs the best is carmines Italian deli in jersey city but Tony's is a fair spot for a meatball sub not bad bread is good meatballs are alright sauce is alright cheese was decent. read more

Their sauce is so delicious I want to go back and stock up on it! Everything is made fresh daily even through the Covid-19 pandemic and you can taste it. I ordered a Stromboli and it was easily the best Stromboli I've ever had which came with a heavy side of marinara for dipping. The dough is tasty and they do not skimp on the fresh ingredients inside. Tony's is my favorite local pizza place and is easily the best in the area! I suggest their sandwiches or Stromboli or anything with their tasty sauce! read more

Da best grandma pie in Jersey & Brooklyn!!!!!!! Over the past ten years we have been trying grandma pies everywhere on the east coast. Not one place comes close.... read more

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant - pizza - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

Food was great, seeing the guys at the counter interacting, particularly with the younger regular customers was heartwarming. A great place to bring the family for pizza read more

You can smell the sauce as soon as you walk in. Behind the counter you can see the chefs cooking and it really gave me the feeling of family in the kitchen. Price was fair, portions were good, and food was delicious. Definitely a hidden gem! read more

I will save you the trouble. Get their Sicilian Style Pizza!, the crust is just the right amount if crispiness. You also should get their chicken parmesan, one of the good ones that Ive had in the area. The place is super clean. Staff are always very friendly and loves their job! Which is always a plus as a customer when you know the staff are enjoying making the food for you! read more

this place hasnt changed in the past 20 years. it's one of the last few legit spots around. the prices r fair too. their pizza sauce and red sauce is gonna be missed if they ever close. ppl wont appreciate this spot enough until it's gone. read more

The pizza was dry and not good at all. I have been a customer for many years and I don't usually complain but this pizza was that bad. My brother picked the pizza up for me and when I called them all they kept saying was they wanted to talk to my brother. I explained he just did me a favor picking it up, he is not eating pizza these days. Meant nothing to Tony's they wanted to speak to my brother. The sauce did not taste fresh, the cheese was dry like a bone around the pizza, the dough was not very good either. I will never buy another anything from them after the terrible pizza and then the way I was treated. read more

This place is still great. I've been coming here for well over 2 decades now and same family runs it and puts obvious pride in their food. Always good, consistent and clean. Highly recommended. read more

I used to get the chicken fingers and they were very good, crispy, looked cut from a actual breast but the past couple of times, it looked like they were from a prepackaged chicken patty and did not taste good to me. If it's not changed back, I will not get the chicken fingers anymore. Very disappointing read more

Yes, there still open during pandemic times! I got the chicken club sandwich it was pretty big, delicious and cheap! It was only 7.50. I think this is one of the best pizzerias in the area. Lastly, shop and buy local people they need us. read more

Always my go-to when doing take out. I have been a long-time customer and am never disappointed. I am a huge fan of their chicken marsala and francese. read more

Stopped in for lunch today. Absolutely fantastic pizza! Super friendly staff too! Will definitely be back!

Pretty disappointed with the pizza given the high reviews here. The sausage thin-crust slice I was was SUPER thin... like the crust cracked when folding the za. I hate that. Meanwhile, the other specialty slices I tried were all done sort of deep dish style... but weren't really thick enough. The Sicilian slice in particular was just too thin. Wife picked these up, and told me the selection on a Saturday around 5pm was limited. That's gotta be prime time for pizza slices. One slice she brought home was just grilled chicken. WTF is that? Lazy, AND the chicken was overcooked. So why 3 stars? The sausage rolls were awesome. Onion and good meat, well rolled, cooked nicely... I really enjoyed that a lot. Pizza, not so much. read more

I went in to get a Chicken parm but I got a chicken parm that was fried to the point it was card board. They threw a ton of sauce and cheese on top melted it and charged me $15. They said please sit by the area where you can be served. The waitress did not give us any silverware. My wife had ordered a slice of pizza which came on a paper plate. We had to go fishing for our own garlic as the wait staff was no where to be found. My some had ordered a soda which came with a fly. This place does make good pizza but that is about it. read more

I moved away from New Jersey about 30 years ago, and now live in Chicago. I miss New Jersey / New York style pizza. I was in town to visit my parents in Edison, and wanted to get my thin slice fix. This place more than delivered, and I was suddenly transported back to my childhood! Great place for authentic old school, thin crust New Jersey pizza! read more

We have ordered in from Tony's often and driven 3 miles to pick up their delicious, genuine Italian food. Tonight we used grub hub and stayed home. The driver was great and the food was stupendous. Best Italian food in central Jersey. Stuffed shells were terrific and the chicken scarpariello was excellent. The variety of entrees is fabulous. No room for dessert. read more

I ordered catering for a party because a family member highly recommended the place. Boy I was glad I ordered here! Food was delish! They were very accommodating with my requests, the staff very friendly and helpful!!! Try their meatballs, eggplant parmigiana, baked ziti and array of salads read more

I work in Edison and Tony's is a favorite lunch stop for me and the guys I work with. The pizza is the best around! Tony's also has cheese-steaks and cold sub sandwiches, which are all excellent! My personal favorite is the "Tony's Special" which is their version of the Italian sub. It is the best Italian sub in the area, by far. You also gotta try the tomato bread. It is excellent and you won't find it anywhere else. If you are more into sit-down traditional Italian dinners then Tony's has you covered, too. One side of the restaurant is set up like a traditional sit down restaurant. read more

great pizzaasss!! Good food, love it very much. Staff is very friendly and helpful, lots of choice and Tony is trying his best when his back feels good.Cannot go wrong. read more