THIS SHIT IS GASSS!!! first time here omg no crumbs i devoured everything!!! the staff was soo nice and pretty. im def coming here again!!

When I lived here many years ago this was the best bagel spot in town, but they've gone downhill dramatically. The bagels are small and dense, and the dough is under-salted. They skimp on butter and cream cheese. They also forgot the lox on my order even though I was the only person in the store - but after seeing how bad the rest of the food was I suspect that I dodged a bullet. Tl;dr - food sucks, don't waste your money read more

Read through some of the reviews. Most people seem angry about something else and take their issues out on the bagels. Not the case. As a guy who was born & bred in NY minutes away from the GWB (and married to a woman from Ft Lee on the NJ side who agrees with this review), the bagels are spot on NY/NJ! We just moved to town, went in and grabbed a dozen so I can't speak to anything else. But this is the best bagel I've had in this state, and frankly, that's all I want from a bagel shop. Cream cheese was good, but I prefer veggies cream cheese with large chunks of veggies, not finely chopped (still good, just my pref). read more

A friend that's lived in Fort Collins their entire life and grew up near Gib's took me to this place for the first time and I really enjoyed it. You can feel the deep community roots and the food is fabulous with mostly college students providing front end service, a great way to build people skills and self confidence. I had sausage, cheese and egg on an everything seasoning bagel and it was delish! I saved the top for later so I had two experiences in one day and avoided a midday carb crash. Winning! read more

The staff is very rude and condescending, treats people of color and neurodivergent like we are aliens. A bunch of spoiled entitled college kids with no more abilities than to make bagels. Got incredibly ill once and management did nothing and told me not to come back. The manager Jacob was incredibly rude and unhelpful and the staff laughed at me when I returned. Given how the world now knows how Jewish businesses treat people of color, I'd recommend not going there if you support Palestine. Really crappy bagels and coffee too. read more

Gib's NY Bagel - This is the guy who was particularly rude. - Delis Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Clearly a local place with some history behind it. Reasonably priced for the portions, though quality is just okay. Bagels are hard to make, though, so I'm sure I'll be back still. read more

Don't go here if you're having a bad day, they'll make your day even worse. Not to mention the bagels are actually terrible and not NY style at all. Their online ordering system is also messed up and doesn't work properly on their end but will charge you and then the employees won't solve it. They make you pay again. Employees are all high school students making eggs in used plastic containers.... read more

I go here at least a couple of times a month usually for lunch since they've added soups and sandwiches and salads. It gives me a lot more to order from everything is always excellent but my go to is their mother's vegetable chicken soup. It's absolutely delicious. Always the perfect temperature. It comes with focaccia bread and you can always get a salad or a sandwich in addition to that if you'd like and they have a good variety of coffee, drinks, and other drinks as well. Everything is always really delicious and very filling. It's one of my favorite places to go when I need some good soup no picture this time but I'll take one next time read more

Great job on the remodel guys! Unfortunately you dumped all your money into a fancy building instead of continuing to make good food. Bagels were burnt, cream cheese was hot and sliding off the bagel. If I wanted a mediocre bagel I'd make on at home. Supported you guys for years - never again. read more

Gib's NY Bagel - A burnt, disgusting bagel. - Delis Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

15 min wait for soup! Just scoop it out at order time! Then forgot bread. Then the bread was cold. Cold bread. Yuck.

Didn't think they could screw up a bagel and cream cheese but they did. And very very very slow.

I'm from the east coast. Bagels are good. Not like an East coast bagel unfortunately. Prices are awesome though. Don't know too many places that you can get a bagel Sammy for 7 bucks. read more

Really good bagel sandwich would come in and eat here again. Bagel came out fast and really hot. read more

Gib's NY Bagel - Everything bagel sandwich with american cheese bacon and egg! I added scallion cream cheese to both sides of the bagel. - Delis Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Love the new renovation- staff was very friendly and kind- absolutely love gibs- breakfast sandwich is hard to beat. Pictures on the wall are awesome- can't recommend enough! read more

My order wasn't ready at the time of pick up. they did not let me know they were out of an ingredient. I waited 20 minutes past the time before I could flag someone down. my hot sandwich was cold and my coffee was 1/3rd empty by the time I received it. Do better Gib's. read more

Great food! Good atmosphere, employees are always nice! Love this place for sure! It's my go to place!

Came here on multiple occasions and havnt been disappointed yet. I've had the lox as well as the egg cheese and sauce bagel on a toasted everything bagel. Everything is just made fresh and the quality is like something you would have made at home but tastes better since you didn't make it yourself. Pro: -Nice crunch to the bagel -Good ratio, not lacking meat or toppings. Cons: -Just a tad pricey, but it is delicious and fresh so cant complain too much -They take too long to make the order. Both times I've eaten here (for here and to go) it was the same thing Tips: -If you're with family or friends try to get a sandwich you both like and split half and half so you can get to explore their menu. They cut the bagels in half too so that makes it easier for you to do that as well. read more

Gib's NY Bagel - Lox bagel - Delis Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I walked in and it seemed to me that it was busy, but the line kept moving. The employee at the register (didn't catch a name) was ON it. When the line was gone, she jumped straight into supporting the production line, refilling stuff. I was in and out with my order in probably about 10 minutes with three people ahead of me in line! My favorite bagel is the jalapeño bagel for sure. So tasty, and I love the spicy tingle it adds to whatever you put on it. I've also heard amazing things about the egg bagels, but haven't tried it myself. The employee from the register brought my coffee over while I was sitting at a table waiting for my order today, I thought that was super nice. read more

The bagels are the most important thing and I'd give theirs a 10/10. They are chewy and soft, big, and they have so many good flavor options. I haven't seen a pretzel bagel anywhere else! I had a honey wheat bagel with extra strawberry cream cheese. (They really loaded it up!) They get quite busy on weekend mornings, so make sure to call ahead, order online, or get there earlier. I'm always surprised though by how quickly they move through the line. Also, they actually have quite a few drink options including things like cold brew (which I got), matcha, chai, and drip coffee. read more

See all

I hate to do it, but I can truly only give Gib's Bagels three stars. Their bagel quality is "meh", the price point (for what your taste buds receive) is steep, and the service is hit or miss. I got a breakfast sandwich today with sausage, egg and cheese on a sesame bagel. It was bland and the sausage could/should have been heated up longer. I cannot say I'll be running back to Gib's anytime soon. If you're looking for a true New York bagel in Colorado, do yourself a favor and visit Rosenberg's Bagels in Denver. While you're there, buy enough bagels to freeze at home. read more

Gib's NY Bagel - Breakfast sandwich with sausage, egg, and cheese - Delis Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

I've ordered from here a handful of times and never once have they toasted my bagel like I've requested. The flavors are mediocre at best. Unfortunately there's not many better options in the area for bagels. If you're on the fence about bagels, I'd opt with your second choice. read more

Very delicious bagels, I highly recommend getting them they are easily accessible and very tasty

First time to Gib's and I'm glad I went. Food was good and lots of options. I will be coming back for sure!

So slow it gives you an anxiety attack. Worst service you could fathom. Bagels are ok but not worth the trouble of you don't have a lot of time to waste. read more

Not sure what happened to this place. In the past I would have always given Gibs 4 or 5 stars. The service is very slow and lack of customer engagement was less the satisfactory. read more

YUM. Best bagels in Fort Collins. I'm picky, too. Usually order the NYC with extra lox. Good coffee, too. Friendly staff. Love this place. read more

Walked in, no line, placed order. Sat down and waited and saw the people that had walked in before me get their food. Then the high school rush came and I saw them all start to get their drinks and sandwiches, I ordered literally a bagel with cream cheese. After waiting far too long, I asked a girl behind the counter about it (very nicely as I didn't even want to ask in the first place) and was cut off after two words with "it's in the queue", followed by her walking back and rolling her eyes and complaining about me to her coworkers, who were 19 feet away. I was humiliated and almost left without it because I felt stupid for asking. Low and behold they came back a few minutes later and asked my name because THEY LOST MY TICKET. Which I don't care, just admit it and say sorry. But to gaslight me and talk shit within listening distance is just a joke. Won't be back again. read more

I can't believe a bagel shop could be this slow. 4 behind the counter, one order ahead of me. Sat here for over 15 minutes waiting for one toasted bagel with cream cheese. I hope I am the exception but for five bucks a bagel, I'm going elsewhere. read more

Less than one star. I walked in and waited 20" for nothing. Three crew members not a lot of customers, but totally not able to accommodate orders!!! The frosting on the bagel is when the gal at the cash register was opening a Bag of cocoa powder with her mouth and pouring it into the container!!!!! Never again read more

The quality of Gib's has really decreased significantly. I have always tried to stay loyal to a local bagel shop but my last several experiences have been frustrating - bagels and food are sloppily thrown together with skimpy use of cream cheese or topping, coffee weak or burnt, parts of the order are often wrong or missing. And the wait is unreasonably long. I am super disappointed and will be looking for a new place for bagels. read more

Extremely disappointed. I went to Gibs all the time growing up and it was my favorite bagel place in Fort Collins but wow the service is slowww. I showed up before they opened and it took them 25 minutes just to make a smoothie making me late to work and it's literally just a premade mix they add milk and ice to. The food is good but order ahead don't waste your time going in read more

Good bagels. Fun choices, sorta pricey for college kids but I'd spend it because the bagels are so yum yum. Awesome fun staff I really enjoyed them! Pictures included below! Fast service, only 1 fill up per drink due to covid. read more

See all

So I gave a 3 because the food is decent, staff are friendly but...... the bathrooms are a problem, I mean a BIG PROBLEM, I had even brought it up the last time I had been there, today I went again it had been awhile..... the bathrooms are super nasty please do something for the love of god! read more

I've been coming to Gib's for several years now. Gib's has the best bagels in town, without question! The everything bagel is my favorite! I enjoy the multiple options of cream cheeses and the breakfast sandwiches are amazing. The coffee is just OK, and I usually don't like getting it at Gib's. While they have options for light roast, dark roast, and a smooth blend, it never quite taste like the quality that I would expect from a place with bagels this good. The service needs work. I can't say I've ever been impressed by the service I received at Gib's. Sometimes they are mildly friendly, and sometimes it seems as though they just don't care. Maybe it's the early mornings that they have to maintain. In any case, I will continue to get the bagels because they are delicious. read more

I am not sure how there are even bad reviews here. I have been coming here for over 20 years and the bagels are always on point, fresh, and delicious! I've never had a bad bagel here and the service is usually very good. The line can back up and be longer at times but that's because the food is so delicious. My favorite bagel here is the everything bagel but really they're all delicious. Their homemade cream cheese is our wonderful and the atmosphere is cozy and nice. The best deal is to get the Gib's dozen which is actually 13 bagels. There are also have wonderful sandwiches, bagel knots, coffee, tea, as well as juices and soft drinks. This is the original Gib's Bagels and my favorite. All the locations are good but I prefer this location. Parking is ample and there's always tons of variety. If you've never been to a Gib's Bagels, then do yourself a favor and head over. If you've been but haven't in a awhile, go back and eat a tasty bagel. read more

We love Gibbs bagels but the service has really gotten bad lately. The wait time is really long and we were mostly done with our bagels before we got our drinks. We will think twice before we come back on a Sunday morning. read more

I come here at least once a week and love it! The quality and customer service is amazing, and I refuse to go to any other bagel place in FOCO! read more

The bagels are good, but the service is consistently terrible....there usually is a (very) slow moving line, but even if you walk in with no one in front of you, you might have to wait 15 minutes for a sandwich! read more

Food is good most of the time but the people who work here frequently forget your order and refuse to comp you even if you have been waiting a half hour or more for your order. Also unless you get extra cream cheese on your bagel they barely put any on there at all. 2 stars for decent food but would one star purely for the braindead customer service that has pissed me off enough times now to not return read more

I've been a loyal customer for 26 years and I absolutely LOVE Gibs. Today I called in an order shortly after they opened and service was spectacular. I got a bagel and it was hot and fresh and ready so quickly. Everyone in there was so nice and friendly and I just wanted to say thank you!! read more