If you are looking for everything that makes a true New York pizzeria special, Gino's of Nesconset absolutely delivers. From the second you walk in, you get that classic NY pizzeria feel. The aroma of fresh pizza hits you immediately, the display cases are packed with options, and there is that comforting neighborhood energy that makes you feel like you have been coming here for years even if it is your first visit. The variety is exactly what you would hope for and more. Rows of specialty slices, classic cheese and pepperoni, Sicilian squares, gourmet pies, heroes, pasta dishes, and so many appetizers it is almost impossible to choose. Everything looks fresh and made with care, not just thrown together. You can tell they take pride in what they serve. The staff were incredible. Friendly, patient, and genuinely welcoming. They move quickly but still take the time to answer questions and make recommendations. That balance of efficiency and warmth is something you only really find in great New York spots. And the food. Absolutely outstanding. The crust had that perfect NY texture, crisp on the outside with just the right chew. The sauce was flavorful without overpowering the cheese, and the toppings were generous and fresh. Every bite tasted exactly how a real New York slice should taste. This is the kind of place you bring friends from out of town when they say they want "real New York pizza." Five stars all the way. read more

Gino's of Nesconset - Detroit style - Pizza Near Me - Nesconset, New York

See all

Great food, great service, pasta night is the best deal! Great for dine-in! Clean interior and friendly vibes read more

See all

I don't know if it was just busy, or different people. We seemed to have gotten someone else's order, we discovered when we opened everything when we got home. We called, and they guy on the phone spoke broken English, couldn't understand what we were saying. We were not going to pack up everything and drive 20 minutes, then wait another 1/2 hour for them to correct it. We ate the squashed rice balls, and the whole wheat pasta drowned in vodka sauce. read more

I cant and dont know where to begin...I have new neighbors and wanted them to try Ginos ...mind you I've been going there since they opened...I was so embarrassed the dough was raw when I told the kid after a week passed by he asked if I took a picture ....REALLY ...INSTEAD OF OFFERING ME A NEW ONE ...I wi still go but totally embarrassed... read more

I haven't tried the pizza yet, but the penne alla vodka is decent. The sauce is creamy and comforting with a light tomato sweetness, though it could use a bit more depth of flavor. 5.9/10. read more

I went to this pizzaria with my son, who is disabled. As he was ordering, the cashier was making fun of him and toying with him, telling him to wait, while he acted like their was a problem with the register screen. We both left, never to go back. read more

Best Party Food! This review is much deserved and long overdue.  We have catered MANY parties from GINOS of NESCONSET over 10+ years years and every time our family and guests rave about the food.  From appetizers like rice balls (my Aunt Mary from Queens loves them) and Buffalo spring rolls (my fav) to the salads, pizza, pasta, heros and entrees your family and friends will be thrilled with the delicious food and very, very full, lol.  SO MUCH FOOD!  And the prices are great$$!  We had over 80 people, got the large package so it worked out to like $9/person.  You can't get a crappy fast food meal for that low a price these days. Our family can seriously eat and we had more than enough for the party, the AFTER party (iykyk) and leftovers today so we didn't have to cook, just sit on the couch and recover, lol! This doesn't mean there aren't other amazing places to get food.  There are!  It's just reminding people who live in Nesconset,  Smithtown,  Ronkonkoma that this small family business is right in their backyard making kick-ass food for your epic party. Order your party food from Ginos of Nesconset and ENJOY! read more

See all

the food is good and after moving here we always ordered here. The last three times we've ordered the customer service has been been horrible. 1st time i had asked pizza to deliver at a certain time it came an hour early. pizza was cold for the guest. second time we waited almost two hours. the third time we asked for pizza to get delivered at a certain time. after a half hour passed and no pizza .. they never had our order down. to say we can longer order from here is a disappointment. best white slices too. read more

When considering the worst pizzeria around, Gino's in Nesconset comes to mind. On one occasion, I ordered a chicken Caesar wrap over the phone for pick-up. Any ordinary person ordering this would expect a standard chicken Caesar wrap. However, that wasn't the case here. What I got was a hot slice of pizza rolled up with three pieces of chicken, Caesar dressing, and cooked lettuce. Typically I wouldn't care about a mix up, but because of how ridiculous this was, I decided to call up and ask if they would exchange it for what I originally ordered. Upon returning it, the entire staff decided to wait at the front to insist that I was the one mistaken about what a chicken Caesar wrap entailed. Instead of just exchanging the food and letting me leave, they felt the need to treat me as if I were a complete moron for even questioning what they gave me. They maintained that this was how it's made and told me that if I ever want to order that again I'd have to specifically say "I'd like a chicken Caesar wrap on a wrap". Seriously? I've even gone ahead and added a photo so you can see how absurd this interaction was for yourself. read more

Gino's of Nesconset - a grilled chicken sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Nesconset, New York

Cashier was attentive, Pizzeria was clean, and the pizza was great! Especially enjoyed the Pepperoni, sausage, banana peppers slice. Excellent read more

Gino's of Nesconset - Pepperoni, Sausage, banana peppers and hot honey - Pizza Near Me - Nesconset, New York

See all

Had the very unfortunate displeasure of getting pizza from Gino's today. First off the pizza looked very unappealing, like it was reheated numerous times before making it to my plate. The smell reminded me of a wet sock that my dog chewed. I definitely am mad I wasted my money here today. There are a million better places on the island! read more

Ginos asked for the food back, that they gave me by mistake, in order to get a refund. Food that was in my house. If that isn't gross. Hope they did not resell it to YOU if you order from there. Talk about inconvenience for their mistake. Plus. what are they doing with that food? Terrible customer service...., and YES I brought the food back. read more

i'm surprised at their rating because the customer service was great and the pizza and chicken roll were absolutely delicious!! i work in the area and i'll definitely be back. read more

Dirty, gross, pizza 3/10. Spent $30 on sh**. Like HOW Attitude from lazy dude up front. Ew ew I need a shower read more

Gino's of Nesconset - a half eaten sandwich on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Nesconset, New York

We order from Ginos all the time. However, this time when we ordered 2 chicken vodka slices, it's very obvious that they just threw chicken with vodka sauce on top of a grandma slice. When I called to ask, they said this is what they do when you order a chicken vodka slice. So, the description is inaccurate. read more

Gino's of Nesconset - Pizza Near Me - Nesconset, New York

This is by far my favorite pizza place in the area. I also love the ones in Commack and Kings Park. My go to is the personal pizza, to stay or to go. The cauliflower crust is the best and it's not easy to come across. I usually personalize the pizza and the staff there is more than accommodating when I ask for a million changes. The BEST thing on the menu is the chicken ala vodka. It's essentially chicken parm with vodka sauce instead of red sauce. The chicken is so tender. It's perfectly fried and dredged in the sauce, with melted cheese on top. I suggest getting it with penne on the side, with the vodka sauce. Last thing worth mentioning is their Groupon take out special! It's 49.99 and you get a full pizza, penne ala vodka, salad, chicken parm hero, bottle of wine AND a $10 gift card. Can't beat it. read more

Can't believe Gino's let me down. As I stated in my previous review, I've been coming here for years, and excepted all the mistakes they've made as any business would. The food is good, and I typically have no complaints there. The reason for this updated review is straight up a customer service/managerial complaint. Went in for sit down dinner with the family and asked about an expired Groupon I purchased a while ago and how I can apply it. Anyone knows that if you have an expired Groupon, it can be used at the establishment for the amount paid for which the amount paid never expires. Gino's refused to honor Groupons terms and policy, and told me that since the Groupon is expired, they can't honor it, even the amount paid. Terrible because this should be an easy one. I bet if Joe the owner was there, he'd do the right thing and this wouldn't have been an issue. I have been coming there for years, such a shame they couldn't rectify something simple. Never had a problem with Groupon, even it the Groupon has expired. I contacted Groupon, and they issued my Groupon bucks back to my account. They stated that Gino's should have honored the amount paid. *Joe, your restaurant is fantastic, usually never a problem. Yes, I did tell the server, who then in turn let the manager know. The server took my phone to look at the Groupon, but still told me I couldn't redeem it for the value paid. I was offered a discount on the bill, but unfortunately didn't cover the amount for the Groupon. I wish I could say there was miscommunication, or some oversight, but I did show your staff the terms and service, and all that I had paid for with the Groupon. Again, to anyone reading the reviews, Gino's is a great local pizza place, and I'll continue going there regardless. Please educate the staff. read more

See all

I have only ever ordered take out, convenient for sure. I have tried their deep dish Sicilian, the pepperoni, the cheese pizza and their garlic know. It's good, not my favorite but good. When we moved to the area they gave us a coupon that said - free pizza for pickup or delivery but when we called they said it was only for pickup and they were quite rude. 4 stars for the food and 3 stars for the service... read more

Well very disappointed with our Grandma Pie what happened here. We ordered and were told 25 minutes to pick up, place was empty pie was cold and needless to say it was terrible. To pay $25.00 for a pie that's not fresh. We have many other places near us that we could have ordered from but always liked the Grandma Pie. read more

I'm again annoyed and disappointed that I ordered from here. I'm eating burnt pizza AGAIN for what must be the last five times. I ordered a grandma pie as usual and it was so crispy that the cheese crunched. The taste was there in the sauce but the crust and cheese were ruined from being overcooked. The side crust was black as well as the bottom of the crust in several places. When I arrived to pick up the pizza I even saw them rotating my pizza for at least ten minutes, when it was clearly done already. When they first opened I was thrilled and told family members it the best pizza I've had in a long time. I get that a business can have a busy day or off day, but this has been consistent over the last 5 or so times I have purchased from here. The last several times I ordered I was met with embarrassing pizza. I am incredibly disappointed, and will begin the search for a new pizza place. read more

Gino's of Nesconset - four slices of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nesconset, New York

The place dirty when I walked in, counter service couldn't have benn more rude and when I asked for a little extra mozzarella on the side (maybe an ounce or two) they charged me an extra $2.00 for cheese! CHEESE!!!! 2 bucks for cheese???? Will not be coming back when their are 3 other pizzarias in the area. bye Felicia!!! read more

Good pizza and hot dishes. They also offer really good packaged meal deals. I got the NFL package this weekend which was 1 regular pie, 2 hot heros of your choice and 18 wings. The wings were super meaty and the mild sauce was very flavorful. The blue cheese that came with it was perfect. Chicken parm heros were good and so was the pie. Definitely will be back. I have also eaten at the Kings Park and Commack locations. All around solid. read more

I was very disappointed with this pizza place on Saturday night 12/18. I know 6 pm - 7 pm is a busy hour to order takeout, but this place seems to get overwhelmed and their pizzas interestedly become overcooked. You would think that wouldn't happen if you are trying to move the pizzas along. I know that all businesses have trouble staffing these days, but restaurants need to remember that every time something goes out, it's like your calling card. If you can't cut it when it's busy, why patronize at all.I rarely eat out anymore because I feel I can make it better at home. And why spend the money? read more

Pizza is always good. They have pasta specials. Had a very sweet server named Ella. Will definitely be back.

I did an online order.The first time order was just Ok.Second time I ordered was on Mother's Day. The order was wrong to begin with and the chicken that came with our dinners were like rubber ,not edible .$150 order and couldn't been eaten.It doesn't came with any eating utensils napkins or bread.Your giving the other Gino's a bad rap. read more

This pizzeria is adequate. Only thing I truly enjoyed from my whole meal was the garlic knots but besides that I'm glad I just bought the Groupon because the pizza was nothing special. The penne alla vodka didn't taste really like it should taste so I will never got the penne from there again only Reason this place gets two stars is because of the good Groupon deal and garlic knots. read more

See all

Went there on friday with my boyfriend. As we were walking in employee with suspenders on and a hat blew a cloud of smoke into our face, How unprofessional why are the employees smoking weed in front of the store where there are childeren present. i would not recommed this business to my family or friends horrible experience and the food was below average. read more

Asked for a custom slice on the spot and they knocked it out of the park! Grandma slice with added vodka and pesto sauce. Will definitely be back for more. read more

Ordered the Piesano pie - and it was delicious!!! Thank you, Gino's and all the pizzerias supporting "Back the Blue"!

Pay attention to reviews! This place has severely gone downhill (maybe change of management??) Received a burnt pizza & weird stares from male workers. Not very friendly. The caucasian male with extremely short, buzzed, dark hair that i've seen throughout the years was glaring at me when I was leaving & getting into my car after picking up my order. Meanwhile we never exchanged two words for him to be watching me intently like that. Super weird/creepy + quality of the food doesn't make up for the service. read more

The absolute worst pizza and stromboli I have ever had. Ordered delivery, when it got here it was cold. The pizza was wet and soggy and seemed under cooked. I heated it up but it made no difference. The tip of the pizza flopped down like a wet rag. The Stromboli was undercooked too. It seemed like they used cornmeal or something in the dough. I had to throw out a whole pie and the Stromboli. read more

Went for the signature "Piesano" slice over the counter and twice it had raw dough. The cheese on the regular slice smelled old. If they're charging $9 for one specialty slice and reg slice it should be better read more

I have given the pizza place, three chances and all three times my pizza taste horrible undercooked pay for extra cheese did not get it and pizza was cold. I'll stick to Gino's of Ronkonkoma. read more

When I went to Gino's it was great. I went on a Monday for pasta night With my family. The ambience was great. I got pasta with a chicken parm hero. The staff there were beyond nice, Ella served us and was so helpful, she was so efficient. I will definitely be coming to Gino's again for pasta night! read more

I catered food for my daughter's Sweet 16 on January 20, 2024 and the food was AMAZING !!!!!! Everything was just perfect ! The trays were nice and filled and it came very hot ! The service and staff at the restaurant were so nice and the owner Joe was wonderful with helping me pick out dishes for the party. He was very understanding and accommodating !! Highly recommend them for your next party or just to go there to eat !!!! A+A+A+A+ read more

Placed an order for pickup at 1pm, get there at 130, told that it will be ready in a few minutes. Wait almost 30 minutes to find out its sitting on side the entire time. Plus the order wasn't accurate. Waste of time and no offer of any compensation read more

I was told that Gino's is the best place for Pizza in this surrounding area. Boy was he right. When we first walked in we grabbed a takeout menu and start looking it over. We ordered a pie, half cheese and half pepperoni and we ordered a pie of Grandma's which was delicious. We had a buffalo chicken slice as well. And garlic knots. I must say to my liking the garlic knots was perfect. They wasn't crunchy at all. If you like hard and crunch garlic knots then you won't like these. When walking in it looks like a regular family style restaurant. I never visited the dining area so I can't rate that. We only order pizza so again unfortunately I can't rate the pasta dishes. In regards to pizza we was very satisfied and will return again. My goal is to try the whole menu by the end of the year. So I will be updating this review. read more

This used to be my go to place when I moved into the area 7 years ago. For the first 6 it was consistently good, but in the last year or so it has really gone down. The sauce is very inconsistent... sometimes bland, most times way too sweet, and WAY TOO MUCH! No matter what you order it's bathed in sauce. The portions have gone down and the prices have gone up. I get it, everyone is feeling the crunch. But, if your gonna raise you prices and reduce portions make sure it tastes good! And make sure it's WARM! I'm not that far yet all my orders take greater than 90 minutes and arrive cold. I'm so disappointed! The worst part is they have an item that my daughter loves that no one else has, so I have to keep ordering from here! C'mom Gino's... Get it together. read more

Just when I thought things couldn't get any worse here. They are allowing customers without masks in the restaurant to order. I ended up giving this place another shot out of local convenience. The food was good until one day they messed up my order. I called up and went back to exchange the order. Instead of the staff just apologizing and exchanging my meal, the staff had the audacity to fight with me and laugh in my face after exchanging my order. This place is a complete shit show! Have no clue how its still in business. The customer is always right. read more

I went there on Wednesday with my family later in the night, The food was dry and overcooked the bottom of the slices were burnt. The people at the counter were not attentive and it looked like i was bothering them by asking for my slices. If you're gonna charge so much for 5 slices at least make them cooked properly. read more