Bravo Brave Owner, from turning a shithole into a Palace. I love what you've done to the place. The Pizza is awesome, a ton of many pizza variations and specialties. The sauce on the rigatoni could be better but, its better than any Pizzeria west of Philly. Work on your calzones, they're mushy, i took one home and popped it in the oven and still couldnt save it. The sausage in the calzone was weird. Thin slices of sausage instead of chopped or diced, just didnt give off any flavor. The staff is great, very hospitable, friendly and caring. The place is very clean, and nice to have dinner there. read more

Got two slices today that tasted terrible because they don't clean their ovens properly. Burnt, ashy taste. Worked in pizza places and this is the most basic thing. Clean your ovens out. Would give zero starts if I could. read more

This place used to be the best ... now I don't know what's worse the idiots that run it or the pizza. Either way, there are a lot better options in the area. read more

Too doughy and dry. It's like the flour is falling off the pizza as you eat it. Can't really recommend tbh.

Used to be my go-to place. Recent bad experience has soured me on it permanently. The counter staff was either incompetent or untrained or both. No matter, they all had a bad attitude. They kept telling me my order wasn't ready -- a simple pie and appetizer-- even though I'd placed the order more than 40 minutes before. When I got fed up with waiting, I wanted my money back, and the staff lied that they couldn't refund my money. There are much better places who deserve your money. read more

Great place for a quick bite to eat, especially after a night out. I've heard some things where their food wasn't great but I have never had any bad experiences with them! Love their chipotle chicken pizza. Ugh. Very sweet staff too! Always cracking it up with us when we go. read more

Ordered a quart of Italian Wedding soup, got home and discovered that they gave me pasta fagioli soup. I threw it out, I hate pasta fagioli. Instead of giving me whatever they felt like perhaps they should have told me that they were out so I could have chosen something else. Look into getting better staff, as a Chef I would never make the decision for the customer read more

This place is a hidden gem and if you like Italian wedding soup you need to try it here! Their garlic knots are amazing.

Very good pizza. Perfect undercarriage. Just the right combination of sauce and cheese. This is one of the areas best pizza.

For a small get-together with friends my wife ordered a few dishes from Old Town Pizza. We had chosen this establishment because we had stopped in one day; at the time our gym was near by; and were very pleasantly surprised at the tastiness of the food. For a pizzeria the "zuppa di pesce" that my wife and I shared was surprisingly delightful. Consequently, we thought we would order the same dishes we had had and added the baked clams to try. In addition to the two trays of: "zuppa di pesce" and fried calamari; we also ordered two trays of baked clams. The restaurant added a side order of "spaghetti marinara." The baked clams, regrettably, were inedible. The stuffing was very soft and did not have a pleasant taste. Because my friend and I always compare our own sauces and pasta to all restaurants we visit, we decided to taste the "spaghetti marinara." It would have been better to pass. The sauce was pasty and lacked seasoning as well as the sweetness of a fresh sauce, the spaghetti were cooked al dente but drowned in the poor tasting sauce.. The fried calamari were crisp, tender and flavorful. The "zuppa di pesce" was good. The takeaways: 1. Food arrived hot. 2. Portions are good. 3. Stick to ordering what you have already sampled. read more

Bad takeout. I did Uber eats that was good. But the food was terrible and just plain gross. The Buffalo cauliflower was mushy and the outside slimy. Right in the garbage. I got hot antipasto. The stuffed mushrooms was like a soup. I didn't realize the baked clams was under that soup. It was sweet and bad. I got chicken cutlet parm. They chopped it up into slices. They were so dry. The sauce was way too sweet. Put down the sugar. At first I couldn't tell what was the eggplant and what was the chicken. Eggplant very thick. Thank goodness for the garlic bread and garlic knots. Hopefully their pizza is better because their takeout sucks. I gave it two stars because when I called they were nice on the phone. Still bad food read more

See all

Catered food last minute for my Dept. Just under 500 dollars we had about 70 people show up. Everyone loved the pork osso bucco with risotto. The risotto is unbelievable. Rigatoni Genovese what perfect, penne alla vodka was perfect, sausage and peppers were incredible. Bread basket went great. The antipasto was spot on and they packaged everything and gave us plenty of extra sauce. They ate it up. Thank you so much guys. TFD members loved it. read more

This place is always busy with lots of customers ordering takeout. That shows how good it is. But there are booths for eat-in too. Service has always been good whenever I went there. I usually drop in for a chicken parmigiana hero, but have had other things too. The food is always fresh. A huge parking lot in front makes it easy to park. Take-out usually takes about 20 minutes to prepare, but you can call ahead to have it ready. read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson Station, New York

See all

The food is outstanding, especially their eggplant parmigiana! Better than Grandma's!! Pizza and dinner are the best. Give them a try, you won't be disappointed!! read more

They have great food, but the customer service is terrible, they just hung up the phone, because I ask if they have something else to my to add. I call again 5 times, he just said to me, I tell you when you ready call back. He is a simple lier ... so rude read more

This place has amazing salad pizza and pasta dishes. Love to grab take out or eat in this place. Have been ordering the salad pizza for years. read more

Meatball hero for $10.50, called to ask why there was one half slice of a meatball on hero and was told that's the way Kitchen makes it. Pathetic staff and response. For $10.50 should at least be 3 meatballs on it. read more

Old Town Pizza - This is a meatball hero from Old Town Pizza, they charged $10.50 and there's one little piece of meatball. - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson Station, New York

I like their pizza but it needs to be well done for me. It would be nice to walk in,order a very well done pie at 2pm on a Friday afternoon, wait 15 minutes to go back and pick it up, and it was at least well done, let alone very wwll done. Might help if the guy making the pie grew up eating pizza and not pupusas. read more

I like the pizza from here and they have delicious garlic knots. The inside can be a little crazy when trying to pick up your order when it's busy. The workers are usually helpful and friendly. They have a couple of booths to sit at if you want to dine in, but I usually just do take out. read more

We got wings here for an appetizer with our meal one night, and now it's our go-to place for wings. They are so good!! The size of the wings are perfect and price is on point. We have had the Teriyaki. BBQ, Marsala and Garlic Parmesan. All the flavors a great. read more

Old Town Pizza - owned by a family that has several other pizzerias and a restaurant....They know how to do food...PERIOD!

With exceptional specialty in service and ITALIANO eats Old Town Pizzeria is an array of fineness Served by John was as absolute pleasure the listening of his story within the restaurant business for 15 yrs. and his journey with Old Town Pizza was a remarkable insight to the dedication and integrity he has for his time with the business. When you hear such marvelous feedback from employee's of there employer you can't help but appreciate a business more. The infrastructure of this business is high standards serving fine eats. Rosie was just as welcoming this crew is one fine asset in customer service Sit in service for dining is great Ambiance and decor is beautiful Very welcoming and friendly Prices are excellent Plenty of parking A must try if you haven't A family loved business read more

See all

Ordered a pie New Year's Day as well as a couple of entrees and was brought this horrendous looking pizza 40 minutes later. Pizza was cold in the middle and totally overdone. I can understand being busy and a pie going slightly cold but this clearly was not the case. There was zero cheese pull and this was definitely a pie they baked the night before and was thrown in for a second time. Burnt and inedible. read more

Old Town Pizza - Horrid pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson Station, New York

Our go-to pizza place!! The menu is big and everything is delicious. You can taste that they take the time to make their dough and the appropriate sauces for all the different pizzas they offer. read more

Had the cauliflower pizza, crust was soggy and I live 5 minutes away. Could have used more sauce as it was dry. Staff was friendly and efficient. read more

Stopped in for a slice. Needed a snack. NONE of the workers were completely covering their faces with masks. Most of the cooks in the back room didn't have one on at all! Sorry, maybe I'm overthinking this thing but if you post a sign that patrons must wear a mask to enter, maybe the employees should as well. Oh, I left without my slice. read more

I called at 5pm to order a pie for delivery at my house after ordering for our place of business. Finally 8pm I called again because They never showed. I called three times, got three different stories! The fourth time I called to cancel and make sure they charged my card back. The manager grabbed the phone YELLED at me " there's a pizza coming outta the oven now, you want it YES OR NO" We are new to the area found a decent pizza place that delivers, but constantly at our shop and home. This is s service ? Any reccomendations for GOOD PIZZA WITH GOOD CUSTOMER service? read more

Sad overpriced salad been order odor years never again to charge $2 for extra cheese and it's less than regular disgusting read more

Old Town Pizza - So this is what u get for 10 dollars? - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson Station, New York

The service was reprehensible. I ordered a Caprese salad and they substituted a totally different salad without giving us proper notice. The salad they substituted was a burrata salad without any cheese, which is the reason I'm assuming I didn't receive a Caprese salad to begin with. That's annoying but understandable. However when we called to see if we could get something else more to my taste, the man was incredibly rude and then hung up on us mid-word, which is entirely unacceptable. Do better. read more

Love this spot. Pizza so good and the staff friendly as can be. Sweet and attentive to me and my kids. Don't change!

First, I think they have new owners, I ordered Granny Pie, when I got home I can see it was much smaller then the previous time I bought a G Pie, not only was it smaller, but , I had 4 pieces WITHOUT CHEESE. What's going on ? I'm going back with the 15 cut outs and get a regular pie. Going to look around for another Pizza place. sorry, but I felt taken, NO MORE. ! read more

Just picked up dinner from here for the first time since it was Pepino's years ago. I ordered a large Neapolitan pie and a sausage calzone, both to-go. The cheese:sauce ratio on the pizza was excellent and it's probably the best sauce I've ever had on any pizza in my entire life. That says a lot. But none of us were crazy about the crust. It was kind of bready and not crisp at all. Seems like it was taken out of the oven the second it was done and didn't really have a chance to brown at all. I'm always reluctant to ever ask for a well-done pie, but maybe next time I will and see how that turns out. I'm still giving them 4 stars because the rest of the pizza was just that good and the crust wasn't bad per se. As for the sausage calzone, it wasn't that great. It was HUGE, but the sausage wasn't too flavorful and the ricotta and mozzarella took over because there was just so much of it. However the small container of sauce they give you on the side was other-worldly and I could've drank it out of a glass. The staff was very friendly and made small talk while I waited and the speciality slices looked great. Dat sauce doe! read more

We ordered from this place last night after having an awful customer service experience a few months back & swearing to never order from here again. Last night was an absolute nightmare & reminder as to why we swore this place off initially. 1) My pizza box was delivered completely open, and when I asked the driver why the box was open his answer was, "bc it's not closed". 2) We opted for garlic parm crust, which ended up being a ridiculous amount of chopped garlic sloppily thrown on the pizzas crust & top half of the pizza. My family loves garlic, but this was just ridiculous. 3) After scraping the garlic off, the pizza simply wasn't good. 4) We also ordered clams which were the reason we tried them again bc they were the 1 thing we remember being good, they were awful. 5) I will say, we ordered a chicken Caesar wrap which was good. 6) On top of everything our order was late. Not sure if I'm more annoyed with them, or with myself for trying them out after having swore them off. read more

We wanted pasta tonight and automatically went to old town pizza. It's close and always good in the past. 2 of us has the lobster ravioli and my husband had the pasta pomodoro with sausage. The sauce with the lobster ravioli was awful!! The shrimp & scallops in the sauce tasted like they had been in there for days. They were tough & inedible! The pomodoro sauce was like paste. Now I always knew a pomodoro sauce to be light w/ basil, this stuff was far from it and the sausage in the sauce was so dried out! $70+ dollars for 3 dinners that ended up in the garbage is a disgrace! Not the first time we've been disappointed here, but it will definitely be the last! read more

This is the best restaurant around. They are nice people. Try the classic with garlic and oil. Or the Veal. Written by the old guy who buys food every day. read more

Food is good but the attitude that I received from one of the workers made me never wanna go ever again , shouldn't be getting frustrated with me when I can't pronounce the word right . Terrible read more

Trying Old Town Pizza out again after a rocky first time and I gotta say, I do very much enjoy the food here! My family orders in a lot and lately OTP has been the go to. I get a few different things but I really love their salads! The portions for a size large are astronomical! The Cesar dressing is really good and I am very particular about dressing. My sister always gets the crispy chicken salad and it's very delicious and unique! The delivery sometimes can be longer than what I hope for but like I said in my previous review their ETA is always on point! Good work guys! Dennis: Thank you for reaching out to me. I looked over other reviews and I like how you are continuously willing to make any situation better for a customer. If I could make a suggestion I would recommend to stay open a little later, even if just until 11. Also I've been wanting to try the pasta again! Coming from my personal opinion I would say that with the amount of sauce, less is more. read more

This cute place is a cozy pizza place. They offer great service as well as good food. Never had an issue here. Please support local businesses at this time. read more

So good! I got a cheese calzone there and it was delicious!! Their specialty slices are also huge and you always get something yummy too. I like the chicken bacon ranch and the bbq chicken pizza. The employees working were super nice. I definitely plan on going more often! read more

I ordered two pies and they came extremely burnt , and cold , very unexceptionable even the pin wheel was extremely charred to bits , i will not be coming here again , the amount of money i spend here this is disgusting that you would even deliver something this burnt an not even warm , i waited over an hour for cold burnt pizza not one pie but 2! I want a refund for both of my pies this is ridiculous read more

See all