Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Godfather’s Pizza

    5.0 (1 review)

    Order Godfather’s Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Godfather’s Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Godfather’s Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Daniel G.
    0
    93
    516

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Godfather’s Pizza

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 15,080 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Tiny's - Schnitzel with spaetzle and potato pancake.

    Tiny's

    3.8(30 reviews)
    4.9 mi
    $

    We love Tiny's- an essential Columbia experience that's been around for generations. The owner is…read morekind and contributes to the community in a variety of ways, so you can feel good about keeping your dollars local. They serve an extensive selection of local and German beers. The newly renovated front bar area is very nice too! The exposed brick and the wood bar keep the vibes cozy and inviting. The back bar area has plenty of room for dining and socializing. Wait staff are friendly and helpful and have gone out of their way to accommodate my kids and their tastes. We have been to several community events here. They offer traditional bar fare and appetizers, but in the past several years, they have expanded the German food menu. You really can't go wrong with any of it! On Wednesdays, Tiny's offers soup flights and all of the choices are excellent.

    They weren't busy at all but I waited 20 minutes before I had to get up to get a waitress to give…read moreus menus. Neither of us could drink the iced tea, It was disgusting. The food wasn't very good, my friend ordered German potato salad, but got coleslaw, which was turning bad. Potato skins were wedges - not much cheese and very little bacon. We had to ask for every refill of soda/water, even though we tipped well, we waited at least 15 minutes for the bill until the guy behind the bar noticed and came to our assistance. We stayed and talked, but somebody turned the music up so loud we had to go outside to finish our conversation. Neither of us will return.

    Photos
    Tiny's - The newly renovated front area (at a private holiday party)

    The newly renovated front area (at a private holiday party)

    Tiny's - Jagerschnitzel with mushroom gravy sauce and spaetzle - YUM

    Jagerschnitzel with mushroom gravy sauce and spaetzle - YUM

    Tiny's - German beers on tap

    See all

    German beers on tap

    Eni's Pizza

    Eni's Pizza

    4.3(45 reviews)
    5.3 miPrinceton Heights

    I've had many deliveries from Eni's pizza and i am only adding this review as they messed up my…read moreonline order, but I think it was because the person that called me was not a native English speaker. He called me after I had placed the order and paid and said they were out of the ham for the pizza so he kept saying they would use sausage. I don't like sausage and told the man that called to just make the pizza without the ham (it was to be their Hawaiian special plus I added ham to it and accepted their up charge to do that). I am not sure why they have ham and bacon as options if they don't carry them (or were they just out?) as I asked the caller to sub bacon for the ham and he said they didn't have that either. NOTE: I did use the "SLICE" pizza app to order my meal but the Eni's menu and the Slice app's menu for Eni's appear to be the same. The 2nd surprise to me was that I ordered a salad, this time I decided to try their Caesar salad, and I was surprised as it came DIY style. See pic, but I'm not complaining about the salad, I got all the ingredients, it just seemed strange. So, what was messed up? As I said I don't like sausage at all so I ordered their Hawaiian special of beef & pineapple, plus I added the ham. When the man called me and said no ham, I said three times to just make it like the menu said. The caller suggested sausage and I think he said spicy sausage was available too (again he did not sound like a native English speaker) so I repeated no, just make it like the menu and don't add anything extra to it. So when it arrived, it looked like hamburger / ground beef but the first bite had a powerful unexpected taste, it had sausage. I ate part of the pizza but had to stop due to the flavor. This is the first real problem I've had with Eni's, I did have another issue on a previous order but the owner resolved that one to both of our satisfaction. I still say I love their base pizza as it has a hand tossed dough, basic pizza sauce and good amount of cheese. So in the future I may just order a plain cheese pizza.

    Seeing all these Yummy pizza reviews I had to post the 1st stop on our 2024 Pizza Passport tour!!!!…read more New place on the Passport this year and a place we have never been. Eni's Pizza off Gravois. We went early so there was absolutely no one there. At first we thought they were a new place but the owner stated they had been there since 2016. We couldn't figure out if this was a Pizzeria or a Mexican place cause we got Chips n Salsa??? But good!!! The Fried Cheese was very good and all pizza are 12 inches and they have Specialty ones or you can make your own. We choose Sausage/Pepperoni/ Mushroom. I love the thicker crust and they are Wood Fired!! Very good. The place just added a Mexican Lunch special during the week. They also have some Greek options as well!!! Full Bar as well!!! Service was Great!!! So if you cannot decide between Pizza Mexican or Greek... just go to Eni's!!!

    Photos
    Eni's Pizza
    Eni's Pizza
    Eni's Pizza

    See all

    Godfather’s Pizza - pizza - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...