Today almost turned into a really bad birthday dinner day for my fiancé , but 1803 Pizza/Kitchen…read morecame through in the clutch! I like to take the focus off me by saying I have a procrastination demon because I can wait until the last minute to plan things . Unfortunately, I ran behind at work today and we had a 5:30 reservation for Bar Italia. I've only been there one other time and when I went, it was still fairly new to the area so it wasn't busy. Apparently the residents of Winter Park have now adopted this spot as their official happy hour headquarters because this place was PACKED. I messaged the staff ahead of time letting them know we were running late and asked if we could move our reservation, but unfortunately they told us there weren't any later reservations available. We still decided to drive there anyway since we'll take you without a reservation. Upon arrival, there were already several groups ahead of us asking about seating and everyone was being told the same thing: they were no longer taking reservations for the night and to try back again in 30 minutes. (I didn't expect to be accommodated because I know we were late so please don't take this as me complaining; I am just giving the complete run down.) Thankfully, I had a backup restaurant for us to try which was 1803 Pizza/Kitchen. I had read some reviews that were amazing and some that were kind of on the fence, but I figured we should just try it for ourselves. Surprisingly, there was only one other table dining inside when we arrived, but there were several people constantly coming in and out picking up to-go orders. It felt like a cozy family neighborhood restaurant, I really like that feeling. We ordered the house salad, fries, Margherita pizza, and chicken parmesan, which is made a little differently because the pasta is tossed in vodka sauce instead of marinara. The salad was simple but SO good; it's also enough to share. The balsamic really made the salad and everything tasted super fresh and crisp, which I appreciated. My fiancé doesn't eat onions so they accommodated us by using grape tomatoes instead of their normal tomato/onion blend which was really nice. I'm usually not a huge fan of ordering fries at restaurants because a lot of times they taste like they came straight from a freezer bag , but these honestly tasted like fresh fries and were so good! They also had some sort of seasoning on them that wasn't overly salty but added so much flavor. Our food came out quickly and both entrées were served at the same time. The pizza had the perfect amount of bite, although I do wish the center crust had been just a little firmer. Overall though, the flavor was great. The crust was airy and light, the sauce was delicious, and we genuinely enjoyed everything we ate. My only small pet peeve is that I don't think the pasta itself was freshly made, and that was one of the reasons I originally wanted to try the restaurant because I had read reviews saying they offered fresh pasta. But honestly, everything was still delicious regardless. We ended up getting dessert to-go, so I don't have a review for that just yet, but if it's anywhere near as good as the food was, I already know we're going to enjoy it too!

First time here, went cause there was a van in my neighborhood with the logo and tempting pics of…read morecheesecakes lol. So I decided to go check it out. They were closed but the nice lady inside saw me and let me in. She said they r open just for the sweets but they usually open at 5pm for the pizza. So I got the pistachio. The Ferrero Roche & the Dubai chocolate cup. Well they were all good but my favorite was the cup. So creamy, so good. Now I gotta come back to try the pizza and get some more sweets. Is a cute little restaurant right in winter park. Staff was very friendly. $12 a pop per slice and they do have a punch hole card for every visit ( after 9 punches a free item).

Legit decent pizza. I usually like more toppings the better but the cheese is pretty good and enjoy…read morejust plain cheese pizza the best Service was good and prompt. The place seems like it can get sweaty on a really hot day bc the ventilation seems limited. They have a bunch of TVs all over too Happy hours are Tues - Fri, 3-6p and all day Monday

"What I Ordered vs What I Got"…read more I ordered a simple Chicken Palermo with chicken, shrimp and broccoli. You know, the red/orange ziti pasta? Well, I received an ALL WHITE meal, I wish I knew what flavor it was. It was disgusting. Chicken was raw, the shrimp was weirdly salty, and the spaghetti pasta was barely soaked. Just hard. Shouldn't be an issue to just call and get it straightened out with simply getting my correct order, right? No lol wrong. The woman who answered the phone gave me attitude because I told her my order was wrong and was simply wondering if I could retrieve my CORRECT order. "Well no, I put the right order out and it was sent out" in the most condescending tone. The attitude continued as I continued to explain, very disheartening as I was starving too. She didn't even apologize or say bye at the end of the call, just hung up. Disappointing because this was my second time ordering, I wanted the same experience I had my first time around. I just knew I'd be a loyal customer with 95 orders within three months. Work on it! Your 1-Star reviews are growing and it doesn't have to be that way!

Yes, this place amuses me. And when hunger pangs kick in after a few attempts a light eating, I…read moreknew a calzone was in order to quell my craving for something delicious and filling. And after searching Uber Eats for Calzones, I settled on Goodfellas since I had it before and it was a reasonable price... even for delivery. I like my calzones simple... ricotta, mozzerella and on meat, usually ham or meatballs. If you get too many toppings (insidings?), then they tend to skimp on the cheese so they can pack it in there like Han Solo stuffing Luke into a Taun Taun (especially if you pick pepperoni which just makes is soooooo greasy) They have one of the best Calzone's in town and I have no idea what a large would entail, other than a trip to the hospital. The small is a good value. This would be 5 stars if it wasn't for the super duper small portion of wedding soup. What Italian in their right mind would give a guest such a small portion? It was good, but small. And had ditalini instead of acini di pepe. C'mon man!!!! They do have dining in the restaurant which is always better than getting it to go, but the convenience of ordering and still having it be delicious is a plus!

Always a good Italian restaurant. Service was pleasant during our latest visit…read more Don't skip on the garlic knots. They're one of the bests. They include the perfect amount of olive oil and garlic. I love that the meals include bread and a side salad (house or Cesar). This time I got the Chicken Antonio. The meal included a lot of food. However, I wasn't feeling the taste this evening. It was good, just not great.

A great local NY-style pizza place that uses good ingredients and makes everything nice and fresh…read more I did also really love their beverage fridge - which stood out to me. So many options! This is my husband's new go-to place. He's been dropping by once a week since we discovered it!

I might already be known as the Pizza Connoisseur, but there is so many places I have needed to…read morevisit. I was in the mood for New York style pizza. Just all around wanting no big frills but a plain pepperoni slice. Yelp had led me to Seby's. I placed an online order on a Friday night for an 18 in pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. Once I got to the restaurant, you can tell they are all about the New York vibe. There was all sorts of New York photos and really cool was the New York live stream of someone walking around. We had to wait about 15 more minutes from when it was supposed to be ready but it was a very busy night. Which to me was a good sign. The owner was friendly speaking to many in the front waiting area. Let's get to the food. It was just what I had been craving. It was so delicious would a good amount of pepperonis. It was thinner with great flavor. The crust held up the pizza without being too crisp. We ordered the 18 in but it was SO MUCH PIZZA. For 2 people, I would suggest the 12 in option. The garlic knots were packed with garlic and so yummy. 6 came in an order of knots. Everything heated up amazingly in an air fryer the next day. I have since been back again. Thanks for the great food.

Very delicious and fresh food!! The bread and garlic butter is amazing, the pizza is delicious, and…read morethe calamari is some of the best I've had in a very long time!! Service was great too! Will definitely return and recommend!!

It's been a while since we ate here- my husband loved the stuffed pizza. This time we ordered it…read moreand it's small like a the size of Little Caesars slice! Barely stuffed and it's $8 a slice!! So $16 for 2 mini size slices! The garlic knots use to have a ton of real garlic chunks and olive oil a now it's a little bit if canned minced garlic and garlic powder!! We will definitely not be back

Awesome homemade dough, Tomato Sauce, everything is backed fresh, nothing fried at all. Gelato…read more fresh 8 flavors and two Sorbet too Also awesome smash Burger with oven baked Potato Chips calzone Stromboli, five different salad, three different types of olives and pasta salad

Let's start with ambiance, this place is hands down gorgeous. So much space great for groups. The…read moreservice was amazing, they make you feel at home and are so helpful. We ordered a 12 inch cheese and a 8 inch veggie pizza along with garlic knots. The cheese pizza was delicious as-well as the veggie. The garlic knots have to be the best I've ever tried. Definitely a must go to spot. I will say the style of pizza is pretty known for small slices so if you are going as a group you might need to order more than one pie but it's definitely worth it! In total for all we got is was about 35$. Which is worth it, the food was Amazing.

Pizza was really good, has that NY flavor. Service was excellent the people that worked there were…read morereally nice. I will definitely be going back to get pizza!

I used to go to Anthony's quite a bit - it was THE best pizza (and everything else) around. . …read more Unfortunately, I moved so it was a bit out of the way. I'm so disenchanted with most pizza places since I compare everything to the Original Anthony's NY Pizza - and nothing, and I mean NOTHING, compares. I've been thinking about Anthony's a lot and yesterday while i was out and within 10 miles, I decided to pick up a pizza mid afternoon for dinner that evening since I was embarking on a 5-day fast the next day. I got that bad boy home smelling the fresh garlic all the way and was so hopeful I wouldn't be disappointed. I swear it was better than I expected and hoped. While i was going to ask for extra garlic but did not and it was actually a perfect amount. The onion, mushrooms, and half pepperoni were perfect - excellent products used still. I will not wait this long to return since i couldn't have been more happy with this pizza - it's worth the drive without a question. There are so many 'Anthonys' around, but NOTHING compares to this original Anthony's - it's absolutely the BEST!

Truly extraordinary. Let me start with the service. It is TOP TIER. You couldn't ask for better…read morecustomer service. I thoroughly enjoyed the explanation of how the restaurant came to be. I also enjoyed the walk through of the menu and the different dishes/pizza ordered. My friend and I started with the Burrata. It was phenomenal. I loved the flavor of the balsamic glaze. The rosemary focaccia bread was superb. For pizzas we decided upon the Star Beckham and the Marco. I really enjoyed the star shaped pizza. The triangle crust was packed with a good amount of ricotta cheese. There was lots of toppings and some of the freshest ingredient pizza I've ever had. The Marco pizza was good getting to try the stracciatella cheese for the first time. The restaurant is really cute. Its an intimate dining room area and you can see into the kitchen seeing the pizzas cooking. I had a great time here and a great meal.

Where are my pizza lovers who are getting bored with the same old, same old? Mister 01 is here to…read morespice things up! Mister 01 makes a thin crust gourmet pizza fired up hot. They ferment their dough for 72 hours before serving. Most of their pizza menu is different from what passes for pizza in the US today, but it's nothing you haven't seen if you're a true pizza lover who appreciates authentic pies. You will find arugula, burrata, calabrese, and more here. If you can't find a pizza on the menu that ticks all your boxes, you can also make your own. In particular, for my ricotta lovers, I must insist you try their "star" pizzas where they pinch around the pizza edge to make little ricotta pouches. Think stuffed crust pizza only much, much better! The inside of the restaurant is nice, but definitely casual. Service was great. They do offer takeout and work with the DoorDash types but we found this pizza doesn't travel as well since it's so thin and chills quickly. Eat in if you can. The prices here are a bit higher than I would expect, especially since the toppings are a bit on the skimpy side, but that's really my only complaint. Definitely try this place out when you're craving REAL pizza!