Cancel

Open app

Search

Good Bakes Co.

5.0 (14 reviews)
Closed 12:00 pm - 5:00 PM
Updated 2 weeks ago

Good Bakes Co. Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Good Bakes Co.

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Megan J.

I found Good Bakes Co. when I needed an emergency cake for a book club birthday, and it blew us away. Everyone was blown away by the gorgeous design that harkened to the colorful book cover, and several people(including the birthday girl) said the cake was the best they're ever had. Shayla was friendly, creative and clearly dedicated to making my deadline. I would happily recommend this company to anyone and all of my girlfriends said the same!!

If you're even considering a cake, go with Good Bakes Co! My family and I were renting a house in Kissimmee for my dad's birthday and Shayla made an amazing cake for us! I told her what flavor we wanted and that we would like a cake topper. The cake arrived perfectly and beautifully with a wonderful topper and some tasteful sprinkles to match! The cake was even delivered right to our door. We got the carrot cake which was very moist and was well complemented by the frosting and caramel sauce. I could eat and entire bowl of just that sauce! If you're not sure what you want, just contact Shayla through the website and she'll help you out! The smaller size was enough to feed our family of 7 for a couple days. You won't regret it!

"chocolate decadance" cake. Was so excited that I forgot to take a pic before we took a slice!
Angela L.

Shayla worked with me to create a custom cake that was perfect for my spouse! I really appreciated the level of communication to figure out cake needs and the strategy she put into the cake itself to come up with something to liven up a socially distanced birthday with our little family.

My cake was red velvet with chocolate flavored icing.

Shayla was amazing with executing the idea for my cake. Great communication and customer service. Not only did my cake look beautiful but tasted delicious as well! It was the talk of the night thank u so much! I will definitely be ordering again!

the number two made out of cupcakes

See all

9 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Amanda F.
326
24
20

4 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Shayla D.

Shayla D.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Megan J.
142
10
19

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Shayla D.

Shayla D.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Ema L.
34
12
23

4 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Shayla D.

Shayla D.

Thank you so much for your feedback Ema! It was a pleasure!

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Alishia H.
95
109
45

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Good Bakes Co.

Review Highlights - Good Bakes Co.

My family and I were renting a house in Kissimmee for my dad's birthday and Shayla made an amazing cake for us!

Mentioned in 9 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Sofelle Cake Artistry - Romantic Buttercream Cake with Silver Lace and hand-crafted sugar flowers.

Sofelle Cake Artistry

4.9(27 reviews)
5.5 km

I recently needed a cake, last minute, for my sister's graduation from medical school! I decided to…read morego with Sofelle Cake Artistry because she had nothing but 5 star reviews on google reviews and the wedding websites and everyone seemed pretty satisfied with the flavor. I discussed with Lucy and put my order in for my rather large one tier cake on a Monday, confirmed and paid for that night, and picked it up on a Thursday morning. I don't know many cake artists who would have put up with me! Let's talk flavor: I live in Miami and I was not able to come in to pick flavors so I read the reviews, and decided to go with the Vanilla Cake, Dulce de Leche, and butterscotch buttercream purely on a whim even though the Champaign Raspberry seemed to be the most popular review. I am pleased to report that it was AMAZING!! The buttercream was soooooooo smooth and the butterscotch wasn't over powering, just delicate enough to let the dulce shine and marry with the soft and delightful vanilla cake. It was truly delicious! Even the fondant was yummy and I NEVER eat the fondant. The design was perfect! She gave me some options and we tweaked them and she delivered!!!!! The party was a hit and so was the cake. My sister received many compliments on her Instagram about how "bomb" her cakes looked. It tasted bomb too. Lucy is SO sweet and such a pleasure to work with!! I would recommend her without reservation to anyone, and I am a VERY difficult person to please when it comes to food. I only accept top notch, and she really delivered. THANK YOU LUCY!!!!

Lucy knows her stuff. What a wonderful person and a great baker and teacher. I have just completed…read moremy 3rd class and I have learned so much. I have very little experience and I have produced some impressive cakes in her classes. I am so glad I discovered the classes and D and G Occasions..

Photos
Sofelle Cake Artistry - My wedding cake by Lucy

My wedding cake by Lucy

Sofelle Cake Artistry - Photo Credit: Thinh Le Photography

Photo Credit: Thinh Le Photography

Sofelle Cake Artistry - 1m  Newly engaged?  Call us now to design your unique cake!  #weddingcakes #orlandosbest

See all

1m Newly engaged? Call us now to design your unique cake! #weddingcakes #orlandosbest

Valhalla Bakery - Back prep area

Valhalla Bakery

4.6(42 reviews)
11.3 km
$$

I'm no vegan, but their Guava and Cheese Pastry made me question why not---Unfortunately, I'm not…read moreone to try vegan options often as I'm not vegan myself and have been disappointed by mock-dairy ingredients based items. However, their Guava and Cheese Pastry was so perfectly scrumptious I couldn't tell the difference! Pricing: Ranges but very affordable low cost items for single slices or portions to slightly pricier full pies or cakes etc. Food: Delicious, seasonal flavors and consistent classics keep you coming back for more. My family and I visited Orlando and loved it so much we came back multiple times during our stay. Service & Ambiance: Friendly is an understatement. My family were regulars apparently enough to the point the staff waved them in with a cheery wave hello. The shop is such a hole-in-the wall with simple and bright decorations, that have you feeling like you're visiting someone's home.

To say that I'm impressed with Valhalla Bakery is an understatement. We needed to have some vegan…read moretreats for a going away party, so of course this was the first place I thought of! I've had their pastries before but never any of their cakes. You would never know from looking or tasting the cake that it was completely vegan! It was heavy and full like a regular cake would be, and had a great taste to it! When it came to decorations I gave the team creative control to do what they wanted, and what the result was ended up being very elegant! I also had to get some cupcakes to have as well because why not? This bakery is a great option for vegans and non-vegans alike if you ask me. The presentation and flavor will always have me running back!

Photos
Valhalla Bakery - Outside sign

Outside sign

Valhalla Bakery
Valhalla Bakery - Naked cake

See all

Naked cake

Annette's Cakes and Cake Supplies - Annette Cakes

Annette's Cakes and Cake Supplies

4.1(47 reviews)
10.4 kmEast Orlando
$$

Not impressed at all. I recently bought chocolate from here, and took it to our baking weekend to…read moremake homemade turtles. I've been making them for 25 years and have never had an issue with heating chocolate melts like this, in a Pyrex dish on a double boiler on low. Well, this chocolate never got past the point of a peanut butter consistency. I let it cool and put it back in the bag to take back to this business. Annette herself came out and told me I did something to cause it to seize. I explained that I didn't, because I know how to melt chocolate as I've been doing it for 25 years. My mom for 35-40. We know how to work with chocolate. She wanted to demonstrate how to melt it for me (again, already know how, there is not time to stop and microwave small amounts of chocolate for 30 seconds and then stand there stirring it in a cup every few mins when you're mass producing homemade turtles. I acknowledged that she was able to melt it that way, but explained I was displeased with the product and wanted a refund. She smirked at me!! She stated she could never provide a refund as the health department wouldn't allow product to be returned to the store. Nobody said anything about returning it, throw it away!! I would hope to God she wouldn't resell it to someone! I'll throw it away, I'll whip it out into the field next to your business. I don't want it because it's not good product. I just asked for a refund so I could go buy some good chocolate to use. She is obviously not worried about making sure her customers are happy, because she wasn't worried about losing me as a customer. I will NEVER go back to this business. And I will let anyone who asks me to not use their business and why. Terrible customer service. Terrible first impression. This was my 1st and last time using them.

Wanted to get a custom cake and they basically tried to charge me $100 for a basic small cake and a…read morefake/inedible topper. -.- I'm sure their cakes are good though, I just felt like they were trying to upcharge me.

Photos
Annette's Cakes and Cake Supplies
Annette's Cakes and Cake Supplies - Annette's cakes

Annette's cakes

Annette's Cakes and Cake Supplies - Silicone Hydrangea mold used for pottery detail.

See all

Silicone Hydrangea mold used for pottery detail.

Butter Bliss Bakeshop - Smores hand pie

Butter Bliss Bakeshop

4.8(19 reviews)
9.6 km

Five stars for fabulous local baked goods delivered to your doorstep, contactless if you prefer…read more Available for next day delivery during the week. online ordering was a breeze and the goods were well packaged. Definitely will be ordering again and recommending to others. Glad to have something like this in the area especially one that delivers out to Lake Nona which is rare- so many of the places I'd love to order from don't come out this way or only do so via super pricy third party services. I liked everything I tried- the only complaint was that my s'mores hand pies were more like chocolate hand pies- no marshmallow taste to be found- still delicious and flaky though. The cookies were my favorite but the cranberry shortbread was perfectly tart and buttery as well.

Took park in a Yelp event that included these cupcakes and a bit of a video tutorial with the…read moreowner. It was super fun and very informative. I love when we do things that are different and teach you a fun new skill. In years past I did the Michael's class for cake decorating through the Wilton program and absolutely loved it, so it was fun to get back into this skill set. The cupcakes were delicious and flavorful. The hubs loved the lemon ones we got, and I, of course, loved the chocolate ones :) The icing was pre-bagged in deco bags to help us have some fun, and we got some fun colors. I would like to see them offer some more classes in the future with to-go decorating bags, cause this was a fun adventure!! Overall: A+ Loved the new skill learning and enjoying delicious cupcakes in the process :)

Photos
Butter Bliss Bakeshop - Football theme

Football theme

Butter Bliss Bakeshop - Custom sprinkle cake

Custom sprinkle cake

Butter Bliss Bakeshop - Custom graduation cake

See all

Custom graduation cake

Good Bakes Co. - customcakes - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...