Don't sleep on Susie's! It's a hole in the wall and driving down Karl you might miss it if you're not looking, but dang their sandwiches are good. Firstly, they all come on an Auddino's hard roll. I got the 12" Italian which was topped with Italian deli meats, LTO, hot (salad) pepper rings and their housemade Italian dressing--then slapped on the griddle to warm her up! They have pizza too which i haven't tried. You can call them ahead for quick service when you take out and apparently they deliver too. I'd definitely recomend it as a takeout spot as they have limited seating in their tiny storefront. Lucky for me Susie's is around the corner and apparently they're a big thing. They we're listed on an Ohio Tourism listicle on Facebook as being the #1 sub shop in Ohio! read more

This was a great Italian submarine, I think because of the break they used. The bottom wasn't really thick which made the sandwich much more tasty. There's not much to eating inside however there is tables. I think the carry out orders must be the obvious way to go. read more

See all

Keep hearing about this but I'm just not over this way often. Today I was, and this was right on the way, so duh. Small parking lot, but 10 spaces or so, plenty at lunchtime on a weekday but probably not at peak. No dine-in currently; call ahead, or order there and wait on one of a couple chairs. I got the Big John, an Italian sub with sausage. Came up in about 10 minutes, because I ordered it hot. Very good sub: good bread (Auddino's apparently,) good sausage, good meats, good veggies. And, a good portion at a good price (I got the 8", for $10.) Best in town? I don't know about that. Up in the top 10 or 5, surely, but we have some pretty good ones. But no complaints, for size, taste, or price. A little greasy, which is not a bad thing (for a sub.) I was stuffed. Friendly service, fast for this kind of thing, reasonably priced, and really good food. If I lived closer I'd be back often. read more

I was introduced to this place by my husband years ago and it's been a family favorite for us, especially on a Friday night. The food is always amazing, the service is friendly and the ambiance feels so cozy. The italian subs never disappoint, so good! read more

Susie's Sub Shop - Italian sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I stumbled across an article on the interwebs listing the best sandwiches in every state amd Susieswas the Ohio pick. My boyfriend and I were driving through so we stopped to eat in. More of a takeout spot, but the dining room was clean and comfortable. Service was very friendly. I had the 8" meatball sub with 4 huge meatballs and my boyfriend had 8" sausage sub, and both were pure toasty, cheesy, saucy perfection. 10/10 would detour again. Reminds me of my favorite old school sub shop back home. read more

Susie's Sub Shop - Meatball sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I piicked up subs for dinner, the customer is always good. When I arrived to the location to pick up my subs, my order was ready and still hot. Ive been going there since I was a teenager, it's been in 3 different locations and still good to me. This shop is a family staple. read more

Susie's Sub Shop - Italian sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

What a fantastic joint! We have never been here, so we decided to give it a try before our movie. We got their Italian sub and a personal pizza. Both were amazing. The sauce on the pizza was mouth watering good. The Italian was great, but just a little extra Italian dressing in it would have made it better. I'd advise you to ask for extra dressing. Unfortunately, there is no dine in. I asked when it would be back, and they said hopefully soon. It was blocked off, so you'll have to sit outside. You'll find two picnic tables to the left of the entrance. Other than that, I'll definitely be back to try more subs and a bigger pizza. read more

See all

They have good pizza for sure. There subs are also awesome. I got the pep and cheese it was delicious

Decided to stop in to Susie's Sub Shop this afternoon. It is located on Karl Road. They have been at this location for 3 years. I decided to order a Philly Cheese Roast Beef sandwich and some Garlic Cheese Bread. The Philly Cheese Roast Beef sandwich which had a good amount of roast beef with onions, green peppers, mushrooms and Swiss cheese, all toasted nicely. The Garlic Cheese bread had a very mild garlic flavor to it with a great layer of cheese with some spices sprinkled over it. It was a lot of food for the money. read more

See all

"C-Rating " Cracker thin crust. Liked the crunch but lacked flavor. Didn't care for the sausage. Tasted better fresh, not once it cooled down. Glad I tried it, but it didn't make my list to go again. A- one of my favs B- like but not a go to C- edible, but just okay D- uh... maybe if I am drunk F- oh hell no! never again! read more

Susie's Sub Shop - Garlic cheese bread - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Ordered lunch for my family from here yesterday: a large cheese and a large pepperoni. I'd heard good things about it and it lived up to the hype. The sauce was tasty, and the crust was crispy even hours later when we finished it off. We'll be back for sure. read more

Susie Subs has never disappointed. I usually get either a sub or pizza. Recently I ordered a sausage, pepperoni and I could not have been more satisfied and this is coming from a person who has pretty much given up on outside the home food establishments. Thank you Susie Subs for your consistently in creating subs and pizzas that are always high quality. There are only a couple of places that I will order food and Susie Subs is one of them. read more

Great little locally owned sub shop - had a turkey sub, pepperoni pizza and the pepperoni bites.....all were really good. I'll certainly be back read more

On our quest to try a new pizza place, we traveled to Susie's. This is a small bare bones store with 3 small tables with 2 chairs each to dine in. They are huge OSU Buckeye fans with pictures and collectibles hanging up and on the counter. They offer cans of pop and bottles of water. Boyfriend and I dined in and ordered their Italian sub special of 2 for $12 and shared a medium pizza. We shared one sub and took the other one home. The bread was crisp and thin, which I like. Plenty of meat and toppings and was really good. I believe one of the meats was a little more spicy than I am used to but I liked it. The pizza we ordered with mushrooms & onions with half pepperoni and sausage. The pizza was ok. I think more seasonings in the sauce would have made the difference. I would not mind stopping back in for subs if in the area or even trying the meatball sub. read more

See all

They make really good pizza. The staff is always pretty nice sometimes they are slammed with orders so it's expected for them to be rushing and short. Never had a bad experience with the food. read more

I have been a customer since they were located at Westerville Rd. and Weber Rd. until now when they are maybe seven minutes in traffic from where I live. This has made me hungry so gotta order my spaghetti dinner with a extra meatball. Try them read more

Food is so delicious and the people are great. It's a friendly atmosphere all the way around. If you're looking for made to order fresh food.Try Suzie's subs I promise you won't be disappointed read more

1st time here and got an 8" Big John for $8.50. It's huge, it's messy, it's delicious and now I'm gonna crave it for most likely, the rest of my life. Yeah it's that damn good! They cut a piece of sausage and just threw it on in there, basically a Italian sub with sausage ;-) read more

Susie's Sub Shop - Big John (Wish I never had it, gonna crave it from now on!) - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Nothing Special. Just not good food. Pizza had very little sauce and very little cheese, and the crust was tough. The subs were ok. The people that worked there are very friendly and nice. read more

This is the kind of place you need to go when you're craving a nicely toasted sub. That perfectly crunchy yet soft outer bread is delicious. I got the Philly roast beef. It was exactly what I was looking for! Full of meat and just on the right side of greasy haha. Also, the guy working the counter is really friendly and helpful. I went in and ordered my sub and waited. He chatted me up for a bit and even offered me a slice of pizza while I waited! I will definitely be coming back here! read more

Susie's Sub Shop - Philly roast beef! - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Got a 12in Big John sub that was $13 and a personal 10in pepperoni pizza for $8. The sub gets a four star and the pizza a two. The pizza crust was very oily/greasy. At first I thought the sub was overpriced at $13, and I still felt that is was in the end. It was good though. Parking spaces are very tight. Probably would not get again. read more

See all

This place isn't in the best neighborhood, but the food was great! I ordered a 10 inch pepperoni pizza and a 6 inch meatball sub. The pizza sauce had a nice flavor and the crust was crispy. The meatballs on the sub are huge and the bread was really soft. I will be back! read more

Susie's Sub Shop - Great pizza and meatball sub!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I just had the best Philly ever! They shred their roast beef here at Susies, so you don't get just shavings. It tastes like pot roast on a hoagie. Gotta get it with mayonnaise though! read more

Susie's Sub Shop - Pizza sub - delicious! - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Even in the midst of the epidemic, this shop serves up huge value, great tastes, and a service that is much needed.

Susie's Sub Shop may look unwelcoming from the outside, but once inside the door, it's all smiles, great food and great service. Susie's tosses out a traditional Ohio, edge-to-edge pie. The crust is not crackery thin, but maintains a nice buttery crispness on the bottom. The mushrooms are fresh, not canned (bonus points). The toppings were all quality and the pizza had a little kick to it (either the sauce or the peps, I couldn't tell - but it was very nice). We both enjoyed the pizza. While I'm not the biggest edge to edge fan, if you are, then Susie's is worth a stop. Susie's is one of those great locally owned small businesses where the owners are behind the counter offering up great service with pride in the food they prepare. read more

Susie's Sub Shop - Pep and shroom. - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Best pizza in town very awesome staff and Costmer service and they always make sure they get the food right the first time and they have very awesome subs and the whole menu is so good I will always order from them all the time and can't wait till they start delivery service again but just going back there feels like how much they are appropriate everything and I will always be going back there all the time they are #1 in my book read more

You usually don't find great food next to the Family Dollar store, but that's one of the reasons this place is a gem. I came here because of a review I read on the CMH Gourmand blog. It sounded good, I love subs, and when I read they had an Italian sub with Italian sausage, I practically floated over the place the same day. This place is in a run-down part of town, in a run down building. You can tell that something's up when the proprietor asks "How did you hear about us? Who sent you?" I felt welcome, but it must've been obvious I was from a different part of town. The place is old-school, but in a good way. Not much thought or investment in the way of decor; the place seems pretty dedicated to making pizza and subs as it always has. Unlike the squishy soft subs served up by the big chains, this one was a study in contrast, proportions, and premium ingredients. Contrast - bread that is crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Lots of contrasting ingredients - spice of sausage, coolness of coleslaw, and so on. Proportions - the right amount of everything; a balanced taste. Not dripping with dressing. Premium ingredients - big slices of meat. Locally procured bread and Italian sausage. Not a place you'll stumble upon by accident...unless you're lost. Still, a pretty convenient location (near I71, close to Clintonville) that is close to any number of other places you might be visiting. read more

In search of a decent pizza joint near our home, we tried Suzie's. Not real crazy about the pizza, but the pepperoni and garlic cheese rolls were really good. We may make a return to try a sub. The establishment is small and clean with a small dining area. Service was good but very busy. Not real crazy about the postings stating that they are armed. However, we will continue to search for great local pizza! read more

What find. Had a roast beef Philly style. Great sandwich. Pizza looked amazing. That will be on the next trip. We were warned to call ahead on weekends as the wait can be an hour or more. read more

Delicious sub/pizza/pepperoni rolls! Such a great little find and the workers were so nice!

Just went to the new shop on Karl and am happy to report that while the food is the same, delicious fare I've enjoyed for decades, I won't be returning because signs behind the counter are a bit menacing, referencing customers being filmed and workers bearing arms. Perhaps necessary, but in a hospitality business, far from welcoming. read more

Not only is the food delicious the portion size is filling. My favorite is the Italian sub with double meat and cheddar cheese. And somebody upstairs heard my request, they now deliver(limited delivery area) to my house. Yay read more

Pizza tasted like frozen pizza you can get at the store. Yucky. Need a better crusting more cheese. There were four slices with no cheese at all. I wish I would have taken a picture now. The subs look good so I'm not totally writing this place off just yet. read more

Great pizza and subs. Friendly service. Wish they had longer hours

Wow, probably the best meatball sub I've ever had. Nice size balls, a bit larger than a golf ball. Very tasty also. Great sauce and lots of cheese. That 's it. That's all that should be on a fine meatball sub. I got the 12 inch, thinking I wasn't hungry enough for the 16 incher. I was barley able to finish it. The sub was baked just right, great crusty bread and the cheese was melted to perfection. Will be hard to try something else. read more

I finally found another sub place with a great Italian sub in Columbus. When I lived in CT, there were mom and pop Italian restaurants everywhere that had awesome Italian subs. We don't have as much of that here, but we do have Susie's and their Big Jon sub. There's a lot of meat on this sub, and it all tastes so so good. On top of the Italian deli meats, they throw a couple huge Italian sausages on the sandwich, depending on how big you get it. I think I went with the 12", and I was struggling to finish it by the end. I suggest calling ahead, because it takes about 15 minutes for them to bake the sub, and there's not many places to sit. The bread is made by Auddino's, and it's delicious. They also do pizza, and while I didn't get to try it, it smelled pretty amazing in there. It looks like they sell more pizza than subs. The area can be a bit rough (if you're not comfortable with that), but everyone eating there, and the guys working the place were all super friendly. The parking situation is tough, since there's not a whole lot of spots. I ended up parking on the side of the building in my own makeshift spot. I'd definitely check this place out again and would try the pizza out as well. read more

GREAT SUB!!! The BIG John is full of the usual meats, good quality, with the addition of a delicious sausage link. The place we use to order from closed, just as Susie's opened on Karl? Rd. Welcome to our hood!!! We can't wait to try the Za and other menu items. Happy belly! read more

This place is real. So real it might scare you a little. The decor is gruff, full of faded pictures, smoke stains and peeling paint. The service is a bit surly but still very friendly, polite and welcoming. Real people. The neighborhood might be regarded by some as "hood", to me it's home and I've never felt unsafe here. The food is unbelievably real. Fresh, quality ingredients prepared by people who clearly take pride in what they do, and they do it well. All of this is practically given away to you at insanely low price points. A six inch sub here is equivalent to a 12 incher at most chains and runs from $3.75 to $6.50. This is the kind of place where magic happens. If you prefer your food to be made in a joyless, sterile environment go to subway or quiznos and have a mediocre, over priced sub. However if you, like me intend to "keep it real" with real food, made by real folks get yourself to Suzie's. read more

Susies is located next door to the Daybreak Diner and the Dollar Store is on the other side. When I used to come here it was located on Westerville Rd. The fellow working told me that it had been there for thirty-five years. It's been in it's current location for eight years. I came down here yesterday to get a sub for dinner. I'd been here MANY times over the years but not in a long time. And I really don't remember why. The subs are pretty good. I got the Italian which comes with Italian lunch meat on an Audinos hard roll. For the last few years I've been going to Jersey Mikes. The advantage to Susies is that their subs are toasted where JM's are not. It's a different taste and I don't have any idea why JM's doesn't toast theirs but they don't. Anyway, I'll have to decide if I want to stick with JM's or not. read more

Best Subs in the state of Ohio. I will always take a 15 mile detour to get here. The size is huge the Quality is as good as you will find and the price is always great. The Neighbor hood is pretty tough around it but in the lit everything is good. Try the big John it will surprise you. But the meatball sub is lunch changing! There good people doing it right ! read more

Susie's Sub Shop - The Lunch Changing Meatball! - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio