We've been twice now and both times I was impressed by the food and service. Nice outdoor seating. I loved the bruschetta and the cheese bread. My husband had pizza with prosciutto on it which I'm not a fan because it made it really salty. He loved it though. I wasn't super impressed by the ravioli. It wasn't bad, just sort of bland. Indoor seating is very cozy. Outdoor is nice in a beautiful summer evening. read more

I have been dining here for 13 years and something has changed. The food was "ok" and similar but not the same. The pizza dough was under proved and flat. Desserts were as cold as hell and disappointing ,after we had to ask for them. Entires meal was poorly timed overall and the server distant and terse. Not a great vibe. I miss the former management and Chad. read more

Food is always good, they are consistent with their product which helps a restaurant survive! Service is usually good also. Ambiance is spectacular! read more

Yummy drinks friendly staff, atmosphere was great...hanging with a GF...shopping.... life is good read more

See all

Went to Goodfellos on recommendation that their pizza was amazing. Visited on their wine Wednesday, shared a bottle with the wife had pizzas all around the table. Food was amazing, flavors were perfect ingredients were fresh. Kids enjoyed it. Atmosphere was enjoyable. Waiter, was friendly and accommodating, and not overbearing. Used a credit card to pay, was notified by the credit card company that I used of two fraudulent charges. This was the only place I had use my credit card in the last month where the card was out of my possession and site for any period of time. Just be wary of businesses that deem this acceptable to hire thieves. I tried to call the restaurant the day of the fraudulent charges, and no one answered, and was unable to tell them about this. read more

Great spot in historic Sackets Harbor. Wood fired pizza was delish, great decor, better beer selection, doo-wop playing in the background. A "must stop, eat & drink" spot when visiting the area. read more

Made a reservation upon arriving placed on the other side of restaurant outside. Drink order was forgotten, food took a long time to get to us. When we got it it was COLD. Tasted like it had been sitting a long time. Not once did I ever see a manager or anyone come outside to check on patrons. Not well thought out to place a waitress out there who has to constantly walk back and forth around the restaurant to place orders. read more

I love this place! For years, this is the only restaurant around to continually provide consistent, delicious food in an environment that makes you feel cozy and important! I bring work colleagues here, family, my significant other. It's always wonderful! On one occasion this past summer, my boyfriend and I were dining outside and we had a wonderful evening of several courses. I took only a small bite of my ravioli entree and had them box the rest to go, because I knew I'd want to enjoy their incredible peanut butter pie for dessert! When I heated up my leftovers two days later, I was enjoying when I noticed a wasp had been mixed into the spinach! (I'm a chef - I've seen a multitude of weird things in food, so it didn't creep me out like it might've done to someone not in the food industry.) I was sad, because I wanted to eat the delicious food, but didn't want to take another bite in case there were pesticides that wasps might've been treated with to help get rid of them around the building. (We didn't see any wasps or bees while dining outside. My boyfriend is very allergic (needs an epipen) to wasp stings, so we would've noticed this and moved to another seating area. I figured it came in through an open door to the kitchen, or maybe it was even in the spinach from their supplier. I contacted the restaurant via private message on social media and was connected with the owner. He called me and listened to what I said. I listened to him, and knew that they were a clean and organized kitchen, as I've dined with them for years. I really just wanted him to know what had happened in case there is a wasp problem - this could be tackled before another problem arose. He was gracious and offered me a gift certificate to dine there in the future. I have to say, as a chef and business owner, I am so thankful for fellow business owners who accept responsibility even when it seems like a weird out of place scenario. (I've had to do this in my own business.) I will forever be a faithful patron of Goodfellows and even more so now that the owner took time to make things right. You will likely not encounter a wasp experience like mine, but if you do, rest assured that they will work to maintain their stellar track record of providing an amazing experience for their guests. Thank you, Goodfellows! (As a side note, when I was in my senior year of high school, back in 2001, a woman came to my Gourmet Foods class to demonstrate how to make pizza - she was the chef at Goodfellows! Whoever she is, she had a good bit of influence over my decision to become a chef! Thank you!) read more

We've been patronizing Goodfellos for years, but the last 2 years we've been disappointed. The food quality has changed; the salad got smaller, the pizzas have much less topping, etc.. Ordered take out a while back, waited and waited for our order, just to find out they did not have an order for us. We were then told quite rudely we had to wait. We returned home 1 1/2 hours later (no joke), just to find our order wrong. We just left it be. Tonight we had a reservation for 7 people and when we got there, the hostess seemed confused about our reservation and told us it would be a little while. People came and left, nobody ever went to collect us. After waiting more than half an hour outside, we went to talk to the hostess again and she informed us that she did not have a reservation under our name. When we asked her to check to see if they had our reservation under our phone number, since they took both our name and number, she said a phone number would not help. We were then told they would get us seated in another 15 minutes, but it would be tight. Another half hour went by, but nothing happened, so we eventually just left. Later on we had 2 missed calls from Goodfellos a....so how did they get our number if we did not have reservations? Not planning on going back anymore! The 1812 Brewing Co. next door was happy to take us. Food came quickly and was delicious, the waitress was awesome; quite different from our experience next door. read more

So I tried this place a couple times here in Sackets and well I am sad to say each time there were problems. The first time I ordered pizza and some pasta. Pizza was okay, positive it's brick oven pizza, but that's about it. The pasta, well was different. The chunks of chicken, and vegetables were far and few between. It was a huge serving of pasta though I suppose... The second time I got food there I orders all apps. When they came the crab cakes, that are $16 mind you, look like someone ripped one in half and the other one was no bigger than a solo coffee cup lid. So with that being said I am sure there are bright spots about the food I just didn't find any. Oh and last thing I did reach out to them just to let them know my experiences and the response I got was less than fulfilling... read more

Good Fellos - Crab cakes from Goodfellos. Notice how the sauce container is bigger than the cakes... - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

The food was fantastic, but the service could use a little work. After being seated on the patio, our waitress seemed to be inconvenienced by having to wait on us the entire night. Food came out pretty quickly once our order was placed and it was all really good. The garlic bread was a great starter and the portions are pretty generous. Their patio is an awesome spot to sit and relax in Sackets maybe just with a different server than we had. read more

See all

We had a good meal here sitting out on the semi enclosed patio. I had the Filetto and my wife had Pollo Ala Francese. We took dessert to go. Dinner with appetizers and dessert was about $110 plus a tip with no alcohol. read more

Good Fellos - The view - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

See all

Love this restaurant! Great food, amazing service, and a wonderful atmosphere. Highly recommend!

The food is ass. The waiter was rude barley came up and ask how are food was " it was bad thank you for asking." I can't control where we sit but where we sat was in the corner of the room with rusted down pipes. I mean I feel bad for the SHEFS in the kitchen. It looked like they had no room in there. ‍ read more

I attended wine night and loved the $8 bottles and/or $2 glasses. The ambiance is relaxed and informal and the servers are really nice. I couldn't see the specials so the bartender took a picture on her phone so I could see them! The food was amazing! Seafood penne pasta was a winner! I highly recommend read more

Add Goodfellos to the top of our happy places. Having St. Francis wine on their extensive wine list was a wonderful surprise and omen to a delicious and delightful experience. We are wood fire pizza junkies! The Jeremiah , with its combination of mozzarella, provolone, chicken, caramelized onions ,walnuts ,bacon and feta on A Perfect crust was a satisfying and savory fix! We enjoyed the extensive wine list and St . Francis Chardonnay blessed our Mother's Day celebration with joy in each our glasses. We asked about dessert in advance not to miss a treat of this wonderful restaurant. Evan ,our most excellent and efficient ,handsome and hospitable server treated us royally. We notice that all he served were served well with genuine kindness and hospitality. Our dessert choices were difficult . We ordered two . We usually order one to share. We ordered two to share and the Lemoncella Cake and the Tiramisu were savored . No boxes were needed We are so very happy and delighted to have discovered Goodfellos. We will return with our good friends to dazzle them to a great place to enjoy good food, good booze and a Goodfellos Hospitality. Take a ride to Sacketts Harbor Dock at Goodfellos for celebration!! Another bottle of St Francis will ensure Blessing of Joy and cherished memories! read more

See all

I have only lived in the area for a few months and have already been here a few times. The food, atmosphere and people are amazing. I will continue to come to Goodfellos. By far one of the best restaurants I've ever been to. read more

See all

Food is okay depending on what you order, specials are hit or miss. Prices are a bit high. Great atmosphere to grab a drink while in Sackets. read more

Ordered a pizza to go...very small,thin crust. Expensive 10 inch pizza a barely feeds 2. Flavor was good. A little skimpy on the pepperoni. Walked in on a Sunday, no one at host station. I won't be back to this establishment... read more

Fun place with a bar, inside and outside seating, family friendly and decent pizza. It was a little taste of Italy! They have clean easily accessible restrooms (we had our 3 daughters ages 7, 4, and 1) and but no changing station. The food was delicious, fresh, with high quantity ingredients. The price was reasonable. Perfect for a date night too. read more

See all

If I could give Goodfellos 10 stars I would. It's such a special place for my wife and I. I've lost count of the number of meals we've had there over the last 20 years - it has to be close to 100. We discovered it when we first moved to Sackets. We moved away 13 years ago and sill make it a point to get back any time we're in the area. It's cozy and quaint and the food is always phenomenal. A bottle of wine on the patio is always a good move. read more

Excellent place! I visited while on a work trip. The food was great! The Wednesday Wine special is the BEST. You can't go wrong with $2 a glass. The staff were friendly and excellent! A++++ read more

This place is the bomb.com Best pizza in the area. The brussetta is awesome and the choices make this place the best. Get any pizza. read more

Average pizza. Not too good. Not too bad. Salad meh. Overpriced. The bar tender had an incredibly shitty attitude. You would've thought I was completely inconveniencing the him. Maybe he was just having a really bad day. read more

First timer here-- I came for lunch around 1230 after a long hike. There were a few people sitting outside on the patio, and inside wasn't full at all. My server Tracy, greeted me and asked what I wanted to drink moments after being seated by the host. I ordered 1/2 Caesar salad $10 and the Prosciutto y Fico pizza $18. I was very surprised of how quickly my food came to my table. My entire meal tasted fresh and it was delicious! Tracy checked on me at least 3 more times and she was very pleasant to interact with. I wish I had room for dessert, so I'll be coming back to give it a try! read more

Good Fellos - Prosciutto y Fico pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

See all

The food is good the the service was excellent. My concern is the dining area is cramped and the overall atmosphere very noisy.

This is a really high-quality designer pizzeria. Prices are definitely comparable to the rest of secretary which is a generally pricey area. Quality is what it should be for the price. Portion size might be a little bit light. I would definitely go back as I have gone back multiple times already and I would recommend this to other people. But not anything for daily use definitely for less often or Special occasion quality. They really didn't have any options on the menu under $14 and $15. read more

This is a great place to eat in Sackets Harbor. The service and food were excellent. We choose to eat on the deck on our last visit and had a great experience. read more

This was our first dining experience but it won't be our last. Dinner was delicious and service excellent! Highly, highly recommend!

This is a very busy place but quickly found a seat at the bar. Ordered a rose and a pizza. It was pretty good.

Ordered one of their wood fired pizzas.Pizza was okay but very small 10" basically a personal pizza. The cost was $22 dollars and definitely not worth it. read more

We had dinner at Goodfellos twice on our trip to Sackets Harbor. The pizza was not great, but it was okay. Their appetizers were very good - had the meatballs, caprese bruschetta, truffle fries, and the duck wontons. Definitely suggest eating on the patio. Overall Goodfellos is a good option to have while visiting Sackets Harbor. read more

Excellent find!!! Small, friendly brick oven and bar. Fantastic menu, not disappointed at all. Friendly , inviting staff, easy conversation with other customers, clean. Huge beer menu, old world setting. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Great pizza! Enjoyed sitting on the patio and enjoyed with a glass of wine! Menu is fairly priced and lots of options, will come back to try pizza. read more

Good Fellos - Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Sackets Harbor, New York

food was pretty decent but the restaurant feels cramped with the kitchen being out in the open

WARNING STAY AWAY!!!!!!!!! I was a guest staying at this over rated out dated over priced hotel full of dust and rust along with rooms full of broken moldy furniture. it's more like a air BNB apartment from HELL. I mistakenly decided to get a drink and a meal with my family at the good fellos bar downstairs from this atrocity when we got a drink from the male bar tender working Saturdays who over an accidental broken glass made an unprofessional and snark racist comment implying he was annoyed by our presence and "does not care because he runs the place" (apologizing multiple times) we decided to pay the bill and leave before any physical altercation happened due to his (friends) who along with him and the manager Jeff ganging up on us. working in costumer service in NYC myself I have never been treated with such disrespect. This pregdist establishment should not be allowed to serve the public. My family and I have filled out a police report with the local authorities. read more

We ordered a pizza from here. I really liked it, the sauce was a bit too acidic for me. The husband did not like it, but, I think he was thinking it would be a NYC style pizza and this is more gastropub/Italian family restaurant. We live very close to here so we'll be bavk once we can eat in and enjoy the location. read more

Never a bad meal at Goodfellos. Their pizza is excellent. The cheesy bread is great as well as authentic antipasto, not the crap you get from takeout pizza shops. The pork Milanese is my favorite dish. And we can't forget about wine Wednesday's!!!! read more

Personally I'm not a fan of their pizzas but I love their pastas. Good food, good service, great vibe and by far the best option in the area for dining. Took off a star because for the quality they are overpriced compared to like price point restaurants in other cities, even Syracuse. But, supply and demand! Will absolutely keep coming here bc it hits the spot. read more

Reliably high quality! Pizza types are exotic and always great, desserts are solid, and of course their cheap wine Wednesdays with $7 bottles make everything taste even better read more