We had a pizza that was great New York style. Garlic knots are the bomb. Kids split a meat ball sandwich very good. House dressing is good for dipping the knots. Staff is very nice. This was my 3rd time in and the owner goes out of his way to say hello. read more

Ok, this place is AWESOME, and I found my new weekly lunch spot. Not only is their pizza good, and the lunch portions are generous, the owner is SUPER friendly. I got the lunch special: 2 (huge) slices of pepperoni pizza, a side salad and a drink for $7.95. But there are a lot of different options. It was too much food, so I'll have lunch for tomorrow as well! He also gave me a few garlic knots to try, and they were really good. Next time I'll try the lasagna lunch special! read more

See all

Good people, pizza and garlic rolls are great. Service and food are great. Been going there for a while, wish it was open on Mondays

I only ordered from here because I saw a review of the lasagna pizza on Yelp. The pizza I received looks nothing like the one on Yelp.This hardly had any sauce. It was more like a hamburger pizza. It was far from a lasagna pizza. I'm sure with more sauce and more lasagna looking it would have been a lot better. I think good fellas needs more consistency across the board with their pizzas. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - This hardly had any sauce. It was more like a hamburger pizza. It was far from a lasagna pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Wylie, Texas

See all

Excellent pizza and great customer service. Best pizza I have had since moving here. Very reasonable prices.

My family has been consistently going to goodfellas for as long as I can remember and the food and service is always phenomenal.

My husband and I have ordered pizza from here twice now and have enjoyed it both times! The pizza slices are huge and tastes so good! It definitely reminds us of the authentic thin crust pizza spots we've had in NYC. I can't recommend them enough read more

I tell everyone..... this place is great. The friendliness of the place reminds me of a neighborhood diner but Italian. read more

See all

I love this place. Really good pizza. Have been ordering for delivery from here for years. Stromboli is huge and delicious. Garlic knots are very good with warm marinara sauce. You wont be dissapointed with goodfellas. Oh yeah and the wings are also reall y good. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Wings wings wings! - Pizza Near Me - Wylie, Texas

New to the area so thought I'd try this place. Delivery was on time, the tiramisu and cheesecake was good and that's why it got three stars. We ordered entrées not the pizza. The food was very greasy it definitely lacked garlic which I tend to expect with my Italian food. Even the garlic knots barely had any garlic on them and were greasy. The online menu does not have descriptions for everything so beware of that. We found out all the subs sandwiches have olives as well as lettuce and tomato, but easy enough to pick off. The sub sandwiches are large so definitely worth the price. Chicken al Vodka (we choose hot) had a lot of grease in the bottom and could have used more flavor. Chicken Carciofi with lemon butter was good (I love mushrooms and artichokes) again could've use some garlic, but how can you go wrong with lemon butter sauce. Picture below showing the grease and one meal. All in all we decided we will not order here again when there are better neighborhood choices. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Greasy food - Pizza Near Me - Wylie, Texas

Great pizza and customer service! I enjoy this NY pizza style and by the slice options.

"Hello slackers." That was the owner's greeting for my brother and I. Jokingly, I whispered to my brother, "how does he know our character traits already?" (It must have been my stubble..) This small, almost hidden, Italian restaurant is located just a couple blocks from my brother's home, so we decided to give it a try. As a starter, we had garlic knots (see pictures) which we dipped in their excellent sauce and quickly eaten. We ordered the calzone and the baked ziti. We both struggled to finish our plates, not because it wasn't tasty, but because it was too much for our slacker selves. As we slowly ate through our plates, we overheard, "hello fellas, hey buddy" countless times. The people were laid-back and friendly. I can tell this place is a regular food choice for people since the waitress and chef greeted many of them by their first name. That's not something you can easily find in Dallas. We ordered a large pizza for the ride home (again, see pictures). Although it was lacking some pizza sauce, it was still perfect for later that night. Pricewise, the dinner was inexpensive, only needing to spend $22 plus tip, yet still leaving us full with a pizza to go. As we were leaving, the owner appropriately bid us farewell. "Good night, slackers." I then shaved the next morning. read more

See all

Originally from Long Island, NY., it's very hard to find pizza in Texas that even comes close to New York style pizza. Craig and his crew do an Awesome job of replicating that pizza I grew up on. You'll always be greeted upon entering and thanked as you leave. The restaurant is very clean. They've got a great menu. Craig said they deliver to Sachse but I think I'll just continue to drive up. Definitely worth the trip. All the other pizza establishments have to resort to brochures and specials to get your business. Say what you will about New Yorkers, but we do know pizza. Goodfellas is friggin awesome. Forgetaboutit!! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wylie, Texas

LOVE the pizza here! I order their pizza at least once a week, for the teens and for me too. I am very very picky and theirs is my favorite. Can't go wrong with the price either. I get a large cheese for $10.30 and when I say large I mean HUGE!!!! One slice could fill you up. Give it a try! The owners cool too....."Goodfella's." lol read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wylie, Texas

Best Lasagna Pizza and Eggplant Parmesan. You won't be disappointed. We have ordered many times and have not ever been disappointed. MB & CB read more

First time at this place this evening. Food was excellent and the staff was super-friendly!

First time here. Picked up a Meat Lovers to-go at Goodfella's. Pizza was loaded with toppings and tons of cheese. The staff was super friendly. Best pizza in Wylie. I'll definitely be back. read more

Pizza is excellent highly recommend the garlic knots as well. Have always had excellent service and excellent food. Would highly recommend coming here. read more

Really disappointed that this didn't turn out better. From the delivery to the final product there is much left to be desired. To be fair I don't know if the delivery issue was on Goodfellas or Eat Street, but the order took nearly an hour and a half to deliver and when it finally got here the pizza was half way folded in the box and our garlic knots looked like someone had crushed them. Nevertheless our family pushed forward and figured even crushed food may taste good. Unfortunately we were wrong. Both the pizza and the knots were incredibly bland and greasy. So much so that my kids who will eat anything ate about half a slice and decided they'd be better off with a sandwich. I love finding hole in the wall local places too support, but I'm afraid we will have to leave Goodfellas alone. read more

Ordered to go for the first time. I am a big pizza buff, This was probably the best service ever. They accommodated my custom requests and were super friendly and courteous. Amazing pizza! read more

The owner greats you when you come in, and remembers what you like. The pepperoni rolls are cheesy deliciousness. I ordered the lunch special $7.25 huge portion of lasagna, a salad, and fresh hot garlic bread rolls as well as a drink. You can get pizza even by the slice. I took a stromboli home for later and it was stuffed full of tons of meat and cheese. Lots of choices,all homemade. Check this little place out, you won't regret it. read more

Great pizza by the slice here. First visit after a couple years but I used to frequent this place in high school. Nothing fancy and the leather seats are cracked up bad, but the service (and food!) are great. Only complaint is more sauce on the pizza, but the pizza is still delicious. Can't beat the prices. 2 big slices and complimentary garlic knots for 5$. read more

See all

Absolutely one of my favorite spots! The food is so good and Craig just really makes the place. Service is top notch!

Expected delivery was 45-60 minutes per Yelp app. I waited 1 full hour after ordering JUST 1 PEPPERONI Pizza before I called to check on the status of the order. The girl that answered the phone said it'd be the next pizza "up". I asked what that meant and she quickly told me to speak to her manager. The manager (Craig or Chris) said they'd get it to me as soon as they can. I asked if he had a more accurate estimated time of delivery and he answered by telling me that if I wanted a more accurate delivery time from now on, that I shouldn't order online, but instead call "like everyone else". He said he could guarantee the pizza being delivered within the next 20minutes. It has now been been an hour and 50 minutes, no pizza, no call, no apology. I called back, spoke to the same manager, which told me the same thing; "next time don't order from internet, no good". Said we should be receiving shortly and said next time I call, I would get half off because of my wait. I told him not to worry about a next time. This business is literally 11 minutes from where they had to deliver the 1 pizza to. It took almost 2 hours for my family and I to receive 1 large, single topping pizza. Bad customer service, decent pizza. 1 star is for the pizza. read more

Food was pretty good, the service was the worst I've ever had, seen, or heard of. It was absolutely legendary. The type of punishment you only hear about in stories. If your considering "goodfellas," tonight do yourself a favor order it! If you have high blood pressure, are pregnant or may become pregnant do not dine in. read more

Wouldn't even give them 1 star. I am a very patient person and even gave this place a third try... shame on me... long story short- each time we ordered for delivery they were 2 HOURS late. Oh and the pizza was cold and the cheese pizza was over cooked and tasted like cardboard. Each time we were lied to multiple times about where our order was. They blame grub hub every time. But then apologize and the manager takes the blame when you catch them in a lie. Then the manager hung on me. Yeah you read it right. He didn't get the last word we'll just say that. Seriously he was so rude after I said to just cancel my order. The owner has a very distinctive accent- and Never have I ever been treated this crappy by anyone let alone a manager/owner. #DISRESPECTFUL! read more

Stopped by yesterday tried pizza for the first very delicious would highly recommend if looking for a really good pizza. Will order again and they deliver. Glad I discovered this restaurant for good food. read more

We have never had Stromboli's the way they prepare them. They weren't horrible, but there was A LOT of ricotta cheese in them-way too much. There was no sauce inside. It was basically cheese and bread. We've had many Strombolis and they always have sauce inside. Just looking at the amount of ricotta inside them ruined our appetite. The wings and pasta were great though. I love their pizza too. Just won't order Stromboli's again. read more

This place has really gone down hill. The pizza was just ok at best. They were stingy with the toppings and they were not even spread though out the whole pizza. The place was not clean and I was there just as lunch began. It almost looks like it wasn't even cleaned from the night before. I cannot recommend this spot for pizza unfortunately. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wylie, Texas

Wow this is our go to place and they sent me a burned pizza! I couldn't eat it, it was so bad. I'm just not happy with this place now. Dang, back to Pizza Hut. read more

If you're looking for pizza in the Wylie area, then look no further. Goodfella's is one of the best hidden gems in Wylie. The staff is very friendly, and the pizza is great. The pizza's are huge, and the cheese is some of the best I have ever had on a pizza. It is hard to top Goodfella's when it comes to the pizza. If you are hungry for some other Italian dishes, they have a nice selection and most of them are around 5$. Most of these are pretty good especially when considering the price. A great place for a cheap lunch. read more

It hasn't been good for the last couple of years, but look at their latest coupon I just got in the mail last night....CRAIG IS BACK!! http://i.imgur.com/dPps7gA.jpg Going to start eating there again!! read more

Love the meatball spaghetti. Pizza is awesome and the garlic knots are amazing. Everything is made fresh and timely.

I tried Goodfella's for the first time over the summer, and their pizzas are spectacular. The crust is crisp on the outside, but soft on the inside. A "small" is bigger than some chains' "large". Their toppings are fresh and delicious. The garlic knots are very garlicky and very buttery. The marinara sauce they give you to dip them in tastes very fresh and is highly satisfying. In addition, they have great Italian entrees. Their Eggplant Parmigiana is probably one of my favorites I've ever had. I sincerely think they have the best New York-style pizza in the metroplex, and I haven't had anything there that I have not liked. Giving them 5 stars is an easy choice. read more

I have eaten here since it opened and through multiple owners. Over the years the quality has wavered between decent and ultimately bad. I just have one request, PLEASE try harder. We don't have many options for good pizza around here. Better cheese, better service and fresher topping would be a start. I am willing to keep trying, I just want a little progress and hopefully a clear commitment to improvement. M read more

Very friendly on the phone and you did not feel rushed to place your order. The crust was very tender and tasted like it was made that day. The sauce was nothing outstanding, but tasted O. K. I was surprised at how fresh the pineapple tasted and really enjoyed that. I thought the cheese could be a little better quality. Not the oozy gooy stuff I like. My daughter made the comment that it tasted like NY style pizza, so if that is what they are aiming for, I guess they were successful. I will give them, when they say large, you get a LARGE pizza. read more

Waited over 2 1/2 hours for a delivery and never received the order. Called the restaurant 2 times and got the same response 'the delivery guy left 10 mins ago with your order'. On the 3rd call, I told them we still have not received our order and he said to call GrubHub to get a refund. Which I did.. but he didnt offer any alternative to make it right. He was very rude on the phone and I will not be ordering from them again. read more

this place was very delicious! Highly recommend stopping by and trying It out!! ordered a Pizza, Calzone and Stromboli and was extremely satisfied with it. Will most likely return & bring more people To try it out!! read more

Pizza from this place is great! Enjoy it every time. Also tried Chicken Francese, more eggy than I thought it would be, but very good served with spaghetti. Great for me as I do not like marinara sauce that much. Just butter and white wine with that touch of lemon. Ordered with delivery and the young man they sent out was courteous and smiled. Will continue to patronize this place. read more

Having lived in New York City most of my life, I'm a fairly good judge of NY style pizza and this ranks right up there. The crust is thin and the cheese topping is slightly oily. Haven't tried too many other dishes here except for the garlic knots which were yummy and the calzone which was authentic (ask my Italian husband). The atmosphere is a little stark but reminds me of the pizzerias in the East Village. All and all, the best pizza in Wylie. read more