Forever our "go to" for local pizza. Supporting a long time local business and Mr. Craig the owner. NY style pizza, order it "crispy" for a little firmer crust! We love these guys! read more

My wife and I went to Goodfella's Pizza Saturday night. We ordered their half all meat and their good fellas speciality large pizza. Also we ordered their Cheese Bread. Their pizza is very very good and delicious . They customer service were very friendly. My wife and I will definitely go back again. read more

Love this restaurant- always friendly- pizza is excellent- live the lasagna pizza- my son loves the BBQ Chicken pizza

Great Italian place here in Wylie! I have not gotten a chance to eat inside the restaurant, but I did take a look around when I went to pick up my to go order this time. It was quaint and the staff was friendly... felt very personable and family oriented. All the dishes we ordered were good. I would say my favorite I ordered was the fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken. I like how the sauce wasn't too thick... the right texture and taste. Their prices are great... as well as their portions. Another visit I had a whole ago, we ordered a pizza here and I don't think we cared much for it, but maybe ordered the wrong one? I'd be willing to try their pizza again... because I did enjoy their pasta dishes this time. read more

See all

Best pizza around! Our favorite crust! We usually pick up and bring home and are never disappointed.

The Pizza is always cooked to perfection and the staff are very friendly. We enjoy dining in as well as getting it delivered. The owner is very nice and he tries to remember all his customers by name. For a smaller dining atmosphere it is always very clean. read more

My husband and I just moved to Wylie a few months ago, so this was our first time trying Goodfellas. We ordered a large specialty pizza and it was ginormous! We have leftovers for days. We also got the Goodfellas salad, and it was equally delicious! Everything tasted so fresh!!! Don't get me started on the pizza crust! It was so good and tasted homemade! We will definitely be back! read more

[Take Out Review] The people that work here are so nice! We ordered online for pick up. Super convenient, and the pizza was ready within 25 minutes! The restaurant itself is small, but can fit some bigger groups if some of the tables were combined. Pick up was super convenient and done at the counter. There were only 2 pizza sizes for order (at least on the online portal): large and extra large. We ordered a large pizza between the 2 of us and had plenty of leftovers to share! The garlic knots were great. read more

Craig is amazing really makes you feel appreciated. Definitely recommend his food wings better than wingstop!!!

Goodfella'a Pizza is a gather best pizza in Wylie. I ordered my dinner on -line for pick-up. I got there early and the owner greeted me and he was very talkative and very cheerful as always. I explained to him why I was there to pick up instead of ordering for delivery. I explained to him that my husband, boys and I were retiring and we are moving to far East Texas after living here for than 25 years. My food was ready and I drove home and couldn't wait to chow down. The Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich was just the way I like it loaded with meat, cheese and lot of onions and bell peppers and it was so good I coukd' finish it so I wrapped it up in foil and ate the second half the following day. Thank you Goodfellows for giving me the most enjoyable meal. read more

I am extremely impressed with Goodfella's. They are actually getting better than 5 stars. We had pizza on my birthday a few days ago and everyone said it was awesome. Way better than YONX in Wylie which is supposed to be authentic NY style pie. Thank you Goodfella's for making my birthday special. read more

The best restaurant for eating Italian food and getting a free drinks. The owner is really friendly. I go up there all the time. I hope to go up there for a longer period of time for many many years to come Craig is the Apple absolute awesome guy that I will have ever met over there. Thank you for being in my area and in my neighborhood you guys are the best of the best pizza restaurant in town. read more

For a small pizzeria they always provide a 5 star experience from the food to the hospitality. I love Goodfellas still my favorite and first pizzeria I've had in Texas. I went for the cheese pie which you can never go wrong but as I was reuniting with Craig the owner as he always is working hard and listens too he was preparing an order of garlic bread. I instantly wish I had ordered one at least. It looked so good buttery seasoned garlic sauce on that long hard roll plus the melted mozzarella= yummy looking indeed. Check out my pics read more

See all

Pizza overcooked cheese on top crispy!!! Crust dark brown very dry no sauce that I could find. Like eating cardboard

Service outstanding. Very friendly staff. Fresh pizza and the Stromboli was amazing. Will definitely be back to take a pizza pie home next time. read more

See all

This is definitely one of Wylie's hidden gems. The pizzas are big, they're delicious, and very affordable. Delivery is always ahead of the time quoted. Highly recommend this is all. read more

HORRIBLE. Took 2.5hrs to get the pizza and came raw. Box was soggy and leaked fluid down my arm when I received it and trailed through the house into the kitchen. Incorrect toppings on pizza. Calamari as a side tasted like old oil. The time wouldn't of mattered if the pizza was good but unfortunately we had to throw it in the oven to finish cooking and just did not taste good. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Raw pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wylie, Texas

See all

Becky was helpful amazing in the food came fast and their food was hot and good. I like the place where we sat at

While I had heard good things this was not my experience. Ordered a calzone and it was massively doughy and undercooked. Ordered a pinwheel and it was dried out, tough, and overcooked. Ordered fettuccine Alfredo and I was soupy and bland. read more

See all

I hate when pizza place doesn't work out because I'm a pizza lover ! This happened a couple months ago , but I went in because I was craving a Calzone . There was a young man playing in his cell phone in the kitchen area . I placed my order and he grabbed my calzone with bare hands, not washing them. I asked the person that rung me up if someone else could take care of my food . I think if you're gonna let people use phones in the kitchen , make them wash their hands before touching our food . Cell phone are disgusting read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pepperoni Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Wylie, Texas

Owner and staff are very friendly! The Alfredo pizza makes me hungry just thinking about it!

Never liked this restaurant. Pizza never has enough sauce and the crust is really doughy. I've had it in different settings and situations, and each time it gets worse. That's the best I can say about it. read more

Ordered a Calzone.. when i cut it open the cheese came bursting out at me like a tsunami. it's in my hair, on my walls, and stuck in my dogs teeth. i've never seen so much cheese in a calzone before in my life. giving two stars because the cheese tasted good. but after one bite i was cheesed out. maybe try less cheese in these things. gtg the cheese is currently seeping out of my front door. read more

Goodfella's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wylie, Texas

My Mr. was jonesing for pizza/pasta, so instead of going to the same place in our neighborhood, we tried this place out of our area. This one is located in St. Paul/Wylie and drive over here was very beautiful with whole bunch of beautiful big acreage of land after land and beautiful homes and farm animals. It's very peaceful and serene. When we got here, there were quite few customers and we were greeted by very friendly folks who work there. We felt so welcome and realized that we're not in Plano! It's a sit down place which both of us like. The waitress was very friendly and took our order. The menu has many different items and I decided on spaghetti with mushroom sauce on Marinara and the Mr. ordered 14" Goodfella special, cheesy garlic bread and chicken Parmesan to go and he liked the pizza and my spaghetti was good. The garlic knots with Marinara sauce before the meal were excellent(hot and fresh). We were so glad we came here. We just love the small town feel and friendliness of the people with good food. We will definitely return again next time. read more

See all

Big fan of Goodfellas. We have only ever gotten the pizza but it is always delivered quicker than expected and hits the spot for pizza delivery. read more

Best pizza in the area. Always greeted kindly and warmly. Affordable. We normally get to go but have dined in a few times. Its byob. My daughter likes the wings and we live the house salad dressing. Its a tomato vinaigrette. Do they leave without an order of the garlic knots. Mmmmm. read more

Love there food it is really good. I would recommend the pasta combo. Staff is super freindly and the owner is super nice. The restaurant is super clean and tidy. I would recommend going here. read more

Best Pizza Around! When I want Pizza this is the first place I think of. They also make some really good salads.

We have been going here for the last year. And have realized ordering on the phone is so much better than online. Pizza, garlic knots, salads, baked ziti, and meatballs are so good. read more

This is one of our favorite places to get pizza. You can't beat the quality and price. The owner is very welcoming no matter if it's your first visit or your 50th. We LOVE this place read more

Got a calzone which was VERY cheesy, but good overall. Everyone working is always helpful and friendly. Quieter later in the day but can get busy read more

We've ordered delivery from Goodfella's a couple of times and, I've ordered takeout from there once. The staff was friendly when I was inside the restaurant, but the interior of the place seemed quite dark and cramped. I very much enjoyed the first pizza ordered from Goodfella's that we had delivered back in June 2018. But, since then it's just seemed inconsistent flavor-wise and average, nothing to really brag about. The impression I have is that, this is the type of business that once may have been very good but as time has gone on, mediocrity has set in. The restaurant does not serve bad food, but it also doesn't serve great food. It just serves food. I guess if that's okay with Goodfella's, that's okay. I'll order from here only in a pinch. Make your own conclusions and... Eat well. Be well. Cheers! read more

Small take out or dine in with amazing pizza and fresh baked seasoned chunks of bread and a marinara sauce for dipping that was wonderful. We will be returning to try the other wonderful things to eat. It's small but clean and the portions are generous. Price is reasonable. So bring a friend and your appetite as I'm sure you won't be disappointed! read more

Goodfella's Pizza - a tray of food - Pizza Near Me - Wylie, Texas

See all

A wonderful place with a great welcoming feeling that gets you the moment you walk through the door.

First off the owner is super nice and chats with you as you wait. The food is fantastic. I love the pizza and I'll never order Pizza Hut or dominos again. Never had a problem as I've been coming here for over a year 2-3 times a week. I've also had the spaghetti and fettuccine Alfredo. All I can say is the food is awesome. read more

Never thought I would find a place better than Sali's Pizza in Garland, TX, but this place is better. We took the family and grandkids today. From Stromboli, calzones, spaghetti and meatballs to pizza, all were delicious. Their sauce is so good. The service is also A-1. read more

My order wasn't moved through and I went in next day to either get a replacement or a refund. Staff was not very attentive and told me to talk to grub hub. Bad customer service = no desire to be in the place read more

Have been ordering delivery from Goodfella's for many years - my husband & I love Italian food & this place has such a great variety and their pizza is definitely better than any chain restaurant. We order at least 3-4 times per month and I can honestly say they are consistently fast & accurate. Til next time! read more

There's so much wrong going for this place, all you have to do is go to this place and place an order to go, look at them make pizza and salads. They have pizzas and other things just sitting on the counter to get put in oven when order, that can be hours of cheese and pepperoni sitting there. Next I saw the older gentleman pick off a sausage off my pizza pushed his finger in to see if it's warm. Than he come to me to charge me gets cash gives me change doesn't wash his hand than gets my slices out of the oven and again puts his dirty fingers on it to check the temp. GROSS!!!!!! I didn't say anything I just took it and though it in the teach at work, cost me like 8 bucks for the lunch special but glad I was able to see how nasty they are. See for your self don't just order to go, get odd and see how they do things, plus the you f kids there alga be dirty hands and there hats are dirty, should be white hats but they are black dirt. I hate to do this to businesses but that was way to much!! read more

Great owner and great pizza! When a pizza place can wow you with just a cheese pizza then you know anything else is gonna be good too.